Show and Tell ban - including a poll

[Tao]

The SnT discussion only distracts from the real offender, the overpowered Brainstorm. Banning Brainstorm would significantly weaken unfair Combos as well as RUG Delver without killing them.

[JACO]

Ah yes, the old "OMG, THERE'S A NEW TIER 1 DECK WE NEED TO BAN" rant. I was wondering where all the Modern players got it from.

Yeah, I thought there was a moratorium on assholes starting new threads every week asking for something to be banned.

[csy]

moderators need to crack the ban whip and thread lock implements out. this is almost as bad as a post on the diablo gen forums about error 37.

[Humphrey]

ban Brainstorm

[csy]

if they banned brainstorm Id cash out and only play vintage.

[Phoenix Ignition]

I really hate whoever decided those choices were good. It's along the lines of:

Choose one:
I'm going to vote for Mitt Romney.

I love terrorism and will therefore vote for the Muslim who wasn't born in America.

[honestabe]

http://memegenerator.net/instance/21340244

[baghdadbob]

I like show and tell as an archetype. I think it is fair and can be answered if it has to be. There seems to be a lot of decks in the meta that are all built in response to meta problems. In my opinion this helps create a healthy format like the one we are in now. The only problem I can perceive is guys playing u/w/x delver decks. Get some creativity dawg, and consider sterilization.

P.S. Also hivemind-esque decks are much more broken than show and tell decks.

[majikal]

P.S. Also hivemind-esque decks are much more broken than show and tell decks.

Am I actually reading this or have I lost my fucking mind? Hivemind is a Show and Tell deck.

[Humphrey]

if they banned brainstorm Id cash out and only play vintage.

how to cash out and play vintage dude? You almost need the same stuff, lol
Also I dont know many places where you can play vintage.

Seriously, Brainstorm is the most broken card in the format. There is a reason why Ancestrall Recall is banned, you know?

[Sloshthedark]

brainstorm... blah blah bla

banning it kills combo decks, and all the fun.... just play modern

[Nihil Credo]

beeeeep - metaposting to magic-posting ratio exceeding safety limits - beeeeep - activating safety locks - beeeeep