Elspeth

[Holo_rip]

while playing with Hanni, we've run into a issue.
he has elspeth in play with some stuff.
he do the ultimate thing.

all the stuff ON the table are indestructible.

but, does the stuff that come on the table later are also indestructible ?

thanks

[Goaswerfraiejen]

while playing with any, we've run into a issue.
he has elspeth in play with some stuff.
he do the ultimate thing.

all the stuff ON the table are indestructible.

but, does the stuff that come on the table later are also indestructible ?

thanks

Yes. From the Shards FAQ:



* Once Elspeth's third ability resolves, it's continually in effect until the game ends, even if Elspeth has already left play or leaves play at some point afterwards. It doesn't lock in what it applies to. Since the effect states a true thing about a set of permanents, but doesn't actually change the *characteristics* of those permanents, it will apply to whatever artifacts, creatures, enchantments, and lands you happen to control at any point in the game from that time forward. It will apply to such permanents that come under your control after the ability has resolved, and it will cease to apply to permanents that leave your control. Since the ability doesn't change those permanents' characteristics, if any of them loses all abilities, it will still be indestructible.


If you cease to control one of these permanents, however, it will no longer be indestructible.