View Full Version : 10/11/09 - Star City $5,000 Legacy Open - Philadelphia, PA
NicholasAtSCG
04-21-2009, 06:33 PM
Star City Games $5,000 Legacy Open
This is day two of the StarCityGames.com $10,000 Magic Weekend. Join us Saturday for the $5,000 Standard Open and stick around for Sunday's $5,000 Legacy Open.
One Weekend - Two Events - $10,000
EVENT SITE
Pennsylvania Convention Center
1101 Arch Street
Philadelphia, PA 19107
(215) 418-4700
http://www.paconvention.com/home/
Want to get a jump on Deck Registration? Try out our decklist form (http://www.starcitywow.com/PDFs/MagicDecklistForm.pdf) and come prepared!
SCHEDULE OF EVENTS
Sunday, October 11th (Doors open at 8:00 AM)
StarCityGames.com $5,000 Legacy Open
Format: Legacy
Entry Fee: $30
Start Time: 10:00 AM (Registration begins at 8:00 AM)
Structure: Modified Swiss with a cut to the T8.
Head Judge: Adam Shaw (L3)
K-Value: 32
REL: Competitive
Prizes:
1st: $2,000 & the StarCityGames.com $5,000 Legacy Open Trophy!
2nd: $600
3rd-4th: $400
5th-8th: $200
9th-16th: $100
SIDE EVENTS ALL WEEKEND LONG!
Magic 2010 Casual Drafts
Entry: $10.00
Prizes:
1st Place: 3 boosters (or entry into the next draft)
Due to requests for a more competitive drafting format, we will also offer:
Competitive Zendikar Drafts
Entry: $15.00
Prizes:
1st Place: 8 boosters
2nd Place: 4 boosters
Zendikar Win-A-Box
Entry Fee: $15.00
Prizes:
1st Place: Zendikar Booster Box (36 boosters)
Four Play EDH Chaos Games
Entry Fee: $5.00
Prizes:
1st Place: $20 Dealer Credit
REGISTRATION
Registration begins at 8:00 AM, and ends ten (10) minutes before the event is scheduled to start. Any player who wants to enroll after registration has ended will be able to do so, but will receive a round one match loss. Players arriving after round two has been paired will not be able to enroll in the tournament.
JUDGING
Judges interested in working at this event should contact Nicholas Sabin at eventstaffing@starcitygames.com.
Judge certification for level one is available at this event; interested candidates should make arrangements with Jared Sylva (jared.sylva@starcitygames.com) prior to the event.
NEED CARDS?
Buy, sell and trade with America’s largest Magic the Gathering retailer! StarCityGames.com will have a massive dealer booth set up from 8am through 6pm on Saturday! How may we help you?
TRADING
While trading is fine, please note that buying/selling cards with anyone except for our authorized dealer(s), or soliciting to do so elsewhere, is strictly forbidden at this event. Failure to obey this rule may result in both the buyer and the seller being removed from the event without refund, and banned from attending future events.
Star City Events also reserves the right to limit the amount of space being occupied by any one individual while trading, and does not allow the use of suitcases, handcarts, luggage carts, etc. to be used for the purpose of transporting excessive amounts of trade stock.
DIRECTIONS
For directions to the venue, visit the Pennsylvania Convention Center website (http://www.paconvention.com/home/) or use Google Maps (http://maps.google.com).
MORE INFORMATION
Players who want specific information can contact us at events@starcitygames.com or by calling (540) 767-GAME (4263). New players will want to read our player FAQ (http://forums.starcitygames.com/viewtopic.php?t=288770).
ShiftyKapree
04-21-2009, 09:11 PM
I'll def make it to this one
rockout
04-21-2009, 09:35 PM
Oh you sly cats. You just know how to make me not able to say no.
Jander78
04-21-2009, 09:58 PM
That's more like it. A Legacy Tournament not on a holiday! Will be there for sure.
Nemcon
04-21-2009, 10:26 PM
I'm headin home for this weekend. 40 minutes away? So in
sunshine
04-22-2009, 12:28 PM
Definitely will be at this.
NicholasAtSCG
05-18-2009, 11:15 AM
Definitely will be at this.
Cool -- looking forward to seeing everybody there! :D
suprafan386
05-18-2009, 01:29 PM
Plan on making it to the standard portion now to convince my friends to stay over one more day.
