PDA

View Full Version : Naya Vengevine



Mr. Safety
03-05-2019, 01:26 PM
I still think a Zoo variant is possible in modern, but the power level needs to be stronger than it has been in the recent past. A Rg Hollow One/Vengevine deck made waves in 2017 piloted by Julian Grace Martin at an SCG open, going 10-0 initially in the swiss before going 0-4 in his last four rounds. It was impressive at what it did, but seemed just a little bit off optimal. I was perusing some older modern lists and reading an article from Ross Merriam (way back in 2017, link here>>>https://www.starcitygames.com/article/35617_Building-A-Better-Vengevine.html). The biggest takeaway from that article was putting Wild Nacatl into the deck to make the deck more aggressive and have access to white sideboard cards. Sold.

I always thought the 1-drops in the Rg Vengevine were kind of pathetic (Insolent Neonate) or anemic (Swiftspear in a deck that wants a ton of creatures to trigger Vengevine.) I wondered what I could do with actually good creatures like Wild Nacatl and the Burning Tree/Bushwhacker combo, which conveniently triggers Vengevines. I have since come around to Insolent Neonate, which has become a very good enabler and a passable threat. Menace isn't irrelevant and the discard outlet happening at any time, at a cheaper cost than Bloodrage Brawler, makes it leagues better. I called this one 100% wrong. I am still using Kird Ape over Monastery Swiftspear for the same reason as before: too few spells to trigger prowess. I am using Emissary/Bushwhacker to go wide rather than Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage to go all-in on one threat. I could see going back to the all-in blast if wipers get more prevalent in the metagame (Anger of the Gods, Supreme Verdict, Terminus) but until then the swarm attack seems stronger. There are still lines of attack where getting multiple one-drops into Bushwhacker is enough to win games. If I switch over to Become Immense and Temur Battle Rage then Swiftspear goes strait in for Kird Ape.

On Street Wraith: it really puts a lot of pressure on using my life total as a resource to go fast. However, I think this is a necessary evil to enable Hollow Ones, which have been outstanding. Triggering Vengevine returns with 4/4's for 1, or even 0, has been nuts. Goldfishing has resulted in one game doing 25 damage by turn 3. This won't happen very often, but I have attacked on average for 9 damage by turn 2. I have found that sometimes waiting one turn makes it go from only a few damage t2 to overwhelming lethal t3. This is now my window and goal to hit, turn 3 wins. The ancillary benefit of adding Street Wraith is pure velocity paired with Faithless Looting and Neonate. I churn through much more of my deck than I should for a Naya zoo deck. This enables easy Hooting Mandrils, and if the metagame shifts Become Immense or even Grim Lavamancer (which is also a potential sideboard card.)

Overall, the deck has a slightly less powerful incremental agro plan but more reliable combinations of busted turns. One thing I believe strongly is that Ross Merriam nailed the white splash for Wild Nacatl and sideboard cards.

Update: I tried a RUG variant with Birds of Paradise and Bazaar Trademage, which was disappointing. Trademage lands too late to enable early, busted turns. If this deck is to compete it needs to be explosive turns 2-3. Even a t2 Trademage wasn't enough in most cases, losing too many cards on the effect unless I had exactly multiple Vengevines or Hollow Ones. Back to Naya version with Wild Nacatl.

New list 8/5/19:

4x Insolent Neonate
4x Wild Nacatl
1x Kird Ape
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
3x Hooting Mandrills
4x Street Wraith
2x Ghor-Clan Rampager
4x Lightning Bolt
4x Faithless Looting

4x Windswept Heath
3x Arid Mesa
3x Scalding Tarn
1x Wooded Foothills
2x Stomping Ground
2x Sacred Foundry
1x Temple Garden
1x Forest
1x Mountain

Sideboard
2x Destructive Revelry
2x Stony Silence
3x Path to Exile
2x Tormod’s Crypt
2x Lead the Stampede
4x Leyline of Sanctity



Original List piloted on 3/23/19:

4x Experiment One
4x Wild Nacatl
4x Kird Ape
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
4x Vengevine
4x Hellspark Elemental
3x Bloodrage Brawler
2x Hooting Mandrills
4x Lightning Bolt
4x Faithless Looting
1x Lightning Axe

4x Windswept Heath
3x Arid Mesa
3x Scalding Tarn
1x Wooded Foothills
2x Stomping Ground
2x Sacred Foundry
1x Temple Garden
1x Forest
1x Mountain

Sideboard
2x Alpine Moon
2x Destructive Revelry
3x Path to Exile
2x Stony Silence
2x Surgical Extraction
1x Tormod’s Crypt
2x Lightning Helix
1x Domri Rade

Mr. Safety
03-05-2019, 03:39 PM
{Reserved}

Tournament report, Modern 1K at The Complex, 3/23/19
Players: 59, 6 rounds of Swiss and cut to top 8, payout to top 16

Round 1 - Dredge (2-1)

G1 he does the dredge thing, I don't have a very good start, he gets there on the back of Creeping Chill, multiple attackers, and a big Conflagrate.

Sideboard: -1 Lightning Axe, -4 Lightning Bolt, -1 Experiment One, +2 Surgical Extraction, +1 Tormod's Crypt, +3 Path to Exile

G2 + G3 I don't see any hate, just nutty fast hands. This confirms what I thought about it being about 1/2-1 turn faster than Dredge depending on draw/play. Feels good to not auto-lose without hate. Record: 1-0

Round 2 - Amulet Titan (1-2)

G1 I am able to kill Azusa with a bolt and race.

