Winston
01-12-2016, 10:25 PM
A blue-white control deck based around the premise that Think Twice is garbage drawing two cards for two mana at instant speed is so good we'd gladly build a little differently to accommodate it. I am, or course, referring to the most underrated common in modern, Perilous Research[cards]. By playing permanents that replace themselves, the drawback of Perilous Research can even be used to our advantage, turning it into a unique card advantage engine that thrives in the midrange and the long game alike.
[cards]-Land-
4 Flagstones of Trokair
4 Hallowed Fountain
4 Flooded Strand
2 Celestial Colonnade
5 Island
2 Plains
2 Ghost Quarter
-Draw-
4 Perilous Research
2 Hatching Plans
4 Serum Visions
-Permission-
2 Familiar's Ruse
2 Logic Knot
2 Cryptic Command
-Removal-
4 Path to Exile
4 Supreme Verdict
-Creatures-
4 Kitchen Finks
3 Geist of Saint Traft
2 Restoration Angel
4 Snapcaster Mage
-Sideboard-
1 Revoke Existence
2 Stony Silence
2 Ghostly Prison
2 Negate
2 Dispel
2 Wipe Away
2 Detention Sphere
2 Celestial Purge
The Perilous Engine:
So, let's review: The cards we like to pitch to Research are Flagstones of Trokair, Kitchen Finks, Geist of Saint Traft's Angel tokens, sometimes Snapcaster Mage, and, last but not least, Hatching Plans. (Of course, anything with removal aimed at it or anything that won't live through combat also makes for a good choice.) Between the playset of Perilous and the full complement of Snapcaster Mages, we'll almost always have access to our draw/sac engine.
Flagstones doesn't come in tapped, so it's no problem to drop one on turn two and use our opponent's end step to start digging while fetching Hallowed Fountains to fix our mana. Even without Researches to bin them to, Flagstones are still untapped white sources in a deck with Finks, Path to Exiles, and Supreme Verdicts.
Finks should be fairly self-explanatory. It gains life, it blocks, and it throws three power in front of things, all while coming back and gaining more life. It's a complete nuisance. Honestly, though, I don't find myself pitching him to Perilous very often at all. If the opposing deck plays Paths, however, Perilous saccing Finks is a great play.
Swinging for six and then drawing two makes you feel like a value god, and that's exactly what Geist of Saint Traft does for you. With the Angel token's exile trigger on the stack, simply sac it to Perilous Research.
(Speaking of our creatures: by now you might have realized that Lightning Bolt is terrible against this deck. One of the big advantages it has, honestly.)
While sacrificing Hatching Plans nets you five(!) cards and can make a mulliganed opener much more threatening, you don't want to see it very often - the trade-off for refilling your hand at a moment's notice is doing literally nothing without a Perilous or a Snapcaster Mage in your hand. Ichor Wellspring is a potential replacement for this slot since it does draw a card immediately, but this deck can crack the egg so consistently that the third/fifth card is almost always worth it. Against decks that trade resources on a 1-for-1 ratio like Grixis, Jund, and Abzan, a draw five into Supreme Verdict is almost always game.
Issues I want to address
The Twin matchup is a good place to start. While it's not bad and it stays decent post-board with Wipe Away, Negate, Dispel, Ghostly Prison, and Revoke Existence (lololol Keranos), I would like to really give myself an edge here. This would probably entail replacing Logic Knot, seeing as it's terrible against Remand and those are flex slots anyway. I'm tempted to just go for two Remands of my own, and not for my own permission, but to Remand my own spells in blue mirrors.
There's also the new and already quite popular Bx Eldrazi decks that like to exile graveyards. Without having played the matchup yet there's only so much I can speculate on, but we don't appreciate having our graveyard tampered with. I might even consider going up to two Revoke Existence in the side because Rest in Peace is such a problem - Flagstones and Hatching Plans both need to hit the grave to activate. Anyway, the Eldrazi and other problematic lands are why the Ghost Quarters are in over extra basics. Hitting Eldrazi Temples before turn 4 seems important.
On Think Twice and Sun Titan
These would require greater land counts, to be sure. Think Twice is a draw-go card through and through, and we're more of a tap-out style control that can hold up counter magic when it needs to. We like Serum Visions because we can grab it off the top and cast it immediately while still making plays after, and the Perilous engine is just much more efficient for this style of deck, IMO.
[cards]Sun Titan[/cards is its own thing. I understand that there was a very successful Sun Titan control list recently, and I'm not opposed to including one or two Titans in the main and moving the Detention Spheres in. Having a card that wins me the game if it resolves would be very useful, but I don't know which matchups it would improve and it would require a lot of shifting around and a higher land count. This just doesn't feel like a 26 land strategy - I'm very happy with my 23.
