View Full Version : [PRIMER] Spiral Tide
TheRedBaron
05-02-2011, 12:13 PM
Hi there, long time since I don't make long posts here...
Main deck 60:
4x Brainstorm
4x Ponder
3x Preordain
3x Gitaxian Probe
4x Force of Will
3x Mental Misstep
4x Merchant Scroll
4x Turnabout
4x Time Spiral
4x High Tide
3x Meditate
1x Brain Freeze
1x Blue Sun's Zenith
12x Island
6x "Blue Fetch" (2+2+1+1)
Sideboard
3x Pact of Negation
3x Relic of Progenitus
2x Krosan Grip
2x Rebuild
2x Snap
1x Echoing Truth
1x Wipe Away
1x Tropical Island
Ego, I have to agree with Rex's and Death's Posts respectively. I don't think completely cutting wish is the answer. Wish provides the ability to get "the missing piece".
I don't think Gitaxian probe is good in this sort of combo deck even if opposing MMs couldn't target it. Bottom line is all your other 1 mana cantrips dig 3 cards deep. The probe is only 1 card + intel. My problem with it, is that i don't think 2 life will be worth it most of the time. The deck is already packed, and getting storm count is not a problem with this deck. The probe is better in Belcher type decks IMO, where that 1 extra storm count could be the diff between winning or losing.
About Candles/Retraced Image targetted by MM: People bring in hate bears vs your candles/Images, or have them main anyways. The good players won't MM your candle unless they have 2+ counterspells in opening hand. They will save it for a High Tide. This is why I run 4x candles, I will normally cast candle turn 1 to force my opponent to waste a counter, or see what he does. If i have turnabout + spiral in hand, i don't mind losing a candle.
I'm going to test with 4/3, 3/3 splist FoW and MM.
----------------------------------------
So I played in 2 Legacy events this weekend using Tide, firday night (our normal) and one as a side event at a NatQ, saturday.
Friday: 3-0-1; losing to Merfolk in Top 4
Match 1: W 2-0 vs. Mono G Infect
Match 2: W 2-0 vs. Belcher
Match 3: W 2-1 vs. Merfolk
Match 4: D 1-0-1 vs. Sneak and Show
Top 4: L 1-2 vs. Merfolk
- He had 3 Cursecatcher online game 3.
Saturday: 4-0; Lost to Merfolk again in top 4... I hate folk lol :rolleyes:
Match 1: W 2-1 vs. Sneak and Show
Match 2: W 2-0 vs. Belcher
Match 3: W 2-0 vs. Dredge
Match 4: W 2-1 vs. ANT
Top 4: L 1-2 vs. Merfolk (same guy)
I'm still tweaking my list and here it is. Had 1 MD Repeal and 1 Trade Routes as a difference.
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
2 Preordain
4 Time Spiral
4 High Tide
4 Candelabra of Tawnos
1 Mind Over Matter
1 Repeal
1 Trade Routes
4 Merchant Scroll
4 Force of Will
3 Cunning Wish
3 Turnabout
3 Meditate
6 Fetches
11 island
Wishboard:
standards
------------------------
On a sidenote...
I have been toying around with a B/U High Tide list online. This is far from optimized but the results are impressive, and I think if MM "forces a change" this could be an option. I havn't tried this build with MMs yet. This version goes to Tendrils of Agony[/c] as primary win con, with BSZ as still an option to wish for. Black also opens up the board to an array of options.
Pros:
- very easy to generate 9 storm count
- Proactive hand disruption
- 8 high tide effects, LDV over scroll; MM has less effect.
Cons;
- Wasteland can disrupt you (obvious)
- Kinda clunky and more difficult to pilot, as you have to worry about 2 mana types
- lose a bit more life (more all-in sort to speak)
Tendrils Tide:
[cards]
4 High Tide
4 Bubbling Muck
3 Force of Will
3 Duress
4 Time Spiral
3 Turnabout
4 Candelabra of Tawnos
3 Lim-Dûl's Vault
4 Brainstorm
3 Ponder
3 Meditate
3 Cunning Wish
1 Mind Over Matter
1 Tendrils of Agony
4 Underground Sea
4 Watery Grave
4 Polluted Delta
5 Island
wishboard:
1 Bsz
1 Turnabout
1 Meditate
...etc.
ScatmanX
05-02-2011, 04:37 PM
Tournament report is up:
http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?20754-5-2-Spiral-Tide-at-Paulinia-01-05-2011&p=544131
You can put in the OP if you want.
Any critiques/comments, please let me know.
egosum
05-03-2011, 05:07 AM
Post-Testing thoughts.
OK, so Non-Cunning wish list is tested, aswell as Gitaxian Probe is tested. And hav eto say that I have to agree that some number of Cunning must be kept, and Gitaxian Probe is Rock and Roll, BUT.... cannot replace any otehr single cantrip, this means that finally there is no room in the deck for GItaxian Probe because the other cards are simply more important.
I' ve basically tested against dreadstill, we all know how bad the pairing could be, but the problem is that I found me fizzling too often (I guess more after boarding, just because mybe I added too many counters to the deck playing 10 after board), this was one of the reasons why I missed the full set of Cantrips (my fizzling ratio when playing the full set was really low.
This is the list I'll test by now according to the results I saw.
Main deck 60:
4x Brainstorm
4x Ponder
4x Preordain
4x Force of Will
3x Mental Misstep
4x Merchant Scroll
4x Turnabout
4x Time Spiral
4x High Tide
3x Meditate
2x Cunning Wish
1x Trade Routes/Mesmeric Trance/ Intuition
1x Brain Freeze
12x Island
6x "Blue Fetch" (2+2+1+1)
Sideboard 15
3x Pact of Negation
3x Spell Pierce
2x Wipe Away
2x Snap
1x Echoing Truth
1x Rebuild
1x Meditate
1x Brain Freeze
1x Blue Sun's Zenith
On Trade Routes/Mesmeric Trance: the idea of adding this cycling machine seems pretty interesting. But I'm not sure which one is better. I'll try to make an ehaustive analysis so you can all give an opinion on this subject.
Pros for Trade Routes:
-Lower Cost ( U1 )
-Can be played in the turns before going off without any problems.
Contras for Trade Routes:
-Dies to Spell Snare.
-Only cycles Lands.
Pros for Mesmeric Trance:
-Can be played around Spell Snare ( 1UU ).
-Helps to cycle even the countermagic if it is no needed.
Contras of Mesmeric Trance:
-Cumulatide Upkeep makes it onlly useful while going off.
Intuition May also be added in this slot, so this is still quite dark...
There is only one minor point I' d like to discuss. Now, accepting Cunning Wish stays, would you guys think this change is acceptable?
Main deck:
-1x Turnabout
+1x Mind Over Matter
Sideboard:
-1x Snap
+1x Turnabout
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
DuKeLiO
05-03-2011, 07:59 AM
I don't think change Turnabout for MoM is acceptable. Turnabout enables your turn 3 tricks, and MoM isn't so good in a deck without candelabras. I tested these kind of builds, without more untap effects than Turnabouts and Spirals, and MoM wasn't very good. Maybe you can move the turnabout to the sideboard for another Wish. Then you resolves your problem for having turnabout in side, without having less untap effects maindeck. (but I think you play too few of them for safely comboing on turn three)
Also I think the BSZ maindeck and Brain Freeze in sideboard is better. Your main win condition has to be the BSZ beacuse it is safer, and brain freeze is only an emergency button to solve bad Spirals or racing decks like Ichorid.
egosum
05-03-2011, 08:00 AM
@DuKeLio: I'm not sure about MoM but still, as Probe, wanna test it (never done before). I know it may be a lot better with CoT, but it seems also a nice card along with Meditate. It's working nice so far, just have to test it more. BSZ is only good if played in the Candelabra version, without it is very difficult to generate wuch a big amount of mana. Brain Freeze is just too good, I'm not quite sure why most of you didn't like it. it's a very strogn card against CB+Top, plus killing with double Freeze (with Merchant Scroll or Cunning Wish) reduces by a big amount the Storm Count needed.
Here we have some results.
The list used is the one posted just above with:
1x Mesmeric Trance
-1x Turnabout (the turnabout has been moved to the board for a Snap)
+1x Mind Over Matter
I' ve tested with MWS. Impresive Ratings, nevertheless we all should know that you cannot always find a great player at MWS, even if you ask for it...
Big Zoo:
Played main deck: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Loam Pox: (Feat no Pox, but Small Pox, lots fo discard, Duress, Hymkn, Raven's crime... Isnkhole, SmallPox. Adding Orim's Chant with the Board)
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Won Side: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Naya Zoo: (Feat Mental misstep Maindeck. Very fast build with Nacatl, Ape and Goblin Guide)
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 2
Won Main deck: 1
Won Side: 1
Win Ratio: 66.66%
Dredge: (Feat Mental Misstep, don't know if in the Main or Side, I saw it in the Game 2)
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Won Side: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Team Italia: (For those who don't know is a BRW aggro disruptive deck)
Played main deck: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Merfolk: (with Mental Misstep)
Played main deck: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
(Not Suicide, nor the Gate. With Smallpox)
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Won Sideboard: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
[U]UG Madness:
Played main deck: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Team America:
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 1
Won Main deck: 0
Won Sideboard: 1
Win Ratio: 50%
RUG DreadStill:
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 1
Won Main deck: 1
Won Sideboard: 1
Win Ratio: 100%
Thopter Top (UWg):
Played main deck: 1
Played Sideboard: 2
Won Main deck: 1
Won Sideboard: 1
Win Ratio: 66.66%
Total Win Ratio: 83.33%
Total Win Ratio (against the most representative decks): 11/13 = 84.61%
I know this means nothing but just want to share the early results.
(The most representative Pairings are written in bold letters)
I'll keep testing, and sharing.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
I wouldn't cut a Turnabout maindeck (going to 3) just to use with 2 x Cunning Wish. This seems like being too cute while minimizing the chances you'll draw Turnabout. I would consider to use Wish as a situational card, like grabbing the 2nd Brainfreeze, Ravenous Trap (against Emrakuls), or Pact.
That also means at least 1 Brainfreeze maindeck too.
The Meditate maindeck is a step in the right direction IMO for builds not using Candelabra.
RexFTW
05-03-2011, 02:39 PM
Observations:
I believe mental misstep will be a great sideboard card vs discard spells and goblin lackey. This is a much needed addition. However, Pact of negation is much better against decks playing misstep and force of will because it can answer both of these.
After playing about 50 games, I find that turnabout is probably the least powerful card in the deck and the most likely to be a dead draw pre-combo.
MoM + meditate is almost as good as timespiral.
egosum
05-03-2011, 04:27 PM
I agree, completely, with Pact being better than MM against MM deck. But MM is far more versatile, i.e. it's useful against a wider amount of decks / threats, it also grants longer set up which is always useful in Spiral Tide. This is why I 've decided to put them in that way (MM main, PoN side). What I mean , is that MM is not only a hate card dedicated to stop Lackeys/Stifles/MM/... is a defense card, and a stalling card, so it will be alive every single match, while PoN will be alive only when playing against blue (and not always, for instance against CB - Top decks kinda sucks, or is weaker than opther alternatives at least).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
ScatmanX
05-03-2011, 04:37 PM
After playing about 50 games, I find that turnabout is probably the least powerful card in the deck and the most likely to be a dead draw pre-combo.
Did you just goldfished, or you played out the hole games?
Almost every game I played in the last tournament I attend I used Turnabout for something.
Against Burn: Tap mountains eot, so he wouldn't ReB me after Spiral;
Against MonoBlack: Tap Swamps eot so he wouldn't Extirpate me after Spiral;
Against MonoBlack: Turnabout 3 times, without High Tide, before a 19 card Zenith at myself;
Against Lands: Tapped his lands so he wouldn't cast the Canonist he had, neither attack me with Mishra's Factory;
Against Bant: I tapped his lands after the 1st Spiral, so Stifle wouldn't hit my fetches/CoF.
I think you are underestimating the power of Turnabout here. It is also one of the most useful cards against Counterbalance, either tapping his lands or his Top.
TheRedBaron
05-03-2011, 05:54 PM
Did you just goldfished, or you played out the hole games?
Almost every game I played in the last tournament I attend I used Turnabout for something.
Against Burn: Tap mountains eot, so he wouldn't ReB me after Spiral;
Against MonoBlack: Tap Swamps eot so he wouldn't Extirpate me after Spiral;
Against MonoBlack: Turnabout 3 times, without High Tide, before a 19 card Zenith at myself;
Against Lands: Tapped his lands so he wouldn't cast the Canonist he had, neither attack me with Mishra's Factory;
Against Bant: I tapped his lands after the 1st Spiral, so Stifle wouldn't hit my fetches/CoF.
I think you are underestimating the power of Turnabout here. It is also one of the most useful cards against Counterbalance, either tapping his lands or his Top.
I agree with scatman. Turnabout is a utility spell that takes care of known problems, where as Cunning Wish is the utility for reaction spells. I feel that 3 & 3 split is optimal.
I know this is going to sound odd but I'm trying to make an EDH High tide deck. Can you guys give me a least of some good blue cards that didn't make the cut in legacy but could be included in my deck? Basically I need some good blue business spells. Or is this really not the place to post this?
death
05-03-2011, 10:42 PM
Braingeyser
Attunement
Impulse
Stroke of Genius
Peer Through Depths
Ideas Unbound
Telling Time
Foresee
Opportunity
Serum Visions
Opt
Portent
Lat-Nam's Legacy
Arcane Denial
Three Wishes
Trade Routes
Mesmeric Trance
Palinchron
Reality Spasm
Toils of Night and Day
Twincast
thanks so much! that's exactly what I needed.
ScatmanX
05-03-2011, 11:16 PM
I'd try Trade Secrets.
Have anyone done some testing with it in legacy?
TheRedBaron
05-04-2011, 01:25 AM
thanks so much! that's exactly what I needed.
I'm actually working on an EDH version
Kira, Great Glass-spinner
will be my general with snow lands.
I'm doing
Gauntlet of power
High Tide
Mystical Tutor
great whale
frantic search
isochron scepter
treachery
I need another mana engine lol; i think search is legal in EDH.
EDIT:
Aha ,
Extraplanar Lens
Snowfall
from new set:
Tezzeret's Gambit
Gitaxian Probe
Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur
Are the other mana engine options
I'd try Trade Secrets.
Have anyone done some testing with it in legacy?
This seems interesting, but it would suck vs. random Blue decks/Mirror/Solidarity.
RexFTW
05-04-2011, 12:38 PM
Hah. Nobody mentioned timetwister or Mind's Desire for the edh guy! Only the best cards this deck will never get :(.
Also, if your doing this deck in EDH you should add black and include tutors + necropotence + tendrils of agony. The only reason black isnt played normally is the prevelance of wasteland in legacy not EDH.
Depending how sick you want to be, Red can go in for all of its Draw 7's and molten psyche as well.
Basically you want to play most of these cards:
http://gatherer.wizards.com/Pages/Search/Default.aspx?page=0&action=advanced&text=+[draw]+[seven]
RexFTW
05-04-2011, 12:50 PM
Trade Secrets seems like it is actually better than meditate against some decks!!!!! nice find. Now if only there were space in the board for it....
Time to change the thread from legacy to EDH :laugh:
Yeah I go UBG high tide
green for mainly Heartbeat of spring. Black for the great tutors like Demonic tutor. Anyway I'll post a primer on mtgsalvation after the deck gets okay.
TheRedBaron, Pm me if you want to compare deck lists.
RexFTW
05-04-2011, 06:53 PM
Has anyone tested 1-2 diminishing returns in this deck?
TheRedBaron
05-04-2011, 07:10 PM
Has anyone tested 1-2 diminishing returns in this deck?
You, know... I thought about it. However, I felt that it would be a good wish target if it was an instant. To me Time spiral does what this card does, except bertter.
RexFTW
05-04-2011, 07:23 PM
Unfortunately you can only play 4 timespirals :(
TheInfamousBearAssassin
05-04-2011, 07:40 PM
I'm actually working on an EDH version
Kira, Great Glass-spinner
will be my general with snow lands.
I'm doing
Gauntlet of power
High Tide
Mystical Tutor
great whale
frantic search
isochron scepter
treachery
I need another mana engine lol; i think search is legal in EDH.
EDIT:
Aha ,
Extraplanar Lens
Snowfall
from new set:
Tezzeret's Gambit
Gitaxian Probe
Jin-Gitaxias, Core Augur
Are the other mana engine options
This seems interesting, but it would suck vs. random Blue decks/Mirror/Solidarity.
Caged Sun
Palinchron
ScatmanX
05-07-2011, 07:05 PM
Went 3-1 today. same list.
R1: Elves
G1: I drop lands with Counterspell backup in case he has anything that worries me, but I combo easily with 5 lands I guess.
G2: He drops turn 2 Thorn, and turn 3 Tegg. I combo 2 turns later! (take that hate pieces!)
R2: UBG Landstill
g1: On his turn 4 or 5, he cast Jace, I counterspell, and combo on my turn, Pact protected.
g2: He starts hitting me soon, and I had to waste a FoW on a Standstill, and I bait counterspells on Scrolls and other cards. Unfortunately, I can't find any protection. With 2 life, I had only High Tide and Time Spiral on my hand. I had Tournabouted him in his eot. My draw for the turn: Pact!(could have been Counterspell too... I had lots of mana). I resolve my spells, and kill him.
R3: Bant
g1: I lead with 1 land, and a cantrip finds me another, but I had 2 dead draws next turn. So I FoW his turn 2 Goyf, Counterspell his turn 3 Relicary, and attempt to counterspell his Goyf another turn, but he Pierce's it. I find a land, pass. He cast a dude that resolves, and I go off Pact protected in a couple of turns...
g2: He cast a FoW protected Tegg, which I double FoW(mistake. Should've only FoW'd once...) Then I search for Meditate to refil. When he FINALLY finds his 3rd land, he Zenith's, which I had to Pact. My upkeep I Tournabout myself, pay pact, Turnabout again, cast Time Spiral. My grip had only a Ponder as business, that finds me nothing on the top3 cards. I shuffle, and rip a Time Spiral from the top, cast High Tide, Turnabout, Time Spiral, and then win.