I loved the philly 5k last year even though I scrubbed out but whatever there was a cheer leading contest in another hall.
scrumdogg
05-18-2009, 03:32 PM
That's more like it. A Legacy Tournament not on a holiday! Will be there for sure.
Columbus Day weekend >.> Although, so many cool things to do in Philly anyway and the fall weather tends to be gorgeous. Definitely going to try and make this...
NicholasAtSCG
05-29-2009, 11:19 AM
Columbus Day weekend >.> Although, so many cool things to do in Philly anyway and the fall weather tends to be gorgeous. Definitely going to try and make this...
Cool -- looking forward to seeing everybody there! :D
NicholasAtSCG
06-05-2009, 11:08 AM
As a reminder, please make sure to get good directions to the venue. Personally, I recommend Google Maps (http://maps.google.com)
NicholasAtSCG
06-16-2009, 01:59 PM
Who else plans on coming to this?
Enigma
06-23-2009, 05:42 PM
It might be possible for the montreal's crew to come, but it's really not guaranteed, as it's even 2 hours farther than Boston. :wink:
P-M
NicholasAtSCG
07-09-2009, 05:13 PM
It might be possible for the montreal's crew to come, but it's really not guaranteed, as it's even 2 hours farther than Boston. :wink:
P-M
Considering how well the Montreal Crew did in Boston, I can't imagine Philadelphia would be unappealing. ;)
NicholasAtSCG
07-22-2009, 11:05 AM
Plan on making it to the standard portion now to convince my friends to stay over one more day.
I loved the philly 5k last year even though I scrubbed out but whatever there was a cheer leading contest in another hall.
Such is the randomness that comes along with running events at large convention centers. I've seen more cheerleading/volleyball/glamour contests than you would believe. Weirdest, hands-down, was the Mary-Kay convention I saw once when running an event in Louisville, KY.
NicholasAtSCG
08-26-2009, 11:30 AM
Looking forward to seeing everybody there! :D
boltking
08-26-2009, 01:07 PM
i plan on being there and bringing 2 of my friends
rocketrae21
08-27-2009, 07:31 PM
most likely will be there with 1 or 2 others
NicholasAtSCG
09-08-2009, 02:20 PM
About a month away, now -- who else is coming to this?
NicholasAtSCG
09-22-2009, 01:48 PM
Looking forward to seeing everybody in a few weeks! :)
Damoxx
09-24-2009, 12:24 PM
I'm gonna be in Pittsburg for work the weekend of the tournament, is there a better way than a car to get there?
It's a five hour drive down 76, really not bad. You might be able to catch a ride with people from Pitts. It's like $120 to fly or $85 for a train.
But aren't you working?
Damoxx
09-24-2009, 12:47 PM
But aren't you working?
Actually I work Thursday Friday and then not until Tuesday, so I'm in Pittsburg for work, but not working over the weekend.
NicholasAtSCG
09-25-2009, 11:15 AM
Keep in mind that parking downtown can be pretty pricy: you're looking at $10-15/day in any of the lots near the convention center. Carpooling might be the best way to go, here. :D
IsThisACatInAHat?
09-25-2009, 03:03 PM
I'm definitely coming and bringing 2 people with me. Just so I'm sure, SCG will have a booth with decent stock there, yes? Somehow this tourney caught me unprepared (even though its been on my calendar for over a month) and I'm not looking forward to paying overnight shipping for the 2 cards I'm missing (plateaus) and my team doesn't have dupes of :(
SCG has a very well stocked case. Sometimes they even let you order from the site and pick up at the event.
They buy all weekend too, if you want to pay for your Plateaus with cards.
NicholasAtSCG
09-25-2009, 04:24 PM
Due to the high demand for Zendikar, side event formats and drafts have been updated and modified.
AnwarA101
09-28-2009, 12:41 AM
Due to the high demand for Zendikar, side event formats and drafts have been updated and modified.
Are there any nearby hotels with discounts for this event?
Enigma
09-29-2009, 04:15 PM
Due to the high demand for Zendikar, side event formats and drafts have been updated and modified.
Hey ! Just noticed it's your birthday, let me wish you an happy bday,
and thanks for all those nice tournies!
