[Brainstorming]A deck without synergy...

[bowvamp]

Have you ever felt that, "Oh this card (combo/single card) is so good, even on it's own, there's just no way to make a list of 60 that supports it", feeling? I know I sure have.

How about throwing together random permutations of these cards, and trying them out? Basically making tons of good-stuff lists might actually net us a "better stuff" list.

So let's get started, shall we?
(note: cards w/o descriptions are those that have been "reserved" by the first person to request them on the list)

The singletons

// White
Deftblade Elite
Harm's Way
Island Sanctuary
Mana Tithe
Oblation
Perimeter Captain
Sidewinder Sliver
Survival Cache
Timely Reinforcements
Tithe
// Red
Control of the Court
Custody Battle
Firestorm
Karplusan Wolverine
Scent of Cinder
Skred
Tunnel Ignus
Warmonger
// Green
Birthing Pod
Durkwood Baloth
Golgari Brownscale
Mirri's Guile
Omnath, Locus of Mana
Three Visits
// Blue
Cerulean Wisps
Chronozoa
Glen Elendra Archmage
Land Equilibrium
Looter il-Kor
Rhystic Study
Rimewind Cryomancer
Vision Charm
Voidmage Husher
// Black
Maralen of the Mornsong
Spinning Darkness
Salvage Titan
Soul Reap
Spoils of the Vault
Vendetta
Vengeful Pharaoh
Volrath's Dungeon
// Hybrid & Multicolored
Guided Passage
Jagged Poppet
Wood Sage
// Colorless
Lux Cannon
Plague Boiler
Sun Droplet
// Lands

Combinations
This section has no color classifications because many combos span multiple colors.

Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth + Spreading Algae
Mishra's Bauble + Urza's Bauble + Disciple of the Vault
Serum Powder + Chancellor of the Dross / Chancellor of the Forge / Chancellor of the Annex / Chancellor of the Tangle

Loam Dweller / Rootrunner / Elder Pine of Jukai

Remember, when adding cards to the list, please make sure that it isn't a card that supports an archetype. These cards and combos are based specifically on the idea that throwing together a list of good stuff that isn't good elsewhere can be feasible.

This also doesn't mean that your deck list has to be entirely constructed from cards on that list. Of course if you have enough blue cards you'll run FoW. Ofc you can run the stuff you want in addition to the original flavor.

Edit: Umm, excuse me? This isn't really intended to be casual or budget. Yes, some of the stuff is quite hokey but that's the idea. I'm not posting "my mill list 2011", and berserk stompy is still in established decks afaik. I explicitly mentioned that this was about not gimping your deck, but making a strong deck from a hodgepodge of randomly good cards.

[bowvamp]

I'm reserving this post for successful lists.

Successful Lists

[bowvamp]

I'm reserving this post for lists under development or testing.

Testing & Development

[Mikeleroi]

Well, using some of the white singletons, you can check the thread "Soldiers!".

You have deftblade elite, (perimeter captain was an option, but finally dind´t include it) and tithe. And it has harm's way and mana tithe in the SB.

I would include Kazandu blademaster on the list with cards so good.

[bowvamp]

The idea is that you don't build the deck around an idea. Soldiers isn't what I'm going for, hence the high number of non-aggressive soldiers included.