Search:

YES. Count me in for a Large.

I think that the only question before us is whether or not the ability to just kill the opponent outright is worth the stretch in consistency.

Against both Storm and High tide, the fact that I...

What surprises me the most is how much people don't know how to play against Dredge, honestly. It's not really a secret deck or anything, but people punt all over the place. It's pretty amazing. I...

I played RT's list of Manaless Dredge to 19th place at SCG: KC, 6-2 record.

Round 1: The Mirror. Yes, I'm serious. Nice guy. He wins the die roll and chooses to draw. I drop my head and smile....

My current build is a more dedicated Swath list:

4 Steam Vents
4 Sulfur Falls
4 Scalding Tarn
1 Island
6 Mountain

4 Sleight of Hand
4 Desperate Ritual

Perhaps he did just have the nuts, but your experience is different than mine. They have a fast combo with Lim-Dul's Vault finding the pieces on turn 2, Cloud of Faeries to untap the shelldock for...

Hey guys,

I finished 15th at SCG KC this past weekend with Non-LED Dredge. Decklist available here: http://sales.starcitygames.com//deckdatabase/displaydeck.php?DeckID=36127

Went 6-2, 1 loss...

Nature's Claim, Nature's Claim, Nature's Claim. I love the deck, but Nature's Claim is the anti-hate card of choice in my opinion. It functions similarly in Dredge, for those of us that choose to run...

Not necessarily; I've been boarding Nature's Claim/Chain of Vapor, but I really like the fact that if you have leyline and you play carefully, the only card that can beat you is Leyline of the Void...

I maindeck 1 Terastodon, and I would never take it out. There's a ton of Jace/Foundry decks in my meta, and they all have one of silver bullets starting in G1 like Moat, Academy Ruins with EE and...

Do you want to move the 4th tutor back? It seems like it has more value as a wish target for storm chains. I'd go with 1 or 3. And I'm definitely going with 4.

I've been testing your list for a few days, admittedly against idiots on MWS, and I like Unmask a LOT more than I think I'd like therapy. That one mana is godawful important sometimes, and you never...

Absolutely seconded. Someone make the shirt!

No one has touched this thread for awhile, but there's something I've been kicking around in this deck, hell, pretty much in all my painter builds - Reap.

For those that are as old as me, there...

Has anyone considered Mirror Entity in the deck?

The obvious benefits are mostly because he can be vialed out against Massacre/Pyroclasm and save the board, plus he provides a better clock against...

While correct some of the time, most of the U/B HulkFlash lists I've seen are running two body snatchers. Should you wait this long with your seal and target the Karmic Guide, the proper play is not...

Short answer - No.

Longer answer- chalice for one hurts flash, at least the disciple version. But testing has shown that you can't pull off enough disruption to win.

You have no discard. You...

Sigh.

And, despite the copious and dripping amount of sarcasm in your post when all I asked for was a clarification on an issue that is tantamount to resolving the deck's kill conditions...

Um...

As I stated before, I understand the body snatcher- but if you don't have a creature in hand to discard, you have to RFG it, thereby bypassing the graveyard and going straight to d'ohville....

Okay, you're missing what I'm asking.

The Karmic Guide's trigger uses the stack. What I'm asking is, if in response to the trigger, before the hulk enters play, the opponent plows the guide. The...

I have a quick question, more a bit of understanding;

If they point the plow at the Karmic Guide in response to the CIP trigger, do you then sac the hulk to get body snatcher? What if you have no...

I think that most of the salient points on both sides of the 'will Hulk Flash dominate' debate have been put forth at this point.

What I'd like to do is debate two things on the thread, if...

I actually don't disagree with you, Hanni. I think that, and I'm including myself in this, a lot of playtesting has gone into this format with one of the few large-scale Legacy events of the year...

Although the point has been made before, I believe it bears repeating: unbalanced tier one decks in any metagame are not cause for celebration.

There seems to be a component of players who don't...

[QUOTE=CalebD;126563]Piracy charm has shown up in some thresh lists too. I tested it in this deck for a while, but it ran into my chalice one time too many. [QUOTE]

I'm not sure I understand this....