That's all for now! Hope you enjoy the deck. Please leave some feedback.
[cards]-Land-
4 Flagstones of Trokair
4 Hallowed Fountain
4 Flooded Strand
2 Celestial Colonnade
5 Island
2 Plains
2 Ghost Quarter
-Draw-
4 Perilous Research
2 Hatching Plans
4 Serum Visions
-Permission-
2 Familiar's Ruse
2 Logic Knot
2 Cryptic Command
-Removal-
4 Path to Exile
4 Supreme Verdict
-Creatures-
4 Kitchen Finks
3 Geist of Saint Traft
2 Restoration Angel
4 Snapcaster Mage
-Sideboard-
1 Revoke Existence
2 Stony Silence
2 Ghostly Prison
2 Negate
2 Dispel
2 Wipe Away
2 Detention Sphere
2 Celestial Purge
The Perilous Engine:
So, let's review: The cards we like to pitch to Research are Flagstones of Trokair, Kitchen Finks, Geist of Saint Traft's Angel tokens, sometimes Snapcaster Mage, and, last but not least, Hatching Plans. (Of course, anything with removal aimed at it or anything that won't live through combat also makes for a good choice.) Between the playset of Perilous and the full complement of Snapcaster Mages, we'll almost always have access to our draw/sac engine.
Flagstones doesn't come in tapped, so it's no problem to drop one on turn two and use our opponent's end step to start digging while fetching Hallowed Fountains to fix our mana. Even without Researches to bin them to, Flagstones are still untapped white sources in a deck with Finks, Path to Exiles, and Supreme Verdicts.
Finks should be fairly self-explanatory. It gains life, it blocks, and it throws three power in front of things, all while coming back and gaining more life. It's a complete nuisance. Honestly, though, I don't find myself pitching him to Perilous very often at all. If the opposing deck plays Paths, however, Perilous saccing Finks is a great play.
Swinging for six and then drawing two makes you feel like a value god, and that's exactly what Geist of Saint Traft does for you. With the Angel token's exile trigger on the stack, simply sac it to Perilous Research.
(Speaking of our creatures: by now you might have realized that Lightning Bolt is terrible against this deck. One of the big advantages it has, honestly.)
While sacrificing Hatching Plans nets you five(!) cards and can make a mulliganed opener much more threatening, you don't want to see it very often - the trade-off for refilling your hand at a moment's notice is doing literally nothing without a Perilous or a Snapcaster Mage in your hand. Ichor Wellspring is a potential replacement for this slot since it does draw a card immediately, but this deck can crack the egg so consistently that the third/fifth card is almost always worth it. Against decks that trade resources on a 1-for-1 ratio like Grixis, Jund, and Abzan, a draw five into Supreme Verdict is almost always game.
Issues I want to address
The Twin matchup is a good place to start. While it's not bad and it stays decent post-board with Wipe Away, Negate, Dispel, Ghostly Prison, and Revoke Existence (lololol Keranos), I would like to really give myself an edge here. This would probably entail replacing Logic Knot, seeing as it's terrible against Remand and those are flex slots anyway. I'm tempted to just go for two Remands of my own, and not for my own permission, but to Remand my own spells in blue mirrors.
There's also the new and already quite popular Bx Eldrazi decks that like to exile graveyards. Without having played the matchup yet there's only so much I can speculate on, but we don't appreciate having our graveyard tampered with. I might even consider going up to two Revoke Existence in the side because Rest in Peace is such a problem - Flagstones and Hatching Plans both need to hit the grave to activate. Anyway, the Eldrazi and other problematic lands are why the Ghost Quarters are in over extra basics. Hitting Eldrazi Temples before turn 4 seems important.
On Think Twice and Sun Titan
These would require greater land counts, to be sure. Think Twice is a draw-go card through and through, and we're more of a tap-out style control that can hold up counter magic when it needs to. We like Serum Visions because we can grab it off the top and cast it immediately while still making plays after, and the Perilous engine is just much more efficient for this style of deck, IMO.
[cards]Sun Titan[/cards is its own thing. I understand that there was a very successful Sun Titan control list recently, and I'm not opposed to including one or two Titans in the main and moving the Detention Spheres in. Having a card that wins me the game if it resolves would be very useful, but I don't know which matchups it would improve and it would require a lot of shifting around and a higher land count. This just doesn't feel like a 26 land strategy - I'm very happy with my 23.
That's all for now! Hope you enjoy the deck. Please leave some feedback.