PDA

View Full Version : [Deck] Solitaire (Enchantress)



Pages : 1 [2] 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23

SpatulaOfTheAges
11-30-2007, 06:03 PM
Grass is tehStopzorz vs both Breakfast variants I'm aware of; infinite angels and Ghoul are both unable to get through it.

Wallace
12-07-2007, 08:54 PM
Here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KQPO6H4Ejk&eurl=http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=mtgevent/worlds07/welcome) is a look at Luis Scott-Vargas version of Enchantress at worlds.

ClearSkies
12-07-2007, 10:00 PM
Here (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7KQPO6H4Ejk&eurl=http://www.wizards.com/default.asp?x=mtgevent/worlds07/welcome) is a look at Luis Scott-Vargas version of Enchantress at worlds.

Besides the 3x City of Solitude, his list was sure really standard. I expected some kind of hidden tech (maybe the 3x City of Solitude is it?) when you labeled it like that.

Wallace
12-07-2007, 10:06 PM
Besides the 3x City of Solitude, his list was sure really standard. I expected some kind of hidden tech (maybe the 3x City of Solitude is it?) when you labeled it like that.

I was just throwing up a link so people could see the conversation about legacy, it just happened to be about enchantress.

Jak
12-08-2007, 01:50 AM
If someone can make out all the cards, can they post his list? My eyes fail me.

C.P.
12-08-2007, 02:49 AM
If someone can make out all the cards, can they post his list? My eyes fail me.

What I see so far:

8 Enchantress

4 EGrass
2 Confinement
2 Moat
2 Oring

4 Sprawl
2 Exploration

3 SGlove

1 Sacred Ground
1 Aura of Silence
2 Ground Seal
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Words of War

2 Replenish

2 Sanctum

...is what I see.

ClearSkies
12-08-2007, 10:54 AM
I only see 1 Moat instead of 2.
I also see 3 City of Solitude. (Probably his tech?)

Everything else, I see the same as C.P.'s post.

C.P.
12-08-2007, 01:19 PM
I only see 1 Moat instead of 2.
I also see 3 City of Solitude. (Probably his tech?)

Everything else, I see the same as C.P.'s post.

Forgetting 3 city is my bad, but I still see 2 moat.

Jak
12-08-2007, 01:44 PM
I see 2 moats also. His build is interesting. If I would ever play this deck, Confinement would be a 3-4 of. He did well with it anyways. Is this what most of you guys are playing?

ClearSkies
12-08-2007, 02:15 PM
I finally see the two Moats. I must have been blind earlier or something. -_-

Yea, I play something like that, minus the City of Solitude and one Moat. Everything else is more or less is the same.

No local tournaments around here though, so I haven't really got the chance to test it in a Legacy Tournament even though the deck itself is sitting in my house somewhere. So, I don't really know how well it works in a tournament setting. =/

C.P.
12-08-2007, 03:05 PM
I see 2 moats also. His build is interesting. If I would ever play this deck, Confinement would be a 3-4 of. He did well with it anyways. Is this what most of you guys are playing?

I play 4 confinement, abut I can see myself dropping the fourth.

My list would be:


8 Enchantress

4 EGrass
3 Confinement
1 Ghostly Prison
1 Moat

4 Sprawl
3 Exploration

3 SGlove

2 City of Solitude
1 Sacred Ground
1 Aura of Silence
2 Ground Seal
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Words of War
1 Oring

2 Replenish

2 Sanctum

Something like that.
I want to sqeeze in couple guiles, though.

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-09-2007, 05:40 PM
I've varied between 2-3 Confinements. 4 is too much for a card that's just a fog without the engine in place, and 2-3 + Grove is enough to see it reliably with the engine working.

What's up with the MD Sacred Ground?

And someone should have told him that Choke is better than City of Solitude. And that even if you disagree, the combination is much better than multiple Cities, if you want that many anti-blue spots.

Happy Gilmore
12-10-2007, 12:31 AM
I've varied between 2-3 Confinements. 4 is too much for a card that's just a fog without the engine in place, and 2-3 + Grove is enough to see it reliably with the engine working.

What's up with the MD Sacred Ground?

And someone should have told him that Choke is better than City of Solitude. And that even if you disagree, the combination is much better than multiple Cities, if you want that many anti-blue spots.

When I saw that podcast I had deja-Vu it was like being back at Anwar's first tournament before Legacy was Legacy. In many ways the list has not changed at all. It would have been nice if the pros simply mentioned that they began researching decks for legacy on the source. With few exceptions I saw nothing unusual out of the pros. Mori's deck however, was awsome.

Soto
12-10-2007, 12:46 AM
Do you guys till play Sylvan Library? Like 2-3 of?

Kronicler
12-10-2007, 02:45 AM
LonelyBaritone: If you were going to take this deck to a DLD or an unknown meta, what list would you run? All of the recent lists that I could find seem to be testing something, either a splash or a new card. What has that testing shown? What is the best standard list right now?

Thanks so much,

Kronicler

Julian23
12-11-2007, 11:47 AM
I've been playing the GWr Enchantress built we've all been advocating for quite a while now but recently I had decided to give the "oldschool" UGw Enchantress featuring the Words of Wind combo another chance. I'm wondering what you might think about my current list so far:

4x Argothian Enchantress
3x Cloud of Fearies

4x Enchantress' Presence
4x Utopia Sprawl
4x Exploration
4x Words of Wind
4x Sterling Grove
1x Trade Routes
1x City of Solitude
4x Oblivion Ring
1x Ground Seal

2x Living Wish
2x Stroke of Genius

4x Windswept Heath
4x Tropical Island
4x Savannah
4x Forest
3x Island
1x Plains
2x Serra's Sanctum

Sideboard so far:
1x Verduran Enchantress
1x Cloud of Fearies
1x Serra's Sanctum
1x Selesnya Sanctuary
3x Karmic Justice
1x Sacred Ground
3x City of Solitude
4x Seal of Removal


This is just a very rough list I threw together yesterday. Maybe the seals could/should be maindecked as they are another 1-mana-enchantment that enable the infinite combo along with being good against aggro.
Some thoughts?
And _please_ don't start the whole blue vs. red Enchantress discussion again.

goldenj
12-11-2007, 01:58 PM
@Julian23: no Replenish? Can you explain the living wish and the stroke? What about hoofprints for a win condition if you don't want the mesa? Seems to fit with the more lock-ish nature of the UG.

Vargas' exact list:
4 Windswept Heath
3 Savannah
1 Bayou
1 Taiga
1 Scrubland
7 Forest
3 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum
-------22 land
4 Argothian Enchantress
-------4 creatures
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Elephant Grass
2 Ground Seal
4 Utopia Sprawl
2 Exploration
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Sacred Ground
3 Sterling Grove
1 Words of War
2 Replenish
2 Moat
2 Solitary Confinement
3 City of Solitude
2 Oblivion Ring
1 Aura of Silence
--------34 other spells
4 Leyline of the Void
2 Krosan Grip
3 Choke
3 Thoughtseize
2 Karmic Justice
1 Replenish
--------15 sideboard
In his interview, he identfied the grass and ground seal as crucial. As remarked above the cities are curious. Especially seeing the chokes in the SB.

