View Full Version : Sidisi on the Roof
This is an incomplete concept that uses the following cards:
4 Gravedigger
4 Ghoulraiser
4 Sibsig Muckdraggers
4 Sidisi, undead Vizier
2 Gray Merchant of Asphodel
4 Rooftop Storm
22 cards - to form the following combo
Rooftop
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Ghoulraiser > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 2)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Ghoulraiser > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 4)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Ghoulraiser > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 6)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Ghoulraiser > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 8)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Gravedigger > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 9)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Gravedigger > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 10)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Gravedigger > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 11)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Gravedigger > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 12)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Sibsig Muckdraggers > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 13)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Sibsig Muckdraggers > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 14)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Sibsig Muckdraggers > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 15)
Sidisi > Self Exploit > Sibsig Muckdraggers > Get Sidisi back (Devotion 16)
Sidisi > Exploit Gravedigger > Get Gray Merchant of Asphodel (Burn for 19)
If that doesn't kill on the spot, you do have 30 power on the board.
The questions now are:
What are the best and quickest ways to get Rooftop storm into play and Sidisi into your hand?
MaximumC
03-31-2015, 04:35 PM
I followed you here from the combo thread!
I posit that the kill you propose with Sidisi is not optimal for brewing because it requires you to play 12 copies of terrible creatures in your deck. When you're not comboing off, you are sitting there with a hand full of poop.
I prefered your first take on this:
Storm in play.
Cast Sidisi, exploit herself to get a Gravedigger-type.
Cast Gravedigger-type to get back Sidisi.
Cast Sidisi, exploit herself to get Sedraxis Alchemist (Lava Zombie in older formats)
Cast Alchemist and bounce itself an arbitrarily large number of times.
Win right away if you have a Zombardment-type card in play that cares about ETB effects. (Altar of the Brood, the Red God, that Red enchantment from Dragons)
If not, target the Gravecrawler with the last bounce.
Cast gravecrawler to return Sidisi to your hand.
Cast Sidisi to go get a win condition, probably Grapeshot.
This requires only 3 slots in your deck other than Storm and the Vizer, making it far less cumbersome than Gravedigger.dec.
That said, perhaps Gravedigger.dec is interesting too, since every creature you cast gives you extra value. If only they were not so darn inefficient to start with. Grave Scrabbler, perhaps?
rufus
03-31-2015, 05:20 PM
I followed you here from the combo thread!
I posit that the kill you propose with Sidisi is not optimal for brewing because it requires you to play 12 copies of terrible creatures in your deck. When you're not comboing off, you are sitting there with a hand full of poop.
Are those creatures really terrible? It's easy to underestimate the power of delve.
Ghoulraiser might work better than scrabbler as a lower-cost alternative.
MaximumC
03-31-2015, 06:01 PM
Are those creatures really terrible? It's easy to underestimate the power of delve.
Ghoulraiser might work better than scrabbler as a lower-cost alternative.
Eh? Muckdraggers is the only one of the Gravedigger types he listed that has Delve. He did list Ghoulraiser which, while efficient, is random and so doesn't work if you have other targets in the yard when you try to go off with Sidisi.
YamiJoey
03-31-2015, 06:17 PM
Step 1: Figure out how to get Rooftop Storm into play.
Step 2: Figure out why you're not playing Omniscience.
MaximumC
03-31-2015, 07:17 PM
Step 1: Figure out how to get Rooftop Storm into play.
Step 2: Figure out why you're not playing Omniscience.
Well... it's a difference between 5U and 7UUU, so assuming you're finding a way to ramp into the spell, it's vastly easier to get to Storm than to Omni. I mean, Island+Tron gets you to 5U by itself.
rufus
03-31-2015, 10:49 PM
...
The questions now are:
What are the best and quickest ways to get Rooftop storm into play and Sidisi into your hand?
Since the engine runs recursion anyway, throwing Sidisi into the graveyard might not be terrible, so filter cards like Commune with the Gods and Forbidden Alchemy could work well.
