Search:

Type: Posts; User: DeathwingZERO

Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.02 seconds.

  1. Re: GMTG Graded cards started grading alterations.

    Graded cards matter when it's a matter of it being something you'll hardly ever see again. Mint Alpha Power, or Summer Magic stuff, for example. Card alterations though, they really shouldn't matter...
  2. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    I agree that it's high, but I don't think it's always an auto-include. Regardless of how many TA, Thresh, Landstill and whatever other builds do it, there's still a safe number of blue based rogue...
  3. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    I don't believe that's necessarily the case here, because there's a number of decks packing FoW that don't necessarily agree on Brainstorm or Ponder. In addition, we don't have the wrecking ball...
  4. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    This really is the only thing that people need to look at to understand the level of saturation Tarmogoyf has actually achieved, and what really benefits from it. It's beat out six highly played...
  5. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    Naive troll will be naive.

    Did you even notice that your whole argument about all these cards that are better than others are ones that came out when the game was new? FoW, Lightning Bolt,...
  6. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    Look over the thread and see how many creatures that were once top contenders the card has obsoleted. Competition in design space = competition in the red zone in games.

    That alone is good enough...
  7. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    I personally see no flaw in it being vanilla, because it still eats most of the format anyway (and does so in most formats it's in). I'm just saying from a designer looking in, that's what they...
  8. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    It's points like these that continuously get debunked, and yet nobody seems to be paying attention to it.

    PLEASE tell me the removal package that every deck (and every color, for that matter) that...
  9. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    Your arguments in favor of Tarmogoyf get dumber and dumber as time goes on. I can't believe people aren't downright calling you a troll on the same level as Cavius.

    Ignore the fact that as a...
  10. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    I'm so sick and tired of hearing he's vanilla. Who cares if he can't evade when most decks can't answer him in the red zone alone without going x for 1 anyway? The power to casting cost ratio for the...
  11. Replies
    2,437
    Views
    544,605

    Re: [Deck] Non-LED Based Dredge/Ichorid Combo

    I'd like to see his list. Advocating for 4 Therapy, Unmask, AND Dread Return just seems really......packed tight. I had to cut Unmask to the SB, and I fell 4 Dread Return is just too much dead stuff...
  12. Poll: Re: Would the format be more interesting without Tarmogoyf?

    I'm only going to point out one particular argument that I feel is unjustified by simply putting up a hypothetical situation:

    If Tarmogoyf made other good creatures bad, what can Wizards possibly...
  13. Replies
    638
    Views
    107,545

    Re: GRAND PRIX: CHICAGO!!! - Live Coverage

    Because people make mistakes in this game.

    Long story short, if I trigger your Counterbalance and you do not say you are specifically responding to it, I will assume that you are responding to my...
  14. Replies
    638
    Views
    107,545

    Re: GRAND PRIX: CHICAGO!!! - Live Coverage

    I like how the head judge allowed everyone to have the shortcut when CB is around, but goddamn does that dumb down the game too much. Forgetting triggered abilities and misplaying around them is part...
  15. Replies
    638
    Views
    107,545

    Re: [Live Coverage] GRAND PRIX: CHICAGO!!

    With regards to CB, if you choose to declare a spell or an ability without specifically stating the trigger is still on the stack, it's as if you have decided not to use it, and it has resolved.
    ...
  16. Replies
    638
    Views
    107,545

    Re: [Live Coverage] GRAND PRIX: CHICAGO

    Wow. I recognize a ton of the names, but not necessarily from being Source members. Seems a number of Pros and Semi-Pros decided to come out to this as well.

    Hopefully we see something come of it....
  17. Replies
    20
    Views
    4,991

    Re: [discussion] removal of Mana Burn

    Mana burn has turned into far less of an issue in the game over the years. Getting rid of it really doesn't change anything. Storm decks that cast those Rituals are still out 2 mana accelerants and...
  18. Replies
    638
    Views
    107,545

    Re: [Live Coverage] GRAND PRIX: CHICAGO

    What about Pinder and his boys? I thought they were making it out.
  19. Replies
    2,437
    Views
    544,605

    Re: Non-LED Based Dredge/Ichorid Combo

    I think with the inclusion of Street Wraith it has to follow an all or nothing sort of thing. I don't see much viability of the card if it's less than a 4 of, because it needs to be seen in the...
  20. Re: [Premium Article] The Power of 2007: Legacy Dredge

    That list is utter garbage.

    The main reason for going LEDless is to take advantage of Ichorid beats on a much more regular basis, often as early as turn two, in case the primary combo win doesn't...
  21. Replies
    2,437
    Views
    544,605

    Re: Non-LED Based Dredge/Ichorid Combo

    Bounce is cast either the turn before or the turn you will go off, all depending on the mana you need to do so. The deck plays like storm combo for games 2 and 3, you sculpt the perfect hand while...
  22. Replies
    2,437
    Views
    544,605

    Re: Non-LED Based Dredge/Ichorid Combo

    My SB slots for anti-artifact hate depend on the metagame:

    Needle:
    Any time I see just Relic, or there's Relic and a combination of Factories, AEther Vials, Crypts, and other activated-only...
  23. Replies
    2,437
    Views
    544,605

    Re: Non-LED Based Dredge/Ichorid Combo

    Ichorid is the metagame combo deck. If there's not a lot of dedicated slots to hating it out, it will thrive. But when every single matchup plays 8-12 answers to it in the board (a lot of the time...
  24. Re: [Core Set] Changes with 11th Edition ("Magic 2010")

    I personally liked the design of the new Black Knight. But that's also because I thought the original Black/White looked terrible. Hoping they end up putting new artwork on a number of spells.

    I...
  25. Replies
    11
    Views
    1,984

    Re: [deck]Morgan's Big Pile o' Jank

    I gotta go with Nihil on this one.

    Not only do the Birds speed you up in comparison to STE, they serve to fix all situational mana issues, not just one. Both cards might as well be dead in the...
Results 1 to 25 of 500
Page 1 of 20 1 2 3 4