Search:

Draw card if Life Total > [highest CMC card remaining in deck] + 3 (if red mana available to opponent).

Doesn't sound so significant to me.

Wilder Nacatl [G]

When Wilder Nacatl enters the battlefield, you may choose to have it fight target creature you don't control.

Wilder Nacatl gets +1/+1 for each basic land type among lands you...

The next Commanderesque side-set is gonna be Modern legal :laugh:

I agree Legacy doesn't make them money which only undercuts some of the comments we've seen in this thread about this being some kind of cash grab.

While they might not, relatively speaking, make...

Per usual, there's a lot of unrealistic takes in this thread. They aren't going to take drastic measures that will completely change the entire metagame. Naya_Creatures.dec will never be a thing....

That's kind of my overall gripe with the game in general.

In the early years, they kind of just made random cards without any overall theme and left the players to build decks using whatever...

When you make arguments to "score points" rather than have a genuine debate, it is rather pointless isn't it? No one is talking about Mirage fetches other than to say they are the historical...

I can't understand what you wrote here.



Who said anything about Mirage fetches?

Hit the nail on the head. This is all that needs to be said on the subject. Don't like fetches? They already banned them in Pioneer. Have at it.

That's a fair point but ultimately the point is that those cards are getting printed to a much larger degree as of late.

This is the best take in the thread on this topic. I'll just add that if Tombstalker was blue it would have been relevant until Murktide was printed.

Not sure what you mean.

I wonder how much of this is due to them deciding that its not fun when both players run out of resources so lets make an obscene number of cards that instantly replace themselves.

I've played off an on since the late 90s but when I say new I mean starting with MH1.

Personally, I think Legacy Horizons would be heinous. Modern Horizons is already bad enough. These horizons...

Then we're mostly in agreement. My original point was that the newly printed creatures are not what caused non-blue aggro to fall out. It's only gotten more ridiculous/apparent now because Delver...

Sure. But those didn't become unplayable because of any of the new creatures being printed. They became unplayable because the whole format is way more powerful and plain aggro just doesn't work...

Yup. Unfortunately, if you ban Daze and Wasteland you would probably have to sit there for 2 years banning a ton of suddenly too degenerate strategies and probably end up in a spot looking like...

In world where Murktide, DRC, Delver, and TNN don't exist, Nacatl doesn't suddenly become playable. You explained why those cards are playable: they are backed up by pitch counters and cantrips.
...

I don't really understand the complaint about beat sticks. Should that just not be a thing in the format? Look at the top list of creatures played in Legacy. Its almost entirely comprised of value...

Don't think you can really call either DRS or Monkey definitively better or worse. DRS shuts down graveyards, which Monkey does not. Monkey provides potential card advantage if you get lucky on...

I think you can safely assume that is going to be the norm for MH moving forward.

"We want UR tempo to be a thing in Modern"

"OK. Print it up."

They are highly likely to follow this...

The worst thing was the printing of the card. You're mistaking the correction for the bad act.



Bad analogy / false dichotomy. You correct shitty game design from happening in the future by...

Why would you assume the format would become balanced by banning the two best cantrips? For example, what happens if after that non-blue Wasteland, Chalice, or Depths decks are dominating the...

Or just play Modern if that's the format you want.

Honest question: if they banned Brainstorm would the meta change all that much?

Four Brainstorms becomes four Preordains. The decks running Brainstorm will lose a few % points to the non...