I'm not sure what the acceleration options are in modern.
Phoenix Ignition
04-01-2015, 12:50 AM
Really cool deck idea. How about Mikaeus, the Unhallowed as a 1-of in the deck. I'm not sure it lets you win from 0 dudes on the battlefield, but it doubles your Sidisis, or allows you to sac other gravekeeper effects for extort while getting additional zombies from your graveyard.
I'm not sure it'll fit, but here's a cool card that might be decent: Corpse Connoisseur
Also, for 1 mana, Havengul Lich lets you recast the gravekeepers for free, which is cool.
The_Dingo
04-01-2015, 09:33 AM
Can you play something like diregraf captain to abuse the sidisi exploit triggers?
Tylert
04-01-2015, 10:08 AM
Can you play something like diregraf captain to abuse the sidisi exploit triggers?
If you have rooftop storm in play and sidisi in hand, it seems a little bit overkill to add diregraf captain.
I would add corpse connoisseur to the cards so you can tutor sidisi in your graveyard when you have a gravedigger / ghoulraiser / etc... in hand.
We need to ramp = Green? and protect rooftop storm = discard?
YamiJoey
04-01-2015, 12:44 PM
Well... it's a difference between 5U and 7UUU, so assuming you're finding a way to ramp into the spell, it's vastly easier to get to Storm than to Omni. I mean, Island+Tron gets you to 5U by itself.
So your plan is to play UB Tron, and your win condition is not going to be Gifts Ungiven?
You really need to work out how to make your six mana Enchantment. If you're making Lands and turning them sideways, you need one more to kill with Scapeshift, and it takes up 4 slots, not 10. The Tron angle will not work with a 3BB Spell as your main engine. Simply playing some kind of control strategy with 10 dead cards is suicide, and Twin is also just a better way of doing it.
Figure out how to get Rooftop Storm into play first. Your combo seems like It might even work, as you can just play some random Zombie with a sacrifice clause or something to win the game with. (Doregraf Catain genuinely looks like the best option.)
sjmcc13
04-01-2015, 01:29 PM
Really cool deck idea. How about Mikaeus, the Unhallowed as a 1-of in the deck. I'm not sure it lets you win from 0 dudes on the battlefield, but it doubles your Sidisis, or allows you to sac other gravekeeper effects for extort while getting additional zombies from your graveyard.
If you have a second Sidisi or a Gravedigger type zombie in hand, then you can go infinite with a singleton Mikaeus in the deck.
If you run 8 Gravedigger effects, and a couple singletons you could set the deck to drop a bunch of zombies and Gray merchant to drain for 15 from just storm and Sidisi, with a all of beaters to finish it next turn, with Mikaeus in the deck you have a change to just win right there.
3 BoP
4 Hierarch
4 Rooftop Storm
4 Gravedigger
4 Ghoulraiser
4 Sidisi, undead Vizier
4 Gravecrawler
2 Gray Merchant of Asphodel
1 Mikaeus, the Unhallowed
4 Serum Visions
4 Commune with the Gods
4 Misty Rainforest
4 Verdant Catacombs
2 Forest
2 island
2 swamp
3 Watery Grave
3 Breeding Pool
2 Overgrown Tomb
MaximumC
04-01-2015, 03:06 PM
So your plan is to play UB Tron, and your win condition is not going to be Gifts Ungiven?
You really need to work out how to make your six mana Enchantment. If you're making Lands and turning them sideways, you need one more to kill with Scapeshift, and it takes up 4 slots, not 10. The Tron angle will not work with a 3BB Spell as your main engine. Simply playing some kind of control strategy with 10 dead cards is suicide, and Twin is also just a better way of doing it.
Figure out how to get Rooftop Storm into play first. Your combo seems like It might even work, as you can just play some random Zombie with a sacrifice clause or something to win the game with. (Doregraf Catain genuinely looks like the best option.)
