I know that what I'm going to say is extremely unpopular for all magic players, but I do think that chinese and Japanese cards are overrated. I love them, but nowadays everybody seems to have those. To me, portuguese or French cards are more rare to find and have some awesome text to pronounce (which always leads to hilarious mispronunciations). I have a weird sense of humor I know.
Language is all in the eye of the beholder but I think people would agree Spanish, French, Port as a whole are the least desirable and most sale prices bear this out. One experience was being in France for BoM and the poor French guys trying to trade French cards and basically nobody in the room wanted them, Spanish dudes, 'mericans, Germans, UK guys etc.. Then you had the Russian guys walking around with their little 4 up binders with russian foils asking the moon and hardly anyone acquiescing. I had no problem trading my chinese cards to german guys for german stuff straight up. English traded at market value.
In fact, most of French cards are mistranslated. In France, two cards can have the same name without being the same card. For example : Upheaval & Discombobulate both are translated in "Bouleversement" in French... And it happens many times.
Believe me, even if now French cards are more expensive than English ones, I still prefer VO!
Asian cards, japanese and korean in particular, were highly sought after because of aesthetics and scarcity back in the day due to far east location being isolated and all. The text on japanese cards were thin (easy to tell them apart a few feet away), unique and being unreadable made them especially appealing. The number of players actually playing japanese cards didn't help the supply either. Korean had a very limited run and the language was discountinued somewhere after the Tempest block that is when the demand skyrocketed, though reintroduced in 2012 are still hard to find outside of ebay.
European languages on the other hand are readable. I don't care if russian scarcity is due to hype or not but, stand a few feet away they look like any regular language. That makes them less appealing to me, aside from they can't match my old-border japanese foils. There are reasons why you see more asian cards nowadays, they are valued more as needleds exemplified. I've seen vintage cards altered to japanese, never in any other language.
A few days ago, I played against a United Nations deck that looked like it included some of every possible language. I actually thought it was really cool. Each turn was a little surprise to see what kind of words would be on the stack, and it looked really interesting on his playmat.
I swear to god, my OCD would turn nuts.
I'm struggling with german miracles w/ english Council's Judgment.
Some of it is also about what you started collecting, so if you got the Japanese itch (STD?) and spent time procuring those back in the mirage days you might just want uniformity. Japanese has pretty good reach also, going all the way back to Chronicles / Mirage.
Or Two Card Monte (Painter + HelmLine + Vault Key + Forgemaster to find them all). That deck needs Urborg just to tap Workshop for activation mana. Personally, I like using Chromatic Lantern, since it's castable from Workshop to begin with and accelerates you and casts Welder.
West side
Find me on MTGO as Koby or rukcus -- @MTGKoby on Twitter
* Maverick is dead. Long live Maverick!
My Legacy stream
My MTG Blog - Work in progress
Recieved these two from kidicarus, keep playing WB cards in my ANT, haha!
Team Blood, Beijing.
Currently play: Sneaky Show/ Lands
Not my favourite arts, but still gorgeous pimp. It's like the completely chrome Fisker Karma that roams about town. Totally unnecessary, but nice nonetheless.
-Matt
I haven't resolved a good Channel in sometime. What a fisting that card is.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)