Are the grips anti-deed tech? That's what I run auras for.

The thoughtseize and the leylines of the void are really interesting. I guess that's why the Bayou in the manabase.

Zach Tartell
12-11-2007, 02:23 PM
LIST

This is just a very rough list I threw together yesterday. Maybe the seals could/should be maindecked as they are another 1-mana-enchantment that enable the infinite combo along with being good against aggro.
Some thoughts?
And _please_ don't start the whole blue vs. red Enchantress discussion again.

Julian - I myself am not a big fan of the blue splash. I don't know what sort of discussion you're referring to, either - but I guess that's not really important.

I have several concerns about you list:

You run 3 basic islands. Is that necessary? Let me break it down into another (gasp!) list (I love this function.

Utopia Sprawl doesn't play well with non-forests
Your most important engine is entirely Green. Green mana seems really way more important than blue, to me. I'd rather see you running like two Flooded Strands (since Strand can fetch out either of your duals or the basic against a waste lock) than three islands.
You only have ten Blue spells in your deck. Now, I know that saying "Only ten blue spells" sounds a little hypocritical, but you're only looking to resolve 1 Words of Wind or a Trade Routes with a Cloud of Faeries. That's it. Or, I suppose, the stroke finish, but I find that to be a bit tacky.

Do you need four Words of Wind?


Your win conditions include 3 Cloud of Faeries, or stroke. How do you beat combo? I guess I really can't say anything, on account of the Gwr build doesn't really stand a chance, either. I just forsee you haveing some mad problems against thresh, where Gwr's Blood Moons and (if you still run 'em) Chokes would drop a train on them.
I hate Living Wish. I tried it, and I found it too clunky - I'd rather draw cards that would let me keep my Confinement up, or not spend my early game wasting time with wishing for stuff that you could fit in your deck if you hadn't put wishes in their slots to begin with. I'll admit that having a Grab-An-Enchantress card is nice, but ultimately unnecessary.
I also think that your full playset of O-Rings is a bit of overkill, along with your full playset of City of Solitude between your board and maindeck.
I also don't see Elephant Grass, perhaps the best :g: cost enchantment in the meta right now, included in your list. That takes goblins, Cephalid Breakfast, and Ichorid to the woodshed.


Man, I love me some list functions.


Dear Zach,
I love you and everything you do. Please enlighten me with your boundless wisdom.
Happy Hanukkah,
Kronicler

I may have taken some liberty with that, but since I'm not on Firefox right now I can't tab'd browse, so I don't care to right click and open a new window, so I won't be having actual quotes.

To be honest with you, dude, I have no idea. I think that by cutting two of the following from my previous list: Blood Moon, Karmic Justice, and/or City of Solitude; and switching them to the board for the last two Elephant Grasses is an excellent choice. I just don't like not having my full playset against a random deck. I still haven't gotten data on Eyes of the Wisent, yet. People keep on playing crappy MBC discard decks against me, and I just drop confinement (or resolve an Enchantress) and win. My one match against a thresh player ended on turn two when I played my Moat with a mana open (I kept a 4 land, double exploration hand with Moat on the draw) and he replied something as kind as "Only people of color would run such a questionable card." After breifly exploring the circumstances of my conception and parentage, he decided that he was finished playing, and left.

As for the cards I've been testing lately (are you ready for another list?):

Dropping the black splash hasn't been much of a problem. I really kick myself for buying not one, but two, copies of The Abyss, but I'm not sure that we need it. O-Ring is really good at what it does, and I haven't had a sweeper give my opponent his Goyf or Crucible or Counterbalance back yet.
Blood Moon and Choke are interchangeable. I prefer Blood Moon because of the rampant amount of Non-Basic lands in my local meta, and I would bring it to a large event. If you are guarenteed to go up against a bunch of Thresh, MUC, and Landstill, I'd recommend Choke. It's noteworthy that Choke + Elephant Grass/Ghostly Prison is GG against Thresh.
Hoofprints is amazing. Whoever brought it up to me, I'm sorry I told you you were adopted. It's good, and I think it's here to stay. You don't have to combo with it - just kind of drop it and sit, then go nuts with sanctum and swing in for the win (barring Punishment, Pernicous Deed, Wrath of God, Engineered Explosives, Akroma's Vengance, Kitar's Wrath, Rout (with kicker or not), Damnation, and 4 Engineered Plagues on Elemental). I wish it were instant speed. Maybe against control you could board in Fires of Yavamaia or Concordant Crossroads.

Don't actually do that.




@Julian23: no Replenish?

This guy is on point. I can't believe I missed that.



The thoughtseize and the leylines of the void are really interesting. I guess that's why the Bayou in the manabase.

Hey! Hey! Don't go giving Super Secret Tacosnape, Spatula of the Ages, and LonelyBaritone tech credit to LSV. To be fair, he's a little better known than us. But Tacosnape's first name is Leif, and Spatula is engaged, so he probably has sex with girls. I'm kind of boring.

Anyway, before I digress more, Leyline isn't really a new thing. It's just that I wasn't invited to play my build at Worlds, so you didn't get to see my list on Wizards. That's really the whole story.


Library?

Spatula suggested, and I was swayed into believeing, that Ground seal is just better. It actually serves a purpose, draws the card now, and comes foil. The only time I'd wish I had library was against control. That's it.

Everyone else, I'm too lazy to scroll farther down than I already have. Now I have to go make Cavius angry at me in the "Tartell vs. Whatever his last name is Enchantress thread."

Happy 8th night, all.

goldenj
12-11-2007, 03:09 PM
I wasn't trying to give the credit to LSV. In general, I was trying to point out how closely he followed the deck as practiced in this forum. Certainly Spatula's done more work on the deck longer than anyone else I've seen.

@Julian: the fun Words of Wind kill is Multani.

GreenOne
12-14-2007, 05:12 AM
A few reflections (without using the list function, because I'm not that awesome):

- City of Solitude: lately I messed up with those ones. Threshold usually doesn't have mora than 1 counter in hand anyway (they only play 4 hard counters) so why don't just play a must-counter that does something useful if it comes into play? say...Moat or Choke ad example.

- 2x Solitary Confinament: I really like this. Confinament is really useful when you have 2xEnchantress effects out, and if you have them, chances of you having one of 6 cards (2 confinament+4 grove) are quite high. If you can't mantain it with just an enchantress out it's just a fog effect.. not much.

- 2x Exploration: I already explained why 4 explorations is just bad for this deck IMO. 3 feels like a good number, but right now I'm testing 2 to see if there's more space for bombs in the deck.

- Circle of protection:Green : did anyone ever thought about that in the threshold matchup? Seems like it can stall a lot, but it does not provide much more than Moat's protection. It costs 2 less, btw. Thoughts about that?

- Hoofprints: I'm testing them too as a 1x. It's not overwhelming but somewhat good even if you don't have an enchantress out. Don't know if it's worth the slot though.

