Search:

Type: Posts; User: blacklotus3636

Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4

Search: Search took 0.01 seconds.

  1. Poll: Re: Would you like to see True-Name Nemesis gone?

    I like this. It also proves how much things have changed. I remember it took about a month or so for people to figure out how nuts goyf was and now, he's been outclassed...by a blue creature. To be...
  2. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    I really wish people would comment with something meaningful to progress a constructive argument rather than just name call people chicken little.

    @Scott:
    TNN defenders won't believe the card is...
  3. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    I think your argument is thin. In essence you are trying to say mental misstep>FOW or Daze. Does this line of thinking make sense to anyone?
  4. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    I'm a little irritated with all the people who are like, "oh no! A 3/1 that can't be targeted! I'll just kill with griselbrand or emrakul!". If this logic were true then mental misstep would not need...
  5. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    1 person played 4, 2 played 3 and the other two played 2 copies. The person who played 4 ended up in the finals and the 2 who played 3 ended up in the semi finals. Its 14 total and the more copies...
  6. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    Wow, 5 of the top 8 were playing TNN. That's even more than I thought it would be. Since it became legal its had 3 of the top 8 as a minimum but 5 is the highest I've seen it from the major...
  7. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    Using this logic there is nothing wrong with mental misstep. I mean we already have force of will which counters anything for free and mental misstep goes in all those same decks. What's wrong with...
  8. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    I think this is probably the strongest argument against TNN. Wizards is very concerned about, "unfun" cards. I think the finals match at DC may be quoted as part of a reason for banning come December...
  9. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    Seeing as how it was one of the most played cards at the grand prix according to wizards and ended up in 3 of the 8 decks in top 8 I would say you're very likely to see TNN. However, if toxic deluge...
  10. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    You got me on that one. I tried getting a hellkite before the tournament but I couldn't buy him locally or trade for him in the last week because he's somewhat obscure and underplayed. That would...
  11. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] True-Name Nemesis

    I don't appreciate the attitude but the substance is on the mark. I admit as most fair minded people would that there is insufficient evidence at this point to propose a banning. However, I have to...
  12. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] Identity Nemesis

    Its not just 'my deck' that has a problem. I play many decks and unless you're combo you usually can't stop it because there are only a handful of cards in the format that kill it. All the cards you...
  13. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] Identity Nemesis

    Yes, blightsteel does trample over. Here's what happens:

    Him: land go
    Me: land go
    Him: land brainstorm
    Me: Metalworker go
    Him: true name go
    Me: kuldotha forgemaster go
    Him: play and equip...
  14. Replies
    913
    Views
    195,748

    Re: [SCD] Identity Nemesis

    SCG Dallas was yesterday and first place was playing U/W stoneblade with 3 true name nemesis. There were 8 total true name nemesis's(nemesi?) in the top 8 but considering over half the top 8 was blue...
  15. Replies
    3,880
    Views
    1,243,455

    Re: [DTB] Team America

    @Catmint
    I think its dumb to say that a more controllive version of BUG is strictly better. Leaving out stifle and daze in my meta which is predominantly combo would be a terrible decision. Of the 8...
  16. Re: 4th at Gunslinger Games Dec.3rd in Dallas, Texas with Skinshifter in Team America

    @bignasty 197
    Yea, wasting the green screwed me with the shifters but I honestly think they are better against a deck with large creatures because in many cases if a creature is a 5/5 or 6/6...
  17. Replies
    3,880
    Views
    1,243,455

    Re: [DTB] Team America

    Instead of thinking about it try it out. Tarmogoyf didn't look all that great either until people starting working him into some decks and seeing how good he was. I'm asking you to give that same...
  18. Re: Being On Fire: 7-0 with Grinding Station

    Congrats on the wins. The name made me think it was some kind of weird new deck that used grinding station but from what I saw it seems to be ANT. Its a good deck and everything but it doesn't look...
  19. Re: 4th at Gunslinger Games Dec.3rd in Dallas, Texas with Skinshifter in Team America

    @Di
    You were the Spring Tide player I played in round 6? I had no idea. I've seen you on the boards here for years and I always thought you were one of the smartest guys on here. I don't fault you...
  20. Replies
    3,880
    Views
    1,243,455

    Re: [DTB] Team America

    I just finished 4th with this deck at a large 34 person tourney in Texas with this deck but I chose skinshifter over tarmogoyf for synergy and overall utility. I was hoping to have a discussion about...
  21. Re: 4th at Gunslinger Games Dec.3rd in Dallas, Texas with Skinshifter in Team America

    @Esper3k
    Give drew a special hug for me:)

    @brainwasher
    I'm not disputing whether goyf is strong in Team America. Everyone knows its strong in most decks its played in but in the testing I did...
  22. 4th at Gunslinger Games Dec.3rd in Dallas, Texas with Skinshifter in Team America

    Back in September Gunslinger Games held a huge legacy tournament for a beta savannah. I wanted to play but didn't have the time necessary to do research and playtest as normal because of college. I...
  23. Replies
    62
    Views
    17,317

    Re: Time Spiral

    Time spiral seems fun until you remember it costs 6 to cast. I remember years ago it was banned but in a format where natural order wins the game for 4 mana time spiral seems slow. The only way I...
  24. Replies
    42
    Views
    12,835

    Re: Competitive Mill

    It looks ok but highly situational. Obviously its nice with the fetchlands but if the deck ever becomes a contender then people will be mindful of it. Besides, think about how many mill spells you...
  25. Replies
    1,533
    Views
    370,730

    Re: [Deck] Faerie Stompy

    I was curious if anyone has tested esperzoa. It seems like everyone just sort of wrote him off without really seeing how good he is(or isn't). When I tested him he felt alot like sea drake. I could...
Results 1 to 25 of 218
Page 1 of 9 1 2 3 4