I'm not necessarily suggesting Tron, I'm just saying that Rooftop Storm is not in the same category as Omniscience.
Other ramp options include:
1. Green rampy dorks?
2. Nyxthos?
3. Lost Auramancers?
I dunno!
rufus
04-02-2015, 01:37 AM
..
Other ramp options include:
1. Green rampy dorks?
2. Nyxthos?
3. Lost Auramancers?
I dunno!
Maybe Pentad Prism or Lotus Cobra...
Valtrix
04-02-2015, 02:36 AM
Coalition Relic sounds like a good ramp candidate.
Tylert
04-02-2015, 05:35 AM
What about amulet bloom style for ramp??
MaximumC
04-02-2015, 02:27 PM
What about amulet bloom style for ramp??
Amulet Bloom has better ways to win, though; Titan is so sickly synergistic with that deck. Does it have room for a 10 card combo kill package that isn't related to Titan?
I like the concept of Lotus Bloom + Pentad Prism. Prism is criminally underused, imho, since it can ramp you 2 mana in a single turn.
Maybe you do it like this:
Sidisi On The Roof
Combo (8)
---------
2 Rooftop Storm
4 Sidisi, Undead Vizer
1 Sedraxis Alchemist
1 Grave Scrabbler (In a pinch, you can cheat him out for 1BB with your own discard spells)
Ramp (8)
---------
4 Lotus Bloom
4 Pentad Prism
Protection (11)
---------
4 Thoughtseize
3 Inquisition of Kozeliek (I miss cabal therapy)
4 Abrupt Decay
Tutor: (3)
---------
3 Ethereal Usher (Can get either Storm or Mikeaus!)
Aggro Plan B: (To put on pressure while you durdle for combo) (10)
----------
4 Gravecrawler
1 Lotleth Troll
1 Grim Grin, Corpse Born
3 Diegraf Captain
1 Mikeaus, the Unhallowed
Lands (20)
----------
6 Fetches
5 Shocks
3 Cavern of Souls
2 Mutavault
2 Swamps
2 Island
The gameplan here is to deploy an early dork or disruption to see what's going on with the opponent. Then, on turn 1 or 2, you deploy mana acceleration and apply pressure with creatures. You're aiming for 6 mana on turn 4 with the intention of using Decay or discard to remove your roadblocks to victory.
There are a lot of combos happening here. Rooftop Storm wins in a variety of ways depending on what you've got on the board. Grimgrin and Crawlers can just go bonkers all by themselves.
I think Green adds a HUGE amount to the deck because of Abrupt Decay. I could see increasing the number of Lol Trolls and Captains, too, going into an aggro mode. Perhaps a transformational sideboard against control decks?
rufus
04-02-2015, 03:11 PM
Now I'm wondering: Does Rooftop Storm 0 out Grave Scrabbler's madness cost?
MaximumC
04-02-2015, 04:04 PM
Now I'm wondering: Does Rooftop Storm 0 out Grave Scrabbler's madness cost?
Interesting... well, let's see what the Comp Rules say.
702.34. Madness
702.34a Madness is a keyword that represents two abilities. The first is a static ability that functions
while the card with madness is in a player’s hand. The second is a triggered ability that
functions when the first ability is applied. “Madness [cost]” means “If a player would discard
this card, that player discards it, but may exile it instead of putting it into his or her graveyard”
and “When this card is exiled this way, its owner may cast it by paying [cost] rather than paying
its mana cost. If that player doesn’t, he or she puts this card into his or her graveyard.”
702.34b Casting a spell using its madness ability follows the rules for paying alternative costs in
rules 601.2b and 601.2e–g.
It looks like the answer is... yes? Madness does involve CASTING the card for an alternative mana cost. Rooftop Storm sees that you're trying to CAST it, so it steps and says, yeah, you can pay 0 instead of the "mana cost." I guess maybe there's a hiccup because storm doesnt say "instead of all other costs," just "instead of its mana cost," but I would think that Madness's cost is still a mana cost...
rufus
04-02-2015, 04:24 PM
Interesting... well, let's see what the Comp Rules say.
