PDA

View Full Version : [Report]2nd at German Legacy Champs with Solidarity.



Van Phanel
09-02-2008, 10:03 PM
I played at German Nationals this weekend and after a 4-4 drop and a day off I got to play at the Legacy sideevent on Sunday. The deck I chose was Solidarity, which is totally underrated nowadays. Sure, it loses to Counterbalance every now and then. So what. Counterbalance can be beaten sometimes and Solidarity doesn't have any other unwinnable matchups either. This was my list:

3 Polluted Delta
3 Flooded Strand
12 Island

4 High Tide
4 Brainstorm
3 Opt
1 Peek
4 Reset
4 Impulse
3 Remand
2 Brain Freeze
3 Meditate
3 Cunning Wish
3 Turnabout
2 Cryptic Command
4 Force of Will
2 Flash of Insight

SB:
1 Stroke of Genius
1 Brain Freeze
1 Meditate
1 Turnabout
2 Wipe Away
3 Echoing Truth
2 Hydroblast
2 Twincast
1 Hurkyl's Recall
1 Rebuild

About my cardchoices:

3 Opt/ 1 Peek: Opt is better at fixing landdrops and you never want multiple Peeks. This could be a 4/0 split.

3 Remand: Remand sucks against anything playing Daze and it is not that great against Spell Snare either. Also Tarmogoyf often comes down before you hit 2 lands.

2 Cryptic Command: This card is the most flexible blue instant imaginable. Whenever I play with it I feel like it was made to fit into Solidarity.

SB:
2 Hydroblast: There are less Goblins lately and I have never met more than one Burn in a tournament. Still those two remaining Hydroblast stay in because they are also good against TES, Belcher, Aggro-Loam. Against Goblins boarding 2 Hydroblast is enough if they don't have Chalice. and if they do boarding bounce is better than more Hydroblast anyway.

1 Hurkyl's Recall: As this was a sideevent to German Nationals I expected constructed players to participate with their Extended-Affinity builds with added Fling and Disciple.



145 players participated and this is the tournament from my point of view:

Round 1: Linus (U-W-b Cunning Landstill):

He doesn't apply any pressure and I can combo him out without a missed landdrop on turn 7. He has Spell Snare, FoW and Academy Ruins in play but that doesn't stop me from Stroking him out.

- 1 High Tide, - 1 Force of Will, - 1 Reset, - 1 Impulse
+ 2 Twincast, + 1 Echoing Truth, + 1 Wipe Away

He starts and keeps a hand with two Factories as his only lands + Tormod's Crypt. At some point he gets an Island and a Tundra but on six life I have a Wipe Away on one of them and go off in his next drawstep. When he fails to counter more than two times I am able to Brain Freeze his library away.

1-0

Round 2: Phillip (G-b-w Survival)

I keep an opener with 2 FoW and 2 Meditate and Force his turn 2 Survival. On his next turn Therapy resolves (naming High Tide) and I play Meditate in response to his Flashback. He takes the other Meditate and plays Witness for Survival. I have another FoW for it though and he can't do anything but beat with his Witness and a Faerie Macabre. At some point on 7 life I find High Tide and go off. I get to Flashback a Flash for 8 and stack my bottom seven so I could Brain Freeze + Remand + Brain Freeze myself and then kill him with those seven. My Remand draws Cunning Wish though and I am able to kill him right away.

- 1 High Tide, + 1 Twincast

I keep 2 FoW again and he takes a High Tide away with Thoughtseize. This doesn't stop me from Forcing both his Survivals as I know from Peek that he only has two lands and two Birds of Paradise left. He doesn't draw any more action but I do and I can easily kill him some turns later.

2-0

Round 3: Christian (Dragon Stompy):

I keep a one-lander in game 1 only to fail in finding my second land in Opt + Brainstorm. He also lands a Chalice/1 and adds a Magus of the Moon and Gathan Raiders. At some point I do find land and Cryptic Command for his Chalice. In response to his replayed Chalice I have to go off on four lands and manage to resolve High Tide + Reset + Meditate. I know my bottom cards from Flash of Insight, but to get there I need an untap and anything with "draw a card" written on it somewhere in a Flash for 2 and a flashbacked Flash for 8. I find 2 Islands in that Flash for two and lose.