R4:
We splitted, but played for practice.
g1: I keep a hand with 3 lands. he cast 1st turn Trinisphere. Resolves. I play land, he plays CotV@1. I play land. He play land. I play land, and Scroll for Wish. He Geddon's... I play land, he play land. I play land, he play land. We both discard 1 or 2 cards, and I find the 3rd land, that gets me to Wish for Rebuild, and combo the next turn.
G2: He gets to resolve both CotV and Trini again, while beating me down this time, while I countered 1 Geddon and 1 CotV@2 with Counterspells.I reach 6 mana when I had only one more turn, so his eot, I Wish for Wipe Away, and get his CotV. My turn I play 3 for High Tide, cast Turnabout, and Ponder, that findes me Intuition, that gets me Time Spiral, that get's me 7 blanks. I pass, I'm able to Turnabout his creature, and counter everything he does. I find a Brainstorm from the top, and it gets me nothing...=/
g3: I had Preordain, 2 High Tide, 1 FoW, 1 Counterspell, 1 Turnabout, and a Preordain, that found me 2 lands on top. I don't know why I let him resolve a CotV@1 on his 1st turn, and I lose from there... I also let him resolve a Magus of the Tabernacle... I don't know why... My FoW and Counterspells just sit there in my hand, while I didn't cast them. I eneded up drawing Time Spiral and cantrips, and would be able to win easily only I had countered Chalice... lesson learned.
Well... just sharing reports as usual. This deck is freaking bonkers.
g2: He cast a FoW protected Tegg, which I double FoW(mistake. Should've only FoW'd once...) Then I search for Meditate to refil. When he FINALLY finds his 3rd land, he Zenith's
Did he Green Sun's Zenith with a Gaddock Teeg in play? Does not seems fair to me. :eyebrow:
Diprivan
05-08-2011, 12:59 PM
Double fow means teeg never hit play.
Edit: lol @ double teeg play
ScatmanX
05-08-2011, 01:00 PM
Double fow means teeg never hit play.
Also, Tegg is legendary, so if he would have 2 in play, good for me! =D
Ziilot
05-09-2011, 10:06 AM
Played yesterday in a small tournament (22 players).
Went 3-1-1 in swiss which granted me place 7. Lost to Merfolk in top8 quarters.
My matchups were:
R1 vs. GW ZenithOrder 2-1
Lost one game due missplay
R2 vs. Goblins 1-2
G2 2x Mindbreak Traps
G3 I mulled into five and had to go unprotected. He had pyroblast.
R3 vs. Merfolk 2-1
R4 vs. NO Bant 2-0
R5 ID
TOP 8 vs. Merfolk 0-2
G1 Time spiral gave me 4 lands, 2 pacts and Brainstorm. Brainstorm showed me 2 lands and a high tide. Afterwards he tells me that he didn't draw Force of Will. Oh well, this was the first time my deck fizzles.
G2 Cursecatcher, Spell Pierce and Force of Will was just too much, I only had one Pact of Negation as a protection.
MD:
12x Island
3x Misty Rainforest
3x Scalding Tarn
4x Force of Will
3x Pact of Negation
4x Ponder
4x Brainstorm
3x Preordain
3x Turnabout
3x Cloud of Faeries
1x Snap
4x Merchant Scroll
4x High Tide
4x Time Spiral
2x Cunning Wish
1x Blue Sun's Zenith
1x Meditate
1x Intuition
SB:
2x Spell Pierce
2x Snap
2x Wipe Away
1x Meditate
1x Blue Sun's Zenith
1x Brain Freeze
1x Turnabout
1x Dispel
1x Hurkyl's Recall
1x Rebuild
1x Echoing Truth
1x Ravenous Trap
Maindeck felt really solid, but I still don't like Cloud of Faeries. Well, what can you do if you can't afford Candelabras..
I can't say much about sideboard. I didn't side anything vs. Merfolks and Bant. I don't know about Spell Pierces though, do we need so much countermagic? Dispel was good in wishboard, I wished it once or twice iirc.
egosum
05-09-2011, 10:29 AM
I don't know about Spell Pierces though, do we need so much countermagic?
Try to play against Counterbalance, or Duress/Thoughtseize/Hymn decks (Junk, for instance), you'll tell.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
nayon
05-09-2011, 10:26 PM
Can someone give me sideboarding tips? I never know what to take out/bring in.
ScatmanX
05-09-2011, 10:36 PM
Can someone give me sideboarding tips? I never know what to take out/bring in.
Your list, sideboard, and decks you want tips against would help us help you...
But overall, with the CAB list, I try to decide if I want to combo fast, or do I need to control some elements before I do.
In the first case, I bring Snaps for Counterspells.
In the second case, I bring in Pierces for Faeries.
nayon
05-09-2011, 10:44 PM
Your list, sideboard, and decks you want tips against would help us help you...
But overall, with the CAB list, I try to decide if I want to combo fast, or do I need to control some elements before I do.
In the first case, I bring Snaps for Counterspells.
In the second case, I bring in Pierces for Faeries.
Sorry about that. Well, I haven't nailed down a list yet, I was playing Jesse Hatfield's latest list, but I need to update it for post-NPH, I don't know what list to play. I have Candelabras, but I'm not sure about what I should do. I'll probably play Irenicus's list from the previous page or maaaybe egosum's list?
Edit: Better question: Can someone give me ideas for a post-NPH list?
lebarion
05-10-2011, 04:54 PM
Sorry about that. Well, I haven't nailed down a list yet, I was playing Jesse Hatfield's latest list, but I need to update it for post-NPH, I don't know what list to play. I have Candelabras, but I'm not sure about what I should do. I'll probably play Irenicus's list from the previous page or maaaybe egosum's list?
Edit: Better question: Can someone give me ideas for a post-NPH list?
I think that Candelabra vs. Retraced Image vs. Cloud of Faeries will still be a matter of playstyle, even post-NPH. Mental Misstep apparently make CoF more appealing, but this may be tricky as if they waste MM in your candelabra, they have one less counter to High Tide.
I think we must wait and see the impact of Mental Misstep in the metagame. If it is as broadly played as most people expect, I'd try cutting some Preordains for Impulses, but this is probably not enough. For those who splash G (I do) maybe run 1 Determined MD can be good.
I'm not sure if running MM ourselves is a bad idea.
For what is worth, I attended the same tournament ScatmanX did and went 4-1-2. Win vs Affinity, Deadguy, Faeries and Madness, tie with the mirror, and lost to Team Italia (too much discard, and one fizzle) and GW aggro (in the first game I couldn't find a 3rd land after seeing 9 cards with cantrips, and second game he opened with 2nd turn Gaddock which I countered, 3rd turn Cannonist which I countered, and the turn before I could combo he topdecked Natural Order into other Gaddock...)
nayon
05-10-2011, 07:56 PM
I think that Candelabra vs. Retraced Image vs. Cloud of Faeries will still be a matter of playstyle, even post-NPH. Mental Misstep apparently make CoF more appealing, but this may be tricky as if they waste MM in your candelabra, they have one less counter to High Tide.
I think we must wait and see the impact of Mental Misstep in the metagame. If it is as broadly played as most people expect, I'd try cutting some Preordains for Impulses, but this is probably not enough. For those who splash G (I do) maybe run 1 Determined MD can be good.
I'm not sure if running MM ourselves is a bad idea.
For what is worth, I attended the same tournament ScatmanX did and went 4-1-2. Win vs Affinity, Deadguy, Faeries and Madness, tie with the mirror, and lost to Team Italia (too much discard, and one fizzle) and GW aggro (in the first game I couldn't find a 3rd land after seeing 9 cards with cantrips, and second game he opened with 2nd turn Gaddock which I countered, 3rd turn Cannonist which I countered, and the turn before I could combo he topdecked Natural Order into other Gaddock...)
To be honest, I'm fine with the candles getting countered. I've always felt that draw spells are more important than the candles, especially since I usually go for a Brain Freeze plan (with Ravenous Trap in the board if necessary). But Trade Routes/Mesmeric Trance seem appealing too.
What's this CAB list that's been mentioned? I looked around the thread but couldn't find a list specifically labeled as that.
ScatmanX
05-11-2011, 12:13 AM
To be honest, I'm fine with the candles getting countered. I've always felt that draw spells are more important than the candles, especially since I usually go for a Brain Freeze plan (with Ravenous Trap in the board if necessary). But Trade Routes/Mesmeric Trance seem appealing too.
What's this CAB list that's been mentioned? I looked around the thread but couldn't find a list specifically labeled as that.
Ravenous Trap can now be subbed by the new free Extirpate now.That also handles Emrakul better...
CAB list is in the oppening post, 2nd list.
nayon
05-11-2011, 01:12 AM
Ravenous Trap can now be subbed by the new free Extirpate now.That also handles Emrakul better...
CAB list is in the oppening post, 2nd list.
I don't see why you would prefer Surgical Extraction over Ravenous Trap. Extraction only removes the Emrakul, which shuffles everything back anyway, whereas Trap removes the entire graveyard. With Extraction you need to cast an extra Brain Freeze to ensure you'll win.
Extraction might be better in other circumstances, but it doesn't feel that critical to me. Do you think I should run it main? That's the only justification I can see for running extraction over trap.
rgripp
05-11-2011, 02:51 AM
@nayon
Unless they play more than 1 Emrakul in the deck, in which case you would need to have the same number of traps in hand.
kombatkiwi
05-11-2011, 05:24 AM
Hi guys
What do you think of candelabra
A) It's a staple card, necessary to play the deck
B) The deck can work really well without it, but generally accepted that candelabra makes the deck better (eg Mono Red Goblins can/does work but duals generally improve the quality of (sideboard) card choices)
C) Arguably the best version of the deck does not play candelabra
Also, why don't you call it Tide Spiral? I think that sounds way cooler
Thanks for the help
DuKeLiO
05-11-2011, 05:57 AM
It is obviously than the non-Candelabra versions also work fine, but in my experience, Candelabra of Tawnos is better doing the deck faster (it is really hard comboing with two islands with Candelabras or Faeries).
In my version, Candelabra only remains in my deck when I am trying to race my opponent. Usually in game one it is a good card, beacuse aggro decks are faster on game one. It is a very common move to side it on game two and three, when I will not need race my opponent, only fight against his hate.
I call the deck Spiral Tide beacuse i like words like start with "s", and I can say SSSSSSSSSSSSSSpiralTide ;)
ScatmanX
05-11-2011, 10:18 AM
I don't see why you would prefer Surgical Extraction over Ravenous Trap. Extraction only removes the Emrakul, which shuffles everything back anyway, whereas Trap removes the entire graveyard. With Extraction you need to cast an extra Brain Freeze to ensure you'll win.
Extraction removes all their Emrakuls. It ain't that difficult getting a shitload of storm here.
This deck is calles Spiral Tide because it evolved, after the unbanning of Time Spiral, from Spring Tide.
The candelabra version is called Permanent Waves, and has it's own thread, but no one posts there...
nayon
05-11-2011, 11:14 AM
It is obviously than the non-Candelabra versions also work fine, but in my experience, Candelabra of Tawnos is better doing the deck faster (it is really hard comboing with two islands with Candelabras or Faeries).
In my version, Candelabra only remains in my deck when I am trying to race my opponent. Usually in game one it is a good card, beacuse aggro decks are faster on game one. It is a very common move to side it on game two and three, when I will not need race my opponent, only fight against his hate.
I call the deck Spiral Tide beacuse i like words like start with "s", and I can say SSSSSSSSSSSSSSpiralTide ;)
I agree with the point that candelabras add speed and consistency.
What about Intuition/Meditate? I always want some form of card draw in my hand but always find them to be a bit wieldy.
RexFTW
05-11-2011, 11:27 AM
By the way, this helps the opponent relax during the combo turn. It also helps me make better plays. In fact, I always turn it on when i reslove high tide.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C8OBlq_svBY
TheRedBaron
05-11-2011, 11:38 AM
Extraction removes all their Emrakuls. It ain't that difficult getting a shitload of storm here.
This deck is calles Spiral Tide because it evolved, after the unbanning of Time Spiral, from Spring Tide.
The candelabra version is called Permanent Waves, and has it's own thread, but no one posts there...
Yeah... IMO i believe Spring Tide evolved from Solidarity, which evolved from permanent waves. Candles + M.O.M. + Tolarian academy were there originally, and obviously academy got banned. The deck then focused on MOM and candles + High Tide. Solidarity gained in popularity using Resest + High Tide. Spring Tide evolved from Solidarity adopting CoF + Snap as the primary engine, going back to a "permanent based engine". So, up until the unbanning of Time Spiral you had two primary forms of the deck, Spring Tide and Solidarity.
I don't think you can classify Spiral Tide as any of the aforementioned. Candles and MoM are just a borrowed engine from the ancestor of High Tide decks. This a "Next Level Permanent Waves", kinda.
I agree with the point that candelabras add speed and consistency.
What about Intuition/Meditate? I always want some form of card draw in my hand but always find them to be a bit wieldy.
I usually play with 3 Meditate Main, 1 intuition Main or Side, 1 Meditate side. Sometimes 1 Intuition main AND 1 side. The point of intuition is to be a utility spell. It is that 5th Merchant scroll. It can Literally grab any card in your deck. Need extra land? a candle?... Intuition in response to get 3x Force of Will to counter something... It is purely responsive... This is also why you board stuff in, in variables of three. As in you board in Wipe away x1, Snap x1, Repeal x1 for example.
Meditate allows you to dig 4 cards deep. 4 for 3CMC is about the most effecient you will get, besides ancestral recall
Ziilot
05-11-2011, 07:39 PM
I'm tempted to try Diverts in sideboard. Maybe in place of Spell Pierces, since they are good vs. discard too and Counterbalance isn't widely played in our meta. Neither are CotV / 3Sphere.
Anyone has tried them? Is this again an idea which looks good only in paper..
rgripp
05-11-2011, 07:48 PM
I played 3 Diverts on a 34 person championship in which I split Top 2 recently, and honestly, not worth it. Against discard, you're much better off with a Brainstorm in response or a Meditate to make them 1-for-1ing you silly, or even keeping business cards on the top with Ponder and Preordain.
Best case scenario, you Divert a turn 2 Hymn to Tourach. Normally, you'll just keep a mana open instead of cantripping on the first turns to Divert a Thoughtseize that wouldn't be that much relevant anyway.
And against counterspell, it's better to just play Counterspells or Spell Pierces, because they got way more applications...
ScatmanX
05-11-2011, 08:44 PM
I played 3 Diverts on a 34 person championship in which I split Top 2 recently, and honestly, not worth it. Against discard, you're much better off with a Brainstorm in response or a Meditate to make them 1-for-1ing you silly, or even keeping business cards on the top with Ponder and Preordain.
Best case scenario, you Divert a turn 2 Hymn to Tourach. Normally, you'll just keep a mana open instead of cantripping on the first turns to Divert a Thoughtseize that wouldn't be that much relevant anyway.
And against counterspell, it's better to just play Counterspells or Spell Pierces, because they got way more applications...
There are lots of cards thatt make Pierce better than Divert, not only CB, but Trinisphere, Thorn of Amethyst, Chalice of the Vois, Choke, Armageddon, Zenith, Duress...
RexFTW
05-11-2011, 09:51 PM
Armageddon? I have been playing tournament legacy for 2 years and have never been armageddoned. Not that its a bad card.
ScatmanX
05-11-2011, 11:59 PM
Armageddon? I have been playing tournament legacy for 2 years and have never been armageddoned. Not that its a bad card.
I've been in 2 of my last 4 last tournaments. There are reports.
If you think Divert has wider/better application than Spell Pierce, fell free to use it.
rgripp
05-12-2011, 10:42 AM
Exactly, Spell Pierce is better than Divert, I agree with you. Even against discard, I barely sided the Diverts in.
Infinitium
05-12-2011, 06:01 PM
Drain Power.
Target player activates a mana ability of each land he or she controls. Then put all mana from that player's mana pool into yours.
I was just made aware of this card's existence, and it looks obnoxiously strong as a sideboard versus blue decks in general as well as being easily sided in place of an existing untap effect. Basically it shuts off all their digging power post-spiral as well as counterspell mana and assorted tricks (Extirpate comes to mind) whilst simultaneously ramping our own mana. The best parts? It still abuses the hell out of High Tide and isn't completely dead should you draw the first copy midcombo. Note that with the oracle wording the opponent cannot just tap all of their lands in response to deny you the mana.
rgripp
05-12-2011, 06:24 PM
He can tap his lands and use the mana casting Instants before the Drain Power resolves. That being said, the card is at the very least very interesting...
I see this card as a better Mana Short against blue decks. It's not very much stronger than Mana Short (Instant) is better against every other color. Finally, Turnabout is just more versatile. The only selling point is that it's great against Islands midcombo.
ScatmanX
05-12-2011, 08:07 PM
The only selling point is that it's great against Islands midcombo.
So is Turnabout.
You use at them, they float mana, you declare attackers.
That card should not be use whatsoever.
death
05-12-2011, 10:36 PM
Drain Power belongs to the trash bin. It's worse than Spell Pierce or Counterspell, especially now there are officially 2 free spells against this deck. It will never be good against blue with MM + MM, MM + FOW, or Fow + FoW.
ScatmanX
05-14-2011, 11:33 AM
Now I read Drain Power oracle, and realized I had figured the card wrong. Ok, they can still cast Instants, but it should add a lot of mana to your mana poll for just UU.
To bad the 2nd one for the turn sux...
Since we're tossing wacky ideas, then here's mine:
Extraplanar Lens. This way you can combo without High Tide. If you play it turn 3, then you can play Time Spiral turn 4 without any other card.
Also, it's a continuous High Tide for every turn of the game, which may be usefull some games.
death
05-14-2011, 12:10 PM
Too bad it doesn't tap for mana. It's won't be easy going the zenith way with only 3 lands in play.
RexFTW
05-16-2011, 12:23 PM
Too bad it doesn't tap for mana. It's won't be easy going the zenith way with only 3 lands in play.
Try candelabra + MOM. Then u can zenith with 2 lands :).
ns2973
05-16-2011, 12:40 PM
I'd planned on playing tide at the GP. With the orlando SCG running those 2 landstill varients, i'm concerned a spike of blue permission/landstill spiking for the next couple weeks. I wasn't worired about misstep so much, but misstep, counter, force, etc in a standstill shell doesn't bode well.