...
The rules seem to split 'mana cost' and 'alternative cost'. <shrug>
601.2e The player determines the total cost of the spell. Usually this is just the mana cost. Some
spells have additional or alternative costs. Some effects may increase or reduce the cost to pay,
or may provide other alternative costs. ...
Tylert
04-22-2015, 09:27 AM
Amulet Bloom has better ways to win, though; Titan is so sickly synergistic with that deck. Does it have room for a 10 card combo kill package that isn't related to Titan?
I like the concept of Lotus Bloom + Pentad Prism. Prism is criminally underused, imho, since it can ramp you 2 mana in a single turn.
Maybe you do it like this:
Sidisi On The Roof
Combo (8)
---------
2 Rooftop Storm
4 Sidisi, Undead Vizer
1 Sedraxis Alchemist
1 Grave Scrabbler (In a pinch, you can cheat him out for 1BB with your own discard spells)
Ramp (8)
---------
4 Lotus Bloom
4 Pentad Prism
Protection (11)
---------
4 Thoughtseize
3 Inquisition of Kozeliek (I miss cabal therapy)
4 Abrupt Decay
Tutor: (3)
---------
3 Ethereal Usher (Can get either Storm or Mikeaus!)
Aggro Plan B: (To put on pressure while you durdle for combo) (10)
----------
4 Gravecrawler
1 Lotleth Troll
1 Grim Grin, Corpse Born
3 Diegraf Captain
1 Mikeaus, the Unhallowed
Lands (20)
----------
6 Fetches
5 Shocks
3 Cavern of Souls
2 Mutavault
2 Swamps
2 Island
The gameplan here is to deploy an early dork or disruption to see what's going on with the opponent. Then, on turn 1 or 2, you deploy mana acceleration and apply pressure with creatures. You're aiming for 6 mana on turn 4 with the intention of using Decay or discard to remove your roadblocks to victory.
There are a lot of combos happening here. Rooftop Storm wins in a variety of ways depending on what you've got on the board. Grimgrin and Crawlers can just go bonkers all by themselves.
I think Green adds a HUGE amount to the deck because of Abrupt Decay. I could see increasing the number of Lol Trolls and Captains, too, going into an aggro mode. Perhaps a transformational sideboard against control decks?
Can you explain how do you use the grave scrambler?
I mean, I see that you get to raise something from the graveyard for 1BB when you also have a discard spell in hand, but I fail to see how it does advance our gameplan.
If it is a card to get sidisi back from the grave when you have already searched for rooftop storm or one of the win conditions (Diregraf captain or grimgrin), I'd rather use gravecrawler which does'nt require a discard spell.
Otherwise, I like how you built the deck.
Did you try it in FNM or tournament?
Uroborian
04-22-2015, 01:15 PM
btw i was thinking of a legacy variant with 4 show and tells 4 eureka; allowing us to put in Rooftop/Omniscience. Legacy gives us lotus petals and sol lands and brainstorms, ponders, Fow....Just having that shell makes it viable but idk if its better than any other. Bonus is that your combo is all without passing priority(aka all the effects are on the stack regardless,) so the only way the opponent has to interact will be with counters or a stifle, STP or abrupt decay only lower your devotion of Gray's kill at the end. I might extend this thread to legacy brew after i get more time to iron out some numbers.
MaximumC
04-22-2015, 01:21 PM
Can you explain how do you use the grave scrambler?
I mean, I see that you get to raise something from the graveyard for 1BB when you also have a discard spell in hand, but I fail to see how it does advance our gameplan.
If it is a card to get sidisi back from the grave when you have already searched for rooftop storm or one of the win conditions (Diregraf captain or grimgrin), I'd rather use gravecrawler which does'nt require a discard spell.
Otherwise, I like how you built the deck.
Did you try it in FNM or tournament?
