[M12 Cards]

[HdH_Cthulhu]

yadda yadda yadda

the manacost is the only thing what is not broken! Rly strong effect. Abuseable in many ways, madness, gy strategies and even simple CA

[Darksteel]

what rarity is this being printed at?

Looks like it's a rare. O:

[TheInfamousBearAssassin]

the manacost is the only thing what is not broken! Rly strong effect. Abuseable in many ways, madness, gy strategies and even simple CA

However, manacost is what usually determines actual power level. At that cost I think Magus of the Bazaar would be better in any graveyard strategy, and that card doesn't see play.

[Beatusnox]

Possible two card combo with Molten Psyche. But that is more of a standard fantasy than legacy actuality.

[colo]

Stonehorn Dignitary 3W
Creature - Rhino Soldier
When Stonehorn Dignitary enters the battlefield, target player skips his or her next combat phase.
1/4

I guess that will make Venser (the PW) see some play after all, but most probably not in Legacy. :)

[Gheizen64]

yadda yadda yadda

blue is overpowered etc

ジェイスの文書管理人/Jace's Archivist
クリーチャー- ヴィダルケン・ウィザード/Creature- Vedalken Wizard
,:
各プレイヤーは自分の手札を捨て、その後これによりいずれかのプレイヤーが捨てたカードの枚数のうち最も大きい枚数に等しいだけのカードを引く。
,T: Each player discards his or her hand,then draws cards equal to the greatest number of cards a player discarded this way.

「これは聖なる責務だ。師ベレレンの信頼こそが、私の永遠の忠誠の源だ。」
2/2

Artist:James Ryan 59/249

Windfall Spellshaper. Anyone yet unconvinced R&D loves them some Kool aid?

Hey, i could have been printed in red for some kind of cool pseudo wheel effect but no, let's give retarded effect to blue and blue only! Sigh.

Not that the card is good (a tad too slow for combo, magus of the bazaar is better for dredge etc), but for god sake.

[DrJones]

I think R&D gives blue this kind of stupid effects because in previous incarnations they were fine compared with the rest of stupid effects that were printed on the same set. I call it the Dragonstorm syndrome.

My eyes that are used to see balanced cards hurt by just looking at this card.

[Barook]

the manacost is the only thing what is not broken! Rly strong effect. Abuseable in many ways, madness, gy strategies and even simple CA

It's pretty much instant win with Mind over Matter once it's active. Too bad MoM's mana cost sucks.

[rufus]

It's pretty much instant win with Mind over Matter once it's active. Too bad MoM's mana cost sucks.

Necrotic Ooze+Devoted Druid
Though that's inferior to other ooze options.

Maybe with Magus of the Jar,Shallow Grave and Corpse Dance?

[Sims]

I think R&D gives blue this kind of stupid effects because in previous incarnations they were fine compared with the rest of stupid effects that were printed on the same set. I call it the Dragonstorm syndrome.

My eyes that are used to see balanced cards hurt by just looking at this card.

I'm just trying to make heads or tails of this post. Are you saying that the previous incarnation was fine (Windfall?) or are you referring to the previous incarnation as Magus of the Bazaar?

[Cire]

Another blue card

Lord of the Unreal UU
Human Wizard
All illusions have +1/+1 and hexproof
2/2

Yeah i know there are no (or few...i forget) good illusions out there, but combine with Mirror entity, the entity itself gets +1/+1 and hex proof and has this ability "0:creatures you control become 1/1's with hex proof." Then you can simply wait around with your untargetable army (you can always use the ability again for 0 mana in response to removal in response to your initial application of the ability....that makes sense although i said it in a profoundly stupid way i think) until you have enough mana to simply make your creature's bigger.

Add in the ussual Blue mix of counters and draw maybe mystic and swords (it's hex proof not shroud)... and there you go.

[Humphrey]

If Id run a tribal with shrouded Mirror Entitiy, Id play faeries with Scion of Oona.