Sideboard: -4 Bolt, -1 Lightning Axe, +3 Path to Exile, +2 Destructive Revelry

G2 Is a close game where I have the Destructive Revelry for the Amulet but he still gets down Prime Time before I can kill him. Slow hand, mull to 6 with 2 dudes and 4 lands. I almost mulled to 5 but I felt that I needed to just hope for more dudes to pressure.

G3 I have the Path for the 1st Primeval Titan, but not the second. I make a big blunder and Path the Titan before combat. I likely would have still lost but I would have had another turn to find bolts/blockers to at least kill the Titan in combat. Lesson learned. Record: 1-1

R3 - Humans (2-0)

G1 I play the Bushwhacker game and overwhelm blockers, getting to 4 mana to play Hellspark Elemental into Bushwhacker for one damage over lethal.

Sideboard: -2 Experiment One,+2 Lightning Helix

G2 I get a super early blast of t1 Looting, discarding a Vengevine, t2 BTE > Bushwhacker, attack for 10. The game goes a little while longer with my opponent almost stabilizing with a Mantis Rider, but I overwhelm them after a turn 3 Bolt + Helix to take out 2 dudes. This round was misleading to me about the matchup because I had nutty good draws and my opponent had mediocre draws. Record 2-1

Round 4 - Humans (0-2)

G1 I get a mediocre start after a mull to 6, my opponent mulls to 5. His 5 are better than my 6, he plays Thalia, Heretic Cathar and I have to bolt it on the spot or I can't do anything meaningful for 2 turns. I still don't, he gets there.

Sideboard: -2 Ex-One, +2 Helix

G2 He keeps 7 and I don't have a lot going on, I can't remember but I didn't have a follow up dude after playing BTE turn 2, just a bolt for the Noble Hierarch. He still gets a Vial down and it brings in 1 Reflector Mage, then he plays another on his turn. One takes out a Vengevine, the other a Bloodrage Brawler. I eventually get some creatures down, I think a Wild Nacatl and a Hellspark Elemental. I attack into his team, my only hope that he blocks wrong to buy me a turn. He does not, I die. Record: 2-2

Short rant: he's twitchy as fuck and accidentally looks at 2 cards on his first turn after a mull to 5 in game 1. He calls a judge immediately, but I can't help but think it can't be a coincidence. I sincerely hope he wasn't low-level cheating. He was older than me (I turn 40 this year) and this is a fucking 1K for Christ's sake. He ends up doing poorly further down the tournament, but I will be keeping my eyes wide open in future matches. I've played him before, was twitchy then but not sketchy, if you know what I mean. He just plays too fast, flips cards around too much, bends and creases his cards, practically in half when playing them onto the battlefield. Losing 0-2 doesn't improve my opinion of him, either, lol. Rant over.


Round 5 - Grixis Control (2-0)

G1 I get a decent start, couple 1 drops into a Hellspark Elemental. I see a Mana Leak, Spell Snare, Fatal Push, Snapcaster Mage, and Kolaghan's Command. I play dude after dude and attack for tons.

Sideboard: -4 Lightning Bolt, +3 Path to Exile, +1 Tormod's Crypt (I misread his deck as Grixis Death's Shadow, so board I according to that read.)

G2 I get a fast start but I respect the possibility of Spell Snare. I get t1 Looting into double Vengevine with BTE + Kird Ape in hand, so I'm feeling very good about this. I throw a Hellspark Elemental at him to bait out a Spell Snare, don't see it, hit for 3. Next turn I go for it and attack for 8, make a 3rd land drop and play another Kird Ape. By now I know he isn't on GDS because I saw Cryptic Command and several Field of Ruin's pointed at my duals. He can't keep up, this is a decent matchup for me. Record 3-2.

At this point I have a shot at top 16, which gets $30, so I'm looking for 4-2 and get my entrance fee back.

Round 6 - GB Rock (0-2)

I don't have a lot to say, he had maindeck Nihil Spellbomb, sideboard Finks, and Inquisition wrecks my explosive hands both games. Kalitas is a motherfucking house against my deck, no way around it. He gets it both games, g2 a t4 Languish before landing Kalitas to just completely push my shit in. Great player, super nice guy I know from the community and we're friends on Facebook. I played his wife t3 (humans player) and even though I lose I'm feeling great about the community and the twitchy fucker is a fading memory. Rock player gives me tons of tips on how to tweak the deck, all of which I have incorporated with great promise so far in testing post-tournament.

Final record: 3-3

I'm pretty happy with my outing, it gave me a ton of insight into the deck and plans for changes. I really like the deck, it will likely be my only project for Modern. I like that I can take it in 2 directions: spell-heavy with Monastery Swiftspear/Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage or creature-heavy with Kird Ape/Burning Tree Emissary/Reckless Bushwhacker. Depending on metagame changes, either could be pretty good.

Mr. Safety
03-11-2019, 12:36 PM
I have the maindeck settled for now, testing out Lightning Axe as removal #5 and maindecking a Domri Rade. It means I have to cut a Brawler, which should be fine. In testing Brawler was a little awkward, especially if I didn't have anything relevant to discard (Vine or Sparky.) It still feeds Hoots-McGoots fine, but that is a secondary interaction.

I was saddened to learn that playing a card with Unearth does not count as casting the creature, so it doesn't trigger Vengevine if I unearth it.