What do you guys think?
lebarion
05-16-2011, 01:38 PM
I've played a 28-people tournament yesterday and went 4-0-1, wining against ForgeMaster combo, Big Zoo, Ubg Landstill w/ Mental Misstep and Zoo, and drawing with BW Deadguy. I've lost to Zoo in the top 8 due to bad draws in G2 and fizzle in G3.
The list is similar to Mon's list, except I've tested 2 Impulses in the place of Preordain. Other than that, 19 lands, 3 Wishes, 1 Turnabout in the side.
I'd planned on playing tide at the GP. With the orlando SCG running those 2 landstill varients, i'm concerned a spike of blue permission/landstill spiking for the next couple weeks. I wasn't worired about misstep so much, but misstep, counter, force, etc in a standstill shell doesn't bode well.
What do you guys think?
Although different from the the Ubg Landstill list I've faced yesterday, I believe the match plays very similarly, and I must say it is a lot in our favor. Just make sure to drop a lot of lands, and eventually try to combo. They will probably prevent you from comboing, then you try again next turn. And if you're not able to combo, try again after that. You have plenty of time. Turnabouting his lands may be a good move, as then you must be concerned about Missteps and FoWs only.
In one game, I've tried to combo twice and he countered. The third time i didn't have a High Tide, so i just Spiraled into seven new cards and comboed soon after that.
What I'm really afraid of are tempo decks with Mental Missteps. They might be our nightmare match.
ns2973
05-16-2011, 01:50 PM
You could be right, they were running 15 permission spells, thats quite a bit. Tempo with misstep is a hassle as it was, having 5% of the meta be tempo, 5% landstill and 10% merfolk is a scary idea for high tide. It'll be a fight all day.
Just wondering if this is going to make our positioning that much worse.
GradStudentGuy
05-16-2011, 02:05 PM
You could be right, they were running 15 permission spells, thats quite a bit. Tempo with misstep is a hassle as it was, having 5% of the meta be tempo, 5% landstill and 10% merfolk is a scary idea for high tide. It'll be a fight all day.
Just wondering if this is going to make our positioning that much worse.
I have been toying with the idea of adding 2 missteps main deck to fight other missteps and scary first turn drops such as lackey ,vial or top. I think this deck however gained a lot in the new card Noxious Revival. It is an excellent cunning wish target for High Tides mid combo or even a Time Spiral that is discarded. It greatly improves our match up against discard decks.
Engine
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
3 Turnabout
4 Time Spiral
4 High Tide
Flex
1 Retraced Image
Draw
3 Meditate
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
Tutors
3 Cunning Wish
4 Merchant Scroll
Can-trips
4 Ponder
4 Brainstorm
2 Preordain
Protection
4 Force of Will
2 Mental Misstep
Land
12 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
2 Flooded Strand
2 Polluted Delta
sideboard
1 Meditate
1 Turnabout
1 Brain Freeze
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
1 Echoing Truth
1 Wipe away
1 Retraced Image
3 Pact of Negation
1 Noxious Revival
1 Rebuild
2 Repeal
1 Mental Misstep
ScatmanX
05-16-2011, 02:10 PM
I've played a 28-people tournament yesterday and went 4-0-1, wining against ForgeMaster combo, Big Zoo, Ubg Landstill w/ Mental Misstep and Zoo, and drawing with BW Deadguy. I've lost to Zoo in the top 8 due to bad draws in G2 and fizzle in G3.
The list is similar to Mon's list, except I've tested 2 Impulses in the place of Preordain. Other than that, 19 lands, 3 Wishes, 1 Turnabout in the side.
Congrats! =D
Although different from the the Ubg Landstill list I've faced yesterday, I believe the match plays very similarly, and I must say it is a lot in our favor. Just make sure to drop a lot of lands, and eventually try to combo. They will probably prevent you from comboing, then you try again next turn. And if you're not able to combo, try again after that. You have plenty of time. Turnabouting his lands may be a good move, as then you must be concerned about Missteps and FoWs only.
In one game, I've tried to combo twice and he countered. The third time i didn't have a High Tide, so i just Spiraled into seven new cards and comboed soon after that.
What I'm really afraid of are tempo decks with Mental Missteps. They might be our nightmare match.
The new Landstill seems like easier than UBG, since it don't have Seize and Extirpate on the SB. Just hold a lot of counterspells, Turnabout Eot, and have a Time Spiral backup.
Now, the Merfolk lists are scaring me... I need to practice against those...
ns2973
05-16-2011, 02:18 PM
I've been playing a similar list, although i'm always sad to let mind over matter go. I've found revival to be pretty situational but a house when it's good. I've also been playing surgical extraction out of the board as well, as dredge has been messing with my lifestyle lately.
I ran 1 repeal instead of 2 in the board for the surgical slot.
GradStudentGuy
05-16-2011, 02:29 PM
I've been playing a similar list, although i'm always sad to let mind over matter go. I've found revival to be pretty situational but a house when it's good. I've also been playing surgical extraction out of the board as well, as dredge has been messing with my lifestyle lately.
I ran 1 repeal instead of 2 in the board for the surgical slot.
I may have to try surgical then in the board next time I go to a large event over the trap. I am still not sure if Mental should be a 2x of 3x main. I have been flopping between the two configurations. They have been key against tempo decks and fish but other times I wish they were just more preordains. How many are you running?
I've been playing a similar list, although i'm always sad to let mind over matter go. I've found revival to be pretty situational but a house when it's good. I've also been playing surgical extraction out of the board as well, as dredge has been messing with my lifestyle lately.
I ran 1 repeal instead of 2 in the board for the surgical slot.
Sorry, Nick.
To be fair, my dredges that day were ungodly good against you and it didn't seem your draws were that great, especially game 3.
ns2973
05-16-2011, 02:55 PM
Sorry, Nick.
To be fair, my dredges that day were ungodly good against you and it didn't seem your draws were that great, especially game 3.
All good holmes. In the end though it's not a favorable matchup. The ability to flip multiple cabal therapies and pose an aggro threat as early as turn 1 are both issues in a deck with minimal permission suite. I ended up losing to Pete for the same reason, i can overcome 1-2 therapies, but when you end up with 3-4 it's a tough swing to come back from while fighting the horde of zombie tokens as well.
Huge congratulations to inaki (egosum) for his top 16 at BoM!
I'd be interested in the list you used, if you could post it would be very appreciated! I haven't seen it on the french or italian forums yet.
Thanks!
DuKeLiO
05-17-2011, 08:19 AM
First, congratulations to Iñaki for his top 16 on BoM.
I also tried the deck there. I had a 7-2 finish. My two losses where due to my own play errors. Maybe I have not won the games, but my errors did I lose it.
The impact of Mental Misstep as as huge than I expected. Winning against tempo deck featuring them is only a little more hard, beacuse this decks run Spell Pierce, Spellstutter Sprite or something similar before.
The problem is when you are playing against control.
Before Mental Misstep you have a complete inevitability beacuse his Spell Pierce becomes weaker with the time run, but right now, it is more hard run throw them. But I think the deck continues being comptetive, but the things are harder now.
I,m not sure if I have to go with Pacts right now. Dispel and Spell Pierces are both countered by Mental Misstep, but right now the counter war is when I am trying to play High Tide, and don't matter if my counter cost 1 or not. I played the exact list than last tournaments but I modified my sideboard:
3 Krosan Grip
3 Divert
2 Snap
2 Surgical Extraction
1 Echoing Truth
1 Brain Freeze
1 Hurkyl's Recall (I'm not sure if I have to swap it for a Rebuild or not)
1 Hibernation
1 Mindbreak Trap
ScatmanX
05-17-2011, 10:57 AM
First, congratulations to Iñaki for his top 16 on BoM.
I also tried the deck there. I had a 7-2 finish. My two losses where due to my own play errors. Maybe I have not won the games, but my errors did I lose it.
The impact of Mental Misstep as as huge than I expected. Winning against tempo deck featuring them is only a little more hard, beacuse this decks run Spell Pierce, Spellstutter Sprite or something similar before.
The problem is when you are playing against control.
Before Mental Misstep you have a complete inevitability beacuse his Spell Pierce becomes weaker with the time run, but right now, it is more hard run throw them. But I think the deck continues being comptetive, but the things are harder now.
I,m not sure if I have to go with Pacts right now. Dispel and Spell Pierces are both countered by Mental Misstep, but right now the counter war is when I am trying to play High Tide, and don't matter if my counter cost 1 or not. I played the exact list than last tournaments but I modified my sideboard:
3 Krosan Grip
3 Divert
2 Snap
2 Surgical Extraction
1 Echoing Truth
1 Brain Freeze
1 Hurkyl's Recall (I'm not sure if I have to swap it for a Rebuild or not)
1 Hibernation
1 Mindbreak Trap
7-2 is a very good result too. Congratulations.
I think that paying 1 to cast you Dispel can make a huge difference instead of paying 0 to pay for Pact. Specially in multiples.
How were the Diverts? Do you ever wished they were Pierces?
You never wished you had a draw spell on your sb?
-I think Rebuild is better, because, not only it goes around CotV@2, it cycles, what can make a difference mid-combo.
ns2973
05-17-2011, 11:15 AM
Rebuild is certainly better in my opinion, it bounces, doesn't target, returns your candelabra's mid combo and cycles. I never understood the hurkyls.
lebarion
05-17-2011, 01:54 PM
Congratz to egosum and DuKeLiO for the expressive results!
Reading DuKeLiO last post, in particular this part:
right now the counter war is when I am trying to play High Tide
made me think about Remand. It's old tech from Solidarity, allows you to play Brain Freeze with less storm, makes it easier to dodge Emrakul, and is also useful against Mental Misstep - just counter your own High Tide and play it again next turn. And of course, it gains you tempo sometimes.
Maybe it's a bad idea, but I think I'll try it... what do you guys think?
ns2973
05-17-2011, 04:06 PM
It feels way too conditional in my tastes. The problem is we need to have solid counters to go off, without diluting the base of the combo so we wiff in spirals. I'm thinking of moving a pact mainboard, so i can scroll for it, have force and pact backup to fight misstep.
Infinitium
05-17-2011, 04:18 PM
Defense Grid? I've used it in my non-wish sideboard and it's fairly effective. Gets around MM, doesn't clog your hand post-spiral is a must-counter otherwise and more or less guarantees that you win the first counterwar, as well as slowing the opponent down since it more or less prohibits them from tapping out. It's contraproductive when the opponent also runs discard but no amount of retooling the sideboard will make TA/Dreadstill any less of a horrible matchup.
ns2973
05-17-2011, 04:30 PM
Defense Grid? I've used it in my non-wish sideboard and it's fairly effective. Gets around MM, doesn't clog your hand post-spiral is a must-counter otherwise and more or less guarantees that you win the first counterwar, as well as slowing the opponent down since it more or less prohibits them from tapping out. It's contraproductive when the opponent also runs discard but no amount of retooling the sideboard will make TA/Dreadstill any less of a horrible matchup.
Now THAT is funny, i literally added them to my testing board last night. I'm going to give them a run and see what happens.
ScatmanX
05-17-2011, 04:36 PM
Nice. I tried Defense Grid, but Pierce fucked it up really bad.
Now, it may be the right card again.
rgripp
05-17-2011, 04:59 PM
Adam Barnello suggested Mystic Remoras on his article a couple of months ago. Since on the first couple of turns we're just cantripping, we kinda have the mana to pay for the upkeep for 2-3 turns and still play 1cc cantrips.
On the turn we're going off, we can High Tide in response to the upkeep cost, draw a card for each counter they have and then sacrifice the enchantment.
Besides, it really makes the opposing deck cantrips work for you, and really funny against merfolk if you counter or they don't have a vial.
ScatmanX
05-17-2011, 05:15 PM
Adam Barnello suggested Mystic Remoras on his article a couple of months ago. Since on the first couple of turns we're just cantripping, we kinda have the mana to pay for the upkeep for 2-3 turns and still play 1cc cantrips.
On the turn we're going off, we can High Tide in response to the upkeep cost, draw a card for each counter they have and then sacrifice the enchantment.
Besides, it really makes the opposing deck cantrips work for you, and really funny against merfolk if you counter or they don't have a vial.
What I don't like is that Remora don't offer protection. Sure you can draw counterspells from it, but you can get 2-3 lands, and they get to counter your High Tide the same way.
The good part about it, is that it is also useful versus Discard, specially if played turn 1.
- Why is it funny against Folk if they don't have Vial? you only draw cards for NON-creature spells.
rgripp
05-17-2011, 07:22 PM
Yes, and then they have to use their mana playing creatures and not disrupting you, or disrupting you and not put you in a clock while you get cards for it.
ScatmanX
05-17-2011, 07:48 PM
Yes, and then they have to use their mana playing creatures and not disrupting you, or disrupting you and not put you in a clock while you get cards for it.
From what I see on the latest lists, Merfolk is running all free-counters possible (Daze, MM, FoW), with only a Pierce, at most. They don't seem to have to keep their lands open to use their disrupts...
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 09:35 AM
I played against 'folk today to test.
Won 3/4 preboard against a deck packing all 12 free counters, cursecatcher and standstill.
This deck is amazing against landstill because they have no clock.
~Using hatfield's list with candles and only 4 force maindeck (no other counters).~
Irenicus
05-18-2011, 09:59 AM
I played against 'folk today to test.
Won 3/4 preboard against a deck packing all 12 free counters, cursecatcher and standstill.
That's promising. I haven't had the chance to playtest or play in a tournament with NPH yet. Which list did you use?
At the moment I am thinking about which additional counter (in the maindeck) makes sense the most.
1) Spell Pierce: Good vs Hymn, Zenith and Counterbalance. In addition it helps vs. MUD and Combo in general.
2) Mental Misstep: Good vs Top, Vial and 1cc Discard. Helps vs. opposing MMs too and doesn't need mana during the combo turn.
3) Counterspell: Universal. But doesn't work that well during the combo turn before we have "infinite" mana.
4) Pact of Negation: Helps in an blue-infested metagame. But doesn't handle anything precombo.
At the moment I am thinking about playing a mix of Spell Pierce, Mental Misstep and Pact of Negation in my 75. Haven't figured out which needs to be MD yet. Maybe even FoW isn't a must 4-of.
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 10:26 AM
Remember: every counter you add increases your chance of fizzling by approximately 2%.
Irenicus
05-18-2011, 11:12 AM
Remember: every counter you add increases your chance of fizzling by approximately 2%.
I don't want to warm the discussion about how many counters are needed up again. I am used to play with 8 counterspells in the maindeck and just want go get the maindeck/sideboard configuration right for the current/upcoming metagame.
And I doubt your 2%. How did you get these numbers? When I do some calculations regarding the chance to hit any business after the first Time Spiral I get something like this:
20 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 96,7%
21 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 97,3%
22 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 97,9%
23 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 98,3%
24 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 98,7%
25 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 99,0%
26 Business-Spells, 55 cards in library left: 99,2%
Granted, that's only the first Time Spiral, but adding more counters to the maindeck doesn't change the chance to fizzle by that much.
So I imagine that you are playing a list which is quite close to the Hatfield-list and used it during the testing vs. Merfolk? Honestly I wouldn't have thought that it would do that well vs. Merfolk with 4 MM.
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 11:29 AM
I am playing EXACTLY Hatfield's list with no changes.
If you get just 1 preordain as your "business" what then are the chances of getting more "business"?
You have to do a little more than hit a single cantrip off a timespiral to win.
Irenicus
05-18-2011, 11:38 AM
I am playing EXACTLY Hatfield's list with no changes.
If you get just 1 preordain as your "business" what then are the chances of getting more "business"?
You have to do a little more than hit a single cantrip off a timespiral to win.
It's just an example. I know that with one Preordain the chances are quite bad to win but I just wanted to calculate the chance to hit any business. That might be wrong and there might be a better way to do it. I am going to check hitting at least 2 or 3 business-spells later on.
Then again which calculation resulted in your 2% rule of thumb?
ScatmanX
05-18-2011, 11:43 AM
I played 16 games against 12 counter Merfolk. (aways with SB, on the draw)
Won 7, lost 9, 1 to Fizzle. 6 of those games I lost were due to 1 or more Cursecatcher, most with some other counters.
The ones I won, only 2 I had to go trough 1 Cursecatcher.
With that In mind, I did some digging to find something to hold them back.
I played then 18 games with 2 Pithing Needles (SB, on the draw).
Won 11 games, lost 7. 4 of my wins Needle helped, and only 1 off my losses, it made me lose (where I needed to buy a blue card or a land to go off in my turn, and drew the Needle).
The games I lost, and Needle did showed up, it would be irrelevant if it was another card.
2 Games it would have been better if Needles were Phyrexian Revoker, and would not have been Missteped, while the opponent had 1-2 Cursecatchers in the battlefield.
(avarage turn I had to go off was the 4th)
I really liked Needle, as Merfolk has 8 ways of removing them (while having Jitte to remove Revoker), and it can come in against Counterbalance aswell. I did miss the 2nd Snap though. The 1 I had saved me 2 games, one buying a turn, 1 bouncing a Cursecatcher before I had to go off. Will try to fit him, maybe in place of the 3rd Turnabout, since sometime, I was left with only 1 Island untapped after resolving High Tide, and Snap is better in that situation too.
deitzman
05-18-2011, 12:20 PM
Hi,
i played Spiral tide at the BoM too. Here is my list:
Maindeck:
9 Island
1 Tropical Island
4 Scalding tarn
4 Polluted delta
4 Force of will
4 Mental misstep
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
1 Peer through depths
1 Meditate
2 Cunning wish
1 Blue sun's zenith
4 Turnabout
2 Cloud of faeries
4 Time spiral
4 Merchant scroll
4 High tide
Sideboard:
1 Blue sun's Zenith
1 Brain freeze
1 Meditate
1 Snap
1 Echoing truth
1 Rebuild
1 Wipe away
2 Krosan grip
3 Pact of negation
2 Counterspell
1 Ravenous trap
My results:
Friday Legacy trial: (Didn't have 4 missteps yet, so i played with 1 misstep, 2 counterspell and 1 pact main)
R1 vs Mud: 2:1
R2 vs B/G (ritual, seize, inquisition, misstep, hymn, sinkhole, hypnotic, stalker, shade and beast within in the board... propably the worst matchup you can imagine besides pox): lucky 2:1
R3 vs Mud: 2:1
R4 vs Canadian: 1:2
R5 vs Merfolk: 1:2 (lost G3 due to a big mistake during comboing. Otherwise i would have won this match)
R6 vs GW Zenith: 2:1
R7 vs Canadian: 1:2
R8 vs Enchantress: 2:0
=> 5/3/0
Saturday Legacy main event:
R1 vs RedMud: 2:1
R2 vs TheRock: 2:1
R3 vs B/G: 0:2 (Friday R2 opponent. He crushed me both games, nothing i could have done)
R4 vs G/W Zenith: 1:2 (G1 fizzle. I went off with 4 islands + 1 fetch in play and 2 tides, 1 meditate, 2 brainstorm in hand but those drawspells found 8 lands and 2 counter :(. G2 he has some hate but i win easily. G3 He as a lot of hate incl. choke but i have about 4-5 turns to draw a land or turnabout to start the combo. Unfortunatelly that doesn't happen.)