So right now I'm testing a list with 2 Explorations, 2 Confinaments and 2 Ghostly Prison.

// Lands
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
4 [B] Savannah
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
1 [A] Taiga
9 [ON] Forest (1)
2 [MM] Plains (1)

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
2 [US] Exploration
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
2 [OD] Ground Seal
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
1 [ON] Words of War
2 [LRW] Oblivion Ring
2 [JU] Solitary Confinement
1 [AT] Sacred Mesa
1 [LG] Moat
2 [UD] Replenish
2 [IA] Wild Growth
2 [CHK] Ghostly Prison
1 [LRW] Hoofprints of the Stag

// Sideboard
SB: 2 [OD] Ground Seal
SB: 2 [8E] Choke
SB: 3 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 3 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 1 [7E] Sacred Ground
SB: 1 [7E] Compost
SB: 1 [DIS] Dovescape
SB: 1 [TE] Warmth
SB: 1 [DK] Blood Moon

What are your thoughts about 6x maindeck propaganda effects? Are there better BOMBS to play in their place? I wish I had a Moat, but I'm not gonna spend 40 bucks on a 2nd of a card which is played by (maybe) 2 decks. I still got an ethic to respect.

edgewalker
12-14-2007, 02:10 PM
The only problem I I have with propaganda effects now is that they don't stop a lot of the creatures it needs to. So many decks no will only have 1-3 creatures out and they're all usually a pretty big clock, so paying 2 each turn isn't that bad. Hell, breakfast only needs to do it once, and threshold needs to do it what like 4 times? I'm not saying go out and buy the moat, but is there anything else that can stop creatures from just straight up attacking without any conditions?

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-14-2007, 03:01 PM
Choke + Elephant Grass.

GreenOne
12-14-2007, 04:17 PM
The only problem I I have with propaganda effects now is that they don't stop a lot of the creatures it needs to. So many decks no will only have 1-3 creatures out and they're all usually a pretty big clock, so paying 2 each turn isn't that bad. Hell, breakfast only needs to do it once, and threshold needs to do it what like 4 times? I'm not saying go out and buy the moat, but is there anything else that can stop creatures from just straight up attacking without any conditions?

mmh Island Sanctuary? worse than confinament. Porphiry nodes/drop of honey would be good.. if it wasn't for argothians.. Genju of the fields... if it wasn't for 5/6 Tarmos I'd think about him. Kirtar's Desire seems a playable card.. it's cheap and has a Stp-similar effect. Gossamer Chains with their WW in the cc are too clunky, even if I like the effect. Dueling Grounds let the 'goyf in, even if alone. Story Circle can be quite good coupled with propa effects, but a 2 card combo is not what the deck needs. Pariah is a Fog+Removal effect, that can be quite good. Crackdown is good vs thresh, but that's it, it does nothing vs goblin or control. Parallax wave can buy some time, but doesn't take care of Mongeese. Aurification can be nice, but leaves you open to an alpha strike from gobbos or in pain when low on life vs thresh. Worship to combo with Argothian? Form of the dragon is, unfortunately, uncastable.

The good thing about playing a lot of Propa effects is when they come in multiples. Paying 4 mana is something Threshold can't always afford. However, I'd drop the 2 Ghostly Prison if only there was something (non-moat) better.

ClearSkies
12-14-2007, 05:56 PM
Doesn't Humility + Moat solve just about any creature problems?
However, it does shut down have of your enchantress effects.

alebronwebb
12-15-2007, 06:16 PM
what do people think about SB Titania's Song, i have for a while and is really good against Stax and other artifact heavy decks.

ClearSkies
12-15-2007, 06:26 PM
what do people think about SB Titania's Song, i have for a while and is really good against Stax and other artifact heavy decks.

Yea, it is a really good card that shuts down a lot of random stuff.

Like Engineered Explosives, Nevinyrral's Disk, Chalice of the Void, entire affinity deck, and so on.

Maybe it would be a good idea to mainboard it depending on your meta...

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-15-2007, 11:54 PM
I had thought about that recently, and I know I've advocated it in the past, but is it really any better than Dovescape?

ClearSkies
12-16-2007, 01:29 AM
I had thought about that recently, and I know I've advocated it in the past, but is it really any better than Dovescape?

I don't think it is fair to compare it to Dovescape. Titania's Song removes annoying artifacts in play and doesn't really affect your future enchantment castings. Also, it is cheaper (and easier) than Dovescape to play.

However, Dovescape solves almost all the non-creature problems, but it stops you from playing any more enchantments.

alebronwebb
12-18-2007, 08:47 PM
yeah, im going to have to agree with ClearSkies on this one, Dovescape is really good but it hurts (maybe) since we play mostly non-creature, and Dovescape can be hard to cast sometimes.

Titania's Song is quick, takes care of threats already in play, and isn't mana reliant at all.

alebronwebb
12-19-2007, 12:00 AM
here's the list i've been running for a while, what do you think.

lands 21
2 Serra's Sanctum
3 Savannah
1 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath
5 Plain
6 Forest

creatures 4
4 Argothian Enchatress

other 36
3 Exploration
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove
2 Solitary Confinement
1 Words of War
1 Sacred Mesa
2 Ground Seal
2 Oblivion Ring
1 Karmic Justice
4 Elephant Grass
1 Moat
2 Sylvan Library
1 Aura of Silence
2 Replenish

SB 15
1 Replenish
2 Ground Seal
2 Choke
1 Sacred Ground
1 Blood Moon
2 City of Solitude
1 Titania's Song
2 Compost
2 Aura of Silence
1 Eyes of the Wisent

I am really considering adding 1 Hoofprints of the Stag MD probably in place of Karmic Justice, i realize that it contradicts Moat. I don't play Moat every game so it might not be a big problem anyways.

Zach Tartell
12-19-2007, 02:26 AM
yeah, im going to have to agree with ClearSkies on this one, Dovescape is really good but it hurts (maybe) since we play mostly non-creature, and Dovescape can be hard to cast sometimes.

Titania's Song is quick, takes care of threats already in play, and isn't mana reliant at all.

Dovescape is excellent for the exact reason that you listed - it negates the counterpackage of dedicated blue-based control like MUC or Landstill. It also, when resolved, wins the game single-handedly against combo. Half of your Enchantresses still resolve, and if you even land one, then you're cycling for Decree tokens (sort of - gotta play along to get that analogy) while your opponent sits of spells that don't replace, and (with the exception of Decree of Justice when hardcast and Engineered Explosives) don't create that many guys. I dont' want to be dramatic (I lied - I do), but Landstill cannot win through a resolved Dovescape. Nor can Combo of any sort (unless solidarity goes off in response to it, then floats a trillion mana, then lets it resolve, then plays Stroke of Genius for a trillion)

Let me shudder as I look at your list:


21 lands
5 Plains

Seriously? Do you ever have a need for five plains? I would run a fourth Savannah, or fetches, or anything instead of any more than 3 Plains. How is the 21 Land treating you, though? I see you dropped an Exploration, too - the NoVa crowd has cut one or two as well.


