PDA

View Full Version : UB Selection



bowvamp
03-28-2010, 10:51 PM
Selection is a very un-ordinary deck.
The main concept of the deck is to win against all odds, and randomly.

Most of the cards in Selection are pretty straightforward, but work nicely nevertheless.
The land base is nothing out of the ordinary:
4 Polluted Delta
2 Swamp
4 Island
4 Underground Sea

2 Bojuka Bog
Bojuka Bog is mainly to help support the rest of the deck against it's arch-nemesis, Loam.
4 Wasteland
Wasteland is here because the deck can handle it. Wasteland just messes around with so many decks, and since Selection isn't curve-centric, Wasteland helps against those decks that are.

The straightforward creatures:
2 Dark Confidant[cards]
The tempo gain is enormous, and he acts as an alternative to drawing, which as we'll see later is very, very good.

3 [cards]Sower of Temptation
Sower steals the other person's creatures. Originally, I had this slot as Threads of Disloyalty, but Selection doesn't really have any other way to deal with creatures, so I needed a catch-all solution.

The straightforward instants:
4 Force of Will
We definitely have enough blue to support it, so why not?

4 Spell Snare
Spell Snare delivers a way to deal with most threats out there, and easily takes down the most critical cards in the format.

4 Daze
Allowing us to run less lands is really good! Slotting 4 Daze into the list gives the opponent hell when they least expected it.

The straightforward Sorceries/Artifacts
2 Umezawa's Jitte
Jitte is nice because it allows Selection to add an extra dimension to its creatures. Most of the creatures in this deck would do their thing regardless of if they could swing for 2 or 1, but Jitte makes them shine as CREATURES, not just utility.

4 Thoughtseize
Thoughtseize is also nice, because it allows us to cull what we don't want from their hand. Basically, it does what it does, and get's done with it. I can't think of a single strategy that's immune to thoughtseize. Honestly, not even dredge. (Don't mention lands, thoughtseize absolutely kills them T1 on the play)

4 Hymn to Tourach
2 for 1 in CA. Nuff said.

Now for the part that's not typical:
2 Cunning Lethemancer
Hits both players, quite like Anvil/Chains. Has to be protected however which is why it only warrants 2 copies.

4 Big Game Hunter
Who knew that this little toolbox card often seen in Survival was so powerful? Basically, he owns beaters like:
Tarmogoyf,
Jotun Grunt,
Abyssal Persecutor,
Dreadnaught, (Totally rocks doing that)
KotR,
Tombstalker,
Crusher/Terravore,
etc etc

4 Anvil of Bogardan
Enables combo lock, and BGH. Also allows you to find what you may need/want in order to finish the game such as Jitte or Sower.

3 Chains of Mephistopheles
Shuts down draw engines of any kind (makes Standstill worthless), and utterly pwns the other player when paired with Anvil. Notice that we don't run anything with the word "Draw" besides chains and Anvil?

Ok, now for an overview of how the deck works.
Basically, the deck draws it's strengths from it's lack of card quality engines (top, brainstorm, tutors/toolboxes) and instead chooses to fight with whatever it gets, sculpting synergy out of nowhere. Let's start with the purpose of the creatures; the creatures are here to provide utility along with being Jitte targets. Creatures are meant to be protected, and that's why we have counters and discard. Succeeding in protecting our creatures is what wins us games. However, if they drop their big bomb, we have Anvil/Chains & Lethemancer to nab BGH.

BTW How do I use card tags with the new forum?

jrsthethird
03-28-2010, 11:05 PM
Interesting. Deck doesn't look like much (Cunning Lethemancer FTL?) but I would be interested in seeing how it really stacks up. Post some of your matchups and maybe a tournament report if you've had enough time to test.

Card tags: [ cards ]Cunning Lethemancer[ /cards ]

remove the spaces.

alderon666
03-29-2010, 12:11 AM
You lost me at.



4 Big Game Hunter
Who knew that this little toolbox card often seen in Survival was so powerful? Basically, he owns beaters like:
Tarmogoyf,
Jotun Grunt,
Doran,
Abyssal Persecutor,
Dreadnaught, (Totally rocks doing that)
KotR,
Tombstalker,
Crusher/Terravore,
etc etc


Running blue, fetchlands and not running Brainstorm is a sin. Please confess before playing another game of Magic.

dahcmai
03-29-2010, 12:53 AM
The thing I see right off the bat is how do you kill someone? Seems you have Confidant, Sower, Lethomancer, and Big Game Hunter for kills. A single Moat or something just spells doom. Lightning Bolt becomes a concern since you don't have much to actually win with.

mikez0r
03-29-2010, 01:20 AM
You should find another card to combo off of chains of mephistopheles other than anvil of bogardan. If you play anvil of bogardan before playing chains you are just helping your opponent get card quality to beat you with, while you played a useless card. I realize that Big Game Hunter has synergy with anvil but that's the only card out of the whole deck.

If you have any sort of instant draw on their turn it will work better than playing an anvil with chains. Playing Sensei's Divining Top would help you with the chains combo lock, just tap it to draw a card on their upkeep, if they don't have any cards in their hand they won't be able to draw any cards for the rest of the game. Top would help you when you don't have chains to mediate the damage from confidant.


On a side note, I love dark confidant's interaction with chains and you should have another chains since they stack their effects.

-4 Anvil of Bogardan
+3 Sensei's Divining Top
+1 Chains of Mephistopheles

Gocho
03-29-2010, 10:12 AM
You lost me at.



Running blue, fetchlands and not running Brainstorm is a sin. Please confess before playing another game of Magic.

He plays Chains + Anvil combo. With both of them in play nobody can draw and Brainstorm says:

Discard 3 card, return 2 card to your library.

jrsthethird
03-29-2010, 11:04 AM
Discard 3 card, return 2 card to your library.

Sounds like a sweet common, put it in the next set!

bowvamp
03-29-2010, 06:42 PM
The thing I see right off the bat is how do you kill someone? Seems you have Confidant, Sower, Lethomancer, and Big Game Hunter for kills. A single Moat or something just spells doom. Lightning Bolt becomes a concern since you don't have much to actually win with.

Correct, that does pose a rather significant problem, especially against burn. However, moat does not prevent my Sowers from attacking and Sower can also steal their creatures. A definite issue, nonetheless.

Lightning bolt is a concern, yes. Especially against decks like burn which pack tons of bolt effects.
Perhaps an alt win con is necessary in the SB, or if it's enough of a problem, MD.

george.mikal
04-12-2010, 04:33 AM
yes dahcmai is right...Especially against decks like burn which pack tons of bolt effects.
Perhaps an alt win con is necessary in the SB, or if it's enough of a problem, MD.

Poron
04-13-2010, 03:15 PM
you play blue, you need a WC, you can run StifleNought...

bowvamp
04-17-2010, 06:35 PM
@Poron: Stiflenaught requires too many resources for a deck like this. Yes, stifle is a good control spell on its own, but stiflenaught is a 2 card combo, and in this deck, I can only run 1 due to my other limiting my card-draw options.
@george.mikal: Yeah, I think that burn, or even instant speed removal are enough of a problem to warrant slots in the MD.

Welcome to the world of Marsh Crocodile! The big Croc' allows for a fatter, more reliable creature than could previously be delivered, along with discard and it bounces BGH for more abuse! It's basically all this deck could wish for! Yeah, so:
-2 Jitte
+2 Croc'

Moonlight
04-18-2010, 07:21 PM
play some tombstalkers?
Your yard is filled with crap i guess ;)