I need 2 slots dedicated to anti-burn, which could be Lightning Helix, Blessed Alliance, or Feed the Clan. Of the three Helix seems to have the broadest utility by swinging races and being removal, Feed the Clan is the narrowest by just gaining life (possibly 10 but more often just 5), and Blessed Alliance is somewhere in the middle. It is unlikely that I get to 4 mana to escalate it for both life and a sac removal, so it will be one or the other. It is likely better against Shadow/Angler but I already have Paths in the board for those threats. Redundancy is good, but I don't want to over-sideboard. I need to maintain a critical mass of threat density.

EDIT: How good is Aven Mindcensor? It seems slow without some sort of mana acceleration like Birds of Paradise or Noble Hierarch. Floor doesn't seem very low, ceiling seems quite high. Flyers are an issue if I somehow don't get through on the ground.

Mr. Safety
03-20-2019, 03:32 PM
List is settled, sideboard notes made, tournament is on Saturday. Testing has been incredibly positive, going about 1 turn faster than Phoenix and Dredge on my best draws and on-par with my slower draws. Deck name established: Hell Awaits (slayer fans? anyone?)

Playing this one for Jeff Zandi and playing to win.

Mirrislegend
03-20-2019, 06:54 PM
This is spicy as hell. I wish you the best of luck!

bigwerdz
03-22-2019, 05:12 PM
I dig the list. I only play modern if I can find a deck with kird ape I like. Kick ass so I can start playing modern again!

Phoenix Ignition
03-22-2019, 06:17 PM
List looks cool. I haven't played magic in a long time so can't really comment on it. Never even seen Bloodrage Brawler before, seems like the possible weak link but without playtesting it I wouldn't put any weight in that comment. Definitely depends on how much the discard helps you.

Good luck!

Mr. Safety
03-23-2019, 07:56 PM
Went 3/3, beating Dredge, Humans, and a Grixis control deck. Lost to Humans, Amulet Titan, and BG Rock.

Scoops: Burning Tree Emissary, Reckless Bushwhacker
Poops: Bloodrage brawler, Experiment One, and Hellspark Elemental

Hellspark was ok, good at applying pressure, same with Brawler. Both were underpowered though, just not efficient enough. Good perception Phoenix Ignition; i needed more outlets for vengevine/hellspark but it wasn't quite right (meaning brawler.)

I am going to go back to the drawing board and work in Insolent Neonate, Street Wraith, and Hollow One. I think wild nacatl, kird ape, bte, and bushwhacker are good enough to warrent making room but ex-one, brawler, and hellspark are not. I'll finish up a tourney report and update the list. Still planning on hybridizing zoo with a vengevine strategy, maybe getting closer to the Rg hollowvine list that was making waves last year.

Mirrislegend
03-25-2019, 03:18 PM
Maybe Pelt Collector would be better than Experiment One? Definitely plays nice with Vexing Devil. Still kinda slow.

Mr. Safety
03-25-2019, 05:06 PM
Thanks for the response! I've seen the Pelt Collector lists, they are cool and new but still underpowered I think. I don't think I want any of the 'grow' creatures, honestly. They are too much of a liability late game. I've basically resigned myself that I will sometimes be just cycling Hollow One in the mid game if I'm empty handed and I don't have enough lands to play it. The payoff for Hollow One is so much better when you put in the work rather than a grow creature. I'm digging through my deck, filling my graveyard, and possibly enabling Vengevines. Pelt Collector is just another Experiment One with trample. I think Pelt Collector and Ex-One would be pretty cool in a Winding Constrictor deck, but not here.

I'm not even playing Vexing Devil, which I think is a trap card. It fools you into thinking it's either a 4/3 creature or a Fireblast for R. More often than not it's a 4 damage burn spell in a deck that absolutely needs to build a board presence. Being too slow isn't even the issue; I could always squeeze in Boros Charm if I wanted something that was 4 damage and sometimes something else. I can appreciate the allure of a cool card, but I don't think I want it.

Thanks again! I love the feedback, and honestly, I could be completely wrong. I was wrong about Neonate, I could be wrong about Pelt Collector, too.

Mr. Safety
03-27-2019, 10:33 AM
I'm debating strongly a light blue splash for Izzet Charm. The looting effect is what I want, but the Spell Pierce and removal are both very appealing as well. At that point, it sort-of becomes better to go to Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage/Monastery Swiftspear.

Mirrislegend
03-27-2019, 06:13 PM
Grishoalbrand used to splash blue for Izzet Charm. People seemed to like the flexibility a lot, but I think it got completely replaced with Cathartic Reunion.

If you splash blue, you can SB Bant Charm!

Mr. Safety
03-28-2019, 07:21 AM
Cathartic Reunion seems like it's a little too volatile, but with it being on-color it might be a necessary evil. I don't like that it's 2 mana, so maybe I shave down to 2 copies.

What I was hoping for was Izzet Charm being a looting effect that doubles as a Spell Pierce, which would be incredible in some matchups. I'm not sure it's worth the mana-base shakeup though.

I'm still testing it with just Neonate/Looting/Wraith as my engine, and it works ok so far. The alternative 'play 1 drops and attack' plan is still very good.

Mirrislegend
03-28-2019, 04:25 PM
Cathartic Reunion seems like it's a little too volatile, but with it being on-color it might be a necessary evil. I don't like that it's 2 mana, so maybe I shave down to 2 copies.

What I was hoping for was Izzet Charm being a looting effect that doubles as a Spell Pierce, which would be incredible in some matchups. I'm not sure it's worth the mana-base shakeup though.

I'm still testing it with just Neonate/Looting/Wraith as my engine, and it works ok so far. The alternative 'play 1 drops and attack' plan is still very good.

I wasn't actually suggesting Cathartic Reunion; just explaining why it is no longer played in Grishoalbrand.

