[SCD] What if tarmogoyf were banned?

[perm]

What sort of ramifications would the banning of T-goyf have?

[heroicraptor]

Tarmogoyf won't be banned. This thread is even more useless than the one about banning FoW.

[perm]

First of all, I didn't assert that tarm should be banned or will be banned. I am asking for us to think about it.

Also, FoW serves a necessary function of preventing combo from autowinning all the time. Tgoyf is just a too-good creature

[dontbiteitholmes]

This really belongs in the community forum I think. It's more just a, "Hey, what if Tarmogoyf never existed?" Thread than any kind of real format discussion.

[Nelis]

Do we really have to go through all this shit (and FoW shit) every other month?

[Vacrix]

What if the sky were falling?

[MMogg]

What if the sky were falling?

I'd roll a 1d6 and blame:

Wizards
Hasbro
Mana flood
Mana screw
Tarmogoyf
Force of Will

[Killing Joke]

I'd roll a 1d6 and blame:

Wizards
Hasbro
Mana flood
Mana screw
Tarmogoyf
Force of Will


See. I'd really like to be able to give reputation on posts like that.

[Piceli89]

What if Tarmogoyf were banned?

Nourishing Lich would be tier 0,5. Now it's just tier1.

[kiblast]

please, stop posting useless threads. really.

[perm]

lol @ uppity neckbeards getting angry. I think we could all agree that the format would be more healthy, fun and interesting if goyf were banned

[menace13]

See. I'd really like to be able to give reputation on posts like that.
Nahh, MMogg is already loved any place he goes.

[Nelis]

lol @ uppity neckbeards getting angry. I think we could all agree that the format would be more healthy, fun and interesting if goyf were banned

hardi-fucking-har!

[DragoFireheart]

http://www.thedaystarisbright.com/gallery/d/549-1/beating-a-dead-horse.gif


Haven't we done this before? Yes, banning Tarmogoyf would also worse creatures to become more viable. Would it be good for the format? I don't know but I honestly don't care as it will never be banned in the near future.

[Iranon]

Decks that fill their graveyard could run Care Bears like in the old days or sacrifice staying power for explosiveness by running things like Quirion Dryad. Aggro/Control decks that are mostly a collectioin of good cards rather than subscribing to a coherent strategy would become a little more trick-oriented at the expense of muscularity. Aggro decks would become a little more focused, with a clearer distinction between fast and midrange builds.
And after the initial noise, hardly anyone who didn't spend a lot on them would care.

[Raptor]

What sort of ramifications would the banning of T-goyf have?

We wouldn't have posts about how cheap Mister Johny and Miss Marple got them.


By the way, I got them for 15$.

[DrJones]

I'm pretty sure it would get cheaper to buy. I'm not so sure if magic dealers would suddenly start throwing themselves out of windows.