- 1 Peek, - 1 Impulse, + 1 Echoing Truth, + 1 Hurkyl's Recall

I mulligan to five and he starts with a first turn Chalice/1. He doesn't apply to much pressure at first but then has three morphs. All three happen to be Gathan Raiders when he discards three cards to have hellbent. When I show him the Echoing Truth I have since the beginning of the game he doesn't look very happy. The turn after this I draw my fourth land so I can counter his topdecked Seething Song and bounce his Chalice with Cryptic Command (he has only one mana left). On his next turn I go off in response to his replayed Chalice.

He has a first turn Mags of the Moon with a pitched Spirit Guide and I have to FoW because I hold 2 Deltas and one Island. He doesn't have another play for two turns, only a Rakdos Pit-Dragon on his turn 4 which I Remand while he has to sacrifice his City of Traitors. He plays some more spells but before he gets even close to lethal damage I kill him.

3-0

Round 4: Pascal Tschirner (Goblins):

G1: After a FoW on his Lackey he applies like no pressure and I only have to go off on turn 8. I manage to see 23 cards between Meditates and cantrips and then look at a hand of 3 Reset, 2 Turnabout, 2 FoW and 5 lands. As I have resolved two Meditates I can't even use my Turnabouts as Time Walks and I am dead.

- 1 Peek, - 1 Impulse, + 2 Hydroblast.

G2: He starts G2 with a Piledriver. After an extremely bad Brainstorm I mill myself for nine with a Brain Freeze and hit one Cunning Wish. At this point I feel pretty secure with FoW + Hydroblast in hand but he has two Earwig Squads. I can only deal with the first one and the second one takes all my winoptions away.

3-1

Round 5: Dennis Sinner (Affinity)

In G1 I can Wish for Hurkyl's recall and still don't fnd a High Tide. I try to go off without it but don't have enough mana.

+ 1 Hurkyl's Recall, + 1 Rebuild
- 1 Cunning Wish, - 1 Cryptic Command

I keep a probable turn 4 kill and find Hurkyl's Recall in an Impulse. When he goes for lethal I bounce all his Artifacts and he can only Fling me for four so I am still save on 11 life. Three turns later when he has recovered I get to kill him.

In game 3 I have a pretty good opener without High Tide but with Rebuild to buy a lot of time.

4-1

Round 6: Dennis Rosinski (Aggro-Loam)

Some turns into game1 I go for a Cunning Wish and realize that my sideboard Meditate is missing. I call a judge and get what I deserve: a gameloss.

In the nest game I pitch a Brain Freeze to FoW early on and Wish for an Echoing Truth to answer his Chalice when he resolves Burning Wish for Cranial Extraction. I can Remand this once but then it resolves. He names Cunning Wish so I have only one Brain Freeze left but that is enough to finish him two turns later before his Goyf would be lethal.

- 1 Peek, - 1 Impulse, + 1 Echoing Truth, + 1 Hydroblast

I stop hitting landdrops after my third and hold High Tide, Reset, 2 Meditate, Turnabout and FoW. When he goes for a Chalice/1 on his turn 5 I Force it pitch Turnabout but he has another Chalice. I have to go off in response but my Meditates hit mostly spells so I have no problem with finishing him off.