I think Izzet Charm in the MD and Bant Charm in the SB would add a lot of flexibility and mid-game strength to the deck.

Mr. Safety
03-28-2019, 07:14 PM
Cool, i'll test those out. Mana gets wonky, but thats ok, i have the lands to make it work. I worry slightly about Bant charm being in all secondary colors, its mainly a red deck. I keep forgetting about Naya Charm as well, which could be good as a tap down to get dudes through. I think the place to cut for Izzet charm is Kird Ape. Its the weakest creature and Charm should still let me filter into 1-mana creatures, as well as turning Hoots into a 1-mana creature often enough. I'll stsrt with a straight swap and go from there. Opening up blue could be nice for sideboard options, too. If we somehow get Shardless Agent in Modern Horizons I think I can switch over to RUG colors very easily, cutting Wild Nacatl for the cascade value.

Also debating Silence in the board. It adds a mana to the 'combo' turn, but that seems reasonable with the haste dudes.

EDIT: Silence Sideboard:

2x Surgical Extraction
3x Path to Exile
2x Stony Silence
2x Silence
1x Domri Rade
3x Ancient Grudge
2x Alpine Moon


I think Silence could be very powerful, as could Naya Charm. Charm does a lot by tapping down creatures for alpha-strikes, in a pinch killing a creature, or getting a key card back from the graveyard. I think I'll slot one into the maindeck in place of a Kird Ape for now.

Mirrislegend
03-29-2019, 01:44 PM
If we somehow get Shardless Agent in Modern Horizons I think I can switch over to RUG colors very easily, cutting Wild Nacatl for the cascade value.

RUG splash w for Nacatl and SB options doesn't seem too greedy to me. Unless we get Wasteland or something similar in Modern Horizons, greedy manabases will still reign supreme. Current mana bases are greedy but respect Field of Ruin, Assassin's Trophy, Path to Exile, and Settle the Wreckage by playing a non-negligible number of basics. This greatly reduces the power of and frequency of Blood Moon. So just go nuts!

Mr. Safety
03-29-2019, 07:11 PM
I think you are probably right. I can get the Izzet Charm in by cutting Kird Ape x2. I could also sideboard 1x Steam Vents and 2-3x Izzet Charm for grindier matchups. A lot of different directions to test. I want to try Naya Charm as well.

Thanks for keeping the discussion alive! Its so helpful to just bounce around ideas. Besides Bant charm, what other blue spells do you think are worth siding? I could see some counters, but i think i need to stay proactive. Stubborn Denial comes to mind.

Mr. Safety
03-29-2019, 09:31 PM
Izzet charm has been nice, countered a cryptic command ftw in one game. I need to relearn fetching correctly though so Wild Nacatl is still a 3/3. Might cut the remaining 2 kird apes for Grim Lavamancers. Still a creature to trigger vines but adding non-combat reach.

Mr. Safety
03-30-2019, 11:27 AM
Test cards, its a long list lol...theres another 1K on 5/11, gotta get ready.

Izzet Charm
Thought Scour
Become Immense
Bant Charm
Edge of Autumn
Stubborn Denial
Grim Lavamancer
Mana Tithe

Mr. Safety
04-02-2019, 10:43 AM
Testing has been poor for the blue splash. I can't fit in Thought Scour and Izzet Charm, so messing with the mana isn't worth it. Back to strictly Naya colors. Those two slots have become Domri Rade (maindeck) and Naya Charm. I need something to have a chance at re-loading. It was only natural to have one of those flex spots be Domri, thereby freeing up another slot in the board. Naya Charm does a lot of things for the deck, but it's mostly there to tap down blockers and get in FTW. Returning a creature to hand, even for WRG, is still pretty good considering it will help re-trigger Vengevines. Getting a Street Wraith back to enable Hollow Ones isn't bad either. Main selling point: it's never dead. It shakes up board stalls, almost always in my favor. Bolt, Naya Charm, Bolt for 6 damage isn't terrible either, even though it costs 5 mana. That's still ahead of market price for a Fireball effect.

I've been watching a lot of videos from 2017, which pilot the Swiftspear/Goblin Guide/Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage setup. It's very explosive, but I still believe going wider with BTE/Reckless Bushwhacker is better. Once they start eating at the graveyard Become Immense becomes unplayable. I can still see an argument for Temur Battle Rage, but the most it would ever do is 5 damage. For now the plan is to be slightly more resilient with Naya Charm, Domri Rade, and going wide.

I'm down to only 1 Kird Ape, it's just 1-drop #9 for the deck. Once I get a feel for how Naya Charm/Domri affect the deck I might end up dropping the Kird Ape for a Grim Lavamancer. It's one more step towards a deck that has more mid-range potential, but possibly at the cost of slowing down too much. Only testing will tell, I have until May to figure this out.

Phoenix Ignition
04-02-2019, 04:38 PM
Agreed with 4 color being too greedy. Even if no one punishes you, hitting the right colors is extremely difficult for powering Nacatl early and leaving up the right combination for other things you'd want to do.

I just can't see Domri being the correct choice for a deck. 3 mana is the most significant investment you're currently paying and he doesn't add much pressure by increasing your clock or even give you significant card advantage. In terms of planeswalkers, it's one of the least scary to play against. If you need something late game to prevent stalls, I'd always go 1 mana higher for the planeswalkers that are way more powerful, Chandra, torch of defiance or Koth of the hammer or maybe Garruk relentless. You have enough card filtering to just discard them if it's early game and you don't think you can support it that game.

