Search:

Hey, there was mine too!

Yes, definitely wasn't good :)

My thought on this were that Thassa's oracle was perfectly fine, you could still win with it but extremely unlikely it could be good - and that the season was underway, I already had received WoP...

My apologies, I should have written here.

What first happened is that you were the only one to send me a deck before the deadline - you won our MU 6-0 btw, and your deck would have beaten almost...

With the (current) special rule, crack the earth works normally as long as the opponent does not only have lands. The opponent can chose to sacrifice either a land or their other permanent. It is not...

Well, crack the earth would be crazy good, one sided innocent blood that can take artifact/enchantment.

That might not sound so scary, but it would change from "what happens if hand and lands are...

Sure. You're the second to raise concerns over Saga, so let's do your phrasing.

I would say yes to both.



Exactly:)



Yes

I should have answered sooner, sorry!

Start date, Thursday April 30th, at 19h CEST!
Like this we have a bit of time to fix and decide things.





Fully agree, but that's part of the fun!

Thanks for the feedback!

Here is what I am proposing for the next 4CB season. Let me know if you would like it, and/or if you want to change something.

Format: legacy. All legacy legal cards are legal.

Special rules:...

It seems there is a general consensus for a backbuild banathon season.

I can start one soon, with a first deadline in a month for Summer break.

Everyone would be OK with that?

Thanks a lot Asthereal, these seasons were an absolute blast for me :)

I think we can just take the MTR rules then?
It seems clear enough.

And so we draw with Rooster, right?





I would really like that (having to beat all precedent winning decks) as well,...

1. Asthereal (TO): Blooming Marsh, Chatter of the Squirrel,
Pendelhaven, Mind Rake
3-3
3

2. alphastryk: Pendelhaven, Urborg, Tendrils of Despair, Chatter of the Squirrel
3-3
6

3. dte:...

Sure for >3.
Bannathon and having to beat the decks 1-3 also are a bit synergistic, so you cannot reuse any of the cards of the decks everyone is trying to beat.

We still ban every deck that scores 3+, that should avoid that the same bad threats are played over and over ;)
Maybe I am wrong, but then it can probably be fixed mid season.

Already 5, very...

Great you like it!

I am pretty sure that then a few strategies more (less?) powerful would evolve and regularly come back.
But the biggest reason to ban each card is to prevent anyone to run the...

I did not realise the deadline / lists publication was tomorrow*for the last round.*
Meanwhile I wanted to talk about the ideas for the next season.
Also there was this proposition from Phasmoid:
...

Edit: fully answered above. Timestamps prime.

And what happened in Silk vs Rooster, with Rooster OTP?

Does Alpine moon naming port makes it unable to make squirrels, even if nest is played afterwards?

This is where I am not sure about...

@Phasmoid: I agree with your analysis, you should WW our MU.

On the other hand, pact is an instant, so you have to play Otawa, so you should DL them?

@Rooster, OTP shouldn't you get draws vs FTW, Reeplcheep and alphastryk?

I do not get this.
Silk does not care about nest, because moon beats it?

Silk OTD:
T1 land
T1 land, token 1/1.
Now Rooster can play a nest, but the moon next turn will not let it make...

1. Asthereal (TO): Angel's Grace, Pact of the Titan, Pact of the Titan, Rustvale Bridge
3-3. Discard all T2 or lose.
3

2. dte: Blooming Marsh, Chatter of the Squirrel, Pendelhaven, Mind rake...