Search:

That’s your problem, who comes to Legacy to play fair? Just play something broken, ignore the card, and win the game instead of worrying about a three-power vanilla creature for 1UU.

We have all these ridiculous decks, and here I am just innocently wanting to play tier III decks with my Earthcrafts and Frantic Searches. Thwarted once again.

It has potential synergies, but the likelihood any deck of that sort would run it over Careful Study/Faithless Looting is rather low. As for sol land decks, they dump their hand so quickly the card...

Steering slightly back on topic because I care...

...unbanning Frantic Search would have little impact on High Tide being a format player overall. It still completely shits to Leovold and Sanctum...

We did actually do something like this years ago (maybe around 2004-2006 or so), back when the site still had an actual front page and such. We probably had a dozen or so articles on here, though the...

I wasn't missing that fact, I was merely pointing out that Survival as a card would be far more manageable as there are better and maindeckble options to handle it. Clearly DRS fits in that shell,...

What's also relevant is that the best and most common graveyard hate used today (Rest in Peace, Surgical Extraction, not to mention Deathrite Shaman which is a maindeck card) was not printed at the...

I personally don't think it is necessarily good to remove Lands as a deck and I really enjoy it as a part in the format. Lands essentially gave me a free win in round 13 of Grand Prix Indianapolis to...

As someone who has played 1.5/Legacy since 1999 and been bored with the format for over a year because it has become stale as hell from a design perspective, Caleb's proposals (albeit a bit insane)...

The DCI did absolutely nothing after they "fixed" Flash in April 2007, only a month prior to GP: Columbus, even though they certainly had knowledge about the detrimental effects it would have on the...

Why would Spiral Tide run Memory Jar when, for a single additional mana, it could run the same effect that untaps all its lands? I'm not even sure why this is honestly a question or being discussed.

So if you're conceeding that the deck should be UB, why bother playing a tide-based version instead of Rituals, which are faster, much better off Mind's Desire, and don't require the deck to run weak...

I don't think it's plausible for Mind's Desire to fit into an existing build of High Tide. It can be built around it, sure, but it'd look drastically different than what the current decklists look...

What are you talking about? Brainstorm was never a problem before Mental Misstep, nor would it be in the event Misstep was banned. Does Brainstorm get stronger with the absence of Mental Misstep?...