If you can't hit 4 mana reliably, I'd shift the creatures into giving you more reach. Grim Lavamancer is a great 1-cmc for late game even if it competes for graveyard resources, and Ghor-clan rampager can provide the extra burst you need or turn into a 4/4 creature in top deck mode. Tireless Tracker and Knight of the Reliquary are decent cards to increase your late game potential, even if you don't plan to abuse them.

Most of these higher cmc suggestions could replace Domri but as you are an aggro deck you wouldn't want to use many of them.

Mr. Safety
04-02-2019, 07:12 PM
Agreed with 4 color being too greedy. Even if no one punishes you, hitting the right colors is extremely difficult for powering Nacatl early and leaving up the right combination for other things you'd want to do.

I just can't see Domri being the correct choice for a deck. 3 mana is the most significant investment you're currently paying and he doesn't add much pressure by increasing your clock or even give you significant card advantage. In terms of planeswalkers, it's one of the least scary to play against. If you need something late game to prevent stalls, I'd always go 1 mana higher for the planeswalkers that are way more powerful, Chandra, torch of defiance or Koth of the hammer or maybe Garruk relentless. You have enough card filtering to just discard them if it's early game and you don't think you can support it that game.

If you can't hit 4 mana reliably, I'd shift the creatures into giving you more reach. Grim Lavamancer is a great 1-cmc for late game even if it competes for graveyard resources, and Ghor-clan rampager can provide the extra burst you need or turn into a 4/4 creature in top deck mode. Tireless Tracker and Knight of the Reliquary are decent cards to increase your late game potential, even if you don't plan to abuse them.

Most of these higher cmc suggestions could replace Domri but as you are an aggro deck you wouldn't want to use many of them.

Thanks! Domri is really for the grindier matchups, like Rock and UWx control. I do like the Ghor Clan rampager suggestion, and i totally understand what you mean. In practice Domri has been better than you suggest, but your point stands. I really like the gc rampager idea, like, a lot.

What are your thoughts on Naya Charm? Too cute?

Phoenix Ignition
04-02-2019, 07:35 PM
Is Domri better at his job than Chandra, torch of defiance would be, though? 1 mana is a big difference on paper, but if it's for the grindy, long games then you'd be much better off going big in that slot. You have options in that respect because Faithless Looting allows you to play dead cards in certain matchups. It's like how blue cards in Legacy are that much better because even if Jace is bad in this matchup, he pitches to Force of Will just the same as a cantrip would. Domri seems all-around mediocre instead of throwing a haymaker in 50% of matchups and pitching it in the other 50%.

Naya Charm seems too cute and also not necessary if you build the deck to be slightly more evasive. Ghor-Clan Rampager and things like Grim Lavamancer would mean you don't rely on an alpha strike to close out the game. Naya Charms first 2 modes are extremely lackluster so tapping their team would be the only real reason to play it. It has to be dead or sub-par at least 4/5 of the time, which isn't so bad because you can pitch it to Faithless, but there have to be more impactful cards to be playing in that slot.

Mr. Safety
04-03-2019, 07:34 AM
Good points. I think I'll work in Ghor-Clan and Grim Lavamancer, leaving Naya Charm behind. Domri I'm still testing, but I think it will eventually get cut as well. Chandra seems like a very good suggestion as well.

Thanks!

Mr. Safety
04-03-2019, 08:39 PM
Small update: ghor clan = awesome, putting in 2 straight away. T1 nacatl/neonate/ape, t2 attack for 5-8 is very good. I have popped Neonate too soon in some situations, same with wraiths. This gives me another avenue to apply pressure while i work on a window for the engine to pay off. Domri still in board as a proxy until i can get a Chandra, or maybe garruk relentless, which seems ok as well.

Ajani Vengeant and Gaddock Teeg are on my mind for sideboard as well. Lavaman is always an option for grindier matchups as well.

I hit 4 mana pretty often, to answer an earlier question.

Mr. Safety
04-08-2019, 10:32 AM
Ghor-Clan has been great, pretty sold on those 2 slots.

Sideboard has changed. The BGx matchup is horrible; a single IoK can unravel an incredible hand. So I'm playing a set of Leylines for the Rock/Jund/Shadow matchups where I expect to see a lot of discard. No more messing around with lifegain options to race burn, leylines come in to shut off half their deck. Leylines can be discarded to Looting/Neonates, and I can cast the Leylines if it comes to that. My approach is changing quite a bit as well; I'm starting to look at this as a combo deck, not an agro deck. I need to sideboard accordingly. Boarding slots are Bolts and Ghor-Clans, maybe shaving a Hoots if I need a 7th sideboard card.

2x Surgical Extraction
2x Destructive Revelry
2x Stony Silence
3x Path to Exile
2x Alpine Moon
4x Leyline of Sanctity

Mr. Safety
04-14-2019, 12:29 PM
I am hoping for a draw/discard outlet for this deck in Modern Horizons. Discard/draw is objectively worse for this style deck in particular, where a card like Cathartic Reunion is nuts in dredge due to the critical mass of cards you can discard.

Like this would be nuts:

Red-Flavored Opt
R
Instant
Draw a card, then discard a card.

Mr. Safety
04-22-2019, 08:39 AM
Light up the Stage seems potentially very good here. I have 2 flex spots, this might become an option. I'm not worried about the 3 mana 'hard' cast, I hit 3 lands in almost every game. Chipping in with a Neonate/Nacatl/Ape is very typical in the early turns as well.