R5 vs Team America: 1:2
R6 vs B/G/r: 2:0
R7 vs G/W Zenith: 2:0
R8 vs Mud: 2:0
R9 vs Deadguy: 2:1 (I usually board out 1 tide against black decks because of extirpate but i forgot it this time. This mistake almost cost me G3 but i'm able to lay down 7 lands, eot rebuild his sculler, 2 canonists and vial and combo off. 3 spirals later the stormcount is high enough to freeze him.)
=> 6/3/0
R3 was pretty much unwinnable and the loss against TA was fine too. But R4 vs G/W was just ridiculous.
Sunday Legacy side event:
R1 vs a friend with Pox: 2:1 (he was pretty unlucky there)
R2 vs R/b Goblins: 2:0 (no disruption)
R3 vs U/R Control: 2:0 (no pressure)
R4 vs U/r Sneak show: 0:2 (tough matchup and he drew pretty good)
R5 vs another friend with TES: 2:0 (I was paired down so he scoops me in the prices. We play for fun where i semifizzle G3 so i can't mill his whole library. At least this prevents him from comboing so he just makes some goblins. I draw no gas and die to the green guys shortly after.)
=> 4/1/0
All in all i'm really satisfied how the deck performed. I love it's sturdiness, i. e. i had to mulligan only like 4 times during the whole weekend.
The grips in the sideboard were needed exactly zero times but i think i'll keep them just in case xD .
Missteps were great but i'd like to cut them down to 3 so i can add one more business spell, propably preordain or a second meditate.
Rebuild was a beast all day. Cycling is nice, vs Mud cc3 is awesome in combination with echoing truth and it solves mother+vial@2+canonist no problem.
Clouds did their job and i cycled them at least as often as i cast them. Sure they generate less mana than candelabras most of the time but that matters as good as never. I mostly go off with 4+ lands in play so when i fizzle it happens because i drew not enough gas to keep going. Clouds help in this case, not much but everything counts in such a situation.
Grats to dukelio and egosum for their nice finishes. I watched egosum play a few times but didn't realise it was him. Some beautiful lands you got ;)
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 12:20 PM
Sideboard plan vs new 'folk.
+2 Mental Misstep +3 pact of negation +1 snap +1 intuition +1 repeal +1 Brain Freeze
-1 Blue Suns Zenith -1 Mind Over Matter -3 cunning wish -2 Preordian -2 ponder
Misstep targets cursecatchers or vials or missteps (only if you have no pacts in hand).
Cunning wish is too slow vs 'folk so it comes out. BSZ is not needed vs them so neither is MoM. 4 cantrips are cut for intuition and bounce. If there is a nice counterwar all you need to do really is find a merchant scroll or brainfreze after you spiral :).
Sideboarding is the hardest part of this deck.
Here is my list.
Maindeck:
Artifacts
4 Candelabra of Tawnos
Enchantments
1 Mind Over Matter
Instants
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
4 Brainstorm
3 Cunning Wish
4 Force of Will
4 High Tide
1 Intuition
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
Sorceries
4 Merchant Scroll
4 Ponder
2 Preordain
4 Time Spiral
Basic Lands
12 Island
Lands
2 Flooded Strand
2 Misty Rainforest
2 Polluted Delta
Sideboard:
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
1 Brain Freeze
1 Echoing Truth
1 Intuition
1 Meditate
3 Pact of Negation
1 Rebuild
1 Repeal
1 Snap
1 Turnabout
1 Wipe Away
2 Mental Misstep
This is 73/75 hatfields list and 60/60.
The only change is to the sideboard:
-2 repeal
+2 Misstep
Remember: every counter you add increases your chance of fizzling by approximately 2%.
But the extra counters allow you to go off more frequently in the first place. A build with just 4 FoW as resistance will die more often to Tendrils of Agony, Counterbalance, Iona, etc. before that small increase in the fizzle percentage even starts mattering. The Hatfield list would be ideal if we weren't playing against people who try to stop us from going off in the first place.
ns2973
05-18-2011, 02:53 PM
I think what we need to focus on is increased ability to sculpt. So for me, maximizing cantrips and merchant scroll targets are key. I may move a pact to the main for that purpose, JUST as a merchant scroll target when i'm going to try and force it through.
lebarion
05-18-2011, 03:08 PM
I think what we need to focus on is increased ability to sculpt. So for me, maximizing cantrips and merchant scroll targets are key. I may move a pact to the main for that purpose, JUST as a merchant scroll target when i'm going to try and force it through.
I play a more controlish build than most people here apparently do, with 3 Counterspells and 1 Pact of Negation maindeck. While I agree that the counterspells maindeck are argueable, I believe the 1-of Pact of Negation is a must even in combo-oriented builds. It is just that good to Scroll for it.
ns2973
05-18-2011, 04:10 PM
Yeah i think it has merit as well. I dunno about maindeck counterspells though, again i want to be able to sculpt as much as possible to beat discard etc.
I'm going to try a maindeck pact, defense grids in the board and do some testing.
ScatmanX
05-18-2011, 04:30 PM
I'm going to try a maindeck pact, defense grids in the board and do some testing.
I tested Grid yesterday, and it was very lackuster. 1st, you waste a hole turn casting it. 2nd, if your opponent have 3 Islands open, after High Tide, he can cast 2 FoWs. It also don't solve the Cursecatcher problem, and Control decks like Landstill will just have answers for it on their SB.
I really would like to hear what do people that tested Mental Misstep main thought of it.
deitzman
05-18-2011, 06:29 PM
I really would like to hear what do people that tested Mental Misstep main thought of it.
Before New Phyrexia i played 3 counterspells maindeck and really liked them. But IMO you just have to play misstep now if you want to stand a chance vs tempodecks like thresh, team america and merfolk.
They all pack up to 8 free hardcounters for your high tide now so even turnabouting their lands doesn't really help anymore. They once were slightly good/even matchups for me but now got pretty tough to beat. At BoM i played against Canadian thresh two times and the amount of countermagic they had postboard was ridiculous (daze, pierce, misstep, fow and pyroblast), though it was quite close most of the time. Keep in mind that i didn't play with 4 MMs at this point, which would have been clearly superior than what i played, namely 1 MM, 2 counterspell, 1 pact.
Against merfolk it hits cursecatcher (MVP), other MMs of course and vial, therefore its pretty good there too.
Furthermore MM is nuts vs dredge which is otherwise hardly winnable. It's like a timewalk for free if you hit their discardoutlet on the first turn. When they slowdredge you win crucial time and it still counters their best card against us, therapy.
Vs all kinds of tendrilsdecks MM shows it's power too. I always scroll for MM to counter their protection (chant, duress, swarm) because they wont risk going off unprotected as you can always have the fow ready to wreck them.
I must say MM sucks vs G/W and Mud most of the time but those are still positive matchups. Here the MMs are mostly fodder for brainstorm and fow so they rarely hamper you. However once in a while you can use them on goblin welder, voltaic key, mother of runes or aether vial thus they aren't completely dead.
Vs black midrange like Deadguy or Junk they are just ok as they take care of duress&co but to be honest, counterspells were way better because they additionally could fight hymns, bobs and vindicates. Normally we still beat this kind of decks anyways.
All in all i think misstep strengthens our difficult matchups and weakens the good ones a little bit. Seems fair to me. Currently i wouldn't want to play without them now there is so much tempo around.
rgripp
05-18-2011, 06:35 PM
Makes a lot of sense. Care to post a list?
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 08:37 PM
But the extra counters allow you to go off more frequently in the first place. A build with just 4 FoW as resistance will die more often to Tendrils of Agony, Counterbalance, Iona, etc. before that small increase in the fizzle percentage even starts mattering. The Hatfield list would be ideal if we weren't playing against people who try to stop us from going off in the first place.
This is simply not true, except when playing against hymn/counterbalance decks. This is why we have a sideboard.
There is no longer a reason to play Iona when you can play Emrakul.
I believe the 1-of Pact of Negation is a must even in combo-oriented builds. It is just that good to Scroll for it.
Scroll for force of will is not good enough? :)
RexFTW
05-18-2011, 09:38 PM
Decks Ponder is good against:
All
Decks Mental Misstep is good against:
Vial decks
Combo decks
Decks Mental Misstep is average against:
Control
Tempo
Decks Mental Misstep is bad against:
Hymn
Midrange Green
Burn
Decks Mental Misstep is terrible against:
Stompy
Zoo
Just Sayin.
This is simply not true, except when playing against hymn/counterbalance decks. This is why we have a sideboard.
There is no longer a reason to play Iona when you can play Emrakul.
Scroll for force of will is not good enough? :)
True, you get to sideboard into the counterspells, but being automatically 0-1 against a ton of matchups kind of sucks. For example, you will never be able to take g1 from any good TES/ANT/Reanimator/Dredge player, since a 3.5 turn "clock" + 4 FoWs isn't enough, and playing the control role is almost impossible when you just have the FoWs. I don't get the 3x Meditates at all. You get a bit lower risk of fizzling, but you also ensure you have no chance in the harder matchups. I'm not sure the Hatfield list was ever optimal to begin with, but it definitely isn't now with MM around.
@deitzman: I agree with everything you said.. I think this deck is forced to maindeck MM now, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. The card almost always does something relevant, and in the deck's tougher matchups it's a very, very good card.
Decks Ponder is good against:
All
Decks Mental Misstep is good against:
Vial decks
Combo decks
Decks Mental Misstep is average against:
Control
Tempo
Decks Mental Misstep is bad against:
Hymn
Midrange Green
Burn
Decks Mental Misstep is terrible against:
Stompy
Zoo
Just Sayin.
Actually, MM is pretty decent against Zoo and Burn since it will either slow them down a ton by countering Nacatl/Goblin guide or it will stop red blasts in sideboarded games. Beforehand, you almost always had to burn a FoW on G.Guide since it would do 6 damage otherwise.
ScatmanX
05-18-2011, 11:36 PM
Scroll for force of will is not good enough? :)
No. Sometimes you don't have the extra card to waste.
Decks Ponder is good against:
All
Decks Mental Misstep is good against:
Vial decks
Combo decks
Decks Mental Misstep is average against:
Control
Tempo
Decks Mental Misstep is bad against:
Hymn
Midrange Green
Burn
Decks Mental Misstep is terrible against:
Stompy
Zoo
Just Sayin.
Control: Counter opponents Misstep
Tempo: Counter Misstep and Stifle and Pierce
Hymn: Counter Duress/Seize
Midrange Green: Enlightenet Tutor, Noble
Burn: Every burn. It buys a turn.
Stompy: Yeah, it sucks.
Zoo: Countering Nacatl saves you 4-7 life on the draw, and ~9 life on the play. Also, post Spiral, it can counter that Bolt that might kill you.
Just Saying: well, this wasn't an argument, was it?
egosum
05-19-2011, 08:31 AM
I wish I had time to made this post earlier, but after BoM 5 I ' ve been very busy coming back to reality.
First of all I' d like to thank all people that congratulated me for the result and congrats every single person that made this incredible event possible.
I'm not sure if I'll write a report (starting with a 0-1 made me take very few notes...), but I'll say I made a 0-1 to 8-1 (every single round was crucial after the first one). I faced, in no particular order: 2x Sneak Show (lost to one of them), UW Landstill, Mono Brown MUD, Team America, Bant, Imperial Painter, GW Aggro (kind of Maverick) and something I can't remember by the moment.
I finished 3rd in the swiss and lost to Reanimator in the top 16. The game went like this:
I started, Island + go. He duressed I misstep back. Next Turn he Careful Study (Iona in the yard) and reanimate which I FoW, then next turn he reanimate again and I FoW only to see he exhumed his Iona with the two other lands he had in play.
Second game he played Show and Tell in the 3rd turn and I FoW but he FoW 'ed back, playing an Inkwell Leviathan. I was at 18 life so that meant 2 turns to go. I went off at 4 life but then happened what haven't happened in the whole day I fizzled after resolving 2 Time Spirals, with 22 Storm Count, 4 untapped lands, 16 mana in the pool, 5 High Tides on line, and my hand was: 3x Spell Pierce, 1x Turnabout, 1x High Tide, 1x Force of Will and 3x Lands. I tried to get a turn by playing Turnabout in his turn for tapping Leviathan but he FoW'ed and I was at 1 life. You know wha't s worst... my next draw would have been a Meditate... Well this happens. My final result for the event was 9th.
Here is the list I played:
"Spiral Tide"
Main deck 60
Lands 18
2x Flooded Strand
2x Misty Rainforest
1x Polluted Delta
1x Scalding Tarn
12x Island
Protection 7
4x Force of Will
3x Mental Misstep
Cantrips 12
4x Brainstorm
4x Ponder
4x Preordain
Tutors 7
4x Merchant Scroll
3x Cunninng Wish
Bussiness 15
4x High Tide
4x Turnabout
4x Time Spiral
3x Meditate
Win Condition 1
1x Brain Freeze
Sideboard 15
3x Pact of Negation
3x Spell Pierce
2x Wipe Away
1x Echoing Truth
1x Rebuild
1x Snap
1x Surgical Extraction
1x Meditate
1x Brain Freeze
1x Blue Sun's Zenith
I' m very happy with the list, I thought the lack of Intuition may hurt but it finally don't. Nevertheless if I should make any change in the list for future events it will be the addition of Intuition, but I' m not sure what would it replace...
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
mrjumbo03
05-19-2011, 09:25 AM
If ever you decide to put Intuition back in, you can always move 1 Turnabout to the side since you're back to 3 wishes anyway. Congrats on the finish! Goes to show that you don't need a thousand dollars to play the deck effectively!
ScatmanX
05-19-2011, 09:39 AM
Congratulations Iñaki!
Have some questions:
- Do you ever felt the need to have 1-2 more untappers other than only 4 Turnabouts? It seems a bit low.
- The Brain Freeze in the main was usefull? Why not BSZ?
- Having 3 Meditates was usefull any time before the combo turn?
Thanks.
egosum
05-19-2011, 12:13 PM
@ScatmaX: definitely no. Historically High Tide decks play 7 untappers (if they are of good quality, like in solidarity 4 + 3 Turnabout + 1 sided), and spring Tide play like 10-11 (but they are low quality, untapping only 2 lands). Here in Spiral Tide I play 8 (Spiral + Turnabout) + 1 Snap in the side. And it is all I need for redundancy, more will be stuck in my hand generating lots of mana for no use at all.
Brain Freeze is simply one of the best card in my mai deck for many reasons:
1st- I kiled with brain freeze most of times because it needs a lot less mana for the win.
2nd- It enables the double freeze kill with 1 Freeze + 1 Merchant, or 1x Freeze +1x Cunning, or 1x Merchant + 1x Cunning, ... BSZ is better in the candelabra versions where you generate more mana. In my build BSZ is another utility wish card that also enables kills if needed, but is not my main win con.
3rd- Is one of the best cards in the main deck, if not the best, against our worst match up: CB-Top, I ve won a billion games thanks to it, making my opponent wasting mana, or even getting rid of the Top. Also allows me to play 2x Brain Freeze when siding against Counterbalance.
Meditate is a very important card in the MM metagame. It's been my response to the testing I made previous to BoM. It happened that tempo decks feat. MM where quite hard to win without them just because when I was going off I needed at least 3 cards to do the combo and 4 more card to "protect", while they had all those turn just to play their dude and cantrip into counters, and since now thay are packing more efficient counters this was a problem. Adding meditate allowed me not only to go off more confortable but to meditate the turn before I want to go off against this kind of decks, either making them waste one counter or filling my hand to fight theirs propperly. SO I think that meditate is very very important in the post MM enviroment.
And of course, thanks for the congrats!! :-)
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
RexFTW
05-19-2011, 02:57 PM
Agree. People playing MM not Spell Pierce makes meditate and intuition very strong.
This may be a crazy thought but, I think the printing of mental misstep may actually help this deck. If it replaces daze and spell pierce then we will be able to resolve our powerful draw spells and tutors more easily! call me crazy....
this is back on page 12 or so :)
RexFTW
05-19-2011, 03:58 PM
- Do you ever felt the need to have 1-2 more untappers other than only 4 Turnabouts?
I think this depends on your philosophy. If you want to win after playing only a single spiral then having more untappers is needed. If you are fine with untapping lands using spirals then you do not need much more. Playing multiple spirals can be risky against blue decks, red elemental blast and decks playing mindbreak trap.
Against REB, and blude decks sometimes it is necessary to turnabout them on their endstep so that non free counters off of spirals are not blank. This requires more untappers.
Cyceron
05-20-2011, 05:36 AM
@egosum: Could you post some boarding tips agains various archetypes for the list you used at BoM? Like when you move PoN or pierce from the board...
PanderAlexander
05-20-2011, 07:04 AM
I wish I had time to made this post earlier, but after BoM 5 I ' ve been very busy coming back to reality.
First of all I' d like to thank all people that congratulated me for the result and congrats every single person that made this incredible event possible.
