Search:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mRe8J4scGtU

But they are the Emperor Palpatine in the shadows behind the Darth Maul that just got killed.

About as safe as drinking gasoline.

As much as I agree with the sentiment of "Not being able to resolve spells sucks", CounterTop is a functionally superior Chalice that lets you change the number of counters on it at instant speed for...

From the Vault: Mistakes



Because everyone loves watching their opponent stare at the same three cards for 10-20 seconds multiple times within each and every turn. It's like when an NFL team...

Not to mention the other card printed to punish Top, Deathrite, and ever-present fetchlands: Harsh Mentor.

They just banned Top before Mentor got the chance to prove himself.

Chalice in Xerox?
Perish in Elves?
Canonist in Storm?

The world is upside down.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QM2zcv5AfaM

I member.

First, I was simply attempting to provide an example for personal preferences in deck selection, regardless of who the player is. The assumption that both are just as likely to win was presented as a...

Assume one player has access to both Miracles and Sneak & Show, and that both are just as likely to win the tournament.

"Miracles will be a boring grind all day, I'll go to time a few times, and...

Allowing them to play around things like Choke and Winter Orb also. Gush is too many tricks in one barrel.

I'll admit I never saw Gush in action in a competitive format, so I have no comment there, but those other two longshots are never coming off the list. I do remember Gush enabled the 'other Forces'...

Demonic Cantrip
Sorcery, B
Draw two cards, lose two life.
~this~ can't be cast unless you control a basic Swamp.

There's a template for you, regardless of playability in the format. I could...

Funny how you can deduce what people are playing based on what they hate about the format... myself, for instance, I think True-Derp shouldn't have been printed. Maybe that doesn't scream D&T by...

They both apply then lol.

Tax/Rack was considered pretty broken in it's day. Both those cards are still legal, and nowhere to be seen, despite the former coming off the banlist. Also, Chalice has been run since it's printing,...

Here's the thing: If CB were broken, people would still be playing it. IMO Top was the right call, even if it hurts other decks.

Abzan? Pshaw. I still call it Rock.

/signed

If a solution is indeed necessary to punish greedy manabases with RainbowXerox.dec, I don't think banning cards is the right one. I'd vote for some good old fashioned efficient land destruction....

Racist? So blue is 'persecuted' and every other color is 'priveledged'?

Insert Willy Wonka sarcasm meme.

I've decided I'm going to count silently to ten, then begin audibly counting upwards while staring at my opponent if they go into a deep tank without the board state changing. Some people try too...

I refer you, sir, to the title of the thread.

"Banned List Speculation"

So it's a versatile card that has various applications, and not all of them include casting it. The same could be said of many other cards. Probe being used to enable delve only highlights how broken...

Probe being one of the many cards that enabled the broken delve cards does not make Probe itself broken. Baubles enable delve too, are they broken? The interaction between Probe & Therapy isn't...