Search:

Why Sacred Mesa over Sigil? Other than Humility I see no reason for this really. Sigil ends the game quicker 99% of the time which can be huge with a deck like this where you are sure to find...

How can you justify running 4xSeal of Fire but not a single Words of War?

Island Sanctuary is a pretty poor replacement for Moat because Moats biggest strength is that it allows you to lock down many creatures while still drawing cards for turn so you can use it in...

Interesting take on the deck. If you're going all in on the combo route I guess that seems like the way to build it but how are your results and why not just play a "real" combo deck at some point?

I run too many fetches to play Suppression Field. I've seen it in list before and never liked it, seems to hurt us as much as it does them most of the time since it slows down Words of War quite a...

I personally wouldn't sideboard in 4x Leylines if the only thing in the opposing deck they are going to stop is 4-8x discard spells. Discard isn't that big of a deal to me really unless it's backed...

I wouldn't go so far as to say I endorse Trap I just think it's a better SB than Leyline when it matters. So if you're worried about Storm that's probably the way to go. At the same time storm is...

Never been a fan of Leyline. It's only really good against Storm decks and decks we already have a favorable matchup vs. (burn for example) and I'd really rather have Mindbreak Trap if those decks...

At one point I was a fan of 2x Sigil but no longer. 2x win cons is fine. As has been said you have no problem finding them when you are ripping through your deck and if they get answered you have...

I agree with most of what Spatula says.

I do disagree somewhat on hands with no Enchantress and Guile being more or less automulls. I've personally had plenty of success with hands with no...

If you want to go that route I've had as much success as anyone in significant tournaments with the deck. I think you need to look up straw-man argument since I never went there. I'm just getting...

Or I could have been referencing the fact that 90% of the "new" innovations people bring up every other page have been discussed roughly 100 times already. Feel free to search this thread for...

1: I'd recommend testing that. I did and it was terrible. Drawing 2 Moxes before turn 3 sucks.

2: I'm fine sometimes with zero out. I think a lot of people only look at the deck from one...

1: Tournament reports are only as valuable as the hindsight analysis of card choices they provide, unless maybe they perform well in which case the list can be analyzed in that light. Most people...

It's not fair to say Top is better in games that go 5+ turns. Guile is better early game when it needs to be and if the game goes late you probably got more use out of it than you would have Top. ...

It's not an improvement over Mirri's Guile and Guile is not an underpowered card.

Early game you can drop Mirri's Guile, dig through your library and not waste mana that you should be using to...

I wouldn't even say I don't like it, I'd say I outright hate it. I mean for myself, really I could care less if other people want to run subpar lists, if Enchantress starts putting up enough results...

I wouldn't name Brain Freeze with Nevermore unless I had a Sterling Grove down already to protect it. Obviously you name Brain Freeze with Runed Halo unless maybe you have an Emrakul MD in which...

I wouldn't name Brain Freeze with Nevermore unless I had a Sterling Grove down already to protect it. Obviously you name Brain Freeze with Runed Halo unless maybe you have an Emrakul MD in which...

I have actually found Deed to be instant lose G1 a lot of the times. I mean sometimes you can power back from one or Replenish and get back in the game but it's by far my worst nightmare beyond...

I've been working on Enchantress for around 2 years now, after very thorough testing of 2-4 Mirri's Guiles I've found 3 to be the perfect number. Granted lists have won without Guile, but on the...

I have a little bit different numbers personally

Cards I don't consider to have a variance MD, meaning if you don't play exactly this # you are doing Enchantress wrong in my opinion.
2x Replenish...

Karakas is only really needed vs. Reanimator and sometimes random jank like Show/Tell or maybe Dredge. I'd sooner stuff 4x Karakas in my sideboard then even consider running Crop Rotation. If you...

Yeah decking anyone with Enchantress seems shaky at best.

Wheel is not the best graveyard hate in the game for sure but it is one of the best options for us for a variety of reasons. Wheel is...

Yeah that was me. Truth be told I was hoping MM wouldn't be banned in which case I'm pretty sure I would have easily made top 8. Hell I should have anyways since I was the only X-1-1 not to make...