*report*
Congrats on the very sweet finish, I'm glad the no-candelabra version can still put up such a good result especially in this post-MM meta.
egosum
05-20-2011, 07:48 AM
I normally play the second and third game with 10 coubnters in the deck (unless I'm playing straight "non-denial" aggro decks), and it depends on the pairing, for instance if playing against CB-Top I play with 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spel Pierce, if facing Tempo decks 4x Fow +3x MM + 3x Pact of Negation (if I face team america with 4 Hymns, i.e. if he played 2 or more in first games, or if I know...) , against heavy "duress" decks 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spell Pierce, if I 'm expecting Pyrostatic pillar or Chalice of the Void, well it depends if Pyrostatic Pillar is in a Zoo or Burn deck I play 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spell Pierce, and in the deck has no relevants 1 drops just the 4x Fow and 3x Pierce. This is more or less how I side. I know is not very accurate, but hope this answers your question, if it doesn't just tell me and try to make a precise table of boarding.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
Cyceron
05-20-2011, 08:02 AM
Thanks mate :) I've been putting the deck together for the last 2 months but never had a chance to actually play it (haven't had the time). I hope that changes soon:)
bondafong
05-20-2011, 09:10 AM
I normally play the second and third game with 10 coubnters in the deck (unless I'm playing straight "non-denial" aggro decks), and it depends on the pairing, for instance if playing against CB-Top I play with 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spel Pierce, if facing Tempo decks 4x Fow +3x MM + 3x Pact of Negation (if I face team america with 4 Hymns, i.e. if he played 2 or more in first games, or if I know...) , against heavy "duress" decks 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spell Pierce, if I 'm expecting Pyrostatic pillar or Chalice of the Void, well it depends if Pyrostatic Pillar is in a Zoo or Burn deck I play 4x Fow + 3x MM + 3x Spell Pierce, and in the deck has no relevants 1 drops just the 4x Fow and 3x Pierce. This is more or less how I side. I know is not very accurate, but hope this answers your question, if it doesn't just tell me and try to make a precise table of boarding.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
What do you remove for the 3 counterspells then?
RexFTW
05-20-2011, 07:27 PM
What do you remove for the 3 counterspells then?
preordain im sure.
Ziilot
05-21-2011, 04:10 AM
Regarding to Iñaki's list; various sites have listed that you played 2 brain freezes main ergo 61 cards. That's right?
1maarten1
05-21-2011, 08:57 AM
Regarding to Iñaki's list; various sites have listed that you played 2 brain freezes main ergo 61 cards. That's right?
he played 1, eternal-central.com is 1 off ;)!
egosum
05-21-2011, 01:34 PM
What do you remove for the 3 counterspells then?
It depends but the candidates are:
1x Cunning Wish
1x Turnabout
1x Meditate
1x High Tide
1x Preordain.
You can never cut more than 1x cantrip these are the soul of the deck.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
RexFTW
05-23-2011, 03:44 PM
Just won a tourney with the hatfield list. The source ate my report and im not typing it again. Too bad.
nayon
05-23-2011, 03:45 PM
Just won a tourney with the hatfield list. The source ate my report and im not typing it again. Too bad.
Did you face a lot of Misstep decks? If so, what was your plan against them? Also, by Hatfield list, I presume you mean you ran 0x misstep yourself?
ns2973
05-23-2011, 04:51 PM
Did you face a lot of Misstep decks? If so, what was your plan against them? Also, by Hatfield list, I presume you mean you ran 0x misstep yourself?
I'd also be interested in this data. Thinking of running it in providence this week.
RexFTW
05-23-2011, 04:58 PM
I faced Bant with MM and merefolk with MM twice.
Bant got ROFLPWNED due to not having gaddock teeg or cannonist in the sideboard.
Merefolk first time in swiss the deck took a dump on me and I lost with mull to 5 both games. Faced same merefolk and won 2-0 in T8.
I run 73/75 identical to hatfield. The only change:
-2 Repeal (sideboard)
+2 MM
My merefolk sideboard plan is posted on the previous page I think.
If you are considering this deck it requires a ton of practice to play against counters and discard. Also sideboarding can be complex. However, most people do not have experience playing against it so this gives you a large advantage in most matches.
Omega
05-23-2011, 06:27 PM
Out of curiosity, how does the deck survive in the current metagame with Misstep?
How over priced are the Candles?
I'm thinking of getting rid of most of my collection. Not sure if I should settle with this deck :/
RexFTW
05-23-2011, 06:52 PM
The printing of MM actually improves the merefolk matchup IMO. Their deck is slower due to running less guys and MM is good against their vials and cursecatchers.
Candles are about $250 right now making the deck ~1200$ assuming you already have force of will.
This is about the same price as a 3 color deck like bant as blue duals are about 100$ each.
This deck fears one card: Counterbalance .
egosum
05-23-2011, 06:56 PM
Once again, Candelabras are NOT needed.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
ns2973
05-23-2011, 07:30 PM
But i think it is agreed that the optimal version is the candle version. It's like saying you can play team america without tarmogoyf, sure you can run other ways to win, it's just not optimal.
Piceli89
05-23-2011, 07:56 PM
But i think it is agreed that the optimal version is the candle version. It's like saying you can play team america without tarmogoyf, sure you can run other ways to win, it's just not optimal.
The comparison doesn't stand. The power difference between a TA with Tgoyf and another with, say, Albino Troll is far superior than the difference between a Candelabra build and a Candelabra-less one.
Especially now that Mental Misstep is hyped everywhere.
egosum
05-23-2011, 08:03 PM
@ns2973: this statement is not even close. Candelabra version is a different approach to Spiral tide, it kills with BSZ and generates more mana, while the non-candelabra build kills with freeze normally (which I think is by far more optimal, but I agree it goes with the player). The candelabra ersion is opened to further hate than the non candelabra one (pithing, revoker, qasali, grip,...). Candelabra version has more relevant targets for MM and less slots to fight this new tempo/control decks on steroids. More permanents means less isntatns, this means less flexibility. Though Candelbra versions are easier to handle (nto big difference though) because they have a well defined game plan, which also makes them a lot more predictable.
I do mean that are simply different, I'd never dare say one version is superior, I' ve done extremely good results without candelabra at every tournament I assisted since Spiral was out (4th place out of 40, 9th place with the same points as 8th but out due to tibreaker out of 110, and 9th out of 633).
So my advice, if you play a candelabra version, try to play the non candelabra one (I played both and prefered the candelabra-less because the flexibility it has, not for budget options, I have a full Power 9 and full Pimped Spiral Tide deck among others, also have the access to the candelabra playset if I'd want it for any tournament, this is not bragging, is just to show that some people dont play Candelabras just because he thinks they are NOT needed,and IMO overkill), you 'll see how good could it be, just don't give up at your first defeat (counterbalance pairing is slightly better when you play Brain Freeze, and even better if you play 2 after siding...).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
nayon
05-23-2011, 08:11 PM
I like Candelabras because it makes people waste their Missteps on them, clearing the way for High Tides.
I like Candelabras because it makes people waste their Missteps on them, clearing the way for High Tides.
So, basically Candelabra starts kicking ass once you're in the 0-2 bracket
But seriously, I sometimes envy the fact that Candelabra makes bounce spells from the SB into mana generators at the same time, but dying to Pithing Needle and Stifle while not being pitchable to FoW sucks.
btw, congrats Iñaki. Would you mind listing your matchups? (if you didn't already, in which case I have missed it)
nayon
05-23-2011, 08:22 PM
So, basically Candelabra starts kicking ass once you're in the 0-2 bracket
Yep. But people do make mistakes, and if it actually resolves and you start comboing, it's still good. The actual question here isn't candelabra but the ability to resolve HT in the MM meta.
egosum
05-23-2011, 08:27 PM
@nayon: Sorry if it sounds rude, but this is non sense.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
rgripp
05-23-2011, 08:38 PM
Nayon, you can't really make list decisions this big based on "people might make a mistake". While mistakes happen and you should play giving your opponent all opportunities to make a mistake as possible, you can't really count on it happening.
nayon
05-23-2011, 08:48 PM
Nayon, you can't really make list decisions this big based on "people might make a mistake". While mistakes happen and you should play giving your opponent all opportunities to make a mistake as possible, you can't really count on it happening.
I'm not making the list decisions based on that. What I tried to say was, it's a bonus that that can sometimes happen. For me, Candelabra is no question because I have to go for the Zenith kill because Emrakul and Progenitus are very popular in my metagame.
For me the most important question is: How do I deal with Mental Misstep? If the answer is "I can't", then running this deck is a no-go for me because almost every single deck in my meta runs it (folk, team america, sneak attack/SnT, reanimator), so I have to have a way to deal with it. I also know for a fact that there are people in my meta that will Misstep a t1 candelabra, so it is actually a relevant point for me.
So the primary thing I'm looking for is, what's the answer to Mental Misstep?
egosum
05-23-2011, 09:08 PM
Fighting MM: Force of will, MM (yourself) and/or Pact of Negation, major answers. You also have Spell Pierce, Defense Grid.
Fighting Emrakul: BSZ is not the only option. There is one big answer which is Surgical Extraction, which is a must in every Spiral Tide build IMO, it also handles Iona very well.
Progenitus can die to a big Brain Freeze with a small BSZ after that.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
nayon
05-23-2011, 09:08 PM
Do you recommend Missteps main deck? if so, what's a list you would run?
egosum
05-24-2011, 04:32 AM
I would recommend to play 3 missteps main deck.
If you want a list for reference you can see this: http://www.thecouncil.es/tcdecks/deck.php?id=6147&iddeck=44561
Which is the list I played in BoM 5 it is also posted here (post #349).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
ns2973
05-24-2011, 12:04 PM
Do you recommend Missteps main deck? if so, what's a list you would run?
In a candle build, mine looks like this. It's what i think i've settled on for the grand prix. It's had a lot of success for me pre misstep, and i'm liking the 3 misstep/1 pact mainboard.
2 Flooded Strand
11 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
1 Pact of Negation
2 Polluted Delta
4 Brainstorm
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
4 High Tide
3 Mental Misstep
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
4 Merchant Scroll
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
3 Cunning Wish
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
4 Time Spiral
nayon
05-24-2011, 04:15 PM
Quoting Mike Flores:
Opponent: "High Tide isn't good anymore, I have Mental Missteps"
Mike: "So do I. You don't understand how this game works"
-------------------------------------
Basically he says that the deck is still really good. I'm starting to believe he's right. I'm not sure about the exact brew though. I don't want to cut Intuition, what's the rationale for it? I've almost always loved it. Also, what about Peer Through Depths? Taking a page from the Solidarity book.
warai
05-24-2011, 04:27 PM
You cut the Candelabras that are the weakest link when it comes to untap effects since Turn About or Time Spiral are better and should be enough, and put 3/4 Mental Misstep. Although I'm not a Spiral Tide player I still think this deck will do very well in the coming GP Providence.
ns2973
05-24-2011, 04:51 PM
Quoting Mike Flores:
Opponent: "High Tide isn't good anymore, I have Mental Missteps"
Mike: "So do I. You don't understand how this game works"
-------------------------------------
Basically he says that the deck is still really good. I'm starting to believe he's right. I'm not sure about the exact brew though. I don't want to cut Intuition, what's the rationale for it? I've almost always loved it. Also, what about Peer Through Depths? Taking a page from the Solidarity book.
On intuition: I flex one in from time to time and one is always in the board as a wish target. I have been considering cutting down to 2 preordains to get there.
On peer through depths, it's a great card, but it's a sorcery, so we can't tutor it, meditate is better in that slot in my opinion, as it gives greater flexibility and is tutorable.
Yeah i've been questioning the people saying MM is the end of this deck. In the end, it made team america and fish harder, and everything else pretty much the same. Landstill is a new concern, but apart from that? No biggy.
On intuition: I flex one in from time to time and one is always in the board as a wish target. I have been considering cutting down to 2 preordains to get there.
On peer through depths, it's a great card, but it's a sorcery, so we can't tutor it, meditate is better in that slot in my opinion, as it gives greater flexibility and is tutorable.
Yeah i've been questioning the people saying MM is the end of this deck. In the end, it made team america and fish harder, and everything else pretty much the same. Landstill is a new concern, but apart from that? No biggy.
Peer through depths is Instant, but suffers from costing 2 mana to find 1 card.
Intuition is pretty good maindeck, but you almost always have to side it out against black decks because you will just lose to Extirpate (and now also Surgical Extraction), so in sideboarded games you have to be careful when using it.
ns2973
05-24-2011, 04:54 PM
Peer through depths is Instant, but suffers from costing 2 mana to find 1 card.
You are right my bad, it's the better impulse. I was thinking of the draw three discard three sorcery. Apologies.
GradStudentGuy
05-24-2011, 05:38 PM
In a candle build, mine looks like this. It's what i think i've settled on for the grand prix. It's had a lot of success for me pre misstep, and i'm liking the 3 misstep/1 pact mainboard.
2 Flooded Strand
11 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
1 Pact of Negation
2 Polluted Delta
4 Brainstorm
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
4 High Tide
3 Mental Misstep
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
4 Merchant Scroll
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
3 Cunning Wish
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
4 Time Spiral
I have been playing with an almost identical list with one more island instead of the pact. Do you miss the island at all? I know a lot of games I feel I have barely enough land at 18.
nayon
05-24-2011, 05:39 PM
In a candle build, mine looks like this. It's what i think i've settled on for the grand prix. It's had a lot of success for me pre misstep, and i'm liking the 3 misstep/1 pact mainboard.
2 Flooded Strand
11 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
1 Pact of Negation
2 Polluted Delta
4 Brainstorm
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
4 High Tide
3 Mental Misstep
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
4 Merchant Scroll
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
3 Cunning Wish
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
4 Time Spiral
What about the sideboard?
ns2973
05-24-2011, 07:30 PM
I have been playing with an almost identical list with one more island instead of the pact. Do you miss the island at all? I know a lot of games I feel I have barely enough land at 18.
Not really. With SOOO much dig you really don't run inot it as often as you'd think. I'm loving the maindeck pact over that island. Especially in the current MM metagame, you can very easily have MM, force and pact protection when you go off on turn 4, which i'm a fan of.
As for my board, it's essentially floating, but here's what i'm testing
1 noxious revival (kinda meh so far)
1 surgical extraction
1 turnabout
1 intution
1 snap
1 rebuild
2 pact of negation
3 spell pierce
1 brain freeze
1 blue sun's zenith
1 wipeaway
1 meditate
Probably pullint the revival for echoing truth. thought it might help the team america match, problem is by the time it's live, you are pretty much dead.
RexFTW
05-25-2011, 12:14 AM
In a candle build, mine looks like this. It's what i think i've settled on for the grand prix. It's had a lot of success for me pre misstep, and i'm liking the 3 misstep/1 pact mainboard.
2 Flooded Strand
11 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
1 Pact of Negation
2 Polluted Delta
4 Brainstorm
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
4 High Tide
3 Mental Misstep
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
4 Merchant Scroll
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
3 Cunning Wish
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
4 Time Spiral
fyi this is hatfields list - island -mom -intuition +3 mm
ns2973
05-25-2011, 09:58 AM
fyi this is hatfields list - island -mom -intuition +3 mm
Well of course there are similar cards, it's a pretty tight list. But the hatfields didn't run the maindeck pact, ran 2 MOM, ran 4 candles, ran intuition etc.
I'm not taking credit for the build, i'm saying i've had better results in this meta with this tweak currently. Hell i even beat countertop a couple last night.
Surgical extraction is just a house.
RexFTW
05-25-2011, 11:11 AM
How are you using extraction? I am curious.
nayon
05-25-2011, 11:12 AM
How are you using extraction? I am curious.
Don't know about him, but I'd use it to remove FoW/MM before I cast time spiral.
RexFTW
05-25-2011, 11:39 AM
seems like wishing for pact is safer, unless their hand is empty. In most cases.
ns2973
05-25-2011, 11:47 AM
seems like wishing for pact is safer, unless their hand is empty. In most cases.
Well, extraction has been amazing for me against dredge and CB mostly. Last night, he turn one tops, i MM the top, turn 2 merchant scroll for extraction and bam, no more tops. It's great against control, really really versatile and strong.
It's not built for the combo turn, it's for turns 2-3 to protect combo, even against hymn, thoughtseize, etc it's a house. It's a free spell too, so it's pretty fast and really with this deck you are only worried about a couple cards in your opponents library anyway
RexFTW
05-25-2011, 11:57 AM
Well, extraction has been amazing for me against dredge and CB mostly. Last night, he turn one tops, i MM the top, turn 2 merchant scroll for extraction and bam, no more tops. It's great against control, really really versatile and strong.
It's not built for the combo turn, it's for turns 2-3 to protect combo, even against hymn, thoughtseize, etc it's a house. It's a free spell too, so it's pretty fast and really with this deck you are only worried about a couple cards in your opponents library anyway
I think this makes more sense! it seems best against heavy control.it also shuffles their deck.
However, you cannot merchant scroll gor extraction.
Irenicus
05-25-2011, 11:58 AM
Last night, he turn one tops, i MM the top, turn 2 merchant scroll for extraction and bam, no more top.
I hope you meant Merchant Scroll for Cunning Wish for Extraction. Otherwise it isn't working.
nayon
05-25-2011, 12:00 PM
I hope you meant Merchant Scroll for Cunning Wish for Extraction. Otherwise it isn't working.
I think this makes more sense! it seems best against heavy control.
However, you cannot merchant scroll gor extraction.
So basically it's good when your opponents have multiples of a card and you 3-for-1 yourself for 5 mana and 2 life? Seems strong.
Unless you play it MD, then what are you taking out for it?
ns2973
05-25-2011, 12:00 PM
I hope you meant Merchant Scroll for Cunning Wish for Extraction. Otherwise it isn't working.
Nope, game two i side it in like a boss. Then with the scrolls i have increased redundancy of threat. Trust me, it works just fine.
Edit: If you are a dope like me
whienot
05-25-2011, 12:10 PM
Nope, game two i side it in like a boss. Then with the scrolls i have increased redundancy of threat. Trust me, it works just fine.
Nice cheat. Merchant Scroll can only fetch blue instants.
egosum
05-25-2011, 12:12 PM
Nope, game two i side it in like a boss. Then with the scrolls i have increased redundancy of threat. Trust me, it works just fine.
so you cheated. Please re-read the Merchant Scroll carefully and you'll realize why.
Surgical Extraction is a swiss knife, of course, but the deck has a game plan and normally wasting a wish for Srugical extraction is not part of the plan. But Extaraction is the best piece of hate against Sneak Show (Emrakul), Someone trying to reanimate Iona. This is the main purpose of the card, it can also be usefulin some other ocasions but won't happen too often, like: Extracting CB/Top, Extracting FoW/MM (as Rex said if opponent has cards in hand wishing a Pact is better option), Extracting Therapies/Bridges/Returns/Dredger/... from dredge, ...
