Search:

Curse of Death's Hold is kinda up in the air after Splendor came out. I think with Plague Engineer in so many lists, people are steering away from lists that have too many X/1's.

I'd probably...

Really would suggest at least something to lock against Storm or other non-creature combo in game 1. I don't like having to rely on constant supply of discard. 3 cmc "can't lose" Gideon and/or...

Bahra mentioned that Cavern naming Human was huge throughout the challenge. 2x Cavern to enable some powerful tools might should be something to explore. Perhaps more Trackers could be fit in. I...

I believe the most powerful thing about combining with Scapeshift is that you get to use one Wish early for control - grabbing Therapy or removal essentially. Then your 2nd drawn Wish is ready to...

I've seen: Therapy, Innocent Blood, Subterranean Tremors, Lost Legacy, Toxic Deluge, Slaughter Games, Tsunami, and Pyroclasm. Probably lot of talk about it if you search the thread for Scapeshift. ...

Most people I've talked to don't seem particularly impressed. I wouldn't mind seeing it 1-2 of at most to beef up the number of GSZ. There are certain situations where they are very similar. ...

Still very hesitant to be so on board with the Forests-double-mana static ability. You want to include Terastodon/Primus/Progenitus? Sure, but that sounds like a NO Nic Fit list and would be a new...

Actually think I might prefer the Girl to the Wurm. Against Elves, DnT, and a pile of Emptied goblins...that one mana can mean the difference between getting the effect in play vs dying from the...

Nicely done :)

Dovescape is imo way better than people give it credit for. You are afraid of dying to opp spending 1 card to get 1 bird? At least that's what typical cantrip is going to be. ...

For better or worse, most folks moved over to the discord.

I've played her in lists with Titania and Trackers.

The issue with Safekeeper + Ramunap + ??? is like...it's a bit over the top. Safekeeper to protect something that will win (???) ((unless you...

If you're in fair Junk, I'd be even tempted to run 2 of them maindeck. Card is pretty insane upgrade over Rec Sage.

Fair Junk with Archons? Maybe I could be tempted back to it.

I think I lost only 1 game where I resolved Dovescape, and it was at a point where nothing else would really have won.

It can really depend on your list though. Lingering Souls creates 6 birds...

Agreed that carpet is usually better. I do like carpet sometimes against tempo decks - oft times threshold/delver just dies on the spot if you can just resolve one high-cmc spell. ...

Welcome!

The 6 Rector / Eureka list posted above is probably a bit closer to what you might be having in mind. Check out the posted Sneak Attack lists and you'll see that there are many many...

Agreed that we shouldn't leave interesting stones unturned. I'm curious in general about a more reactive blue nic fit shell with a large Wishboard - whether it be Nyx or not. At first I was...

Very nice! Glad it ran well for you. I experimented with a Helm list for a few online leagues. Was quite nice hitting storm and dredge.

How did you like the Ob Nixilis? I enjoyed Nissa, Vital...

100% this.

BUG is the one that imo is least defined. Million ways you can build it.

Too many variations, and this list is just myself cherry picking the versions that stick out to me as having...

You may be surprised by the ability of the deck to handle combo and obscure matchups, but I will leave that up to your own testing. Quite a number of times I've been able to squeak out Dovescape...

What I've been on for a while. Feel free to sub Pushes for Swords if you want more ways to kill Rector. I don't think they are that necessary and I've liked being able to handle Anglers and Marit...

There's an option for a sideboard fatty to bring in as a GSZ target as a secondary plan in post-board games, that has already been on our agenda for awhile. Sigarda, Titania, Carnage Tyrant, take...

Have you tried Nyx Fit? Can attack a diverse/unknown meta simply because it has an answer for everything. Academy Rector for Dovescape, Overwhelming Splendor, or Cruel Reality/Sandwurm Convergence...

It'll happen sometimes.

In my Nyx List I really did enjoy having 1 Guile to go alongside the couple of Libraries. Think about the timeline of your play. Sometimes you can manage Deed on turn 3...

Would mainly agree here, definitely for game 1 at least. Deck has ~24 ways of getting a creature on-board to sac (though that drops to ~16 if you've run out arbor already) and doesn't take long to...

That is curious, I might try that out. I've been on 3 swords, 1 decay, 2 brutality, 2 deed for a while for removal. 2 library, 1 guile, 3 leaps with 3 souls. I did like it back when I had 4 souls....