Search:

i think also yawgmoth's bargain is fine for 6 mana drawing one card for one life is too expensive and wouldn' t break the format
peer into the abyss is just one more mana and win right there

ragavan is just a better card than drs which is banned in legacy.
see in vintage where ragavan sees more play than drs right now

yeah Underworld Breach is tier one but why not just ban led ?

the problem with what you are saying is that show and tell wins if not COUNTERED while with tinker you have much more answers you have also removals ; meaning you have no dead cards in your deck to...

Just cast your one mana sword, your two mana diabolic edict in this term show and tell is much more problematic cause griselbrand or omnisience is GG and it doesn't even produce card disadvantage.
...

I am on the contrary for the ban of goblin recruiter, but tinker is safe because it is card disadvantage, most decks have answered to the creature/artifact you go for cause it doesn't produce an...

Can you tell me which artifact is not answered by sword/council/command/disenchant etc... ? There are two memory jar which is banned and sundering titan. If you except sundering titan tinker is fine....

yeah tinker is safe recruiter isn't

goblin recruiter is unfair cause it is game with food chain yeah, you search for your deck and just win next turn exiling recruiter for 4R casting ringleader*4 have an hasty warchief and win with...

it was back in the time of food chain gobelin so food chain+recruiter is game over and recruiter on himself is very good.

Food chain in play cast recruiter and nex turn you draw 16 gobelin and...

you don't need an additional card you search for ringleader put it on top with others gobelin and start your chain.

Can someone tell me what you get with tinker that wins the game ? Everything...

yeah just go ringleader put it on top and you draw 4 goblin that you have chosen each turn

Tinker is card disadvantage except if you go for sundering titan other way show and tell is better cause it wins if not answered (omniscience and you just win) ; tinker you get a creature it gets...

I am personally convinced tinker is a good unban while memory jar is banned. All you get is card answred by swords to plownshares/edict except for inkwell leviathan which is a three turn kill slow...

I think you could add dark depth and led in the list. As for myself I don't find TNN and terminus (now that top is gone) broken.
But if DRS get banned reanimator (so you would need to ban grisou)...

there is the CONSISTENTLY and through HATE which intriges me. I didn't say it can't kill turn 3 I said that most of the time it can't and surely not CONSISTENTLY and through HATE.

So I have found the list from extended scourge here :
http://www.starcitygames.com/magic/extended/10649_Evolution_Minds_Desire_in_Post_Rotation_Extended.html

Are we really scared of this deck in...

Yeah so please post your list. I don't see how IT is going to give you 5 mana.
Something like that wouldn't work to me :

4 DR
4 CR
4 GP
4 CabalT
2 tendrill
4 BS
4 Ponder

Yeah fox I know how mind's desire works. The question is : would storm be playable with MAINDECK 4 empty+4 tendril+4 mind's desire +4 others 4-6cc+ bombs cards. You need at least 18 WINNING TARGETS...

It is a 2cc card which does close to nothing on his own. If you are gone play the 3cc combo squirrel stuff good luck with your pile !

We already have lot of better decks and this deck would be...

Memory jar is not that broken when we have 2cc griselbrand through entomb. 5cc just draw is not good enough for this format, will see some light play but not more.

Mindtwist I see this card could...

Just 4 sotf 4 vengevine and some fauna shaman in ELF cutting glimpse and some others elfs.
You have acces to survival+NO ftw