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
Irenicus
05-25-2011, 12:12 PM
Nope, game two i side it in like a boss. Then with the scrolls i have increased redundancy of threat. Trust me, it works just fine.
You can't scroll for Surgical Extraction! Other than that I will give it a try and add it to my SB.
Piceli89
05-25-2011, 12:15 PM
Well, extraction has been amazing for me against dredge and CB mostly. Last night, he turn one tops, i MM the top, turn 2 merchant scroll for extraction and bam, no more tops. It's great against control, really really versatile and strong.
It's not built for the combo turn, it's for turns 2-3 to protect combo, even against hymn, thoughtseize, etc it's a house. It's a free spell too, so it's pretty fast and really with this deck you are only worried about a couple cards in your opponents library anyway
So, what's the point to do a (non.-legal) play to get rid of 4 cards, when you could have Scrolled for a win-piece, or for a Fow to avoid that tricky CB to stick if you feared any?
troopatroop
05-25-2011, 12:15 PM
Nice cheat. Merchant Scroll can only fetch blue instants.
YES. NICK SENNET STILL CHEATS! Cast more Goblin Welders through Chalice!!! :D
.....UUUUUUGHHHHH..... That felt soo good...
nayon
05-25-2011, 12:21 PM
So, what's the point to do a (non.-legal) play to get rid of 4 cards, when you could have Scrolled for a win-piece, or for a Fow to avoid that tricky CB to stick if you feared any?
Exactly. Cards like Extraction/Extirpate are only good in best case scenarios, and are traps. Unless you're playing against something like reanimator. Even then it doesn't help too much. Cheating with Merchant Scroll doesn't help too much either.
ns2973
05-25-2011, 12:22 PM
YES. NICK SENNET STILL CHEATS! Cast more Goblin Welders through Chalice!!! :D
.....UUUUUUGHHHHH..... That felt soo good...
Actually i completely apologize, you are all right i'm a dumbass lol.
Irenicus
05-25-2011, 12:38 PM
Ok, back to discussing Spiral Tide again. ;)
Just saw that Spiral Tide finished 1st and 2nd in a 100 person tournament:
http://www.thecouncil.es/tcdecks/deck.php?id=6171
What do you think about the decklists? Some points of discussion could be:
- Palinchron
- No Mental Misstep in either list
- 4th Preordain over 4th Ponder
- Neither version (with or without Candelabra) is better
nayon
05-25-2011, 12:43 PM
Ok, back to discussing Spiral Tide again. ;)
Just saw that Spiral Tide finished 1st and 2nd in a 100 person tournament:
http://www.thecouncil.es/tcdecks/deck.php?id=6171
What do you think about the decklists? Some points of discussion could be:
- Palinchron
- No Mental Misstep in either list
- 4th Preordain over 4th Ponder
- Neither version (with or without Candelabra) is better
I'm still not sold on the yes/no Mental Misstep issue. Palinchron is kind of amusing, but is it worth a slot? I usually find myself lacking card draw effects rather than untap effects. But I never played this deck post-misstep, so candles getting countered might be a real issue.
ns2973
05-25-2011, 12:45 PM
wow, really interesting. 3 pacts mainboard? Palinchron is kinda funny, couldn't you just capsize a candle for the same effect though? And capsize is tutorable. Odd, although maybe it wasn't used for infinite, just for another untapper.
egosum
05-25-2011, 12:56 PM
This is the last LCL, which is my metagame, both players play in Barcelona, which is my city. I should say their list are same before NPH release, and the 3 pact main deck used to be an standard for most of list before that deate (reference: see the first post of this thread).
Palinchron has been discussed quite few times and he is just overkill (similar to Cpasize with Cloud/Candelabra) once you can go infinite mana, you have already won.
You'll lose lots of games for cutting any single cantrip by this moment, full set of 12 is needed for consistancy (early land drops and post spiral bussiness).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
mistercakes
05-26-2011, 02:23 AM
the guy in the list with the palinchron has 3 ponder 4 preordain. just with goldfishing this deck preordain seems to help dig more. what is the overall opinion...if you're cutting 1 cantrip, is it a ponder or a preordain.
nayon
05-26-2011, 02:48 AM
Carsten's got an article with two lists on SCG, one being Iñaki's: http://www.starcitygames.com/magic/legacy/21964_Eternal_Europe_Everything_You_Need_To_Know_For_GP_Providence.html
mistercakes
05-26-2011, 08:43 AM
anyone here going to GP providence? if so we can meet up there and talk about some strategies/tech.
-rob
ns2973
05-26-2011, 09:53 AM
I'll be there. Probably chilling at the source area. I'm 6'3, tough to miss.
RexFTW
05-26-2011, 11:21 AM
Inaki, how often do you find yourself merchant scrolling or Cunning Wishing for Turnabout?
rgripp
05-26-2011, 11:31 AM
I'm guessing never, not counting when he SBs one out shenanigans, he plays 4 Turnabout MD...
RexFTW
05-26-2011, 11:40 AM
Well there is merchant scroll....
egosum
05-26-2011, 12:33 PM
Quite often. Pre combo, I usually fetch for it if I have other pieces in my hand (High Tide ans Spiral) and protecion so I am ready to go off. While going off quite often aswell, it is my only untapper and, if possible, I try go go for the meditate/turnabout, rather than resolving another spiral (it's just safer).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
Irenicus
05-26-2011, 05:51 PM
@ Egosum: I am going to play a version similar to yours. But I don't like Meditate that much and I don't understand that you don't play one Turnabout in the SB even though you play three Wishes. Therefore I will try three maindecked Turnabouts and one Candelabra. By the way, do you board out a Turnabout to wish for vs. some matchups or Extirpate in particular?
@ all: I had some trouble with the UR Painter deck. They play more disruption (Blast, FoW, Misstep) than we do, are in some way resistant to countermagic (Welder) and have a fast clock too. Therefore I am thinking about playing one Emrakul in the SB. This should slow them down enough or even win by itself. In addition to the Painter-matchup, is there any other deck against which you would bring in Emrakul? I know that some earlier versions of Spiral Tide used to play one Emrakul in either the main- or the sideboard. Does anyone know why they did that?
Thank you all in advance!
leegoo
05-26-2011, 05:55 PM
@ Egosum: I know that some earlier versions of Spiral Tide used to play one Emrakul in either the main- or the sideboard. Does anyone know why they did that?
To beat people to death with a 15/15 Spaghetti monster.
egosum
05-26-2011, 09:28 PM
@ Egosum: I am going to play a version similar to yours. But I don't like Meditate that much and I don't understand that you don't play one Turnabout in the SB even though you play three Wishes. Therefore I will try three maindecked Turnabouts and one Candelabra. By the way, do you board out a Turnabout to wish for vs. some matchups or Extirpate in particular?
@ all: I had some trouble with the UR Painter deck. They play more disruption (Blast, FoW, Misstep) than we do, are in some way resistant to countermagic (Welder) and have a fast clock too. Therefore I am thinking about playing one Emrakul in the SB. This should slow them down enough or even win by itself. In addition to the Painter-matchup, is there any other deck against which you would bring in Emrakul? I know that some earlier versions of Spiral Tide used to play one Emrakul in either the main- or the sideboard. Does anyone know why they did that?
Thank you all in advance!
Well as I said meditate is needed to beat the tempo on steroids decks that nowadays run all over the tables, meditating the turn before you 'll go off is a very strong play. I used to do it, but this is the point, I' d like to play 8 untappers in main deck and after lots of testing I realized that wishing for and untapper was only needed when facing a fast aggro build, and in this scenario snap does the same function, but just better. Once I'm the combo chain it' been better to have all them main deck so I can draw them more often and I' m not forced to Spiral again, I use Spiral as panic button not the combo engine (I think Christian misunderstood this and write it in his article). Wishes are not to waste, is a very potent card that needs more relevant targets such as meditate, Pact, freeze, BSZ, Surgical extraction or a randon bouncer. Yes I normally side 1x Turnabout since 2nd and 3rd game tend to be an attrition war so you don't need to rush that much, and I play very comfortable with one in maindeck for post board games.
As lego Said Emrakul was there as an alternate win con (also as hate for the mirror) but he was antisinergic with the whole deck (Meditate + Pact), and once you can cast it you'll be able to kill in any other way (even a second freeze main deck would be better). He is not worth even a sideboard slot.
According to Painer stone: I' ve played some of them and never had a problem, you have a lot better manipulation and very relevant countermagic (now with misstep you can go 1 for 1 against Grindstone, Pyroblast, Welder...).
Just one final note: 4x Turnabouts are very important becase they are not only a combo piece, but one of the most important disruption tools we have so having multiples never hurt Ç(for instance against Painter, that you said it was hard, jsut turnabout them EoT, if the used coutnermagic is okay, and if they do't they are dead. Same play can, and is recommended, to be done against blue countermagic decks, Tempo, Landstil, .... so you can go off and play your Tides freely).
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
Chikenbok
05-27-2011, 04:32 AM
Any considerations as to bringing back in 3 x Cloud of Faeries considering the fright and ease of hate that's brought in for Candles? Faeries + Snap + MD BsZ makes a Blue sun kill feasible again and CoF can cycle. Just a few cents before I hit the papers again.
Irenicus
05-27-2011, 04:42 AM
Thank you for your post, Iñaki! I think I know when and how to use Turnabout. But what happened vs. Painter was that he went off turn four on the play with triple backup and in addition had a 2nd Painter after I had countered the first one. And they have up to 8 free counterspells and turnabout doesn't help vs. blast when they have an active Mox Opal. I don't that say that the matchup is horrible but I had some trouble with it and it seems to be bad for us. By the way, do you bring in Bouncespells vs Painter? I only boarded Rebuilt, but Snap might have been good too.
In the end it is quite easy for Painter to assemble the combo over a few turns and stop our combo at the same time. They just play more counter and threads than we do and our library-manipulation is fine, but doesn't help enough vs Painter in my experience. But I might take the wrong role in the matchup. Usually I try to be the controlling player.
RexFTW
05-27-2011, 12:20 PM
I think worrying about the painter matchup is a waste of time. The deck is very expensive because of the recruiters so almost nobody plays the deck. It is definitely less than 1% of the meta.
The guy (Drew) who has top 8ed several SCG with Painter goes to my local store for Saturday legacy tournaments so I play against it a lot. The matchup is not bad. If they draw the nuts they win. If not you win.
Irenicus
05-30-2011, 03:46 PM
Did anyone play in the GP last weekend? As far as I remember there was only one Spiral Tide that made Day 2. :frown:
videogamer99
05-30-2011, 11:29 PM
Im going to be building this deck soon. I built the pauper version of it and I had a lot of fun with it. Im going to start with Iñaki's list from the BoM. Any advice for someone new to this archetype? Like some sort of crazy interactions or any other general tips.
ns2973
05-31-2011, 09:40 AM
Did anyone play in the GP last weekend? As far as I remember there was only one Spiral Tide that made Day 2. :frown:
And that was me. (unless someone else made it.) I ended up making day two then scrubbing out due to a mull to 4, then getting paired with Kronenberger blue, piloted by Chris himself, who was an awesome guy.
nayon
05-31-2011, 09:49 AM
And that was me. (unless someone else made it.) I ended up making day two then scrubbing out due to a mull to 4, then getting paired with Kronenberger blue, piloted by Chris himself, who was an awesome guy.
Can you make a tournament report?
ns2973
05-31-2011, 09:54 AM
Sure i can. Give me a day or two. i took some notes. I didn't know if people would want to read a report if it was just a day two. I only ended up in like position 100 or something.
nayon
05-31-2011, 09:58 AM
Sure i can. Give me a day or two. i took some notes. I didn't know if people would want to read a report if it was just a day two. I only ended up in like position 100 or something.
You still played High Tide to second day in a GP. I think how you lost and stuff would be valuable information.
AnwarA101
05-31-2011, 02:12 PM
And that was me. (unless someone else made it.) I ended up making day two then scrubbing out due to a mull to 4, then getting paired with Kronenberger blue, piloted by Chris himself, who was an awesome guy.
Would you post your list for reference?
ns2973
05-31-2011, 02:21 PM
Would you post your list for reference?
Sure:
2 Flooded Strand
11 Island
2 Misty Rainforest
1 Pact of Negation
2 Polluted Delta
4 Brainstorm
3 Candelabra of Tawnos
4 High Tide
3 Mental Misstep
4 Ponder
3 Preordain
4 Merchant Scroll
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
3 Cunning Wish
3 Meditate
3 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
4 Time Spiral
SB
1 Ravenous trap
1 surgical extraction
1 turnabout
1 intution
1 Echoing Truth
1 rebuild
2 pact of negation
3 spell pierce
1 brain freeze
1 blue sun's zenith
1 wipeaway
1 meditate
Doing it again, i'd add an extra island. I'll write a full report, but i lost 3 of the 5 matches i lost due to land screw or mulligans.
AnwarA101
06-01-2011, 09:48 PM
Doing it again, i'd add an extra island. I'll write a full report, but i lost 3 of the 5 matches i lost due to land screw or mulligans.
I have found 18 lands to be a good number for this deck. Did you have access to the 4th Candelabra or did you choose to only play 3? Did you consider playing the 4th Misstep perhaps over the maindeck Pact of Negation?
ns2973
06-02-2011, 09:38 AM
Yes i have access to a playset, i've found 3 to be the right number for me. As for the misstep, no i didn't. Maindeck pact was amazing for me all day. The ability to just scroll for it the turn before you combo, without the card disadvantage of force game 1 is just huge.
I'll have my report up today.
mistercakes
06-03-2011, 01:22 AM
i tried teferi in this deck. used him in the gp. whenever i got him i was pleased, try him if you haven't already. i was able to block a goyf and kill it as well! =P
also i played vs painters servant deck. after he decked me, i cunning wished, turnabout, turnabout, get blue sun zenith, cast it for 0, draw it. tried to cast time spiral but he had more counterspells. anyway, just some food for thought.
-rob
RexFTW
06-04-2011, 02:56 AM
also i played vs painters servant deck. after he decked me, i cunning wished, turnabout, turnabout, get blue sun zenith, cast it for 0, draw it.
sick!
Piceli89
06-05-2011, 11:48 AM
i tried teferi in this deck. used him in the gp. whenever i got him i was pleased, try him if you haven't already. i was able to block a goyf and kill it as well! =P
-rob
How many Teferis were you using? And, more importantly, how did you side out and tweak your sb to put those in- and against what did you board him in? 5 lands isn't easy to hit, unless you're playing against Landstill, which is already really good. I guess it doesn't make the cut for the Merfolk MU- and the Merfolk MU is the hardest to win as of now, really. They happen to have everything they need to beat you.
On another note: I'm going to write about a top8 i did recently and my considerations about MM in Spiral Tide.
ns2973
06-06-2011, 12:09 PM
Report of my GP day two is up
http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?21114-Changing-with-the-Tide-Taking-Day-Two-Then-Taking-Beats&p=557194#post557194
warai
06-08-2011, 05:53 PM
http://castlesandcooks.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/06/collective-voyage.jpg
So what do you guys think of this new weapon for Spiral Tide? This card can help us ramp faster or it can give more lands to follow a Turn About/Untap Effect.
nayon
06-08-2011, 05:54 PM
It looks awesome, we can rid our library of lands to reduce dead draws, but then again it can be misstepped. It's a tool that makes the deck better, but doesn't necessarily solve its problems imo.
ScatmanX
06-08-2011, 06:20 PM
It looks awesome, we can rid our library of lands to reduce dead draws, but then again it can be misstepped. It's a tool that makes the deck better, but doesn't necessarily solve its problems imo.
Yeah, but if they can't misstep everything.
I'm looking forward testing this card.
After a Spiral, when you have 6 or 8 mana, if you have 1 of those, then you won, getting rid of 4+ lands on the deck, and making your cantripping much better.
egosum
06-08-2011, 07:02 PM
Seems like a win more, and even worse is off-color.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
GradStudentGuy
06-08-2011, 09:11 PM
I don't think it is worth opening the deck to wasteland for that card. If we want extra land drops in blue we already have access to retraced image.
Infinitium
06-09-2011, 06:49 AM
Worth testing at the very least. Splashing green isn't horrible overall considering Xantid Swarm and assorted other sideboard cards. I like how it's essentially only a 1-mana investment in case of counters. Also make no mistake; this is much, much stronger than Retraced Image.
Pneumatiker
06-09-2011, 07:07 AM
If you are affraid of Mental Misstep, you could go with New Frontiers.
GradStudentGuy
06-09-2011, 12:29 PM
There have been rumors running around about this non confirmed card which will have a greater affect on High Tide then mental misstep. It basically is a very hard counter to any card in our deck once we have a decent storm count. If this card is true should we use it as well possibly over pact of negation?
Flusterstorm U
Instant
Counter target instant or sorcery spell unless it's controller pays 1.
Storm
1maarten1
06-09-2011, 12:59 PM
There have been rumors running around about this non confirmed card which will have a greater affect on High Tide then mental misstep. It basically is a very hard counter to any card in our deck once we have a decent storm count. If this card is true should we use it as well possibly over pact of negation?
Flusterstorm U
Instant
Counter target instant or sorcery spell unless it's controller pays 1.
Storm
Meh, I think its kinda the same as MM for this deck: Just play your own. Its much tougher for non-blue storm combo.
egosum
06-09-2011, 06:39 PM
This new card is truly rock and roll, and without CB out there it may replace spell pierce in the sideboard, just because it does at least a similar job.
Greetings,
Iñaki.-
mistercakes
06-13-2011, 12:09 AM
Just wanted to see the ruling on this, let's say we're playing against the hive mind deck.
they drop a hive mind. do their stuff...if i cast meditate, the hive mind gives them a copy. theirs resolves first, then mine. does he take his turn and die to the pacts or do i have a turn first?
was just thinking of ways to beat hive mind since it's pretty popular now, and it's nice that meditate gives us an out.
-rob
nayon
06-13-2011, 12:10 AM
Just wanted to see the ruling on this, let's say we're playing against the hive mind deck.
they drop a hive mind. do their stuff...if i cast meditate, the hive mind gives them a copy. theirs resolves first, then mine. does he take his turn and die to the pacts or do i have a turn first?
was just thinking of ways to beat hive mind since it's pretty popular now, and it's nice that meditate gives us an out.