P-M
Mister Agent
09-29-2009, 11:46 PM
That's more like it. A Legacy Tournament not on a holiday! Will be there for sure.
Awesome Rick! I have my bet that you'll make top 16 at least. Hopefully cdr will cover some of your matches as well since I would be delighted to watch you play.
hungryLIKEALION
10-03-2009, 03:21 PM
Two of my friends asked me If I wanted to go to this last night, so it looks like I'll likely be there! Can't wait to meet some of you guys.
NicholasAtSCG
10-05-2009, 11:05 AM
Are there any nearby hotels with discounts for this event?
I'm afraid not; I'd advise you to try Priceline, though. I was able to get a very good deal on the hotel we're using for staff.
At the moment, I'd be driving by myself. Any Syracuse or Binghamton people have extra space in their car or need a ride?
herbig
10-06-2009, 02:05 PM
At the moment, I'd be driving by myself. Any Syracuse or Binghamton people have extra space in their car or need a ride?
What day are you going down?
Is anyone going down Friday night for the Standard event on Saturday?
rocketrae21
10-06-2009, 04:24 PM
are there going to be other dealers there or just SCG because its their event?
quicksilver
10-06-2009, 04:26 PM
Just SSG
What day are you going down?
Is anyone going down Friday night for the Standard event on Saturday?
I'm working the event, so I'm staying Friday/Saturday/Sunday night.
herbig
10-06-2009, 06:08 PM
I'm working the event, so I'm staying Friday/Saturday/Sunday night.
PMed.
Now, who's got a hotel I can get in on?
Looks like I won't be able to make it. Apoligies to anyone who was going to borrow a deck.
herbig
10-08-2009, 02:27 PM
Looks like I won't be able to make it. Apoligies to anyone who was going to borrow a deck.
well that sucks. How the hell am I going to get down there..
Argen
10-09-2009, 02:24 AM
I have a hotel room at the airport that someone could get in on. PM me if interested.
Madmaniac21
10-09-2009, 04:49 PM
Was going to this ... until I realized it was a Sunday.
And Monday is not a holiday for us who are open when the market is :(
Do we have any updates from this? Number of players? Etc?
HAVE HEART
10-11-2009, 01:56 PM
Apparently five Jund lists made the Standard top eight, and the Legacy decklists should be out "no later than Monday."
NjPunk1
10-11-2009, 11:31 PM
147 people for legacy i think. Cedrick made top 8 with belcher. I also saw NO Thresh, Dredge, CB top, white stax, a Dark Depths combo, and i forget the rest of the top 8.
DCTopTeam
10-12-2009, 01:22 AM
Where the F are the decklists?!??! Its been "This and that made the Top 8," "There were no X and Y decks in the T8," etc etc.
DECKLISTSSS
IsThisACatInAHat?
10-12-2009, 01:36 AM
Did the CBTop-Dark Depths thing make top 8? That guy lost his round 8 match and his opponent definitely did make it. Handful of CBTop-goyfs and 2 combo in the T8. The field had lots of control, lots of stormcombo (especially doomsday?) and not enough zoo to go round. Which made me and my TES a sad panda. That and fucking dragon stompy.
rocketrae21
10-12-2009, 10:16 AM
The top 8 was. White Stax vs Dark Depths. Dredge vs 43 land. Blecher vs Canadian Thresh. Bant vs Counter top of some sort. Didnt watch that game too much. Top 4. White Stax vs Dredge. Bant vs Thresh. Top 2 Stax vs Thresh. I don't know who took the trophy but top 4 split the cash.
Muradin
10-12-2009, 10:30 AM
Dark Depths combo sounds pretty cool actually. Props to the pilot for playing such a deck and having success with it.
