Search:

This considerations are sound, but I agree only partially because:
- with things like all spells you instantly lose if you don't have an answer, with ragavan you don't (and please, all spells was...

I love posing as a contrarian (in this case, pretend -not even so much- ragaBan could remain in the format)



WHY?

I mean, about "Those non games shouldn't exist". WHY?!
I could say those...

Except you can't cast a card that's already in your hand using LED mana.

Don't be too quick to think the joke is on blue players.
Once, turn 1 game 1 of a big event in Italy, I vendilion clique'd my opponent on his draw step and won because he drew a card while having...

Not that I am in principle against the ban of anyone among Astrolabe, Veil and/or Oko, but pages of discussion and expectation for the next monday announcement and nobody names the elephant in the...

Man, in the comment you were replying to I had just told you I was not speaking of moon deck at all! LOL :cool:
I just cited in my reasoning moon IN the five colours good stuff deck :tongue:
If you...

Maybe I have troubles explaining myself in english since I'm not native spekaer, but I was pretty sure I never said Red Stompy decks were kept in check by Astrolabe.
I just said I find awful you can...

The first is just your thoughts (which I think it's obviously wrong: as if perfect mana fixing at no cost apart from having a deck with less than 60 slots maindeck -but hey! that's un upside too)...

Maybe I shouldn't have dig out again that thing, but fetchlands aren't really the main problem here and clearly Astrolabe is; simple "proof" is, nobody ever played competitively -that I know of- five...

The card that should be banned, the sooner the better, is Astrolabe.
Just check this high GP finish (37° among over 1600) by Niklas Holtmann:...

Maybe certain format expectations are precisely the reason why people play Legacy instead of something else like Modern and Pioneer.
In fact you yourself have to admit:

So with you faboulous...

When Dice_Box speaks you surely find interesting things. TNN may be a "bad taste" card but at least try to use some real argument.


Is there really? If your in the wrong colours your answers are...

I agree with all that you say except for this last part: traditional Zoo (read: Naya, be it fast or big) is obsolete because now the best aggro creature is delver, and nemesis brickwalls you. (Please...

FLAME PLEASE!
Ah, the smell of napalm in the morning!

The best decks in legacy might not be playing-brainstorm

What a pity.
(Yes, that's a flammable :tongue: comment, but since there is again someone speaking of brainstorm :cool:)

https://magic.wizards.com/en/articles/archive/news/november-26-2018-banned-and-restricted-announcement
Next B&R Announcement: January 21, 2019

I'd bet maybe changes (both bans and unbans...

I reply since it almost seems to me as a debate with creationists :tongue: :cool: :laugh:
Or maybe this blue fanatics do see the format for what it is, and simply denounce the opposite POW...

No they don't. If you ever play blue, please continue keeping this one-lander ponder, so you'll continue losing. And even more certainly, brainstorm DOES NOT let you keep one lander, because you then...

Double posting since you edited yours after mine above :cool:


I think you have highlighted the core of the disagreement. (By the way I am following the format since I started playing again in...

Thank you for your very positive post! Just throw name at people, attack some straw man, and don't bother giving some real argument.
I feel exactly the same from the opposite point of view: people...

Actually, how much you suppose they are overperformin is pretty relevant for at least two reason:
- a little overperformance is arguably a problem
- a little overperformance could just be "noise"...

No it wasn't and this shows precisely my point.
My data was just a single tournament admittedly, but at least for THIS tournament it shows that when you CAN do the analysis, blue decks DO NOT...

It's wonderful and it's precisely why I am beginning to think I could play pauper as well :laugh:
Alas, I'm afraid January will see the ban of gush and/or foil and/or gitaxian.






...

Once again, Birds gets it[/QUOTE]

If this kind of reasoning was true, then since not every deck has use and space for brainstorm, the card must have its drawbacks. Get this brainstorm haters! We...

Congratulations, you just admitted cheating.
Infraction procedure guide (October 2018)
3.3 Tournament Error — Slow Play (Sanction: Warning)
Definition: A player takes longer than is reasonably...