-rob
You both skip your next turns, so it's your turn again, so you lose. I think.
death
06-13-2011, 01:05 AM
There's no out except drawing multiple FoWs + Counterpell/Spell Pierce/M-Scroll. Pray you get to drop that 3rd land and be able to C-Wish for MBT assuming you get into a counter war. Cast Spiral on your T4 and hope he doesn't draw any of his 4 FoWs, 3 MBTs/3 Intuition/3 Spell Pierce/4 Pact of Negation (if he has a Monolith out).
nayon
06-13-2011, 02:04 AM
There's no out except drawing multiple FoWs + Counterpell/Spell Pierce/M-Scroll. Pray you get to drop that 3rd land and be able to C-Wish for MBT assuming you get into a counter war. Cast Spiral on your T4 and hope he doesn't draw any of his 4 FoWs, 3 MBTs/3 Intuition/3 Spell Pierce/4 Pact of Negation (if he has a Monolith out).
If he casts negation during your turn, you might try repealing his monolith if that will put him under, but that's very fringe.
Flusterstorm beats Hive Mind pretty bad though. You get the storm, they don't. Wishing for flusterstorm might give you an out. Also weird cards like Last Word. Not sure if this works, but Trickbind/Stifle on their Hive Mind trigger should work? Stifle is shaky because they can play another pact, but trickbind should seal the deal.
Flusterstorm and trickbind seem like the best options, but even flusterstorm is a bit fringe.
Other, weirder options:
Venser, Shaper Savant on your copy of the pact while it's on the stack. Time Stop during your turn with pact triggers on stack.
Of course, none of these stop you from dying to a Show and Told Emrakul. But there you have a 1 turn window to go off.
mistercakes
06-13-2011, 06:52 PM
actually venser is pretty cool there. he can bounce emrakul too.
If he casts negation during your turn, you might try repealing his monolith if that will put him under, but that's very fringe.
Flusterstorm beats Hive Mind pretty bad though. You get the storm, they don't. Wishing for flusterstorm might give you an out. Also weird cards like Last Word. Not sure if this works, but Trickbind/Stifle on their Hive Mind trigger should work? Stifle is shaky because they can play another pact, but trickbind should seal the deal.
Flusterstorm and trickbind seem like the best options, but even flusterstorm is a bit fringe.
Other, weirder options:
Venser, Shaper Savant on your copy of the pact while it's on the stack. Time Stop during your turn with pact triggers on stack.
Of course, none of these stop you from dying to a Show and Told Emrakul. But there you have a 1 turn window to go off.
Against an active Hive Mind, Stifle on your upkeep trigger (no matter if they counter your Stifle), will still cause their Stifle-copy to target your Pact-trigger. However, if they cast 2 Pacts and ship the turn, you're still out of luck. Last option is to play Chronatog. *shrug*
death
06-13-2011, 07:07 PM
you: turn 2 Chronatog + Force backup
him: turn 2 SnT Emrakul, the Aeons Torn
you: *shrug*
you: turn 2 Chronatog + Force backup
him: turn 2 SnT Emrakul, the Aeons Torn
you: *shrug*
Can't win them all.
mrjumbo03
06-15-2011, 02:09 AM
Is there a reason to not run all 8 Fetchlands? Is there math behind having just 6 Fetchlands instead of the full 8?
AnwarA101
06-15-2011, 02:38 AM
Is there a reason to not run all 8 Fetchlands? Is there math behind having just 6 Fetchlands instead of the full 8?
Eight fetchlands is not an upper limit anymore. You could play 12 or even 16 fetchlands. My reasoning for six fetchlands is that the deck really only wants a fetchland for Brainstorm (and sometimes Ponder) and every additional fetchland adds very little and gives you some drawbacks. The first is that it costs you 1 life for each additional fetchland that you draw and it opens you up to non-basic hate whether that is Stifle, Pithing Needle, Magus of the Moon or whatever else.
Grumpollion
06-15-2011, 05:00 AM
Does M12 Windfall-Man go in this deck?
http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=331214
Fatal
06-15-2011, 05:09 AM
It require tapping so not worth, but very interesting card in slower formats as EDH for example :].
(nameless one)
06-15-2011, 08:26 AM
Are there any new innovations for the non-Candelabra lists post Mental Misstep? What does the current list look like?
emidln
06-15-2011, 06:13 PM
Spell Pierce has been pretty absymal for me and I cut it. Running ego_sum's maindeck from bazaar of moxen feels pretty good
Looking forward to playing 4x Flutterstorm in my 75.
RexFTW
06-16-2011, 03:09 PM
I doubt flutterstorm will see play. It is worse than spell pierce because it does not counter artifacts and enchants.
GGoober
06-16-2011, 04:18 PM
It is really good in storm-based decks though, especially a deck that doesn't worry about generating blue mana. It can do a lot more damage in situations where Pierce is just a 1-1.
E.g.
A: High Tide
B: MMS
A: Meditate in response
B: Daze/FoW
A: Flutterstorm Daze/FoW AND MMS.
B: Gets 2-1'd easily for 1 blue mana.
In situations against enchantments/artifacts, Pierce is better, but these are the decks that Spiral Tide are good against since they have an abysmal clock and you can sculpt for many turns and just win the counterwar (even if it's Counterbalance which is actually not being played much at all these days). I think Spiral Tide has bigger issues with decks with clocks + permission than decks with slow clocks and heavy permission.
Cyceron
06-17-2011, 04:13 AM
It is really good in storm-based decks though, especially a deck that doesn't worry about generating blue mana. It can do a lot more damage in situations where Pierce is just a 1-1.
E.g.
A: High Tide
B: MMS
A: Meditate in response
B: Daze/FoW
A: Flutterstorm Daze/FoW AND MMS.
B: Gets 2-1'd easily for 1 blue mana.
In situations against enchantments/artifacts, Pierce is better, but these are the decks that Spiral Tide are good against since they have an abysmal clock and you can sculpt for many turns and just win the counterwar (even if it's Counterbalance which is actually not being played much at all these days). I think Spiral Tide has bigger issues with decks with clocks + permission than decks with slow clocks and heavy permission.
Hmm, first of all in the scenario above, if you have the extra blue to pay for the Flutterstorm you could also pay for Daze with it. Second thing is that you already must have 5 lands to afford tide, meditate and flutterstorm, so at this point it doesn't really matter if you counter MM or not unless its like 7th turn already...
Piceli89
06-17-2011, 01:54 PM
Hmm, first of all in the scenario above, if you have the extra blue to pay for the Flutterstorm you could also pay for Daze with it. Second thing is that you already must have 5 lands to afford tide, meditate and flutterstorm, so at this point it doesn't really matter if you counter MM or not unless its like 7th turn already...
I think that wasn't a great example, because you are not going obviously to tap yourself out with Meditate with High Tide on stack, since you need mana to play an untapper. This could only happen with 6 lands on the board on in Solidarity as a bait spell.
(But, Flusterstorm is pretty good at letting a Meditate slip through the permission wall of a blue based deck, where it's extremely crucial to refill the hand before going off.)
Flusterstorm is better used against Team America, where it's an uncounterable, un-missteppable response to Tourach and Stifle, without doing card disadvantage. Pierce used to be good until Mental Misstep was printed, against tempo decks. FS, on the other side, if used correctly, can even provide actual card advantage. Some concrete examples?
-Your opponent Hymns to Tourach. You have 2 lands untapped, one of which is a fetchland. You can fetch in response, they'll Stifle, you Flusterstorm for 3 and, baring Daze or Force of Will, you have 2x1ed.
-The example above, but you have 2 Islands. You can attempt to Brainstorm in response to Tourach as if you wanted to hide your cards, they'll probably Misstep. That's where you get your comfortable 4-powered FS, resolve your Brainstorm, negate their disruption and have them tap out or almost.
-You can bait your opponent in cantripping into Stifles as long as you keep your fetchlands uncracked; then, you can use their Ponders and Brainstorms as Storm boosters to Flusterstorm a double Stifle on a fetchland. If done in their EOT, you get them to waste 2 cards and tap 2 mana.
-Flusterstorm works wonders with Pact of Negation against tempo decks. Their best bet is to stop your High Tide from resolving. Turnabout and Spiral usually require a Force of Will, baring REBs.
It usually takes double Tide or a combination of Tide and counters to resolve it, since Misstep exists. Now you can just cast Tide, having it countered, Tide again/Pact, having it countered again, and Flusterstorm everything to win the counterwar.
-Another scenario that I could see a lot is them Vendilion Cliqu'ing you after you drew. You can response with High Tide, to which they'll Misstep. You Pact of Negation the Clique. They Force, or whatever. You Flusterstorm for 5 they're tapped out because of the Clique, you have basically done a 2x3 and proceed going off with them out of gas.
-Flusterstorm still remains a catch-all even if High Tide resolves and they have several mana untapped, since you're going to ramp spells pretty easily (also, don't forget the high number of cc1 cantrips this deck packs). At worst, it is a Turnabout that costs 1, which comboes well in emptying their mana and passing phases. Or with another Flusterstorm.
-Flusterstorm is miles better than Spell Pierce against Dredge and ANT.
Seriously, card's retardedly good, and it's just a matter of time before people start to run it and consistently beat the flurry of Mental Misstep in the format. It just requires a lot of thought on how to hold your spells in order to maximize its efficiency, and how to bait the most of opponent's permission.
Flutterstorm is a strict upgrade to Disrupt. Many of the points Piceli89 made are all valid too. I'll be packing FS into my Tide lists as soon as I pick them up.
Piceli89
06-17-2011, 03:12 PM
they're already going 20$ a piece. Fuck Wizards and their stupid business escamotages.
nayon
06-17-2011, 03:22 PM
they're already going 20$ a piece. Fuck Wizards and their stupid business escamotages.
Just buy the commander decks. It's way more value for your money.
RexFTW
06-20-2011, 06:35 PM
I think that wasn't a great example, because you are not going obviously to tap yourself out with Meditate with High Tide on stack, since you need mana to play an untapper. This could only happen with 6 lands on the board on in Solidarity as a bait spell.
(But, Flusterstorm is pretty good at letting a Meditate slip through the permission wall of a blue based deck, where it's extremely crucial to refill the hand before going off.)
Flusterstorm is better used against Team America, where it's an uncounterable, un-missteppable response to Tourach and Stifle, without doing card disadvantage. Pierce used to be good until Mental Misstep was printed, against tempo decks. FS, on the other side, if used correctly, can even provide actual card advantage. Some concrete examples?
-Your opponent Hymns to Tourach. You have 2 lands untapped, one of which is a fetchland. You can fetch in response, they'll Stifle, you Flusterstorm for 3 and, baring Daze or Force of Will, you have 2x1ed.
-The example above, but you have 2 Islands. You can attempt to Brainstorm in response to Tourach as if you wanted to hide your cards, they'll probably Misstep. That's where you get your comfortable 4-powered FS, resolve your Brainstorm, negate their disruption and have them tap out or almost.
-You can bait your opponent in cantripping into Stifles as long as you keep your fetchlands uncracked; then, you can use their Ponders and Brainstorms as Storm boosters to Flusterstorm a double Stifle on a fetchland. If done in their EOT, you get them to waste 2 cards and tap 2 mana.
-Flusterstorm works wonders with Pact of Negation against tempo decks. Their best bet is to stop your High Tide from resolving. Turnabout and Spiral usually require a Force of Will, baring REBs.
It usually takes double Tide or a combination of Tide and counters to resolve it, since Misstep exists. Now you can just cast Tide, having it countered, Tide again/Pact, having it countered again, and Flusterstorm everything to win the counterwar.
-Another scenario that I could see a lot is them Vendilion Cliqu'ing you after you drew. You can response with High Tide, to which they'll Misstep. You Pact of Negation the Clique. They Force, or whatever. You Flusterstorm for 5 they're tapped out because of the Clique, you have basically done a 2x3 and proceed going off with them out of gas.
-Flusterstorm still remains a catch-all even if High Tide resolves and they have several mana untapped, since you're going to ramp spells pretty easily (also, don't forget the high number of cc1 cantrips this deck packs). At worst, it is a Turnabout that costs 1, which comboes well in emptying their mana and passing phases. Or with another Flusterstorm.
-Flusterstorm is miles better than Spell Pierce against Dredge and ANT.
Seriously, card's retardedly good, and it's just a matter of time before people start to run it and consistently beat the flurry of Mental Misstep in the format. It just requires a lot of thought on how to hold your spells in order to maximize its efficiency, and how to bait the most of opponent's permission.
I think all of these are good legitimate points. However, all of these are for control decks. I think this card is at best a sideboard card as it is terrible against aggro and mediocre against combo.
Piceli89
06-21-2011, 06:33 AM
I think all of these are good legitimate points. However, all of these are for control decks. I think this card is at best a sideboard card as it is terrible against aggro and mediocre against combo.
What?
I mean, imagine Flusterstorm against ANT. It is, at worse, a Spell Pierce (e.g. in response to a single Duress), at average it can catch a protection and an acceleration made in response to something else, and at best it is a Mindbreak Trap on Tendrils. Also, it is pretty cool to Flusterstorm an Infernal Tutor on stack evn if they have X mana spare to negate the possibility to Ad Nauseam or chaining multiple tutors to Tendrils (even if it would be better to cast it directly on ToA).
Imagine FS against Dredge. Spell Pierce had the serious downside that it quickly lost its power due to them chaining free Therapies from the graveyard leaving their (only) 2 lands untapped. With Flusterstorm, it's very easy to reach 3 storm (with a Brainstorm, for example) and go out of the Pierce range. It gets even better on Dread Return, since they use to pass from Therapies before. Of course it doesn't solve the real problem in this matchup, which is beat followed my a lot of disruption, but it can be considered an upgrade to Pierce and it also hits Return, differently from Mental Misstep.
Flusterstorm against Hive Mind is bonkerz, you need to have a Force of Will to stop Show and Tell/Hive Mind, they counter back, you Flusterstorm the counter and they're done baring double counter, which should imply they have slowed down enough for you to find your own disruption.
I'm not completely sure about this one, but if you Flusterstorm a Pact after Hive Mind, the copy of Flusterstorm put on the stack by HM shouldn't have Storm (Storm triggers when you play a spell). That means you're very likely to have them dying from their own Pact if they don't have enough mana to pay for it.
ScatmanX
06-21-2011, 10:44 AM
I'm not completely sure about this one, but if you Flusterstorm a Pact after Hive Mind, the copy of Flusterstorm put on the stack by HM shouldn't have Storm (Storm triggers when you play a spell). That means you're very likely to have them dying from their own Pact if they don't have enough mana to pay for it.
They may have their 1 copy of Flusterstorm target their on Pact, and not pay for it, therefore not needing to pay for the Pact later. Nevertheless, they should not resolve a Hive Mind with Flutterstorm + 1 Counter on our hand. Also, if they do, Pact on't kill us, because our Flusterstorm will counter it.
RexFTW
06-21-2011, 10:48 PM
if you have counters, why arent you countering their hivemind? O wait cuz you cant. Just sayin.
at best it is a Mindbreak Trap on Tendrils that costs 1 mana and does not exile the spells.Fixed.
mistercakes
06-24-2011, 12:27 AM
10 Island
2 Tropical Island
3 Misty Rainforest
3 Scalding Tarn
4 Time Spiral
3 Preordain
3 Ponder
4 Merchant Scroll
2 City of Solitude
3 Cunning Wish
3 Turnabout
4 Brainstorm
3 Mental Misstep
4 High Tide
3 Meditate
1 Pact of Negation
4 Force of Will
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
Sideboard
1 Hurkyl's Recall
1 Rebuild
2 Brain Freeze
1 Surgical Extraction
1 Snap
1 Turnabout
1 Meditate
1 Pact of Negation
1 Echoing Truth
2 Spell Pierce
1 Curfew
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
1 krosan grip/mindbreak trap
been playing around with this on magic online since i secretly love city of solitude. it's been producing some decent results. you guys might want to give it a try.
Inkwizition
06-24-2011, 04:25 AM
Meh, I'd rather play Defense Grid than the green splash, and even that doesn't improve the Merfolk matchup that much.
frenchy-man
06-24-2011, 05:52 AM
if you have counters, why arent you countering their hivemind? O wait cuz you cant. Just sayin.
Fixed.
+1
And try to counter that jace with your flutterstorm, you'll have some troubles.
Piceli89
06-24-2011, 06:02 AM
If your argument to not pick Flusterstorm is "try to counter their Jace with Flusterstorm" in Spiral Tide, you might as well try a different deck.
RexFTW
06-24-2011, 04:00 PM
Countering Jace is key when playing against a deck with 30 counterspells. So is countering Aether Vial, Standstill, Sterling Grove and various hate bears. The only key thing that flusterstorm counters is discard spells. Pact of negation is better against counterspells.
Also, misdirection is better against hymn and thoughtseize. Just Saying.
ScatmanX
06-24-2011, 04:34 PM
Also, misdirection is better against hymn and thoughtseize. Just Saying.
So is Divert.
Wasn't you the one saying that Flusterstorm is bad because it cannot counter Jace? Than you suggest Missdirection?
I think you should review your concepts.
And I do not think countering Jace or Standstill or Vial are the best plays we can do against several decks.
mistercakes
06-25-2011, 01:50 PM
3-1'd a daily today
round 1: rug (win 2-0)
round 2: death and taxes with mental mistep (2-0)
round 3: BUG landstill (1-2)
round 4: WUB lots of counterspells (2-0)
so that was 4 rounds, 3 of them had 4 force of will + 4 mental misstep. round 1 had daze. also the 3rd and 4th rounds were playing discard.
city of solitude is an absolute house and i don't really see how to win consistently without it vs decks with 8 free counterspells + more if they are smart enough to keep their islands untapped while we're going off.
i think the list i'm running is the same, although i would change a sb spell pierce to another pact of negation.
the cities just force your opponent to waste all their counter magic on that card. if for some reason they are dry on counterspells when you play it, you're free to win at your leisure afterwards.
replays are on magic online if you look for this morning's daily. 6/25 9:30 AM EST.
RexFTW
06-25-2011, 09:31 PM
So is Divert.
Wasn't you the one saying that Flusterstorm is bad because it cannot counter Jace? Than you suggest Missdirection?
I think you should review your concepts.