sauce
10-12-2009, 10:46 AM
staxx won apparently, thats all i know :mad:
Bluemagex2517
10-12-2009, 01:03 PM
I got on here to nurse my ego, but apparently no one has posted my list yet. Since you all want decklists: I was the dredge player:
4 GOLGARI GRAVE-TROLL
4 STINKWEED IMP
3 GOLGARI THUG
4 TIRELESS TRIBE
4 NARCOEMEBA
4 BLOODGHAST
1 SADISTIC HYPNOTIS
1 CEPHALID SAGE
1 FLAME-KIN ZEALOT
4 BREAKTHROUGH
4 CARFUL STUDY
4 CABAL Therapy
4 BRIDGE FROM BELOW
3 DREAD RETURN
4 UNDISCOVERED PARADISE
4 GEMSTONE MINE
4 CEPHALID COLOSSEUM
2 DAKMOR SALVAGE
1 CITY OF BRASS
SB
4 PITHING NEEDLE
4 CHAIN OF VAPOR
3 FORCE OF WILL
2 ANCIENT GRUDGE
1 ANCESTOR'S CHOSEN
1 SADISTIC HYPNOTIST
If you are wondering why Bloodghast, I might have a primer/tournament report posted on this site at some point. I lost to exactly 1 deck all day, and it was White Stax. IDK his list, it seemed pretty stock except for Baneslayer Angel, which won him the game against the dark depths deck. He top decked it to block Tombstalker. I wish he wouldn't have. I'm reasonably sure White Stax is one of my worst possible match-ups. We did indeed split the top 4, but that trophy would have been nice.
EssKay
10-12-2009, 01:12 PM
Results are up at SCG:
http://sales.starcitygames.com//deckdatabase/deckshow.php?&t%5BC1%5D=leg&start_date=2009-10-04&end_date=2009-10-18
Mark Sun
10-12-2009, 01:34 PM
SB
4 PITHING NEEDLE
4 CHAIN OF VAPOR
3 FORCE OF WILL
2 ANCIENT GRUDGE
1 ANCESTOR'S CHOSEN
1 SADISTIC HYPNOTIST
Nice! When I was in my "what-kind-of-crazy-shit-will-fit-in-Dredge" phase, I briefly considered Force, which I declined to add because it would take away a crucial draw spell or another body for Therapy/DR in Narc. Great job, did you use it that much all day in g2/g3?
No Landstill lists, makes me a sad panda.
DownSyndromeKarl
10-12-2009, 01:47 PM
I'm reasonably sure White Stax is one of my worst possible match-ups.
I thought you had good match-ups against everyone? hahaha
BTW, Congrats.
rockout
10-12-2009, 01:59 PM
Interesting top 16. No landstill in the top 16 = frown town but congrats to everyone. Glad to see someone doing well with stax and hexmage + depths.
Eldariel
10-12-2009, 03:05 PM
I find the Hexmage-list fucked up; MD Confidant seems like a no-brainer and no pinpoint discard outside Therapy seems meh. It really seems too built around Bloodghast, which admittedly is decent but can't carry the whole deck. That said, the heavy LD package makes sense. I wonder why no Life from the Loam since he's already in black though.
Grim Discovery feels quite weak; Volrath's + Life is a much better engine for LD-heavy builds. That said, I prefer the Sui Black shell. But yeah, for a slower shell, that seems good. Scoops to combo tho.
Enigma
10-12-2009, 03:16 PM
That TOP8 is particular. It profites fully from the new cards: enemy fetches for BUG CBT, Bloodghast for 2 different decks, BSA for WStax. But a lot of these decks are just not enough good against Zoo, but better against Merfolk.
And... same thoughts as Eldariel about the Eva Green/Dark depths.dec, it has some really debatable choices.
Neverthless, a big congratz to those guys, mostly the CT and CB players to win through all these so-so MUs. And congratz to Cedric... CT is a pain for his deck.
P-M
Jim Higginbottom
10-12-2009, 04:51 PM
I heard Cedric thought he was the best legacy player in the room. Belcher is a deck that plays itself...I'd expect better from a "pro". What a douche.
firstshot
10-12-2009, 05:03 PM
While Cederic can be arrogant he can also have card access issues. Or maybe he saw that FOW wasn't that popular which makes belcher real good.
FoulQ
10-12-2009, 05:33 PM
I hope Cedric knew he was going to play against Canadian Thresh and still decided to not split the money.
sick variance
10-12-2009, 05:56 PM
I hope Cedric knew he was going to play against Canadian Thresh and still decided to not split the money.
Splitting 5ks is terrible, even if you are going in to a bad match-up you should always play them out.
Horror Business
10-12-2009, 06:03 PM
While Cederic can be arrogant he can also have card access issues. Or maybe he saw that FOW wasn't that popular which makes belcher real good.
