Search:

http://www.iplaymtg.com/data/attachment/forum/201506/27/165810bswi4y5z008sditj.jpg.thumb.jpg
Closer to a Modern card, but also possible combat trick in legacy?

Abrupt decay laughs at it. Maybe a meta choice, e.g. against Moat.

TC is a straightly 3-for-1, so pepole did't play "situational" 3-for-1 like AV or standstill when TC flooded the format.

Now TC is gone. IMO standstill is a playable card again.

Almost every deck which plays Bob, also plays shaman. Can't expect opponent lose 3+ life during their own turn.

The reason why we do not play Sygg, is the crowd slots. Sygg is not unplayable, but today even reejereys are reduced for putting Progenifish in…

Yep. When a merfolk player could devote Thassa into a creature, usually he is already have a good board situation. Obvious a win-more card.

Thassa does not die to Decay...but other merfolks do. It...

Cosi's Trickster is just another Bloodhall Ooze. Have be seen some Modern play, but too "situational" in Legacy, and a dead topdeck.

About cavern...

Do you frequently get your fishes countered? If you often get countered, what is the kind of counters your opponents used?

Is Progenifish a poor design? Yes.

A boring card? Yes.

Banned-level power?No.

Since "broken" cards like SnT, Cradle and one-drop planeswalker are all in the format...

Too "passive", and narrow. Hexproof cannot stop boardswipe and sacrifice.

Against usual remove spells ,just to side in more counters would be better. And we all used to have Kira in sideboard.
...

After Progenifish printed, we have no reason to stick Vial on 2.

4 images are an obivious “Tnn-creep” choice. Such configulation has worse synergy with every other merfolk, except Tnn. I would never cut reejery for that.

Against Rug：

Could they block your 3-power tnn?…No.

Could you block their 3-power delver?…( ).

Do they have remove spell for your 3-power tnn?…No.

Do you have remove spell for their...

Does it reads as "Mini-Progenitus"? He is extremely hard to die!

Who play moat today?

Wake up！Merfolks are not slivers. Could you also ask wotc for merfolks who bring “destory artifact or enchantment etb”and“t to add 1 mana of any color” to all merfolks?

Tidebinder Mage
UU 2/2
Creature - Merfolk Wizard
When Tidebinder Mage enters the battlefield, tap target red or green creature an opponent controls. That creature doesn't untap during its...

What is the reason to choose Aquetect's will over Spreading seas?

Maybe the "extraordinary" number of creatures, could bring higher chance to ensure having a merfolk on board.