Show and Tell Banned?!?....Soon?

[apple713]

Anyone think that Show and Tell will be banned soon?

The reason I think this will happen is because it puts Wizards in a difficult position when they want to print really amazing creatures. Show and tell only gets better as more creatures are printed.

With their previous decision to ban Survival I would not put it past them to do the same to Show and Tell .

[Chikenbok]

This one time: http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?14662-All-B-R-update-speculation/page219

[Esper3k]

Ban Brainstorm (no really please don't, WoTC).

[apple713]

Ban Brainstorm (no really please don't, WoTC).

brainstorm is great but it doesn't win games nor is it a tutor. its just a cantrip on steroids. Back to conversation about show and tell...

[Chikenbok]

Why isn't this thread locked yet.

[death]

in before lock

related links:
DCI update 12/20/10 - Survival banned; Time Spiral unbanned (http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?19534-DCI-update-12-20-10-Survival-banned-Time-Spiral-unbanned&highlight=survival+banned)
[Let's Bitch About] Show and Tell (http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?21580-Let-s-Bitch-About-Show-and-Tell&highlight=show+and+tell+ban)
Ban on Brainstorm: Yes or No (Post Snapcaster Mage) (http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?22547-Ban-on-Brainstorm-Yes-or-No-(Post-Snapcaster-Mage)&highlight=ban+brainstorm)

Move on.

peace,

your MTGS Librarian

[SilverGreen]

it puts Wizards in a difficult position when they want to print really amazing creaturesBut no.

WotC doesn't give a piece of cake to Legacy when printing what they want to print. They'll keep printing Emrakuls and Griselbrands and Ominisciences at will, and Show and Tell will do absolutely nothing to restrain them of doing so. It never did.

If, IF they ban S&T someday, it'll be for an entirely different reason.

[Humphrey]

Ban Brainstorm (no really please don't, WoTC).

Thats my phrase

[feline]

They just announced what they are and are not banning and they didn't do anything for Legacy this time around, I think Show and Tell is fine right now just based on that.

[Esper3k]

Honestly, I think Show & Tell is fine. Legacy has such a large card pool that it can usually adapt to any deck that's dominant. It's not like Show & Tell is even really dominating right now. Didn't we just see 3 Jund decks in the last SCG T4?

[thefringthing]

I would be pleased if the card were banned. I think its power-level is a bit above the acceptable threshold for Legacy, it's difficult to interact with, and it certainly isn't a very fun or interesting card.