Search:

Since Wizards seems to like the general idea of quasi-remakes of Reserve List cards lately, how terrible or busted would the following be?

Survival of the Unfit
:1::g:
Enchantment
:g:, Discard...

Well, Black does it too: Praetor's Grasp (EDIT: yeah, just realized you said without paying, oops) but I agree, I think it is OP then. As it is, I think that would be playable, since it is near a...

I think the UB one should be "Sword of Dreams and Nightmares" and "Return target nonland permanent to owner's hand." A la, Consign to Dream (but nonland is pretty much needed, so it isn't a lock)....

No offense meant, but this is kind of uninspired design, it is literally just Sword of Light and Ice.

You got some unique abilities on the others, but this one seems to drop the ball.