2 Confinement

This makes me feel uncomfortable, too. How do you do against Burn? Combo? Agro? I often just fog with a Confinement, if I have to buy time.

The rest of your main deck seems pretty normal. I'm thinking about putting the Seal of Primordium back into the main - seems like too many decks are playing Enchantments and Artifacts, now a days.


Your Sideboard

I don't like this. Run either 3 City of Solitude or 3 Eyes of the Wisent - boarding in the split feels really awkward. I've recently not had the gumption to take my City of Solitude out of my side and add the sweet Sim-Chinese Eyes that I picked up, so I don't have any data on it. What have you found?

Also, what's up with the whole "only one" approach to Blood Moon? The matches where you want it, I've found, you want it now. Landstill of any combonation of colors (shuts off man-lands and wasteland, though the latter pales after you've dropped the Moon), 43 Land-variants (Port, Waste, Man-lands, Barbarian Ring, ect), and un-prepared Thresh variants (seriously - they only run like two basics, and both are Islands) all shit the bed to a resolved Moon early game. Turn two is a good time to drop it, and it's eaisest to do that when you have mulitiples.


Uh... what about Titania's song?
Yup. It's not that good. I picked up a playset of Antiquities ones, hoping to break it, then never wanted it. Ever. I played it for like 5 local tournaments and a 6 round DLD (where I finished 4-2) and hadn't ever boarded it in to great success. Even if you have a bunch of Stax and affinity in your meta it's not that good - just splash Blue for Energy Flux and watch 'em weep. I'll admit that it doesn't answer Disc (though, to be fair, when's the last time you sat down across from one of those?) or EE, but I'm cool with that - anti-destruction stuff usually doesn't work, so you may as well make 'em pay with mulitple Karmic Justices and Replenishes. Or, I suppose, Pithing Needle.

Edit:
Also, Hoofprint tokens fly. So... don't worry about that.

alebronwebb
12-19-2007, 02:48 AM
wow, man. I'm still getting a feel for the deck. I realize that there might be a few odd choices but i'm no expert on the deck, so please calm down man.

i never said Dovescape is bad, i dont run it because i dont have any right now. I traded them off when they were released, saying "crap card".

right now i dont have the fourth Savannah or it would be in there. so it will be 4 plains soon. whats the problem with 21 lands??? really.

i took out 1 Confinement for Karmic, but will more than likely add it back.

and yes i suck at making SB, but Eyes hasn't been that good to me.
Hoofprints (crappy reading skills, sorry) is way better since it goes with the Enchantress and Sylvan Library.

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-19-2007, 09:17 AM
I don't think Zach meant to come off as hostile. It's just that he's usually drunk.


Dovescape is excellent for the exact reason that you listed - it negates the counterpackage of dedicated blue-based control like MUC or Landstill. It also, when resolved, wins the game single-handedly against combo. Half of your Enchantresses still resolve, and if you even land one, then you're cycling for Decree tokens (sort of - gotta play along to get that analogy) while your opponent sits of spells that don't replace, and (with the exception of Decree of Justice when hardcast and Engineered Explosives) don't create that many guys. I dont' want to be dramatic (I lied - I do), but Landstill cannot win through a resolved Dovescape. Nor can Combo of any sort (unless solidarity goes off in response to it, then floats a trillion mana, then lets it resolve, then plays Stroke of Genius for a trillion)

Let me temper this by saying that the combo effect is irrelevant in a six mana enchantment. It could read "Target player reveals his library, and loses if he reveals Dread Return or any card with Storm", and it wouldn't effect the match-up, because it's six mana.

What Dovescape does is answer control.


I don't like this. Run either 3 City of Solitude or 3 Eyes of the Wisent - boarding in the split feels really awkward.

Actually, the split is probably going to be better.

A) City of Solitude is not useful in multiples.
B) Cabal Therapy
C) Meddling Mage
D) Haunting Echoes
E) In this particular case, Chalice of the Void
F) What's the disadvantage of overlapping different cards?

Zach Tartell
12-19-2007, 12:50 PM
wow, man. I'm still getting a feel for the deck. I realize that there might be a few odd choices but i'm no expert on the deck, so please calm down man.

I wan't trying to come off like a hater, but I think that you have some appauling choices. I don't want to be a dick, especially over the internet - it's much more fun in person, and people who don't know you often respond like you did.



i never said Dovescape is bad, i dont run it because i dont have any right now. I traded them off when they were released, saying "crap card".

If you are playing a deck with 4 revised dual lands and a Moat, I reckon you can fork up the mighty 65 cents (http://magictraders.com/cgi-bin/query.cgi?list=magic&target=dovescape&field=0&operator=re) US to pick up a Dovescape.


right now i dont have the fourth Savannah or it would be in there. so it will be 4 plains soon. whats the problem with 21 lands??? really.

I wasn't making fun of your lack of Savannahs so much as your abundance of Plains. And as for the 21 land, I was meerly asking how you felt about it. I've run 20 since I started playing the deck, and haven't really tried to fool around with that, 'scept for that one time I left a Savannah in my car. Just trying to get more data, hoss.


i took out 1 Confinement for Karmic, but will more than likely add it back.

Your lack of capitolization is startling. How do like only one copy of Karmic Justice between your main and board? Do you ever feel like you might want another, like in matches against 4c Landstill, Truffle-shuffle, or any deck with multiple copies of Pernicous Deed, Engineered Exploives, or Crime // Punishment?


and yes i suck at making SB, but Eyes hasn't been that good to me.

That's what I've been feeling, lately. Like, the matches that I board it in against (with the exception of Thresh blends) I'd rather just have another City of Solitude.


Hoofprints (crappy reading skills, sorry) is way better since it goes with the Enchantress and Sylvan Library.

That does have some savage synergy. Check out that aliterition. I dropped Library a couple weeks ago on Spatula's suggestion to just run more copies of Ground Seal in the main. Haven't missed it since, except against Crontrol matches, where an extra 4 cards for 16 life is almost worth it.


I don't think Zach meant to come off as hostile. It's just that he's usually drunk.

Hater. Just because I've been basking in a post-Hanukkah glow of booze doesn't mean that I'm constantly drunk. And, let's be honest, a Tuesday night?


Let me temper this by saying that the combo effect is irrelevant in a six mana enchantment. It could read "Target player reveals his library, and loses if he reveals Dread Return or any card with Storm", and it wouldn't effect the match-up, because it's six mana.

What Dovescape does is answer control.

It's also very good at winning game 2 against combo. But then they usually just win in their first turn game 3. I've actually taken down belcher (making me currently 1-3 against it in tournament play with Enchantress) with it before, just because I kept a hand with stupid mana and he went for warrens tokens, walking into my turn 2 Ghostly Prison (I used to run it back then), turn 3 Dovescape. I can't say that it's really that good against combo, but if you can resolve it, you win (Ichorid doesn't really feel like combo to me, though, so I'll amend that statement if I have to).

