Sleeve suggestions?

[stage]

Hi, I'm looking to replace my cheap ultra pros with something durable and easy to shuffle. Any suggestions?

Thanks!

[[SLAYER]chaos]

KMC matte

[Kayradis]

My little pony.

[Purgatory]

chaos;762417']KMC matte

+1, they tend to get dirty quickly, but they're very durable.

[Lord_Mcdonalds]

KMC Mattes are your safest bet.

Dragonshield aren't bad, they are super durable (insofar, I can count on one hand the amount I've had split on me), just they get very ugly quickly and have a tendency of being poorly cut (to the point where I've recieved packs I actually cannot use in tournaments with out getting deck checked/dq), has the side effect of meaning you can't use sleeves from other packs, although that only tends to happen with certain colors

[davelin]

+1, they tend to get dirty quickly, but they're very durable.

+2

[JPoJohnson]

I asked this a couple of months ago and ended up going with double sleeved cards:

Inner Sleeve - KMC Perfect Fit
Outer Sleeve - Dragonshield


I love it, and they've been shuffled and played a LOT and they're still looking good. I didn't have any miscuts in the boxes I got (4), but I may have been lucky as I've heard they have miscuts quite often.

[allek]

Buy the cheapest possible and replace them more often instead. That's what I did after trying KMC, Dragon Shield etc. They all get filthy after a while regardless of price/quality.

[(nameless one)]

I find these to be of great quality. (https://fbcdn-photos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/1422615_212094462303415_1594930524_n.jpg)

[Vidi]

KMC Perfect Fit & Purple Dragon Shield.

[Quasim0ff]

KMC super fits + KMC super blacks is my go-to sleeves.

No problems in forever and ever.

[Luklinda]

I asked this a couple of months ago and ended up going with double sleeved cards:

Inner Sleeve - KMC Perfect Fit
Outer Sleeve - Dragonshield


I love it, and they've been shuffled and played a LOT and they're still looking good. I didn't have any miscuts in the boxes I got (4), but I may have been lucky as I've heard they have miscuts quite often.

Been reading up on the same and ended up opting for KMC Perfect Fit and KMC Hyper Outer because I had store credit built up and they only had 1 box of Dragonshield left. Do the PF sleeves actually slide up as badly as folks claim they do?

[Caniki]

I find these to be of great quality. (https://fbcdn-photos-b-a.akamaihd.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/1422615_212094462303415_1594930524_n.jpg)

Those aren't out until mid-november, but they're made my Ultra-Pro, so I'd expect them to be of the same quality as all of their other sleeves with pictures on them.


I'm a big fan of the Ultra-Pro Pro-Matte sleeves. They double sleeve well, and they're not slippery like new KMC or DragonShields are.

[Madmaniac21]

KMC black your entire collection, ez game for building decks/swapping things.

[JDK]

Inner Sleeve: KMC Perfect Size - not even close. I tried the Ultra Pro ones a year or so ago and they were heavily miscut and just bigger than the KMC
Outer Sleeve: Haven't tried Dragonshield or Legion Gaming (Channel Fireball Sleeves), but I use KMC Matte and Ultra Pro 'Pro Matte' (much easier to shuffle than KMC). As long as you don't use the normal UPs, you should be fine.

[JPoJohnson]

Been reading up on the same and ended up opting for KMC Perfect Fit and KMC Hyper Outer because I had store credit built up and they only had 1 box of Dragonshield left. Do the PF sleeves actually slide up as badly as folks claim they do?

They were all the same size and sleeved up very nicely for me. I had no issues with either brand of sleeve. They both were great and I was able to use every sleeve that came in four boxes of each (total of 800 sleeves all tournament playable, 400 sleeves of both type).

[luckme10]

Yanoman Gunmetal Sleeves (100 ct)

[Deadpool09]

Yanoman Gunmetal Sleeves (100 ct)

If you can find them. Otherwise KMC HYPER MATTE. They're the new ones. Combines the feel of ultra pros and the durability of dragon shield.