5-1

Round 7 against Daniel Scherer (Adan) (NQG/w)

I know that both Adan and his deck might cause problems so I offer him a draw (we could both try to win round 8 for top8 then) but he declines as he seems to feel pretty confident. I do what I can to encourage him by calling him a very good player (he actually is good, so that was no lie) and acting as if I wasn't liking my chances at all in order to get him to play without much thinking and to maybe make mistakes. Actually I think that this matchup is only slightly negative and can totally be won, especially thanks to Cryptic Command. He starts the game with Counterbalance which resolves and adds Top. At first he doesn't find creatures and then he only has a single 1/1 Mongoose which attacks eight times. At this moment I hold High Tide, Meditate, Impulse, 2 Turnabout, Cryptic Command and FoW. I could go for the win by bouncing his Counterbalance right there but that would lose to double-FoW as I could only counter back once. So I decide to play Turnabout to tap his lands at his eot as I think it's very possible that he might Force if he has more than one FoW. And actually he does Force it. That means that I go for Cryptic Commmand at the end of his next turn and bounce his Counterbalance. He FoWs, I FoW back and Command resolves. He had played Tarmogoyf that turn so he has to tap out to look into his Top at the end of my turn and I take the opportunity to go off at the end of my turn as I know that he won't be able to counter. I already have the Brain Freeze and when I hit Remand after some cantripping I am able to mill his library away.

- 1 Remand, + 1 Wipe Away. I consider to board out another Remand or a Turnabout for an Echoing Truth against Gaddock Teeg but decide against it.

Adan starts game 2 with a 3/4 Tarmogoyf and tries to play Gaddock Teeg on his turn 4. I Remand it, he Forces my Remand and that means I get to Force his Gaddock Teeg. He doesn't do much except playing cantrips and a Counterbalance when I am on 5. I can counter it and bounce his Goyf with Cryptic Command in order to gain one more turn and in this turn I go off. After I have resolved a Meditate and Flashbacked Flash I reveal the Brain Freeze and tell him that I can win by milling everything except the cards known from Flash and kill him with those and he concedes (I had exactly the kill I described).

6-1

Round 8: Ralf (Dragon Stompy)

We are the two players with the worst opp-score among the 6-1-players and one of us would be out with a draw so we have to play. When he opens on Ancient Tomb + Chalice/1 I feel relieved as he has flashed a red card during shuffling and Dragon Stompy is a rather good matchup especially with three lands, FoW, Wish already in hand. He gets to play two morphs and only flips one of them so I guess the other one is an Akroma, Angel of Fury which he can't flip because he only has one Mountain and three Ancient Tombs. He even resolves a Chalice/2, but I Wish for Rebuild, bounce all artifacts one turn later and win another turn later.

- 1 Peek, - 1 Impulse, + 1 Echoing Truth, + 1 Hurkyl's Recall.

I keep Island, Brainstorm, FoW, High Tide, 2 Remand + one other card. This hand is a little bit risky but autowins if the Brainstorm finds a second land. I do find that land and my Remands buy a lot of time and he can't do much except beating with a Magus of the Moon and playing a Chalice/1. When he adds a Jitte I have my Hurkyl's Recall ready and bounce both Jitte and Chalice. In response to his replayed Chalice a turn later I play High Tide + Meditate + Opt and find 2 Brain Freeze but no other carddraw. I count and see that I would need one more storm to outright win and fake that I fizzled. I tell him in a disappointed tone that his Chalice resolves, he'll beat for two and he'll replay his Jitte (he couldn't equip it because he only had five mana available). He does so without thinking, I thank him and Brain Freeze his library away.

7-1


Top8:
Quarterfinals: Alexander Gierse (R-b Goblins)

I have the FoW for his first-turn Lackey, but he has some other goblins. When I sit on four lands I already face lethal damage without holding High Tide so I play a mainphase Meditate in order to hit another landdrop. This works and in his drawstep I play Reset, Meditate, Reset, Impulse and still don't see High Tide. The following Brainstorm doesn't show one either and I lose.

- 1 Peek, - 1 Impulse, - 1 Cunning Wish, + 2 Hydroblast, + 1 Echoing Truth.

He starts with a Vial and I could probably win on turn four. He doesn't do much except a Piledriver and later a Ringleader and I have both Cryptic Commands so I can easily win on seven lands.