And I do not think countering Jace or Standstill or Vial are the best plays we can do against several decks.
Logic fail by you.
Flusterstorm is only good against discard. Misdirection is better against most discard. Therefore misdirection > flusterstorm.
3-1'd a daily today
round 1: rug (win 2-0)
round 2: death and taxes with mental mistep (2-0)
round 3: BUG landstill (1-2)
round 4: WUB lots of counterspells (2-0)
so that was 4 rounds, 3 of them had 4 force of will + 4 mental misstep. round 1 had daze. also the 3rd and 4th rounds were playing discard.
city of solitude is an absolute house and i don't really see how to win consistently without it vs decks with 8 free counterspells + more if they are smart enough to keep their islands untapped while we're going off.
i think the list i'm running is the same, although i would change a sb spell pierce to another pact of negation.
the cities just force your opponent to waste all their counter magic on that card. if for some reason they are dry on counterspells when you play it, you're free to win at your leisure afterwards.
replays are on magic online if you look for this morning's daily. 6/25 9:30 AM EST.
list please!
RexFTW
06-25-2011, 11:06 PM
replays are on magic online if you look for this morning's daily. 6/25 9:30 AM EST.
Watched the replays. Interesting games.
His list has maindeck city of solitude(s) and tropical islands.
mistercakes
06-26-2011, 12:02 AM
i probably could have gone 4-0, but i made the mistake round 3 game 2 of using 1 of my 2 pact of negations to counter a misstep, where i should have kept it to have double counter backup for the time spiral. it was pure greed wanting to have 2 high tides before playing time spiral.
greed is not always good!
i used camtasia to record the video, but it's a rather large file (over 1 gb). if it uploads, i'll post a youtube link.
(i posted the decklist on the forum a few days ago, it should be on page 24)
ScatmanX
06-26-2011, 12:28 AM
Flusterstorm is only good against discard.
That is quite wrong.
Misdirection is better against most discard.
But useless against others... Must be nice never running into Duress or Silence.
Also, Double Post fail for you.
RexFTW
06-26-2011, 12:36 AM
But useless against others... Must be nice never running into Duress or Silence.
Side in MM for these.
Suite of MM + Pact + force has everything covered pretty well. Only hymn slips through sometimes as its only handled by force. How you split them between the maindeck and board is up to you though.
ScatmanX
06-27-2011, 03:54 PM
GPT – SJC 12/06/2011
This was last week, but it was writen in portuguese the Day after.
Tournament would give the 1st a ticket to Amsterdã for the GP.
I went to bed @2 am the “night” before, and woke up @4 am, to catch a ride, then a train, then the subway, then another ride, to arrive 8:30 at the tournament.
The report is mainly the combo turn, and my opponents plays, because this deck mainly just sculpts...
DECKLIST (http://www.thecouncil.es/tcdecks/deck.php?id=6374&iddeck=46188)
Round 1 – NO Bant
Game 1 – He mulls to 5, but gets some beats in with Scryb Ranger and Dryad Arbor, then attempts a T3 or 4 NO, which I FoW. He resolves a GSZ@2 next turn for Goyf (thanks god). I take 2 more attacks, and go off with ease getting 2 Tides before TS.
Game 2 – He starts with Goyf, then gets a Vendillion, that takes my High Tide, then resolve a Tegg. With Tegg in play, I know he is low on counters. An Impulse finds me the Tide I needed, and I go for it, paying for Daze, casting Meditate to find more counters, then Snap on Tegg, then Turnabout. He had 2 FoW, but I had 2 Pact, and resolve a TS. After Spiral he gets 2 FoW again, but I play around them. I make a mistake where I use my 2nd Wish, and realize I’ll have to kill him just with BSZ. So I gather a lot of mana, TS again, and get 2 Turnabout, 2 Scroll and a Pact.
1-0
Round 2 – Merfolk
Game 1 – Don’t remember anything. I go down to 5, and have to combo on the 4th turn, trough 2 counters. I do it.
Game 2 – He rushes me. I try Tide+TS, which amazingly resolves, but I fizzle getting onlu Scroll as business.
Game 3 – He forgets to tick Vial once, which costs him the game. He takes me to 4 on turn 4. On my turn I Tide, He MM, I MM, He FoW, I Pact, Turnabout, TS. Then get a good hand and BF him.
2-0
Round 3 – UWR Stoneblade
Game 1 – I FoW a Clique, He resolves a Jace. I make a mistake when I try to GO off (#1), when I had 2 Spiral, Tide, MM and Pact (6 lands) I started with Tide, he MM, I MM, he FoW. I should have let it resolve, and passed the turn. He would not kill me. Next turn I’d just TS with Pact backup, so he would need 2 counters. Well, I Pact’d the FoW, and his last FoW sealed for me, since I had to pay 3UU on my upkeep…
Game 2 – Again He goes for Vendillion, and I FoW. He follows with a Lavamancer. Then Jace, Than Stoneforge. I try to GO off with 5 lands, Tide, MM, 2 Pact, 2 Turnabout, and TS. He has 3 counters for Tide, so I Turnabout twice, and cast TS. I have a bonkers hand. Start with Scroll, then Tide, MM, Pact, Spiral. Then I Brainstorm, and he BS in response, then MM my BS, and I MM back. He Pyroblasts it. I cast Wish. He FoW. I FoW back, removing Turnabout (mistake #2), and He Pierces it. I had only 3 mana left. Had I cast turnabout, then cast 3UU for FoW, I’d have 1 more mana, and would have won.
2-1
Round 4 – Merfolk
Game 1 – I’m low on lands. He gets Vial + Standstill. I have to break it with BS, that gets MM, and he follows with Standstill again. I break it with Impulse to get a 4th land. I Tide+Spiral, which, again, amazingly resolves, only for me to fizzle again. (To be fair, I had Tide+BS+Scroll, and started with BS, where I should’ve started with Tide, and hope for it to get Fo”d or MM’d. He MM’d the BS, and I lost (screw #3))
Game 2 – He hás 0 dudes, and resolves a T2 Standstill. After a lot of turns, and with 7 lands, I eot BS. He MM, I Wish, He FoW, he Pierce BS. My turn I Tide, he Pierce, I pay, he MM, I MM, he MM, I respond with Tide, then resolve a Turnabout. I then cast TS, he FoW. My last card is Pact, and He hás only 2 cards in hand. I Pact, and he FoW again. We’re both with 0 cards. We draw-go for a while. He resolves a Vial, then cast Standstill. I respond with Brainstorm, then Impulse, then Meditate. 2 turns later I go off double protected
Game 3 – I have to GO off turn 4 or 5, with only 2 protecs, and get there. Get a good hand, and win.
3-1
Round 5 – The Rock
Game 1 – 1st and only time I win the Dice roll that Day. His 1st move is a Vindicate. I respond with Meditate, then FoW. He Extirpate FoW, and cast Goyf. I GO off 2 turns later.
Game 2 – He IoK, I have TS, FoW, Turnabout, Lands, and BS and Preordain. If it were Seize I’d have countered it. He then gets a Goyf, then another. I Meditate, he Seize, I MM, with FoW still backing me up, then win. 4-1
Round 6 - Merfolk (3rd one)
Game 1 – He gets Vial, and my life crumbles fast. Turn 4 or 5 I go off trough 2 counters + Catcher, and win.
Game 2 – He is slower, but have 2 Cursecatchers. On his 5th turn, I eot Snap a Catcher. My turn I have only 2 counterspells, and have to even counter his Dazes. I get 1 land short from Turnabouting and winning.
Game 3 – I keep a nice one. He goes with Vial, that drops CC and Coralhelm. His 3rd turn he cast another CC. I MM it, paying mana for it, and tapping out. He Dazes, and I MM again. My turn I resolve a Tide+TS when He had only 1 counter. I draw a so-so hand. Lead with Tide, that eats MM. I respond with BS, then Impulse, then Meditate, which He FoW’s, and I respond still with Turnabout, Impulse, Turnabout, Wish for BSZ, and cast it for 9 at me. I counter his FoW, draw 4 more, then finally let him counter my Tide, casting 2 others, Scroll for Turnabout, then BF + Zenith him.
5-1
3rd on swiss.
Top 8 – Affinity.
I’m glad I added Hurkyl's Recall last minute.
Game 1 – He leads with 2 Mnemites and land. I had Preordain, Impulse, MM, Tide, TS and lands. 2nd turn he cast the 2cc guy, and hits me. I Impulse. He cast Master of Etherium, and hits. I Impulse AGAIN to find a 3rd land drop and pass. He uses Contested warzone, and swings for my exact life total. I die with the combo on my hand.
Game 2 – I lead with Preordain, He with land, Springleaf. I Impulse. He Signal Pest, 2x Frogmite, then Seizes, which I FoW removing Snap. I Brainstorm, Fetch, and Impulse. He gets a Cannonist. I Brainstorm AGAIN. His turn he taps for that equippament, so I can Chain of Vapor his Cannonist. My turn I Preordain, than Preordain AGAIN, and found nothing. I had 5 lands, and TS in my hand. ANY Merchant Scroll, High Tide, Rebuild, Recall, Turnabout (14 cards total)
I’m quite disappointed with the loss, knowing that I’d play later with Maverick (which is easy as hell), and then another Merfolk (which I had previsiously 3-0’d, even with 2 “fizzles”)
Props:
- Super Bizarros team, for trading boosters for Beer =D
- The store
- Comboing trough lots and lots of FoWs, Mental Missteps and Merfolks
Slops:
- Perder top8 match fácil;
- People splitting, and no one going to Amsterdã…
Cheers.
Edit: on decklist:
I only wish I had 1 or 2 more Fetches.
Impulses rocked, and were golden in Stack wars.
3 Pact/FoW/MM seems right today.
SB Needs Surgical Extraction.
I still prefer BSZ over Brain Freeze on the main.
Piceli89
06-27-2011, 07:47 PM
Weren't 9 protection spells maindeck a bit overload (maybe that's why you fizzled so much)? I'd never go beyond 8. Reducing Force of Will to 3 sounds like a good idea, but I'd personally play 3 Fow-3 MM- 2 Pact. 9 just seems to much, considering you are maindecking protections that are, after all, situational (MM is just ignored by some decks or comes too late to slow down aggro decks enough, Pact is almost useless against any form of non -blue deck).
Also, while the inclusion of Impulse is a good idea, I'd never cut the cantrips to 8. As Egosum said, those are the soul of the deck, granting consistency and a cheap way to filter draws post-Spiral. The 1 mana more required by Impulse, although digging deeper and being instant, may cause you to slow down further and give fast decks a choice in case of hands without a t1 Preordain (which is left as the only cantrip worth of being cast on the first turn. You generally don't cast Brainstorm randomly baring a Merchant Scroll or a Fetchland following after).
Related to a different issue: I know what I'm going to say will sound blasphemous, but has anyone had the desire to cut a Merchant Scroll from the maindeck, or better, try a different configuration without it? I know it's a cheap tutor that makes this deck better than Solidarity and grants consistency and a solid 1x sideboard plan (see Hurkyl's Recall against Affinity, for example), but I found myself not wanting it against the plethora of blue decks, where tapping out at sorcery speed may give them the right signal to drop their Counterbalance/Meddling Mage/whatever else and basically forcing us to change our gameplan to get rid of the problematic card. I've found that the greatest strength of this deck is the capability to play in a reactive role casting Meditate and Wishes in response to their spell, allowing us to bury them in instant-speed card advantage or selection. Merchant Scroll doesn't fit in this place; the only sorcery I'm fine in casting are the cheap cantrips and Time Spiral.
I'm siding 1-ofs out consistently against any deck packing blue, since it's also a tempo sink to lose a turn getting Snared, Dazed, or worse, Catchered. Of course Scroll still shines against aggro decks where it allows you to build the combo hand more rapidly, but still, I find it weaksaucy against blue based decks, before comboing (and against Dredge, where Cabal Therapy just makes it a waste of resources).
ScatmanX
06-27-2011, 08:03 PM
@Piceli: Maybe 9 protec was overload, but due to the amount of Folks/Blue decks, I think it was fine. Maybe 8 is the right number though,and I'd too cut the 3rd Pact.
The "fizzle" was not due to it though. Every tournament I expect the deck to fizzle once. The 2nd one was more like a missplay.
About Impulse: I run 19 lands, so cantripping T1 to find them is less necessary, while Impulse is way better than Ponder mid-combo. And Impulse IS a cantrip, so I do not run only 8.
About removing Scroll: It seems bad.
Against control, where you say it is bad, I think it is just as awesome. Scrolling for Pact when you need protection, Meditate when you need to refuel, preemptively searching for Wipe Away when playing against CB... The tutoring power is what make this deck better than Solidarity (and of course, Time Spiral...)
Hi!
I recently bought 3 Candelabra of Tawnos and I really want to play them in a spiral tide-format. Now I'm guessing theres alot of people here with huge skills in deck building. Can one of you please make me a working list so I can start trying the deck out? I cant really build hatfields list from ages ago when so much has happened to the format (Flusterstorm maybe but mostly Mental Misstep)
Regards,
Markus
mistercakes
06-28-2011, 08:31 AM
i've found with testing that the candelabras have to be foregone due to mental misstep. i also have candelabras, and when i feel like i still want to make use of them, i just bust out the 12 post deck.
current list for magic online:
10 Island
2 Tropical Island
3 Misty Rainforest
3 Scalding Tarn
4 Time Spiral
3 Preordain
3 Ponder
4 Merchant Scroll
2 City of Solitude
3 Cunning Wish
3 Turnabout
4 Brainstorm
3 Mental Misstep
4 High Tide
3 Meditate
1 Pact of Negation
4 Force of Will
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
Sideboard
1 Hurkyl's Recall
1 Rebuild
2 Brain Freeze
1 Surgical Extraction
1 Snap
1 Turnabout
1 Meditate
2 Pact of Negation
1 Echoing Truth
1 Spell Pierce
1 Curfew
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
1 krosan grip or mindbreak trap or wipe away
i might run the brain freeze maindeck irl, but online there's a lot of show and tell style decks where brain freeze is still good, but i'd rather have the card draw game 1.
mistercakes
06-28-2011, 08:31 AM
i've found with testing that the candelabras have to be foregone due to mental misstep. i also have candelabras, and when i feel like i still want to make use of them, i just bust out the 12 post deck.
current list for magic online:
10 Island
2 Tropical Island
3 Misty Rainforest
3 Scalding Tarn
4 Time Spiral
3 Preordain
3 Ponder
4 Merchant Scroll
2 City of Solitude
3 Cunning Wish
3 Turnabout
4 Brainstorm
3 Mental Misstep
4 High Tide
3 Meditate
1 Pact of Negation
4 Force of Will
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
Sideboard
1 Hurkyl's Recall
1 Rebuild
2 Brain Freeze
1 Surgical Extraction
1 Snap
1 Turnabout
1 Meditate
2 Pact of Negation
1 Echoing Truth
1 Spell Pierce
1 Curfew
1 Blue Sun's Zenith
1 krosan grip or mindbreak trap or wipe away
i might run the brain freeze maindeck irl, but online there's a lot of show and tell style decks where brain freeze is still good, but i'd rather have the card draw game 1.
RexFTW
06-29-2011, 09:14 AM
When my candelabra gets missteped I have a disco party on the table right in the middle of the game. That is great news!
I know what I'm going to say will sound blasphemous, but has anyone had the desire to cut a Merchant Scroll from the maindeck, or better, try a different configuration without it?
You know, this is an excellent point. We are playing the only deck in the format that can play demonic tutor. This is ultimately quite unfair and I think we should not take advantage of this situation.
ns2973
06-29-2011, 01:45 PM
When my candelabra gets missteped I have a disco party on the table right in the middle of the game. That is great news!
Very much this. Candelabra is almost BETTER in the MM era because it allows people unfamiliar with the deck to misplay.
Michael Keller
06-29-2011, 01:52 PM
There's actually a really funny story I have regarding this deck:
I was going to attend the Star City Baltimore Open with a home brew I had been working on for a while. After my wife dropped me off at the Metro to go out to meet Dave Price and ride with him to Baltimore, I reached in my bag on the train and realized I had grabbed the wrong bag (both black bags - no deck, nothing).
Fail.
So, Dave let's me borrow High Tide and I wound up playing it (for the first time in sanctioned play ever) to a respectable 4-3 finish before dropping after Round Seven. A few of my losses could be attributed to lack of sleep and hunger, but no one really expected the deck there and it wound up doing some damage. I actually started off 2-0 and was on the verge of running it up to 3-0 before dropping Round Three at table one in three very tightly contested games.
I wound up running one Misstep main and one in the board, and it worked out really well. I'm not an experienced pilot with this archetype, but I can say from an unbiased point of view and seven grueling rounds that I would up the count of Misstep to two main and one board (at least with Dave's version, which in turn is Anwar Ahmad's, too). It really worked out that well.
I just went 5-1 in a Magic-League trial finishing 2nd with Spiral Tide.
;
2-0 vs Forests.dec
2-1 vs Dredge
2-0 vs Zoo
Bye
2-0 vs Merfolk
Final : 1-2 vs Zoo because he got nut draws with Steppe Lynxes and Burn and a Choke on turn 3 when i had no FoWs in hand.
My list ;
// Lands
2 Misty Rainforest
4 Flooded Strand
12 Island
// Spells
2 Meditate
4 Ponder
4 Turnabout
4 Force of Will
1 Brain Freeze
1 Pact of Negation
4 Merchant Scroll
3 High Tide
3 Cunning Wish
4 Time Spiral
1 Snap
4 Brainstorm
4 Mental Misstep
3 Preordain
// Sideboard
SB: 1 Meditate
SB: 1 Brain Freeze
SB: 1 Pact of Negation
SB: 1 High Tide
SB: 2 Snap
SB: 3 Spell Pierce
SB: 1 Blue Sun's Zenith
SB: 1 Wipe Away
SB: 1 Mindbreak Trap
SB: 1 Hurkyl's Recall
SB: 1 Echoing Truth
SB: 1 Ravenous Trap
RexFTW
06-30-2011, 11:15 AM
Very interesting, Pich has 1 Hightide in the board game 1.
ns2973
06-30-2011, 11:40 AM
Very interesting, Pich has 1 Hightide in the board game 1.
Yeah, i've toyed with it as well. It allows you to wish for it if absolutely necessary.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.