Mr. Safety
05-24-2019, 11:24 AM
From the Modern Horizons thread, this is the new direction for this deck. I am very excited! I'm trading off a 3/3 ground pounder (Wild Nacatl) for Birds to settle mana and getting a 3/4 flyer that feeds synergies. Overall, this is a great tradeoff. Hoots and Izzet Charms are flex spots, giving me 6 spots to screw around with if something else gets printed to help out (a Careful Study variant would be an auto-include.) I still like the go-wide aspect of BTE/Whacker because it allows Birds to attack for damage. I will likely stay away from Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage for now, but it's always an option.


https://i.redd.it/4bthgtmi00031.png
Serendib + one-shot Bazaar activation? This card is weird.

This will singlehandedly unite Vengevine and Hollow One. It's better than Cathartic Reunion because it's a creature to help trigger Vengevines. I'm on board with this janky stuff. It makes me want to get brewing for modern:

4x Insolent Neonate
4x Birds of Paradise
4x Bazaar Trademage
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
3x Hooting Mandrills

4x Faithless Looting
4x Lightning Bolt
3x Izzet Charm

4x Scalding Tarn
4x Wooded Foothills
1x Misty Rainforest
2x Steam Vents
2x Stomping Ground
1x Breeding Pool
1x Forest
1x Island
1x Mountain
1x Desolate Lighthouse

Megadeus
05-31-2019, 09:15 AM
From the Modern Horizons thread, this is the new direction for this deck. I am very excited! I'm trading off a 3/3 ground pounder (Wild Nacatl) for Birds to settle mana and getting a 3/4 flyer that feeds synergies. Overall, this is a great tradeoff. Hoots and Izzet Charms are flex spots, giving me 6 spots to screw around with if something else gets printed to help out (a Careful Study variant would be an auto-include.) I still like the go-wide aspect of BTE/Whacker because it allows Birds to attack for damage. I will likely stay away from Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage for now, but it's always an option.



This will singlehandedly unite Vengevine and Hollow One. It's better than Cathartic Reunion because it's a creature to help trigger Vengevines. I'm on board with this janky stuff. It makes me want to get brewing for modern:

4x Insolent Neonate
4x Birds of Paradise
4x Bazaar Trademage
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
3x Hooting Mandrills

4x Faithless Looting
4x Lightning Bolt
3x Izzet Charm

4x Scalding Tarn
4x Wooded Foothills
1x Misty Rainforest
2x Steam Vents
2x Stomping Ground
1x Breeding Pool
1x Forest
1x Island
1x Mountain
1x Desolate Lighthouse


Is Izzet Charm worth it? Also I was thinking maybe the new big Pyromancer (can't remember his name). He loots away vines and stuff. He's not as good as Trademage but it's essentially another 3 Mana payoff guy. He also poops out extra tokens to attack with bushwacker. And at worst he just draws 2 cards in a deck that's got a lot of built in card disadvantage.

Mr. Safety
05-31-2019, 09:25 AM
Is Izzet Charm worth it? Also I was thinking maybe the new big Pyromancer (can't remember his name). He loots away vines and stuff. He's not as good as Trademage but it's essentially another 3 Mana payoff guy. He also poops out extra tokens to attack with bushwacker

Good thoughts. I was worried I didn't have enough interaction for the deck. Izzet Charm was borderline splashable in the Naya version, just not quite there, because I needed another discard outlet. What makes it shine is the Spell Pierce mode. I could easily see cutting to 2 copies, this was just a rough list for testing. With Faithless Looting, Insolent Neonate, and Bazaar Trademage in the deck I don't see the need for Charm as much, but the redundancy seems good.

For reference:

https://img.scryfall.com/cards/large/front/2/e/2e139ad1-1079-49e9-babd-6399c44ad333.jpg?1558464704

I am skeptical. Discard before draw is so much worse than draw before discard, that's what makes Trademage so good. Cathartic Reunion is busted if you have the correct 2 cards to discard but disappointing enough times that I cut it completely. What makes Pyromancer possibly playable is the bodies for Bushwhacker, as you say, but at 3 mana it's just not the right spot on the curve.

Side note: I'm looking at Stubborn Denial again, as well as keeping the Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage plan in my back pocket. The current plan is to go wide with hasty combos turns 3-4 but going tall with Become Immense should be really easy with Bazaar Trademage to feed it.

Phoenix Ignition
06-01-2019, 12:14 AM
I don't really have a suggestion on what to cut but Street Wraith seems like a must play still. Also, I like new Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis

Mr. Safety
06-01-2019, 08:42 AM
I don't really have a suggestion on what to cut but Street Wraith seems like a must play still. Also, I like new Hogaak, Arisen Necropolis

There are some flex spots, probably -1 Hoots, -3 izzet charm, +4 street wraith. Hogaak is interesting, possibly a replacement for the last 2 Hoots. Testing will ensue!

Mirrislegend
07-08-2019, 02:13 PM
Are the Naya or RUG versions of this deck going to resume development? I'm very interested in where this will go.

Mr. Safety
07-08-2019, 03:28 PM
I think I'll wait a little bit for the dust to settle, then purchase some Hogaaks. I think they are definitely going to be part of the mix. I think the RUG version will end up being the better version, mostly due to Bazaar Trademage. With Looting/Trademage/Neonate that's 12 engine cards to fuel Vengevine/Hollow Ones. Once I add in BoPs, Bolts, BTE's, Whackers, Street Wraiths, and lands it's basically built with a few flex spots to consider. Those slots will consist of some number of Hogaaks and Izzet Charms. The next step: finding out if it's still competitive. Turn 3 was the big turn for the Naya version, I am assuming this will be the same.

t1 - Faithless Looting/Insolent Neonate/Birds of Paradise
t2-3 Trademage/setup
t3-4 BTE >>> Bushwhacker >>> attack for a bunch

The Naya version was hitting for around 10 by turn 3 with lethal on-board. I think this will be more consistent at getting those t3 blitzes. Of the t1 plays, Birds is the best, followed by Looting, then Neonate.

