View Full Version : Karametra's Merrow
MaximumC
03-30-2015, 01:11 PM
This is a thread to talk about the two-card combo that seems like it does absolutely bonkers insane things in Modern and yet no one has ever even touched it. Yep, I'm talkin' about:
Puresight Merrow + Karametra's Favor
What's going on here, you wonder? Well, it's like this. You have yourself a Puresight Merrow and it's survived somehow. Slap a Favor on that little blue and white butt. Favor's trigger to draw a card goes on the stack only after it enters the battlefield. Since it's already there, guess what? You can respond to the trigger before it resolves by tapping Merrow for mana. And then, still in response, you can use that mana to untap your Merrow, scrying away your top card if you don't want it. And then you do it again! And again! When you finally like your top card, leave it there and let Favor's ETB ability resolve to put it in your hand.
Congrats, you just cast a 4 casting cost Demonic Consultation. Whoopdie do, you say. However, you also have total control over your topdeck for the rest of the game and you got yourself an infinitely untapping creature in play. It should not be impossible to make this into a game win.
How do you win, though? Well, there's a few options.
1 - Mana Reflection - This gives you infinite mana, but since you need infinite mana to cast this monster, that's not gonna work.
2 - Mesmeric Orb - You can mill yourself to death, but that sucks because mill wins usually require a specific combination of cards in your graveyard and you're very likely to exile one or more parts as you dig for the orb initially. Pass.
3 - Wakethrasher - He goes infinite, sure, but he's a non-evasive, non-hasty dork that costs 3 on top of your combo. Can we do better?
4 - Judge of Currents - Sure we can. Judge only costs 2 and gives you enough life that only a combo deck dealing infinite damage can stop you - and then only if they remove the combo pieces first.
5 - Laboratory Maniac - A good win condition, but you have to pass the turn first unless you have another natural draw.
With all that considered, I envision a heavy disruptive shell designed to dig for and protect the combo. Here's my first draft:
KARAMETRA'S MERROW
Combo Pieces (13):
4 Puresight Merrow
4 Karametra's Favor
3 Judge of Currents
1 Laboratory Maniac
Protection (15):
4 Mana Leak
4 Remand
4 Mizzium Skin
2 Cyclonic Rift
1 Elixir of Immortaility
Dig (10):
4 Commune with the Gods
3 Anticipate
3 Gitaxian Probe
Lands (23)
4 Cavern of Souls
4 Misty Rainforest
4 Breeding Pool
6 Island
5 Forest
It's not very metagamed at the moment, of course, but the idea here is that you assemble your mana while using your countermagic to control the short game. Then, on turn 3 or as soon as the coast is clear, you try to put a Merrow out there and threaten to go infinite next turn. A few card choices to explain:
Mizzium Skin - Very good at protecting all of your vulnerable combo critters.
Commune with the Gods - Digs for either part of your combo.
Anticipate - Very good card selection previously banned in Modern.
Maniac is your kill condition, but since you only want to go to him when your'e about to win anyway, he's a 1-of. If you mill him or just get to infinite life, then you want to outlast your opponent using Elixir. No mean feat with all the milling you're doing to yourself, maybe!
Other possible considerations: The Sphinx and Elemental you can cast from exile to recur? Works nice with cards that also eat your graveyard!
Let's make this deck work, people!
ktkenshinx
03-30-2015, 06:26 PM
One problem here is that Paradise Mantle and Merrow has been a combo for years and it just never took off. This is either because no one noticed it (unlikely) or because it's just not that great in the format (much more likely).
The issue is not so much that Merrow dies to basically every removal spell in the format, or that Mantle/Favor are fragile in themselves. It's that the combo doesn't win the game on its own, and that it take a full turn to use some combo with the card. Judge of Currents gives you a billion life, but that feels much worse than any Finks/Melira engine. Now you are running a 3 card combo where noen of the individual pieces are very strong. Maybe some kind of weird UW Merfolk deck with that and Wake Thrasher? Or Bant Merfolk to add redundancy with Favor and Commune? Overall, the idea seems very messy and a lot worse than other engines available.
MaximumC
03-30-2015, 07:26 PM
One problem here is that Paradise Mantle and Merrow has been a combo for years and it just never took off. This is either because no one noticed it (unlikely) or because it's just not that great in the format (much more likely).
The issue is not so much that Merrow dies to basically every removal spell in the format, or that Mantle/Favor are fragile in themselves. It's that the combo doesn't win the game on its own, and that it take a full turn to use some combo with the card.
I completely agree, but see, that's where Karametra's Favor is a potential game-changer. Instead of having to wait to get your topdeck, with Favor, you can draw whatever card out of your deck that you want. If you have any card in your deck that translates into a win with Merrow+Favor in play, you can do it immediately. Judge of Currents is a lot more attractive if you can wait on Favor in your hand until the coast is clear and then gain 1,000,000 life for 4 mana without passing the turn.
