Search:

Ban Vial lol. I can't tell if you're serious or not.

I think we need a bit more time to see if Deathrite is banworthy or if the meta will correct itself. GP Madrid team trios just finished and there were 3 chalice decks in the top 4 (2x red, 1x...

So is this thread is turning into the MTGSalvation modern banlist thread? Lets ban everything that's not interactive! Lets ban everything that's not fun for your opponent! Guess what? Some people...

Guys, we've gotten off topic.

I for one, think Brainstorm should be banned.

Discuss.

Lol if we apply the "fun" reasoning to Legacy, we will end up with a format similar to Modern where kiddies from standard don't like getting Grapeshot to the face for 50.

Too much effort. Just cast Show and Tell.

Who's eligible to vote? Hopefully not 2016 sourcers.

Embarassing ;)

Did you really compare fastbond to summer bloom lmao.

You mean bad-rituals are too good for modern?

Having Amulet or Bloom on a banlist in any format is pretty embarrassing for that format.

I wasn't really saying it warranted a ban. I was simply comparing it's power level to something already on the banlist.

Why is Channel banned and not Show and Tell isn't? Don't they basically do the same thing?

With such a huge card pool there will always be combo decks and thus people will always play blue -- in their combo decks and against them. By your logic we should have a 300 card banlist which would...

I'm there to beat people playing turn 1 mother of runes.

He's a D&T player. Should stick to Standard.

Why? Because it doesn't fit your "fun" criteria?



I do.

Oh, and attacking with 12 goblins twice can be considered two instances of interaction.

Since when is "fun" a requirement? My turn 1 Belcher meeting a Force of Will isn't fun. Ban Force of Will?



I'm pretty sure casting Mind Twist is fun so your argument is flawed anyway.

Delver is the "go-to" deck for people who don't know the format. Why can't we factor this in? I was merely stating that if you show up to a reasonably large tournament you'll face tons of bad Delver...

Should I cast Delver turn 1 or pass?

All this aside, I'm pretty sure the cards safe to come off are Mind Twist and Earthcraft. Earthcraft would fit nicely in Enchantress, making it do what it wants to do faster by letting you untap...

It wasn't a joke though :P

He pithing needled LED. Storm player goes off the turn after. Judge had to come over and explain that Needle doesn't do anything vs LED.....so he casts Stifle.

Let me clarify. Most Delver players are mouthbreathing mongoloids who's results are carried by herpderp 3/2 flying for U with free spells (see: SCG circuit) (also see: the 7-0 BUG Delver player who...

Play Storm and crush Delver?