Search:

I mean, that's not a bad list but looking over the matchups I feel like he got sorta lucky. I've been pretty worried about Zoo for a long time, if you go back several pages - I felt like Zoo was such...

@ Iare: Glad you like the Perish. It's crazy good, no? That's a really interesting build - I will have to try it. I like the Nyxathid/TS split. Seems like some very strong beats. I would be...

I'm OK with her getting bolted. It's a tempo loss for them, and means one less bolt headed for our other creatures. But that sounds like poor luck... other similar decks find her such a house, like...

Given that Bolts are almost as common as Swords for removal, and that Smother doesn't see much play, I'd honestly rather have Vampire Nighthawk. His lifelink and deathtouch are amazing for his cost.

The best answer to 43 Lands, in my experience, is Extirpate/Leyline. Our best chance is to shut down their loam and crush their Mazes and Factories with our LD suite. If they get to loaming and gain...

Persecutor is interesting... but 4 cc I find scary in this format. Any 4 cc has a lot to live up to. He's been good in Ext for sure, just not convinced I suppose. Of all the options to get rid of...

That's correct... I haven't been keeping up with The Rock for a few years now, so I had no clue they were using KoTR. In this respect my "tech" does seem kinda old. I still think it could work, but...

Well if you notice I said the manabase needed work. I'm not claiming anything for this deck yet. And yes it could be described as a form of Aggro-Rock. I have played Eva Green in the past, as well as...

@Uly Van Hammer: Welcome to the Source! That's not a bad 2 color build, but as you say, it is poor against Zoo. I'm wondering if we can really afford that liability anymore? PRO Bant is still a top...

Iare, you have some good points. I've been unhappy with the power level of the 2CC spells in this deck for a while - Hymn and Sinkhole are both very old cards that simply lose in pure efficiency to...

I'm glad you liked the list. I should have said, Deadguy was my first real Legacy deck, so I've been playing around with it for a while now...

I think 4 colorless is OK in a 3 color deck. Any more...

Now this thread has actually got me thinking... If I were to play Deadguy these days, it might look something like this:

Men (18)
4 Goyf
4 Bob
4 Nighthawk
4 Gatekeeper
2 Stoneforge Mystic
...

Ok, constructive criticism, where to start...

Don't splash G if you aren't willing to play Goyf. Just because a list has succeeded "in the past" doesn't mean it will today, or even that it is...

This deck looked OK to a first glance but then... what? Are you really trying to make Deadguy worse than it already is? Please tell me you made a mistake in posting and that isn't your actual list......

@ Iare

I love Deadguy, and I am saddened to say this - but I also think it is no longer competitive. I think the reason this deck has fallen off the map have to do with a few long-term issues it...

Here's the deck I've been testing extensively on MWS and building to play:

4 Scrubland
6 Swamp
4 Bloodstained Mire
2 Polluted Delta
4 Wasteland
1 Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
1 Volrath's...