I keep a hand with High Tide, 2 FoW, Brainstorm and let his first-turn Vial and second-turn Piledriver resolve. His Matron on turn three gets Forced though and my hand starts looking good. He beats me to three in his turn 5 and has five lands so I start my combo in response to his Vial-trigger on his turn 6 as a Siege-Gang would have killed me. I play High Tide + Turnabout + Meditate and find my boarded Echoing Truth. This means that I bounce his Vial and combo on. When I have enough stormcount I Brain Freeze him for his library and we proceed into his drawstep. He did have the Siege-Gang.


Semifinals: Mike Hofmann (Scepter-Burn)

Because of 4 Price of Progress and Isochron Scepter main this matchup should be better for me than usual Burn, so I'm rather confident.

In game 1 he burns me to 14 and then plays a Scepter with Shrapnel Blast. I Remand it once when he sacrifices his Great Furnace and it seems he doesn't want to sacrifice his Scepter yet when he Incinerates me with three land in play. That is a bad decision though and I show him why by countering his Incinerate and bouncing his Scepter with Cryptic Command. This slows him down so much that I have enough time to combo him out without fear of lethal burn.

- 1 Cunning Wish, - 1 Impulse, + 2 Hydroblast

He starts with Mishra's Factory and again has Scepter that I bounce with Cryptic Command. When I am on four I have to go off but don't find anything in a Meditate so I have to tap his Factory with Turnabout and play a Hydroblast for nothing to avoid manaburn. In his extraturn he attacks me to two and plays Incinerate so I FoW and go to one. In my last turn I only draw the other Hydroblast and his Factory kills me.

In game 3 he mulligans to five and starts with a Scepter with Red Elemental Blast. I bait him with a cantrip and get to bounce his Scepter again with Command. A turn later when I am on 16 I hold the follwing cards: High Tide, Reset, Turnabout, Brain Freeze, Remand, Remand, FoW. I ask him hom many cards he has left and he replies six. I say: "That was not what I wanted to know but it's interesting as well." He counts and has 48 cards left in his library. If he has no or only a single Red Elemental Blast I can kill him and I decide to go for it. I play High Tide, Reset, Turnabout, Brain Freeze, Remand, Brain Freeze, Remand, Brain Freeze, his library is gone and I win.


Finals: Andre Baetz (Black Thrash alias Negrow)

This is the worst matchup out of those Top8 that could happen to me and I know I'll have a hard time. In game one he double Thoughtseizes me and adds a Goyf. When I try to go off on five lands he has triple Daze my High Tide. As I only hold Turnabout as an untap, I have to FoW his third Daze and he has a FoW of his own (with pitch the fourth Daze).

- 2 Remand, + 2 Twincast

He starts applying beats pretty fast with double Yixlid Jailer and I sit on four lands. The turn before he'd go for lethal I play an Eot reset to draw a Spell Snare out but he lets it resolve, so he probably doesn't have one. I play Meditate, he FoWs, I FoW, he FoWs, I respond with Reset and Twincast the Meditate. I find a third Reset but my only other relevant card in hand is Brain Freeze. I neither have enough stormcount to deck him, nor can I try anything else so he wins.


Summed up it was a pretty successful tournament for me and even if I repeat myself, I think that Solidarity is underrated. Sure, it has problems in today's meta, but they are not unsolvable. It does require very tight play though and the ability to Jedi-Mind-trick people into play mistakes doesn't hurt either (see round7).

Props:
+ 145 participants
+ Cryptic Command! (I can't belive how people don't like this)
+ Solidarity in general
Slops:
- The player that got Dq'ed for stalling
- Marius Hausmann not making it to the finals


- Van

J.V.
09-02-2008, 10:15 PM
Congrats on the finish.
[Somewhere, Gearhart just came]

thefreakaccident
09-03-2008, 03:15 AM
I actually find that FT and solidarity are the two most skill intensive decks in the format, the fact that you are able to consistently do well with the deck is a monument to your skill as a player, which will reward you in the future.