Wasn't he playing Lands at one point?
Seems good that if he is arrogant he gets matched up against the deck with Stifle, Snare, Daze, FOW, and blasts out of the board.
sauce
10-12-2009, 06:14 PM
if you're a pro player, would you split with a bunch of noname players?
edit: im not saying thats how i would act, im just bringing up another point of view...
Bluemagex2517
10-12-2009, 06:24 PM
Splitting 5ks is terrible, even if you are going in to a bad match-up you should always play them out.
So you can get $250 instead of $550? Everyone but Cedric was offering to split. Sure his not splitting netted me $300, but if I would have lost to 43 Lands I would have lost $300. If you play you are gambling $300 to gain another $300 on 1 match. Why would you not split, especially if it's a bad match. Say you're 40% to win. That's horrible odds when you have a sure $300 to gain. So thanks Ced for the $300, but I'm sure Chris Woltereck didn't enjoy giving up that $300 to me. Cedric said he lost a lot of money on the trip, so he was trying to win it back. He felt like gambling, and it didn't pay off for him. It also benefited 4 people and sucked for 3 others besides himself.
Esper3k
10-12-2009, 06:25 PM
My friend was the one playing the Stax deck.
Against the Dark Depths deck, while he did have an epic Baneslayer topdeck it was to match his opponent's 1-of Tombstalker topdeck. He also had more outs than just Baneslayers - 4x Armageddon (there was a Magus of the Tabernacle on the board) and 1x Oblivion Ring left. Baneslayer was pretty flashy though :)
sauce
10-12-2009, 06:33 PM
wish there was video of said top8
EssKay
10-12-2009, 06:34 PM
I find the Hexmage-list fucked up; MD Confidant seems like a no-brainer and no pinpoint discard outside Therapy seems meh. It really seems too built around Bloodghast, which admittedly is decent but can't carry the whole deck. That said, the heavy LD package makes sense. I wonder why no Life from the Loam since he's already in black though.
Grim Discovery feels quite weak; Volrath's + Life is a much better engine for LD-heavy builds. That said, I prefer the Sui Black shell. But yeah, for a slower shell, that seems good. Scoops to combo tho.
Yeah that is not at all the list I expected to see. Still nice to see a new archetype show up in a major event so quickly. The sideboard has me all confused though.
FoulQ
10-12-2009, 11:15 PM
Once again, that UBr bitterblossom deck made top 16 of a major tournament.
I think the source needs to investigate that deck a little more than saying "yeah, it has potential."
Jim Higginbottom
10-13-2009, 12:12 AM
So basically he was like, "I'm so good I can win a matchup where the odds are 90% stacked against me." Again...what a douche.
andrew77
10-13-2009, 12:32 AM
It made no sense to play out that top 8, because if it were played out to the end the only way to do better than the original split would be to make it to the finals. My understanding was that it wasn't in Cedric's interest to split so I doubt it was because he thought he was better than everyone else. He isn't one of the top pro's and both Chris Woltereck and Ken Adams are very high caliber players.
Anyway this was a great tournament and I really enjoyed it. I played U/B/G counterbalance to a 5-3 record (scooped round 8 to avoid drawing and losing out on prizes).
emidln
10-13-2009, 12:42 AM
A decision to not split because you play more magic and think about magic often than your opponents likely due isn't necessarily wrong. Now, if you know your matchups with Belcher (as opposed to something with more interaction over a longer period of time that lets you maximize your experience and skill), it still isn't necessarily wrong, but playing by doing it with Belcher you are now simply playing a numbers game. If the numbers are decent enough, the value of writing "I made the finals with belcher at a 5k" might be worth more (for whatever reason) to someone who writes weekly articles (or maybe just for pride's sake) could have been worth the shot.
As a general rule, I don't split except with teammates. As I don't live around many people I talk to about magic often, the chances of me splitting is very small (my brother is about the only person I split with). Part of this is ego, part of it is that I like to play magic, even after 10 hours of playing magic. I don't play magic to make cash (I have a job for that), so I'm not worried about making a $200 bet. I'm not sure if Cedric is full-time magic pro (i.e. no other other job) or not, but if he has other means of making money, he might be of a similar mind.
