Search:

Only 3 Chalices?

Depends on combo: in my experience the worst is Omniscence because S&T doesn't care about Chalice or Trinisphere, and you cannot hide under a bridge as you could against Sneak&Show

Versus the...

For any of you that wants to splash red: years ago I played a version with some equipments (batterskull, sword of fire and ice, jitte, graves, ecc..) and a couple of godo, bandit warlord. Even if he...

I completely agree: I prefer having another fatty (possibly a second copy of sundering titan or a platinum emperion) than the blighsteel since it feels good only if it has haste but, as Rikter said,...

I'm not playing much magic recently, but I've got the intention to make and hybrid MUD/eldrazi stompy (i've already got a list but it's quite unrefined), because I too think tha Seer and Smasher are...

Quicksilver Amulet >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Triassic Egg

Welcome!

I personal never tried Phyrexian Portal because I don't think that this deck can survive 2 turns without doing nothing: first you cast the portal, then the following turn you tutor a card...

About Titan's Presence, what are your thoughts about it? 3 mana should not be too much for us and it exiles basically every creature given you have a creature in hand.

Do you think 2-3 copies will...

While Rage Extractor and Smokestack both do nothing the turn they comes into play, the former needs phyrexian mana cards to do something, while the latter is a lock on its own, so I don't think they...

I like the idea and in the past I wondered about it as well. Porcelain Legionnaire and slash panther are good enough to be played in vintage in some versions of MUD, although the former because is an...

I played dodecapod in the past and while your statements are true unfortunately it's almost always smaller than Tarmogoyf. That's the reason I stopped to play them.

Makes sense: currently I have sleeved up MUD and Shardless Bug, and I choose what to play at each single tournament. But I'm forcing myself to only those decks for the reasons you posted before

Pros.

In a format in which the mana curve leans on 1 and 2 mana spells you can play chalice of the void on turn, which effectively shuts down many of the most played and succesful decks of the...

I used to play razormane masticore in my stompy build (no forgemaster) as a sideboard card (two slots): it was solid in the match ups where it was needed, but the drawback can sometimes "lock" you...

But wouldn't the addition of Daretti, which actually draws cards, help with the variance issues (provided that the curve would be lowered even a bit)?

That's basically how I would like to use...

That's the same thing I'm coming to realize: on the mana base depends the choice of the spells, so if you go for the 12-post route you could aford to play high CC cards (you can do this even without...

Same here.
I think Daretti does everything that MUD wants (card selection and gives another use to spent monoliths and extra chalices and trinispheres, not to talk about the ultimate), and it's a...

Good old stompy list: I approve it.

I always thought that this deck is better played as stompy because I feel the combo is too fragile, so in the past I opted for a similar list splashing red for...

I will not dismiss biskelion so easily, but it's true that revoker stops its primary function, leaving only a beater which the deck has already a sufficient number.

The thing is that revoker stops...

I think that the commander cards will.be illegal.

Sent from my mobile, forgive me for grammar errors.

Are we talking about this list?




If that's so I think you are mistaken: this list is not MUD because it lacks metalworker, this list is not MUD because it doesn't have prison nor combo...

I agree with Alex about lodestone: as written in the past, it's a card that doesn't really advance the game plan of kuldotha builds and can be a little too slow for combo matchup. It's the backbone...

Before talking about how to side you should ask yourself "why I've put these cards in my side?". I'll try to guess:
revokers - they come in against combo (stops LED, belcher, petals, sneak attack,...

I think that there are too many decks based on creatures for gaining advantage from thorn.
It's a fine sideboard card though

Sent from my mobile, forgive me for grammar errors.

Chalice is invaluable and the first reason to play this deck to begin with.