A gravedigger effect allows you to bring in a storm kill out of the board or in the main because it gives you an extra use of Sidisi. If you just go Sidisi->Alchemist, you have infinite ETB triggers but you can't do anything with them unless you already had a triggered ability in play ready to go.
With a Gravedigger, you do this:
1. Cast Sidisi, exploit self, get Digger
2. Cast Digger, return Sidisi to hand.
3. Cast Sidisi, exploit self, get Alchemist.
4. Cast Alchemist, bounce self an arbitrary number of times. (You win right now if you have a Diegraf Capt in play.)
5. Cast Sidisi to get a storm win condition, like Grapeshot.
5. On final cast of Alchemist, return Digger to hand.
6. Cast Digger to get back Sidisi again.
7. Cast Sidisi exploiting whatever to get your storm kill (Grapeshot?)
Without access to a Digger effect in the list, you can only self-exploit once with Sidisi and so you cannot get the second card you need.
Even without the storm kill, having the Digger lets you go from:
Sidisi in hand, + Storm in Play
to
Storm, Sidisi, Alchemist, Grimgrin in play, Digger in yard (This kills if you draw a Sidis or Gravecrawler by going infinite with Grim)
Phoenix Ignition
04-22-2015, 10:06 PM
4. Cast Alchemist, bounce self an arbitrary number of times. (You win right now if you have a Diegraf Capt in play.)
How? Isn't Diregraf Captain only going to work if you kill off a creature, which Sedraxis Alchemist doesn't do? You can get infinite storm and then a storm card though, that seems like a pretty good way to go if you aren't winning through devotion.
What does Sidisi offer that running Conspiracy and then dropping a few Eldrazi doesn't? I think the deck is really cool but am wondering when one would actually play it?
kombatkiwi
05-22-2015, 01:48 AM
What does Sidisi offer that running Conspiracy and then dropping a few Eldrazi doesn't? I think the deck is really cool but am wondering when one would actually play it?
- Rooftop Storm doesn't make conspiracy 0 to cast.
- Rooftop + Sidisi is a 2 card combo, as opposed to Rooftop + Conspiracy + Emrakul
- The zombies on their own can be semi-functional as some kind of midrange tribal deck when you don't have the combo
Kanti
05-23-2015, 03:30 AM
So wait, if the new shell is 4 Rooftop Storm, 4 Sidi, Undead Vizier, 1-4 Gravedigger, 1 Sedraxis Alchemist, 1 Grapeshot... then well, it doesn't seem that bad. One bad thing about running a singleton Gravedigger would be you can't Sidisi>Rooftop Storm>Rooftop Storm>Gravedigger>win. Still though...
edit: idea, instead of Grapeshot just run Grave Titan. Bounce all your opponents creatures, resolve Titan along with a Gravedigger, Sidisi, and an Alchemist. That has to be a win? Also allows for dumb things like going Sidisi>Titan.
kombatkiwi
05-27-2015, 03:03 AM
So wait, if the new shell is 4 Rooftop Storm, 4 Sidi, Undead Vizier, 1-4 Gravedigger, 1 Sedraxis Alchemist, 1 Grapeshot... then well, it doesn't seem that bad. One bad thing about running a singleton Gravedigger would be you can't Sidisi>Rooftop Storm>Rooftop Storm>Gravedigger>win. Still though...
edit: idea, instead of Grapeshot just run Grave Titan. Bounce all your opponents creatures, resolve Titan along with a Gravedigger, Sidisi, and an Alchemist. That has to be a win? Also allows for dumb things like going Sidisi>Titan.
How are you bouncing all of your opponents creatures? Also remember that grave titan is not a zombie
Kanti
05-28-2015, 10:33 AM
Yep, I was stoned, can't bounce your opp creatures. Pretty terrible. Still, the Grapeshot idea does cut down on space. Still a 2 card combo as you have Sidisi.
Powered by vBulletin® Version 4.2.2 Copyright © 2026 vBulletin Solutions, Inc. All rights reserved.