Bluemagex2517
10-13-2009, 12:59 AM
A decision to not split because you play more magic and think about magic often than your opponents likely due isn't necessarily wrong. Now, if you know your matchups with Belcher (as opposed to something with more interaction over a longer period of time that lets you maximize your experience and skill), it still isn't necessarily wrong, but playing by doing it with Belcher you are now simply playing a numbers game. If the numbers are decent enough, the value of writing "I made the finals with belcher at a 5k" might be worth more (for whatever reason) to someone who writes weekly articles (or maybe just for pride's sake) could have been worth the shot.
As a general rule, I don't split except with teammates. As I don't live around many people I talk to about magic often, the chances of me splitting is very small (my brother is about the only person I split with). Part of this is ego, part of it is that I like to play magic, even after 10 hours of playing magic. I don't play magic to make cash (I have a job for that), so I'm not worried about making a $200 bet. I'm not sure if Cedric is full-time magic pro (i.e. no other other job) or not, but if he has other means of making money, he might be of a similar mind.
I'm fairly sure the reason he did it was because he lost so much money on air fair and a room. He wanted to make the money back. I think it was dumb not to split even if he didn't know what he was playing.
FoulQ
10-13-2009, 01:18 AM
A decision to not split because you play more magic and think about magic often than your opponents likely due isn't necessarily wrong. Now, if you know your matchups with Belcher (as opposed to something with more interaction over a longer period of time that lets you maximize your experience and skill), it still isn't necessarily wrong, but playing by doing it with Belcher you are now simply playing a numbers game. If the numbers are decent enough, the value of writing "I made the finals with belcher at a 5k" might be worth more (for whatever reason) to someone who writes weekly articles (or maybe just for pride's sake) could have been worth the shot.
As a general rule, I don't split except with teammates. As I don't live around many people I talk to about magic often, the chances of me splitting is very small (my brother is about the only person I split with). Part of this is ego, part of it is that I like to play magic, even after 10 hours of playing magic. I don't play magic to make cash (I have a job for that), so I'm not worried about making a $200 bet. I'm not sure if Cedric is full-time magic pro (i.e. no other other job) or not, but if he has other means of making money, he might be of a similar mind.
See emidln, you are a respectable non-splitter. You are not not-splitting because of the prizes, but because of intangible things: the reward for hours of persevering playtesting, recognition for your talents and innovations, and a sort of competition and challenge to overcome. It sounds like Cedric split for much different reasons, and I guarantee you "innovation" and "playtesting" were definitely NOT factors.
GGoober
10-13-2009, 07:17 AM
Just curious, but how many Landstill pilots were there at Philly? I'm assuming they either all failed, or there just wasn't enough players?
I'm curious since the T16 seems to be very aggro dominated and the NO-Countertop can be stopped by Landstill's mass removal much better than any deck, not to mention Landstill should own Zoo/Goblins, and since there was only very little Dredge/combo in the T16, I think it should be a great meta for Landstill. So was there little pilots or just every control pilot did bad lol?
(nameless one)
10-13-2009, 08:48 AM
no one showed up with a goblins or they all miserably failed?
Jim Higginbottom
10-13-2009, 08:54 AM
Landstill lost to NO Countertop in round 7.
Amon Amarth
10-13-2009, 09:36 AM
As a general rule, I don't split except with teammates. As I don't live around many people I talk to about magic often, the chances of me splitting is very small (my brother is about the only person I split with). Part of this is ego, part of it is that I like to play magic, even after 10 hours of playing magic. I don't play magic to make cash (I have a job for that), so I'm not worried about making a $200 bet. I'm not sure if Cedric is full-time magic pro (i.e. no other other job) or not, but if he has other means of making money, he might be of a similar mind.
godryk
10-13-2009, 11:40 AM
Once again, that UBr bitterblossom deck made top 16 of a major tournament.
I think the source needs to investigate that deck a little more than saying "yeah, it has potential."
This is the kind of deck that Sourcers (saying "americans" may be generalising) tend to overlook, heck, it needs more CB+Top... It's like Ugr Standstill Faeries, a deck designed by italians that happen to catch up here in Spain with very good results in both countries. But hey, CB+Top owns the format hands down... :tongue:
NjPunk1
10-13-2009, 03:41 PM
I didn't see any landstill all day, and i saw a few goblins players. Near the final rounds all of the top tables seemed to be either combo (belcher, storm, or dredge) or some sort of cb top varient, with a few zoo/goyf sligh decks still hanging in. It definitly wasn't the meta game I expected, and was completly different from the 5k in NC.