I can't emphasize this enough: Trademage drawing before you discard is very, very good. Cathartic Reunion created way too many bad situations where you have cards in hand that you want in your graveyard.

Mirrislegend
07-09-2019, 12:10 PM
I think I'll wait a little bit for the dust to settle, then purchase some Hogaaks.

Hogaak is just over 5 bux a piece at the moment. If I were you, I would buy them now before people realize Hogaak is still playable even without Bridge.

Mr. Safety
07-09-2019, 02:20 PM
Hogaak is just over 5 bux a piece at the moment. If I were you, I would buy them now before people realize Hogaak is still playable even without Bridge.

Good call, I'll snag a set.

EDIT: List for testing

4x Insolent Neonate
4x Birds of Paradise
4x Bazaar Trademage
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
2x Hogaak, Risen Necropolis
4x Street Wraith
4x Faithless Looting
4x Lightning Bolt

4x Scalding Tarn
4x Wooded Foothills
1x Misty Rainforest
2x Steam Vents
2x Stomping Ground
1x Breeding Pool
2x Forest
1x Island
1x Mountain

Tylert
07-10-2019, 05:06 AM
Good call, I'll snag a set.

EDIT: List for testing

4x Insolent Neonate
4x Birds of Paradise
4x Bazaar Trademage
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
2x Hogaak, Risen Necropolis
4x Street Wraith
4x Faithless Looting
4x Lightning Bolt

4x Scalding Tarn
4x Wooded Foothills
1x Misty Rainforest
2x Steam Vents
2x Stomping Ground
1x Breeding Pool
2x Forest
1x Island
1x Mountain


What should be the name of that deck now? (Naya vengevine doesn't fit anymore).
I propose "Bea(s)ts Under the carpet" (Hoogak / hollow one / vengevine in an RUG shell).

Mr. Safety
07-10-2019, 07:55 AM
Beasts under the Carpet sounds cool. I was contemplating "Kinky Fourplay" (Bazaar/4-power creatures), but that would be in somewhat poor taste. "Bazaar and Reckless" sounds ok to me as well.

I can change the heading for the subsequential posts but the original thread title has to be changed by a moderator. I could create a new thread, which I'm happy to do, but a mod would have to delete this one. I like the context of where it began (RG Hollow-Vine) but that could always be included in the primer.

There is a 'hinge' point in the deck, one that will need to be addressed: whether to go wide with BTE/Bushwhacker or whether to go tall with Become Immense/Temur Battle Rage. I tend to think that Hogaak lends itself to going tall, especially with built in trample. Going wide is a little less feasible with Hogaak because two creatures need to be tapped to cast him, meaning there will be fewer creatures attacking with the Bushwhacker bonus. I'm also a little worried I don't have enough green creatures to convoke Hogaak (12 with Birds/Vines/BTE's.) In the Bridgevine deck all the creatures were black except for Vengevine and Hogaak, which were green to support casting Hogaak. In a go-wide strategy, it may be better to just stick to Hooting Mandrils. The efficiency of getting a 4/4 trample with haste for only G may actually be better than an 8/8 trample that needs to tap down valuable attackers just to be cast. I also don't like going tall in the current metagame where UW control is a tier deck. Losing to a Path to Exile would feel really bad. Getting in under Supreme Verdict shouldn't be too difficult, honestly, because there are ways to get Vengevines back or just refill with a Trademage/Looting.

I think that for a little while people are still going to be packing graveyard hate, at least 4 slots in their 75. Surgical Extraction was a maindeck inclusion in a lot of decks before Hogaak, simply for Izzet Phoenix decks. I don't think that will change any time soon. If Faithless Looting were banned instead of Bridge I think I would comfortably say Surgical would disappear from maindecks...but this deck would likely be dead in the water, lol.

Mr. Safety
07-29-2019, 10:23 AM
I'm back on this deck after a disappointing 1K playing an Esper Polymorph brew. I started out hot with 3 wins, then the wheels came off. I just traded into 3x Misty Rainforest and I'm hoping to start digging into testing at a more intense level. The main info I'm looking for is to see what Birds of Paradise does for the deck, as well as possibly dropping Street Wraiths for Nimble Mongoose. The velocity is very good with SW's but Trademage supercharges the graveyard for Geese and sets up combo-like turns.

I'm also interested in trying Edge of Autumn, which could serve as a support piece for Hollow One like Street Wraith, it's a 'free' cycler, and it even puts 2 cards in the graveyard to feed threshold/Hooting Mandrils, and I can hit the 3rd land. I can't imagine it replaces Birds of Paradise, but it might serve to replace Street Wraith. Saving on life total is a concern as well considering the faster decks in the format (Burn, Red Phoenix, Humans.) Edge could serve to manage land flooding in the mid-late game as well.

List for testing:

4x Birds of Paradise
4x Insolent Neonate
4x Burning-Tree Emissary
4x Reckless Bushwhacker
4x Bazaar Trademage
4x Vengevine
4x Hollow One
2x Hooting Mandrils
4x Street Wraith
4x Faithless Looting
4x Lightning Bolt
3x Misty Rainforest
3x Scalding Tarn
2x Wooded Foothills
2x Stomping Ground
1x Steam Vents
1x Breeding Pool
1x Botanical Sanctum
1x Spirebluff Canal
1x Copperline Gorge
1x Mountain
1x Forest
1x Island

Sideboard
2x Alpine Moon
4x Destructive Revelry
2x Surgical Extraction
2x Tormod's Crypt
2x Lightning Axe
3x Dispel


Other cards to consider: Thought Scour, Hogaak, Edge of Autumn, Izzet Charm, Domri Rade, Scavenging Ooze, Nimble Mongoose.