The difficulty is that the combo pieces for Merrow are not ideal, since you don't win on the spot, and that there's not really a shell that supports this kind of strategy. Yet. I think there can be, hence the reason I made this thread. :)
ktkenshinx
03-30-2015, 11:46 PM
I completely agree, but see, that's where Karametra's Favor is a potential game-changer. Instead of having to wait to get your topdeck, with Favor, you can draw whatever card out of your deck that you want. If you have any card in your deck that translates into a win with Merrow+Favor in play, you can do it immediately. Judge of Currents is a lot more attractive if you can wait on Favor in your hand until the coast is clear and then gain 1,000,000 life for 4 mana without passing the turn.
The difficulty is that the combo pieces for Merrow are not ideal, since you don't win on the spot, and that there's not really a shell that supports this kind of strategy. Yet. I think there can be, hence the reason I made this thread. :)
You still have to wait a turn, just on a different set of conditions.
In the Favor scenario, you play a Merrow on turn 3 with one mana open, then wait a turn for it to lose summoning sickness. Then next turn you Favor it and then do as many activation as you want with the draw trigger on the stack. Then you dig to your combo piece, draw it, cast it, and gain lots of life. Minimum mana for this is 4, assuming Judge and Favor.
In the Mantle scenario, you play Merrow on turn 3 with one mana open and equip Mantle to it. Then next turn, you activate it a bunch of times during the upkeep, dig to your card, draw it during the draw step, and then cast it for 2.
In both scenarios, you aren't doing anything with Merrow the turn it hits play. In the Favor scenario, you have at least 1 mana open to defend the card until your next turn, but then 0 mana to defend the card once you are tapped out for combo pieces. In the Mantle scenario, you have 0 mana open to defend the card until your next turn, but then 2 mana to defend the combo once you are playing pieces. So you have to wait in both situations, which is the fundamental problem with the combos.
The combo was much better in the theoretical Overextended format, when you could run it alongside Patron Wizard and stuff like Opposition, which gave you utility from Merrow even without the combo pieces (Trinket Mage could find the Mantle too, and TM was himself a Wizard). So maybe you could get this to work as a combo that is incidental to the rest of your deck, but I don't think you want to build around it in a deliberate way.
cherub_daemon
03-31-2015, 01:10 AM
The major barrier this has to being good is that what this combo does, ultimately, is find stuff that will let you win. In order to find that "winning stuff", you have to find your original combo first. Why not just assemble winning stuff in the first place without building up this weird Merfolk+Aura infrastructure first? There might be several reasons, some of which have already been implicitly or explicitly touched on:
1.) The combo pieces are good on their own or have synergy with an extant shell. No luck here.
2.) The combo pieces are easier to find, either because you can run more, or there are better tutors for them. You could run Paradise Mantle copies 5-8 of Favor. You don't get the card, but it's cheaper AND survives if someone kills Merrow AND doesn't require green before you combo AND it can come down T1 before a relevant counterspell is available. I'd test them.
3.) The combo interacts with or protects the winning stuff in some way. Using Laboratory Maniac as your kill fulfills this.
So while this is kind of messy, especially compared to the most comparable deck in the format (Twin), it is at least not just worse than other ways of finding Maniac. I have a few suggestions, if you decide to pursue this:
1.) Run Counterbalance. This + your combo is self-protecting, as long as you have instant draw to let you draw any cards you cannot exile (probably just Maniac). I would be inclined to run a singleton and "tutor" for it immediately, but I could see arguments for running more.
2.) Run more instant draw. Besides the above interaction with Counterbalance, it also protects your win by letting you draw in response to a spell removing Maniac. Besides the usual suspects, Cerulean Wisps is "free" with your combo out and Scout's Warning lets you win at instant speed or drop Merrow at the opponent's EoT. Repeal is protective. In contrast, Anticipate is not a draw spell.
3.) Run no more than 1 Judge of the Current; it's worthless before the combo is out, and then you can "tutor" for it.
4.) Misc.: Boros Charm protects you from (some) board wipes and spells targeting Favor/Mantle. Spellskite seems like good times, and Twin tends to run it, which leads me to believe this deck might like it as well. Speaking of Twin, some builds run Swan Song because the drawbacks are essentially irrelevant to them.
Valtrix
03-31-2015, 05:05 AM
The combo is just bad, but basically every metric.
1) How many deck slots does the combo take? Merrow + Mana card + thing to get is at probably 10-12 slots, that's a lot.
2) Are any of the pieces good on their own? Not at all. They're all pretty bad.
3) How disruptable is the combo? Super easy--enchantment or creature hate all kill it. Merrow even dies to disfigure.
4) Does it actually win you the game on the spot? Nope. You need an untap step too.
With all of these things one wonders why bother playing with the combo at all...About the only good thing about it is that it can potentially be active on turn 3, but that's really meaningless since twin will just actually win on turn 4.