Bluemagex2517
10-13-2009, 03:55 PM
I didn't see any landstill all day, and i saw a few goblins players. Near the final rounds all of the top tables seemed to be either combo (belcher, storm, or dredge) or some sort of cb top varient, with a few zoo/goyf sligh decks still hanging in. It definitly wasn't the meta game I expected, and was completly different from the 5k in NC.
Yep, Charlotte was dominated by zoo, so in response people brought a lot of combo. Even the lower tables had a lot. I saw helm, doomsday, elf combo and ANT. There was more dredge around, and Ced had Belcher. Seems like a clear response to Wild Nacatl. Just as much as the zoo meta was a response to Counterblance Top at GP Chicago and the rise in popularity of Merfolk.
Now will the meta become all combo filled and ripe for decks like White Stax and countertop? Will the Zoo players switch for fear of combo? I think it was much easier to call the meta for this tournament than the next. Combo doesn't tend to do well on a consistent basis, and Zoo players aren't the type to switch at a moment's notice. People who play combo are willing to play other decks, but switch to combo very readily. If Zoo is still around and combo is still around, maybe White Stax is still the best deck? If Zoo dies down maybe Merfolk will get even more popular. Merfolk seems great against C-top, combo and White Stax, but is terrible against Zoo.
MMogg
10-13-2009, 07:36 PM
Wow, the results are really surprising. No Goblins in the top 16 after all that hype over Instigator.
andrew77
10-13-2009, 08:15 PM
Wow, the results are really surprising. No Goblins in the top 16 after all that hype over Instigator.
Did anyone good actually hype instigator? I mean other than Evan Erwin (who is a terrible player/strategist and just a pawn for wizards) nobody thought it would be good. That's why its only like $7. I think goblin guide and ruinblaster are the only zendikar goblins that would actually be playable.
MMogg
10-13-2009, 11:53 PM
Did anyone good actually hype instigator? I mean other than Evan Erwin (who is a terrible player/strategist and just a pawn for wizards) nobody thought it would be good. That's why its only like $7. I think goblin guide and ruinblaster are the only zendikar goblins that would actually be playable.
I guess you haven't been following the Vial Goblins thread. Instigator has pretty much been considered not only an auto-include, but also something to give new life to a semi-moribund deck to beat. Unless you're implying The Source is not a source for top level Legacy analysis/knowledge. :wink:
FoulQ
10-14-2009, 12:09 AM
Did anyone good actually hype instigator? I mean other than Evan Erwin (who is a terrible player/strategist and just a pawn for wizards) nobody thought it would be good. That's why its only like $7. I think goblin guide and ruinblaster are the only zendikar goblins that would actually be playable.
Alright listen you ....(I won't call you a name today), I've seen you say some questionable stuff in the ichorid thread, goblins didn't suck because instigator is bad, it sucked because as people were saying, HALF THE ROOM WAS COMBO. Do you want to know goblin's worst matchup? You can take a guess.
beastman
10-14-2009, 12:13 AM
Did anyone good actually hype instigator? I mean other than Evan Erwin (who is a terrible player/strategist and just a pawn for wizards) nobody thought it would be good. That's why its only like $7. I think goblin guide and ruinblaster are the only zendikar goblins that would actually be playable.
|^^^^^^^^^^^\||____
|.The STFU Truck..|||'""|""\__,_
| __GTFO 4ever_w_ l||__|__|__|)
|(@)@)"""""""**|(@)(@)**|(@)
Honk Honk!!!
andrew77
10-14-2009, 12:24 AM
I'm sorry I don't pay attention to the goblins thread. I only actually care about competitive decks. For how heavily it is played goblins posts almost no results. Why? Because it is bad. Instigator also happens to be terrible.
Sweetwater D
10-14-2009, 02:05 AM
I'm sorry I don't pay attention to the goblins thread. I only actually care about competitive decks. For how heavily it is played goblins posts almost no results. Why? Because it is bad. Instigator also happens to be terrible.