I only need a few cards for solidarity again, perhaps I will give FT a break and build that up again.

Elfrago
09-03-2008, 03:42 AM
Congrats on the finish.
Very impressive!

deviant
09-03-2008, 06:45 AM
Extremely impressive Van Phanel!

Extremely impressive indeed. We solidarity-players are very fortunate that you don't do better in main events :D

Oh yeah, and I agree with you about Command. It's my pet T2/block card so I tossed it in Soli as soon as you recommended it and it's been doing well. Added bonus is that no-one has yet played around it, but unfortunately you seem to be determined to change that ;)

Seriously though; great report and congrats for doing well again.

Van Phanel
09-03-2008, 06:58 AM
Extremely impressive Van Phanel!

Extremely impressive indeed. We solidarity-players are very fortunate that you don't do better in main events :D



Oh, really?

Check out GP Brussels (http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Events.aspx?x=mtgevent/gpbru08/stand15) and GP Madrid (http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Events.aspx?x=mtgevent/gpmad08/stand15) (I'm Simon Ritzka). /brag



Congrats on the finish.
[Somewhere, Gearhart just came]

lol

deviant
09-03-2008, 09:19 AM
Oh, really?

Check out GP Brussels (http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Events.aspx?x=mtgevent/gpbru08/stand15) and GP Madrid (http://www.wizards.com/Magic/Magazine/Events.aspx?x=mtgevent/gpmad08/stand15) (I'm Simon Ritzka). /brag




lol

I know very well who you are :)
Don't get too flattered now but you are one the names I check in the coverages.
Just remembered that when I looked at Copenhagen standings I thought:
"Great! Side-event report!"
And same thing at the German nats:
"Yay! Go Soli!"

EDIT: Which is to say: keep up the (legacy side-event) good work :D

Bahamuth
09-03-2008, 11:16 AM
You pretty much convinced me on Command. I'm going to play the same list as you in my next tourny, except for -1 fetch +1 island.

If going to a random meta, what would you put in the Recall/Blessing slot in your sideboard? Another Hydroblast?

Nihil Credo
09-03-2008, 07:22 PM
Whoohoo Tide!! And the cycle begins anew. I'd expect Goblins to start putting up more Top 8s again, except they never really went away in the first place, so whatever.

Also this:


All three happen to be Gathan Raiders when he discards three cards to have hellbent. When I show him the Echoing Truth I have since the beginning of the game he doesn't look very happy.

Did you take a picture of his face? Because you totally should have.

Van Phanel
09-03-2008, 07:23 PM
I know very well who you are :)
Don't get too flattered now but you are one the names I check in the coverages.
Just remembered that when I looked at Copenhagen standings I thought:
"Great! Side-event report!"
And same thing at the German nats:
"Yay! Go Soli!"

EDIT: Which is to say: keep up the (legacy side-event) good work :D


Better be careful. I think one Solidarity-player with an incredibly huge ego should be enough. :wink:


@Bahamuth: I'm not sure. An additional Remand/ Hydroblast/ Twincast/ Wipe Away or many different cards could be useful. I'd also consider Repeal (not as Wishtarget but rather to board it) which is great against Threshold and Dreadstill while also useful against Confidants and Vials and I also liked the Hurkyl's Recall as additional Mass-bounce. I personally would probably go with the Hydroblast for an absolutely unknown meta, but in the end you have to feel comfortable with the sideboard so you better chose yourself.

Edit: @Nihil: No, I didn't. You're right though, I should have.

Deep6er
09-03-2008, 07:48 PM
If you don't step up with your ego, then I'll have to fill in the gaps. That would be a lot of work for me, don't you think? Are you really going to force me to be even more egotistical? Bit selfish of you don't you think?

How about you fulfill your God-given right as a good Solidarity player and be an ego-tripping monster? Get to it.

:) Congratulations.

Van Phanel
09-04-2008, 09:24 AM
good Solidarity player

...

:) Congratulations.


Whoa! :eek:

Now, I'm flattered.