Mirrislegend
07-31-2019, 03:32 PM
Trademage, as an enabler, seems too slow. Maybe trim one or two for Izzet Charms?

Mr. Safety
08-01-2019, 09:52 AM
If Trademage ends up being too slow I don't know why I would need to splash blue at that point. I would go back to the Naya version which is more aggressive with Wild Nacatls and Ghor-Clan Rampagers.

I honestly don't think a t3 Trademage is too slow. This deck doesn't rely on continual graveyard value, it comes in spurts. That makes it a little more resilient to graveyard hate. I also like that even if Trademage is slow as an enabler it is still a 3/4 flyer for 3 mana, which is an above average rate. My big concern is the discard 3, which could be a little problematic if I don't have enough value to discard. I end up being a card down in hand, and I don't know how many of those effects the deck can handle (Looting, Neonate, Trademage.) Another option is to jam Bloodghasts instead of Street Wraiths. I wouldn't be able to cast them at BB, no way, but getting them for free with a land drop seems pretty good. I really like that they are extra bodies for Reckless Bushwhacker. It's a little loose, but it might be necessary. I might just need the extra 4 value targets for Trademage.

I am still building the deck, so it's a lot of 'talk but no walk' just yet. I think Trademage will likely be good enough simply because it singlehandedly enables free Hollow Ones.

EDIT: The life loss from Street Wraith may prove to be too much anyways. If that's the case, I think I will need to move over to Bloodghast, Edge of Autumn or Thought Scour. Edge has the, um, 'edge' currently as a free cycling enabler. Golgari Brownscale in the sideboard could do some work as well, or something like Feed the Clan.

Mr. Safety
08-01-2019, 04:44 PM
I am mildly curious if Skaab Ruinator is potentially good enough for the deck. It has a 'cheaper' delve cost at only 3 cards (creatures) and can be cast from the graveyard same as Hogaak. I can however use mana to cast it so I don't have to tap my dudes to get him out there. A 5/6 flyer is nothing to sneeze at either. Hogaak may become necessary, but I'm not entirely sure he dodges another B&R cycle. It's likely, probable even, that Hooting Mandrils is just better.

EDIT: Force of Vigor may be better than Destructive Revelry in the sideboard, especially against t0 Leyline of the Void. The card disadvantage is a bummer, but having it be free seems very, very good.

In the words of Chris Pratt, 'I'm going to make some weird shit.' I'm actually debating 5-colors for the deck, which allows for a Snapcaster Mage + Tribal Flames sideboard option that dodges the graveyard. Switching up a couple dual lands in the main, maybe a fetch or 2, and I can not only enable Tribal Flames but white sideboard cards. Shit's getting weird...and if I run into Blood Moon (not too bad, half the deck is red-based already, I have Birds and BTE's to get green mana) then Force of Vigor gets a little more necessary.

Mr. Safety
08-04-2019, 05:01 PM
Update: bloodghast is garbage. Trademage, unfortunately, is about 1 turn too slow. I don't think its going to make the cut. In a non-dredge deck i think the draw 2, discard 3 is too much for this deck to handle. I would need, at a minimum l, 4 more graveyard based threats to make it work. I just don't have them available. Hooting Mandrils is still great, and street wraith is still necessary. I feel like maybe Seasoned Pyromancer could be good here. It was mentioned earlier in the thread but i haven't had a chance to test it out.

Birds were dissapointing. I got a couple t2 Trademages, but i ended up a card down that cost me. I had to discard valuable cards because i didn't have vengevines. Wild Nacatl is looking really good again

The enablers really have to be 1 mana. Neonate and Looting are the best enablers. I wish there was another Neonate affect available.

EDIT: OP edited with the list I landed on before Modern Horizons. The only changes that would happen at this point would be metagame choices. The Horizon lands seem appealing, but don't support Wild Nacatl. I think I could squeeze in 1, maybe 2 Sunbaked Canyon or Horizon Canopy. Some changes to the sideboard to combat UW control (Lead the Stampede) and Jund (Leyline of Sanctity). Discard is surprisingly good against this deck, especially Inquisition of Kozilek. Both cards are good in other matchups as well, with Lead the Stampede being decent against Tron if they wipe the board with OStone (but I should be fast enough for them) and Leyline stops Burn and Walking Ballista. Force of Vigor is still on my mind, but the main reason would be to battle Blood Moon. However...Blood Moon isn't that great against this deck. The worst it does is turn Wild Nacatl into a 2/2.

Mr. Safety
08-26-2019, 01:43 PM
Deck is dead without Looting. Rip.

Mirrislegend
08-26-2019, 03:32 PM
Deck is dead without Looting. Rip.

As you noted above, Trademage is a little too slow. And so is Izzet Charm, obviously. Given that the format will slow down significantly, maybe the deck still has a chance if you go for a larger blue splash.

Mr. Safety
08-28-2019, 09:50 PM
I don't think it would be worth the effort, honestly. The outlets would be Trademage, Izzet Charm, and maybe Cathartic Reunion? I don't think it would be reliable enough. I was really dissapointed with the minimal testing i did of the rug version; the only good starts had looting.