I HIGHLY doubt you've put in the time others have spent testing him who say otherwise.
Instigator is not terrible, its a must answer threat for the other deck that has excellent synergy with chieftain. It's very good and an auto 4 of in goblins, no questions asked.
It's beyond me how someone could admit to not paying attention to a deck and then brazenly state that a card, who others have tested and found to be very good, is terrible in it. Go peddle your bullshit somewhere else
Jim Higginbottom
10-14-2009, 03:49 AM
If it's so good why were all the goblin players in the scrub bracket?
emidln
10-14-2009, 04:02 AM
If it's so good why were all the goblin players in the scrub bracket?
I'd bet scrubby players. The majority of people in the scrub bracket are there because they are, in fact, scrubs. It could also have to do with bad matchups. I'd still be on generally scrubbery.
Sweetwater D
10-14-2009, 04:21 AM
If it's so good why were all the goblin players in the scrub bracket?
goblins didn't suck because instigator is bad, it sucked because as people were saying, HALF THE ROOM WAS COMBO. Do you want to know goblin's worst matchup? You can take a guess.
I hear the meta is a pretty important part of why some deck place well and others don't.
Also, I didn't say goblins was a top tier deck, that I said Instigator was good in goblins. Goblins is a powerful tribe, to be sure, but it has its weaknesses and in certain metagames it's a bad deck to play. I have no problem with saying that it's not a top tier deck in metagames where the field is stacked against it.
saying instigator is terrible and less playable than something like goblin ruinblaster on the other hand pretty much a baseless claim that andrew (probably) put no testing into whatsoever.
andrew77
10-14-2009, 05:27 AM
I hear the meta is a pretty important part of why some deck place well and others don't.
Also, I didn't say goblins was a top tier deck, that I said Instigator was good in goblins. Goblins is a powerful tribe, to be sure, but it has its weaknesses and in certain metagames it's a bad deck to play. I have no problem with saying that it's not a top tier deck in metagames where the field is stacked against it.
saying instigator is terrible and less playable than something like goblin ruinblaster on the other hand pretty much a baseless claim that andrew (probably) put no testing into whatsoever.
The meta? So you are telling me if there's more than the usual 10 or so percent combo that goblins becomes unplayable? I mean you can't seriously believe it was 50% combo. Most players don't like combo decks for a variety of reasons and would never play it. Due to combo being the rarest style deck when people see 20% of people playing it they are like OMG COMBO WINTER!!!
The fact of the matter is goblins did poorly because it is a bad deck. Sure, I'd bet most of the goblin players were scrubs, but that is because good players don't play tier 4 decks.
FoulQ
10-14-2009, 11:38 AM
Not every competitive deck can place in every top 16 of every major event. Sorry about that. Last 5k there were 2 goblins in the top 16. Where were you then?
Goblins wasn't suited for a metagame full of combo and zoo. It is not a tier 1 necessarily, but it definitely is a strong choice in some metas.
ETA: You know what deck sucks? Landstill. Horrible, horrible deck. Didnt top eight gp chicago and didn't top sixteen this 5k. That's obviously a tier 4 deck. /moron
Jim Higginbottom
10-14-2009, 01:10 PM
First off...Landstill would of been in the top 8 if it hadn't lost to NO Counterbalance in round 7 and I wish goblins players had done better on Sunday...than I'd of actually of gotten to play them and would have roflSTOMPed them. From where I was sitting counterbalance was 50% of the meta...I played 3 counterbalance decks (including Andrew77 round 1) and than played Dreadstill round 7. I only played against another storm deck once and I beat it anyway.
http://media.steampowered.com/steamcommunity/public/images/avatars/f2/f244596a7cb9cf3b9fbad8f1b77a402d2cfa0b4e_full.jpg
pic related: it's me right before I roflSTOMP goblins.
(nameless one)
10-14-2009, 10:26 PM
The fact of the matter is goblins did poorly because it is a bad deck. Sure, I'd bet most of the goblin players were scrubs, but that is because good players don't play tier 4 decks.
i agree with this... it all depends on the pilot of the deck
Belcher combo? its a glass cannon yet it made top 8. Did you see the Depthex deck? A lot of questionable card choices yet he made top8.
Its all about the pilot...
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.