MaximumC
03-31-2015, 12:08 PM
4 mana over two cards is not a lot to pay and protect -- IF it consistently wins the game when it resolves.
The combo is just bad, but basically every metric.
1) How many deck slots does the combo take? Merrow + Mana card + thing to get is at probably 10-12 slots, that's a lot.
2) Are any of the pieces good on their own? Not at all. They're all pretty bad.
3) How disruptable is the combo? Super easy--enchantment or creature hate all kill it. Merrow even dies to disfigure.
4) Does it actually win you the game on the spot? Nope. You need an untap step too.
With all of these things one wonders why bother playing with the combo at all...About the only good thing about it is that it can potentially be active on turn 3, but that's really meaningless since twin will just actually win on turn 4.
I half agree with you. Yeah, it takes up 9+ slots. The combo pieces are not primo Modern cards on their own, but a scrybear and a mana source are at least not useless on their own. (Compare to Duskmantle Guildmage + Mindcrank for a cheap combo that does win but involves a piece that is truly useless on its own.) The combo is disruptable, sure, but so is Twin and Meleria.
It's the last point that is, I think, critical. Can you make a deck that reliably turns 4 mana into a win if you can protect it?
The major barrier this has to being good is that what this combo does, ultimately, is find stuff that will let you win.
Maybe? I mean, if the combo allows you to draw whatever you need and use it immediately, then I don't think it's fair to think of it as a 3-card combo. The idea behind Judge is that he is the only way printed (so far) to really capitalize on Merrow's infinite untap effects immediately. Gaining infinite life for 4 mana over two cards isn't terrible. If we had a reverse Judge that pinged when something untapped, the combo would be complete... but I can't find a piece like that.
How about Skill Borrower? Can that make the kill more reliable? You can also do it this way; Merrow into a Skill Borrower, then mill into Grislebrand. This plan is great when both cards are near the top, but horrible when you have to dig deeply to find either of them. You draw cards you don't have.
In the alternative, what about Pull from Eternity? Is there a combo kill here? You can go infinity with Merrow+Favor, exile until you hit Pull, get Pull into your hand. You can now exile any number of cards from your library and put any of them into your graveyard for W. It's just Entomb, but you also can mill your deck, so... is there some way to use that?
So you could also just go into Kiki-Jiki from Skill Borrower. That's an instant win. It requires you to run many copies of each, though, to make sure that they don't end up in the wrong order for Merrow.
1.) Run Counterbalance. This + your combo is self-protecting, as long as you have instant draw to let you draw any cards you cannot exile (probably just Maniac). I would be inclined to run a singleton and "tutor" for it immediately, but I could see arguments for running more.
2.) Run more instant draw. Besides the above interaction with Counterbalance, it also protects your win by letting you draw in response to a spell removing Maniac. Besides the usual suspects, Cerulean Wisps is "free" with your combo out and Scout's Warning lets you win at instant speed or drop Merrow at the opponent's EoT. Repeal is protective. In contrast, Anticipate is not a draw spell.
3.) Run no more than 1 Judge of the Current; it's worthless before the combo is out, and then you can "tutor" for it.
4.) Misc.: Boros Charm protects you from (some) board wipes and spells targeting Favor/Mantle. Spellskite seems like good times, and Twin tends to run it, which leads me to believe this deck might like it as well. Speaking of Twin, some builds run Swan Song because the drawbacks are essentially irrelevant to them.
These are good suggestions.
So, thinking about all of that, what if you did something like this:
Karametra's Merrow 2.0
Merrow Combo (7):
Drop the number of cards in the combo and rely more on your tutors to find them when the time is right. Switch up some of your Favors for Utopia Vow, which slows you down but also splashes as removal.
3 Puresight Merrow
2 Karametra's Favor
2 Utopia Vow
Win Condition (5):
Uses less slots than Judge of Currents, and costs more mana, but you win on the spot. Note that Skill Borrower can stand in for Merrow if you have Borrower + Mana ability and a Merrow on top. You can activate the Borrower repeatedly many times before letting them resolve all at once.
3 Skill Borrower
2 Kiki-Jiki, Mirror Breaker
Countermagic (17):
Counterbalance has a lot of synergy with Puresight anyway, and it seems like a great way to protect the combo if you know the coast is clear but you only have 2 mana open. The full playset is necessary if you want this effect to minimize the risk of milling a combo piece when you go to find it.
Spellskite seems good because this deck really wants to have lots of ways to protect itself and also provides another target for your mana auras if need be.
Muddle can stop most removal on your combo while also tutoring for missing pieces.
4 Counterbalance
2 Spellskite
3 Repeal
4 Mana Leak
2 Mizzium Skin
2 Muddle the Mixture
Card Draw(8):
4 Commune with the Gods
4 Gixatian Probe
Mana (23):
4 Cavern of Souls
4 Misty Rainforest
2 Scalding Tarn
4 Breeding Pool
2 Steam Vents
5 Island
2 Forest
So that could work.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.