The Windfallguy sucks, its slow and the effect hardly abusable.

[bakofried]

It will be to Windfall what Fauna Shaman is to Survival, so shut your complain-hole, Jones.

And it's a blue ability (Windfall) not a red card (Wheel of Fortune) before the whole color-pie argument starts up.

[DrJones]

I'm just trying to make heads or tails of this post. Are you saying that the previous incarnation was fine (Windfall?) or are you referring to the previous incarnation as Magus of the Bazaar?

Magus of the Bazaar, which was the one IBA mentioned.

It will be to Windfall what Fauna Shaman is to Survival, so shut your complain-hole, Jones.

While it's reasonable to think this way, I see one potential problem in that Windfall was not a repeatable effect, while this one could easily be one.

[trivial_matters]

If Id run a tribal with shrouded Mirror Entitiy, Id play faeries with Scion of Oona.

Scion of Oona only gives other faeries +1/+1 and shroud. This guy is strictly better with Mirror Entity because he protects himself too.

[Cenarius]

Another blue card

Lord of the Unreal UU
Human Wizard
All illusions have +1/+1 and hexproof
2/2

Yeah i know there are no (or few...i forget) good illusions out there, but combine with Mirror entity, the entity itself gets +1/+1 and hex proof and has this ability "0:creatures you control become 1/1's with hex proof." Then you can simply wait around with your untargetable army (you can always use the ability again for 0 mana in response to removal in response to your initial application of the ability....that makes sense although i said it in a profoundly stupid way i think) until you have enough mana to simply make your creature's bigger.

Add in the ussual Blue mix of counters and draw maybe mystic and swords (it's hex proof not shroud)... and there you go.

They do already have a Warchief.

[Atwa]

yadda yadda yadda

blue is overpowered etc

ジェイスの文書管理人/Jace's Archivist
クリーチャー- ヴィダルケン・ウィザード/Creature- Vedalken Wizard
,:
各プレイヤーは自分の手札を捨て、その後これによりいずれかのプレイヤーが捨てたカードの枚数のうち最も大きい枚数に等しいだけのカードを引く。
,T: Each player discards his or her hand,then draws cards equal to the greatest number of cards a player discarded this way.

「これは聖なる責務だ。師ベレレンの信頼こそが、私の永遠の忠誠の源だ。」
2/2

Artist:James Ryan 59/249

Windfall Spellshaper. Anyone yet unconvinced R&D loves them some Kool aid?

This thing is soo going to be in the Memory Jar.dec EDH list i'm putting together at the moment. Windfall every turn with Megrim/Lilliana's Caress on the table? Yes please....

[bakofried]

And yet he does not have haste; so on top of needing to protect him from counterspells, one needs to deal with Pithing Needle, Phyrexian Revoker, and all forms of creature removal. There's enough options out there to deal with him, in several different colors, so he shouldn't make a huge splash.

[nedleeds]

This thing is soo going to be in the Memory Jar.dec EDH list i'm putting together at the moment. Windfall every turn with Megrim/Lilliana's Caress on the table? Yes please....

Just play Chains with him. Then play out of your graveyard. You mind twist your opponent and mill him for X on every activation.

[edgewalker]

Another blue card

Lord of the Unreal UU
Human Wizard
All illusions have +1/+1 and hexproof
2/2

Yeah i know there are no (or few...i forget) good illusions out there, but combine with Mirror entity, the entity itself gets +1/+1 and hex proof and has this ability "0:creatures you control become 1/1's with hex proof." Then you can simply wait around with your untargetable army (you can always use the ability again for 0 mana in response to removal in response to your initial application of the ability....that makes sense although i said it in a profoundly stupid way i think) until you have enough mana to simply make your creature's bigger.

Add in the ussual Blue mix of counters and draw maybe mystic and swords (it's hex proof not shroud)... and there you go.

A lot of the illusions that have been printed have some pretty decent bodies compared to their cost. The only problem is they die once they're targeted. This guy seems like a neat interaction with that