Gyruda + Dauthi Voidwalker

[Scott]

Odd situation came up on MTGO, and I got a reimbursement, but I wanted to make sure the reimbursement was correct and that I understand the interaction.

Opponent has a Dauthi Voidwalker in play and I have a Leyline of the Void in play. I cast Gyruda, Doom of Depths. MTGO pops out menus to show your options of which milled cards to select, but I only had the option of the opponent's milled cards. When I watched a replay, it showed my milled cards going into exile with void counters on them, but not highlighted for Gyruda purposes.

Voidwalker works the same way as Leyline, and I should have had the choice of my milled cards too, right?

[Zoid]

Odd situation came up on MTGO, and I got a reimbursement, but I wanted to make sure the reimbursement was correct and that I understand the interaction.

Opponent has a Dauthi Voidwalker in play and I have a Leyline of the Void in play. I cast Gyruda, Doom of Depths. MTGO pops out menus to show your options of which milled cards to select, but I only had the option of the opponent's milled cards. When I watched a replay, it showed my milled cards going into exile with void counters on them, but not highlighted for Gyruda purposes.

Voidwalker works the same way as Leyline, and I should have had the choice of my milled cards too, right?


If a replacement effect causes a player to exile the top four cards of their library instead of putting them into their graveyard as Gyruda's triggered ability resolves, the creature card you choose may be one of those cards in exile.

As far as I understand as long as the cards are not replaced into a hidden zone you should still be able to select them.

[Scott]

Cheers, thanks