View Full Version : Spell copies on the graveyard?
I have an energy field out and play a grapeshot after playing a bunch of creatures. Do the copies of my grapeshot hit the graveyard and destroy my energy field, giving my opponent a chance to respond lightening bolt me to kill me?
Storm triggers when you cast Grapeshot, and creates the copies on the stack on top of the original spell. A copy of a spell is not a card, so a copy of Grapeshot will not trigger Energy Field after it is done resolving. Only the original Grapeshot will, and it's the last one to resolve.
Storm triggers when you cast Grapeshot, and creates the copies on the stack on top of the original spell. A copy of a spell is not a card, so a copy of Grapeshot will not trigger Energy Field after it is done resolving. Only the original Grapeshot will, and it's the last one to resolve.
Thanks, but for future references, do spell copies hit the graveyard?
Thanks, but for future references, do spell copies hit the graveyard?
Yes, copies behave like normal spells. Copies of spells or abilities in zones other than the stack cease to exist as a SBA though, much like tokens in zones other than the battlefield.
kusumoto
05-27-2010, 11:09 AM
But tokens do hit the graveyard. They are removed from the graveyard immediately, but they do hit it. If the copies of a spell functioned in the same way as the tokens, they would hit the graveyard as well. I'm not saying the copies hit the graveyard, just that tokens do.
Right?
But tokens do hit the graveyard. They are removed from the graveyard immediately, but they do hit it. If the copies of a spell functioned in the same way as the tokens, they would hit the graveyard as well. I'm not saying the copies hit the graveyard, just that tokens do.
Right?
It's not clear what you're responding to or what your confusion is, but:
The key with Energy Field is that copies are not cards. Tokens aren't cards either.
Energy Field 1U
Enchantment
Prevent all damage that would be dealt to you by sources you don't control.
When a card is put into your graveyard from anywhere, sacrifice Energy Field.
kusumoto
05-27-2010, 01:26 PM
OK. That is exactly where my confusion was. The fact that it isn't a card is the part of it I was missing. So if, for example, Energy field said Sorcery instead of card, it would trigger. Even though the copies aren't cards, they are still Sorceries.
That's where I was confused it seems.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.