It does give control Fits, though.



Actually, the split is probably going to be better.

A) City of Solitude is not useful in multiples.
B) Cabal Therapy
C) Meddling Mage
D) Haunting Echoes
E) In this particular case, Chalice of the Void
F) What's the disadvantage of overlapping different cards?

A) Agreed.
B) Replenish? Weak answer, I know, but I reckon that decks with Cabal Therapy aren't usually worried about City of Solitude or Eyes of the Wisent
C) Ok. But, just to be picky, who plays him anymore?
D) Extirpate, you say?
E) Is your Faerie Stompy opponent going to set Chalice at 3 just to make sure that his 4 MD'd FOW's resolve while, at the same time, making sure that none of this threats do?
F) Dissenrgy. Wow, I spelled that so poorly that my face hurts. City says, "Don't play shit!" Eyes says, "I dare you to play something!" You'll notice the difference of stratedgies (man, I cannot spell today): With Eyes you are baiting your opponent; with City you turn him off. The two don't play well together because City acutally does the man's share of the work while Eyes goes shoe shopping before a Manni-Petti party.

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-19-2007, 01:34 PM
It's also very good at winning game 2 against combo. But then they usually just win in their first turn game 3. I've actually taken down belcher (making me currently 1-3 against it in tournament play with Enchantress) with it before, just because I kept a hand with stupid mana and he went for warrens tokens, walking into my turn 2 Ghostly Prison (I used to run it back then), turn 3 Dovescape. I can't say that it's really that good against combo, but if you can resolve it, you win (Ichorid doesn't really feel like combo to me, though, so I'll amend that statement if I have to).

It does give control Fits, though.

Notice that Ghostly Prison is the actual reason you won that game. Dovescape by itself would have been irrelevant. It's simply too slow to beat combo, except when you would have won anyway via the conventional Confinement set up.


B) Replenish? Weak answer, I know, but I reckon that decks with Cabal Therapy aren't usually worried about City of Solitude or Eyes of the Wisent

This is usually going to be true, but not universally, and what advantages does running all one or the other really have?


E) Is your Faerie Stompy opponent going to set Chalice at 3 just to make sure that his 4 MD'd FOW's resolve while, at the same time, making sure that none of this threats do?

That doesn't preclude them having threats on the board, and they do have Cloud of Faeries. Also, other decks run CotV.


F) Dissenrgy. Wow, I spelled that so poorly that my face hurts. City says, "Don't play shit!" Eyes says, "I dare you to play something!" You'll notice the difference of stratedgies (man, I cannot spell today): With Eyes you are baiting your opponent; with City you turn him off. The two don't play well together because City acutally does the man's share of the work while Eyes goes shoe shopping before a Manni-Petti party.

How is that any different than having two Cities in play?

The bottom line is there's no signifigant advantage to running all one or the other unless you know that one is clearly superior to the other. If they overlap in most respects, and both are valid candidates, it's usually preferable to run a mix than all one or the other.

Running the mix also gives you the experience necessary to fully determine if one is better than the other.

alebronwebb
12-19-2007, 02:36 PM
@ lonely
Okay i might have written you on the haters list too soon, your're right i don't know you, but you did come of as a little hostile at first. I am new to the Source so I don't know that many people here.

First off i'll try Dovescape against combo and control, probably a 1 or 2 of in SB.

21 lands really isn't that much different than 20, to me atleast, so i might drop a plains for a MD Karmic Justice.

And, yeah, i haven't been really wowed by Eyes. It looks so good but doesn't really deliever. I've decided if you want more threats just play Hoofprints.

Julian23
12-19-2007, 03:19 PM
Here's a list that placed 3rd in a tourney in Germany with ~40 participants:

3. Tom Hens
Maindeck (60 cards): Sideboard: (15 cards)
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Elephant Grass
4 Enchantress's Presence
3 Exploration
2 Ground Seal
2 Sylvan Library
1 Wild Growth
1 City of Solitude
1 Seal of Primordium
4 Sterling Grove
4 Utopia Sprawl
1 Words of War
1 Moat
2 Oblivion Ring
2 Replenish
1 Sacred Mesa
3 Solitary Confinement



Lands (20):
6 Forest
3 Plains
3 Savannah
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga
1 Tropical Island
4 Windswept Heath

SB:
2 Aura of Silence
2 Chill
3 Choke
1 City of Solitude
2 Karmic Justice
4 Leyline of the Void
1 Seal of Primordium


What do you think of it? His Sideboard choices against control seem a bit odd with 2 Chill, 3 Choke and 1 City. Are we anything close to an agreement which of these three is best? Besides that, 2 Library mainboard just seems terrible to me. I used to play one for a long time because of the great Words of War interaction but eventually figured that it's just a win-more card.

Regarding my blue Enchantress:
I changed the win condition from Stroke to Brain Freeze, completly dropped white and added 3-4 Daze mainboard as well as 3 Pact of Negation Sideboard. I played a small tourney in Munich. Sadly the meta was about 80% Landstill but I managed to place 5th out of 13, mostly because of my superior tie-breakers. After this I came to the conclusion that Blue Enchantress has a way better Combo-matchup because it's actually able to interact with your opponents permanents (meaning it can bounce _everything_ as soon as turn3) but is just _too_ fragile to actually even consider beating control.

So, yeah, I'm back GWr Enchantress :-)

Chippo
12-20-2007, 08:36 AM
Hey all,

Thanks for using my deck on this forum (I'm been watching it already for a long time). But for reference Mol is not in Germany but in Belgium.
My deck currently looks a bit different.

Maindeck (60 cards):
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Elephant Grass
4 Enchantress's Presence
3 Exploration
2 Ground Seal
1 Sylvan Library
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
1 Wild Growth
1 Seal of Primordium
4 Sterling Grove
4 Utopia Sprawl
1 Words of War
1 Moat
2 Oblivion Ring
2 Replenish
1 Sacred Mesa
3 Solitary Confinement

Lands (21):
7 Forest
4 Plains
3 Savannah
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath

The sideboard is my biggest difficulty. For the moment it has (out of memory because I don't have access to my deck at work)
SB:
2 Aura of Silence
2 Eyes of the Winsent
2 Null Chamber
3 Choke
1 City of Solitude
2 Karmic Justice
1 Warmth
1 Seal of Primordium

I know I'm missing one but have no clue what it was again.
Nevertheless I removed the chills which where for the occasional goblins but as they are not played anymore I removed them. Also I found the leylines extremely underwhelming as my topdeck skills are not the best.
The point about sylvan library is true and therefore I removed one but on the other hand that thing singlehandedly (what a word) won me 2 games in a tournament where I have words of war and library out and just stopped drawing and pinged him to death. (And I love the library ever since I played survival, I know it's a fetish)
For the moment I'm thinking of changing the chokes to blood moons as they are much better in a metagame of duals. Although choke is more unexpected. I'm still on the verge of this due to the fact of color commitment.

