What if Goyf was GG?

[InResponseForceOfWill]

Random question I was thinking about earlier: How much less of an impact would Tarmogoyf have on Legacy if it were GG instead of 1G? It'd still be an amazing creature, however it's splashability would be greatly reduced. I think it would still see a lot of play, but it wouldn't be in nearly as many main boards in legacy decks as it is now. Silly question, but I'd like to know what people think.

[rockout]

Don't feed the troll.

[Fuzzy]

And what if Brainstorm was red?

[GGoober]

IBTL.

Goyf IS GG. Nub. Lol, but in all honesty, this has been beaten again and again, it won't be as good as he is now obviously.

[4eak]

Random question I was thinking about earlier: How much less of an impact would Tarmogoyf have on Legacy if it were GG instead of 1G?

Timeless question. It should have been costed appropriately; Pandora's box, etc.


And what if Brainstorm was red?

I actually would have played Standard (not just eternal formats) when the Time Spiral block was T2 legal.



peace,
4eak

[Deadweight]

GW Sur will suck.

[dontbiteitholmes]

I used to always say it should have costed GG but power creep on creatures has come a long way since the printing of Tarmogoyf. Since Time Spiral block most of the former "Best Creatures Ever" are nearly unplayed. I mean Masticore, Morphling, Psychatog, Meddling Mage, Exalted Angel, Eternal Dragon, Flametongue Kavu, Goblin Welder, Meloku, the list goes on and on. Tarmogoyf is becoming more and more fair with every passing set. Knight of the Reliquary, Vengevine, Pridemage, Nacatl, if this continues we could easily assume Tarmogoyf was just a preview of a very good creature card from 8-10 years in the future which would be on par with Futuresight's general idea and flavor.

[Bardo]

If Goyf was GG, Goyf would be GG.