Search:

I’m a little bit sad to come back and find out this isn’t a real deck anymore 😢

What up fellas, I've been away for a while.

So, first of all, I was wondering can someone post the sideboard that Saito ran, or a link? I'm having a hard time making some of the stuff out in that...

At everyone advocating Cavern of Souls...

I'm not saying it's necessarily wrong to use Cavern, but since when has this deck really cared about getting its creatures counterspelled?

Actually I was saying Chalice is a good sideboard card. And Mastery and Brainstorm probably deserve maindeck consideration, in the interest of revamping the deck a little bit, trying something new,...

I like Chalice (and anyone that wants to dig through this thread can see that Chalice has actually seen some fringe use in this deck for a long time now.) But I think it's more of a sideboard card...

I will admit that I haven't tested Merfolk in a while, but if Batterskull/ SFM are really our biggest obstacles these days, has anyone tried testing 2 or more copies of Tower of the Magistrate in...

What equipments do you use in that build? How many copies of SFM? How many merfolk? And with all that, is there room for StP in the maindeck?

It seems like he could be a pretty good inclusion,...

I'd be interested to hear what you think of Brainstorm after some testing. I think it could be potentially worthwhile in a splashed list. But to answer your question towards the end now: No. I...

I'm really not so sure about all this talk of going to less than 4 Reejereys. Using his trigger to alpha strike for the win or to untap and cheat extra fish into play has just happened too often for...

I'm really not so sure about all this talk of going to less than 4 Reejereys. Using his trigger to alpha strike for the win or to untap and cheat extra fish into play has just happened too often for...

So, I was wondering the usual "can I get some feedback on my sideboard" question that seems to pop up every page or so on this thread. I'm playing a conventional list with no Standstill, and my free...

This. Basically, Illusion provides raw speed, while Metamorph gives you flexibility and a little more resiliency (I would argue it's less resilient than it looks compared to Illusion though, since...

I guess the question is, wouldn't Phantasmal Image usually be better than the Phyrexian Metamorph, even with all the Grim Lavamancers running around these days? I feel like having a cheaper overall...

@ Chuck:
My bad... I thought you were one of those people who refute conventional statistical analysis with straw-man type of arguments like "You aren't more likely to draw 'Card X' on any given...

I guess I was a bit impolite earlier; my bad...

However, what Chuck is saying still doesn't make sense. This is because each copy of Standstill is functionally identical in your deck-- "SS1" and...

This makes no sense. Go play some Magic and stop talking out your ass.

I think the one main problem with Standstill as a sideboard card is that you want 4 copies if you're using it, IMO. This is because in games where it's good, you basically want to drop it as soon as...

Totally agreed, 'nuff said. Adaptive Automaton will help some decks; this is not one of them because we already have better stuff. But Automaton, I think, will show up in Legacy, and is gonna help...

Totally agreed, 'nuff said. Adaptive Automaton will help some decks; this is not one of them because we already have better stuff. But Automaton, I think, will show up in Legacy, and is gonna help...

Not digging Turn to Frog. But that squirrel is effing amazing!

Highly controversial?

If you just want to win, and that's your meta, I agree with Taco that you would be better off playing a different deck. Maybe it's just me, but from the description you give I think I would play some...

To answer your rhetorical question: I'm pretty sure no, it's not gonna be. Massacre seems so wrong for this deck I actually assumed it was a mistype, but I'm not sure. Perish is, obv, a way better...

Seems to me like Propaganda looks pretty hot in that meta. I count about 8 out of 12 of those decks that it would hit pretty well.

Also, just as a general question for everyone, I've noticed that...

Well, I wouldn't suggest trying Vedalken Shackles if I hadn't tested it a fair amount. I'm not pretending it's perfect, or if you'll notice, even necessarily advocating it, but I do believe it's a...