Right thanks for any comment on this.
Cya Tom

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-20-2007, 09:00 PM
Have people reached any conclusions about Eyes?

alebronwebb
12-20-2007, 10:13 PM
@Spat

I have found Eyes to be not really worth it imho, I'd rather play City and just say NO. If you want more win-cons Hoofprints is much better, takes sick advantage of the enchantress engine.

I'll admit I saw Eyes and said "holy crap" this is awesome, but city is really what the deck wants imo. I could be wrong but oh well, thats my two cents.

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-21-2007, 02:28 AM
The thing is I always find myself preferring Choke to City of Solitude. City of Solitude has a more obvious impact, but Choke is just so devestating to their overall gameplan, even without any back up.

City of Solitude obviously does one particular job, with no questions asked, but I've been finding that Choke is just more effective in all the matches where you wanted City.

If you don't have an Enchantress, Choke has an effect, where City doesn't.

If you do have an Enchantress, you have to wait to play it until after you cast City. Choke you could have played afterwards. Either one is going to be countered if they have one (most of the time), but City of Solitude is an easier target for a Krosan Grip. Once either one resolves, your engine should come on line pretty easily; FoW could still stop your next Enchantress if they topdeck it with choke in play, but you now have additional outs in Elephant Grass, which combined with Choke can hold off pressure for a very long time. Against Landstill, City doesn't prevent a sweeper, but Choke sometimes will.

Against decks no playing blue, both are worthless.

I really can't see a scenario where City is better; Choke is less obvious in its job, but more effective.

from Cairo
12-21-2007, 03:51 AM
I really can't see a scenario where City is better; Choke is less obvious in its job, but more effective.

Sensei's Top (stacking Cbalance), FOW or Daze targeting a spell you want to resolve all jump out at me as situations where a City of Solitude on the table is much better than a Choke on the table.

Choke ties up lands for sure, its a good card. But it still allows the opponent to make choices on how they want to budget their mana to answer your threats, and allows them to answer them at instant speed. City of Solitude on the board means you're resolving spells until they find an answer.

I think they both work well together, in that if an opponent has to remove a City of Solitude and they don't have much mana to work with as a result of Choke, they are in alot of trouble. I don't see one of these enchantments as being a real replacement for the other. City of Solitude holds it own and is even stronger when paired with a card that hinders mana use: Choke, Back to Basics, Blood Moon, etc.

alebronwebb
12-21-2007, 04:50 AM
@Spat
I am not gonna argue on bit, pretty much because your spot on.
Theres is a lot of testing to be done to find out which one is "better" in certain spots. The biggest problem against playing blue is well getting them on the board. Personally i would try to bait counters with Choke then land City against most control deck, but thats just me. Choke is very good at just destroying their game plan. But i would feel better if i could sneak in a City the Choke.

Coke is probably better against Landstill because they do paly sweepers like Deed and such.

And against non blue decks, haha Blood Moon (well most of the time). Love the look on Fish player faces.

Man i have a lot of testing to do. Now if i could somewhere to play, man Oklahoma sucks :frown:

GreenOne
12-21-2007, 05:40 AM
City nullifies 4-8 of their cards (FoW + Counterspell/Spell Snare) where Choke nullifies their entire gameplan and has a lot of sinergy with Elephant Grass. It also help a lot in preventing hate: it's hard to play Deed, Krosan Grip, EE, use Sensei's divining top etc without mana. Oh, threats cost mana too.

However, many chokes maybe too redundant.. Usually play 0-1 Cities and 2-3 Chokes.

SpatulaOfTheAges
12-21-2007, 09:46 AM
I agree that a mix is ideal; nothing is as sexy as them tapping out on their turn because of City, then you playing Choke.

I was speaking in terms of limited spots, for instance people who MD one or the other.

Choke lets them budget mana, but without availability to their cantrips, they have so little mana that it's usually irrelevant. Blood Moon is similiar, but I don't like the risks that Blood Moon runs; if they do run a basic forest, Blood Moon could be entirely counteracted. If they get a threat in play first and they have a basic island, they might still have everything they need. It also lets them keep digging with Top, although it does shut off their shuffle effects.

Shtriga
12-26-2007, 02:15 PM
I've been playing this deck a bit for the last couple of days and I found that I really like the auratog+rancor combo

Julian23
12-29-2007, 04:34 PM
The Problem with Auratog and Rancor is that the first is very vulnerable to removal as well as being a non-enchantment spell while Rancor itself sits dead in your hand until you draw the Auratog since you cant enchant your own enchantress. Our current win conditions of choice (Words of War, Sacred Mesa, maybe Hoofprints) are superior choices to me.

Shtriga
12-29-2007, 05:01 PM
yea, I took the togs out as there were a lot of problems involved with him.

hoofprints of the stag on the other hand is sick

SpatulaOfTheAges
01-01-2008, 01:34 PM
I've been playing with it, and I have to say, Hoofprints hasn't excited me.

In the Goyf-meta, however, I've tested and been pretty pleased with Kirtar's Desire/that two mana instant pacifism thing. The former is cheaper, but the latter can be pretty good with Grass(they pay to attack, then you fog them, potentially buying another turn(situationally)).

Hoojo
01-01-2008, 04:34 PM
I've been playing with it, and I have to say, Hoofprints hasn't excited me.

In the Goyf-meta, however, I've tested and been pretty pleased with Kirtar's Desire/that two mana instant pacifism thing. The former is cheaper, but the latter can be pretty good with Grass(they pay to attack, then you fog them, potentially buying another turn(situationally)).

Would Temporal Isolation be more effective?

Temporal Isolation
1W
Enchantment - Aura
Flash
Enchant creature
Enchanted creature has shadow.
Prevent all damage that would be dealt by enchanted creature.

Nihil Credo
01-01-2008, 06:55 PM
Would Temporal Isolation be more effective?

that two mana instant pacifism thing

SpatulaOfTheAges
01-01-2008, 10:29 PM
Yeah that thingy.

I don't have enough testing to say which of the two is better. But one of them seems like a good fit right now; I would say a much better fit than Oblivion Ring.

Honestly. How many times have you(you know who you are) ACTUALLY hit an artifact/enchantment that mattered with that thing?

Zach Tartell
01-01-2008, 11:00 PM
Honestly. How many times have you(you know who you are) ACTUALLY hit an artifact/enchantment that mattered with that thing?

Counterbalance is a bitch. I hit that shit all day long. Or I've slided out a Pernicous Deed when he could only pop it for one, which is pretty sweet.

In reality, the loss of Seal of Doom's happens-right-now-ness sucks. But I'm pretty sure that O-Ring should at least keep 1 MD'd slot, if only because it can hit planeswalkers or other madness. I'll tool around with a singleton of that Shadow-maker in the board for creature matches, maybe two.

Bryant Cook
01-03-2008, 02:28 PM
Counterbalance is a bitch. I hit that shit all day long. Or I've slided out a Pernicous Deed when he could only pop it for one, which is pretty sweet.

In reality, the loss of Seal of Doom's happens-right-now-ness sucks. But I'm pretty sure that O-Ring should at least keep 1 MD'd slot, if only because it can hit planeswalkers or other madness. I'll tool around with a singleton of that Shadow-maker in the board for creature matches, maybe two.

How is Counterbalance a bitch? Half of the deck costs 3. Oblivion ring it. Don't you play three of them?

GreenOne
01-03-2008, 02:43 PM
How is Counterbalance a bitch? Half of the deck costs 3. Oblivion ring it. Don't you play three of them?

Counterbance is not a bitch. Between Oblivion Ring, Aura of Silence, Choke, City of solitude, adn much of the deck being at 3cc I never found Counterbalance to be a significant threat (at least in threshold).

SpatulaOfTheAges
01-03-2008, 07:37 PM
Yeah...and if it is a threat, it's because they found a 3cc spell with Top, in which case O Ring isn't buing out any outs.

I guess occasionally you'll mess up a bad player with Deed, but that's a pretty remote situation for 1-2 mana more over the creature removal you could be running.

GreenOne
01-04-2008, 05:06 AM
I guess occasionally you'll mess up a bad player with Deed, but that's a pretty remote situation for 1-2 mana more over the creature removal you could be running.

I don't think the deck needs a fast creature removal. Oblivion Ring is good vs EE too, as rarely a thresh player has 5 mana to cast it for 3 and activate it in the same turn. same goes for Pernicious Deed in GBx aggro-control decks.
Oblivion Ring is what the deck was asking in terms of a versatile card to deal with hate post side and, with the unbanning of Replenish, is what the deck really needed to be a contender in the meta IMO.

The 2cc creature removal gets hit by Spell Snare too.

PS. that deck is sick. Yesterday I went first turn Utopia Sprawl and the opponent cast in sequence: turn 1 Spell Snare(Argothian), turn 2 Counterbalance, Turn 3 Trygon Predator (?), Turn 4 Trygon Predator (???) and I still won. Oblivion Ring, Replenish and Sterling Grove for the win!

Wallace
01-11-2008, 04:56 PM
Don't know if this will have a place in here?

Idyllic Tutor

http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/images/smilies/mana2.gifhttp://forums.mtgsalvation.com/images/smilies/manaw.gifSorceryhttp://mtgsalvation.com/images/spoiler/morningtide-rare.gifSearch your library for an Enchantment card, reveal it, then put it into your hand. Then shuffle your library.

GreenOne
01-11-2008, 06:48 PM
Don't know if this will have a place in here?

I'd say no. Grove is better at searching for enchantments while the draw engine is on, and it's quite slow to tutor for a Presence and start the engine.

MattH
01-12-2008, 12:06 PM
It's a cool card, but no.

Julian23
01-14-2008, 09:32 AM
One clear "no!" for that tutor in enchantress. I'd rather ran Enlightened Tutor which itself is subpar to Sterling Grove.

Nightmare
01-14-2008, 12:12 PM
When did this site become a Vintage site?

Oh wait, it didn't.

Who gives a crap about Bargain? Stick to relevant Legacy discussion.

BTW, That tutor is pretty bad in Enchantress.

galeng
01-14-2008, 04:50 PM
I've been seeing this deck a lot recently, and heres and it seems to be really fragile. Here are reasons it is so:

1. Scoops to enchantment hate
2. It has 8 of the cards that it absolutely needs to run and those cards can be removed or disrupted (not enough).
3. It seems to only have 2 cards that can win them the game. Whenever I play against this deck, they just mill themselves and lose because they run out of win cons.
4. There is no control element to this deck to protect itself. It's 100% engine. And no, elephant grass doesn't do shit, they'll just pay 2.

Some tips for playing against this deck is to either disrupt their enchantress or their win con (whatever's easier).

Brehn
01-14-2008, 05:03 PM
1. Scoops to enchantment hate
You could say, TES scoops to Combo hate, Ichorid scoops to Graveyard hate, Goblins scoop to Creature hate, ... wait a second, which deck besides Aggro Loam (Burning Wish -> Tranquility) plays serious Enchantment hate? Anyway, just some days ago I've won a game 2 vs Aggro Loam after he played Krosan Grip, Tranquility, Hull Breach, Krosan Grip in this order. Maybe it's because I didn't scoop. Maybe it's also because I played a list that included Replenish.


2. It has 8 of the cards that it absolutely needs to run and those cards can be removed or disrupted (not enough).
I think it has 12. Sterling Groves should count.


3. It seems to only have 2 cards that can win them the game. Whenever I play against this deck, they just mill themselves and lose because they run out of win cons.
Are you sure you're playing against players that actually know the deck? This has never ever happened to me, even after Extirpate.


4. There is no control element to this deck to protect itself. It's 100% engine. And no, elephant grass doesn't do shit, they'll just pay 2.
Elephant Grass doesn't do shit? Moat doesn't do shit? Solitary Confinement doesn't do shit? Yeah, right.

Some tips for playing against this deck is to either disrupt their enchantress or their win con (whatever's easier).
Some tips for playing against Threshold is to either destroy their Goyfs or their Mongeese (whatever's easier). Thanks for the insight.

galeng
01-14-2008, 05:16 PM
What im trying to point out here is that this deck lacks any disruption, where as all the decks you've listed to compare do have a solid disruption package, so they can fight threats like the ones mentioned.

I'm extremely sure this deck just scoops to any disruption, where another deck would just simply answer it.

GreenOne
01-14-2008, 05:17 PM
I've been seeing this deck a lot recently, and heres and it seems to be really fragile. Here are reasons it is so:

1. Scoops to enchantment hate
2. It has 8 of the cards that it absolutely needs to run and those cards can be removed or disrupted (not enough).
3. It seems to only have 2 cards that can win them the game. Whenever I play against this deck, they just mill themselves and lose because they run out of win cons.
4. There is no control element to this deck to protect itself. It's 100% engine. And no, elephant grass doesn't do shit, they'll just pay 2.

Some tips for playing against this deck is to either disrupt their enchantress or their win con (whatever's easier).

1- Who does play Tranquility? However, Replenish works around that (and Pernicious Deed and blahstuff...)
2- You have 4 tutors (sterling grove) to get those 8 cards and sometimes happens that you can just win the game with Sacred Mesa or Hoofprints without an Enchantress effect out. Sometimes Moat wins the game on its own (like vs non-red threshold, vs ichorid, vs 43Lands, etc)
3- There are 3 ways to win the game: Sacred Mesa, Hoofprints and Words of War. You also have 4 tutors to get them before milling and 2 Replenish to get back them if they get countered. You probably played vs incompetent people.
4- The control elements of the deck are here just to gain some time and get the engine running. Believe it or not, Elephant Grass is quite good vs SuiBlack decks, Ichorid, Goblins and Breakfast. It also happens that the deck is playing Oblivion Ring and Moat. Oh, and Solitary confinament can make people scoop quite oftenif your draw engine is on.

Countering win condition doesn't really work, as the deck is capable of assembling it's win conditions and play them in a single turn, and if they get all countered, Replenish them back. Countering The draw engine works thought, as works ruining the manabase with Sinkhole/Pox effects.

What were you playing against Enchantress? I suppose some sort of middle-range disruption deck. The deck has serious problems with Black disruption decks, so maybe you were just playing one of the worst matchups (besides Storm combo).

Brehn
01-14-2008, 05:34 PM
There's a slight difference between "scoops to" and "sometimes has problems with" you might be missing. Sure there might be games where a single Thoughtseize is "gg", but again, there are games where a single Force of Will/Tormod's Crypt/Pernicious Deed is "gg" to TES/Ichorid/Goblins. The comparison to Goblins is not bad though: After two Swords and a Deed they can still go Matron->Ringleader->Warchief+Piledriver and win, without previous disruption. Same applies to this deck: just let them Thoughtseize the Enchantress, Force the Presence, Stifle the Grove, Waste the Sanctum, then cast Replenish and watch them scoop. It reminds me of the Double-Tendrils-plan of Iggy Pop: You have 2 Forces? I don't care.

Also, please explain what you're actually referring to with "disruption". Elephant Grass and Moat can actually be quite disrupting for the aggro player. Also, please tell me which other deck "simply answers" the disruption as you've written, because I might want to pick it up.

dontbiteitholmes
01-14-2008, 06:38 PM
I never found Black to be a terrible matchup. I played this deck when Pikula was heavily played and I found if you get any Enchantress out there's not much they can do about it, even less so if they are Mono-Black, and then every card in your deck cantraps. Not to mention Elephant Grass is almost a Time Walk, Karmic Justice makes LD suck, and now you have Replenish. Also there's plenty of SB options available if Mono-Black was heavily playing in your meta. If anything combo is the real problem.

GreenOne
01-14-2008, 07:16 PM
I never found Black to be a terrible matchup. I played this deck when Pikula was heavily played and I found if you get any Enchantress out there's not much they can do about it, even less so if they are Mono-Black, and then every card in your deck cantraps. Not to mention Elephant Grass is almost a Time Walk, Karmic Justice makes LD suck, and now you have Replenish. Also there's plenty of SB options available if Mono-Black was heavily playing in your meta. If anything combo is the real problem.

I found that Smallpox, LD, vindicate, and edict effects hurts a lot pre-side. Often I just can't reach the 3rd land, too often they 2for1 me with sinkhole vs land+utopia/wild growth. Turn 1 thoughtseize that take away your Enchantress is bad news, as it's a turn 1 Hippie. Not that we can't work around those, but I can't say it's a comfortable matchup. I'd say like 40-60 or worse in G1, 45-55 or 50-50 G2-3. Not great.

dontbiteitholmes
01-14-2008, 07:54 PM
I found that Smallpox, LD, vindicate, and edict effects hurts a lot pre-side. Often I just can't reach the 3rd land, too often they 2for1 me with sinkhole vs land+utopia/wild growth. Turn 1 thoughtseize that take away your Enchantress is bad news, as it's a turn 1 Hippie. Not that we can't work around those, but I can't say it's a comfortable matchup. I'd say like 40-60 or worse in G1, 45-55 or 50-50 G2-3. Not great.
Well for one I've never been a fan of Wild Growth but I can see how that would hurt. The only games I ever lost were ones where I failed to get to 3 lands, but coming out the side I had a second Karmic Justice and single Sacred Ground (because Geddon' was a concern) and there's plenty of ways to side for this matchup. I don't know I still don't like Wild Growth but apparently Lonelybaritone has the be/all end/all say in what's good and what's not in this deck and has plenty of time to write insulting replies so I won't waste my time with that.

Zach Tartell
01-14-2008, 09:12 PM
I was going to let the dust settle and write an excellent, list-filled post about the comparative awesome in different lists and choices in win cons, but then somebody said I'm a dick, and I'm not about to prove him wrong. I'm going to take this from the bottom, and work my way up (In oldness of posts).


Well for one I've never been a fan of Wild Growth but I can see how that would hurt. The only games I ever lost were ones where I failed to get to 3 lands, but coming out the side I had a second Karmic Justice and single Sacred Ground (because Geddon' was a concern) and there's plenty of ways to side for this matchup. I don't know I still don't like Wild Growth but apparently Lonelybaritone has the be/all end/all say in what's good and what's not in this deck and has plenty of time to write insulting replies so I won't waste my time with that.

Since I'm not a fan of disecting posts (on account of you lose that little arrow that you can click on to jump to the post I'm talking about), let's get some sweet, sweet list function on!


Wild Growth - I agree with you, hoss. I don't quite follow what you say hurts with it (loss of the land it's enchanting? I suppose that counts), but the problem with cards like that is that you can lose the land they're attached to, setting yourself up for 2-for-1-ery. I've been a pretty stout advocate of the 20 land, 4 Exploration, 4 Utopia Sprawl configuration since the start. Well, at least since I stopped running Form of the Dragon as a win-con.
Like I done said, it's tough to find the perfect amount of land. One memorable local I left two beta Savannahs (yes - let me flaunt my beta Savannahs) stuck in my deck box, playing a 59-card, 18-land deck. I never once was stuck on 2 or 3 land, and frequently got land flooded. Maybe 22 (via GreenOne or SpatulaOfTheAges's builds) lands would be better for you.
Karmic Justice is straight nuts agaisnt a lot of difficult matches. It makes Pernicous Deed more often than not both a one-sided Wrath of God and Armageddon for the mere cost of waiting to rebuild via playing a ridiculously redundant deck or Replenish.
I kind of stopped running Sacred Ground, which is unfortunate - I had literally just picked up a playset of Russian 9th ones when I decided to set my Serra's Sanctums aside for a while and try my hand at other archtypes. It's really good at waht it does. The only problem is that I'd rather run something to help me bounce back from discard (e.g.: Spiritual Focus) than something to help me bounce back from land desturction. If Armageddon or Waste-locks (or Smokestack, for that matter) are big in your meta, run this guy. If not, there are better things. Totally up to you.
Damn straight I'm the end-all be-all of Enchantress. If you want to send me money for being this awesome, I'll PM you my address.



I found that Smallpox, LD, vindicate, and edict effects hurts a lot pre-side. Often I just can't reach the 3rd land, too often they 2for1 me with sinkhole vs land+utopia/wild growth. Turn 1 thoughtseize that take away your Enchantress is bad news, as it's a turn 1 Hippie. Not that we can't work around those, but I can't say it's a comfortable matchup. I'd say like 40-60 or worse in G1, 45-55 or 50-50 G2-3. Not great.

I don't want to come off condecending at all here, hoss. You frequently bump this thread enough for me to talk a bunch, and we all know that I love the sound of my own voice. But you have such a problem with black agro? My most recent list does honestly have only two Elephant Grass mained, but I don't really have that much mono-:b: agro to sweat in my meta. Is your issue with discard, quick creatures, or LD?


There's a slight difference between "scoops to" and "sometimes has problems with" you might be missing. Sure there might be games where a single Thoughtseize is "gg", but again, there are games where a single Force of Will/Tormod's Crypt/Pernicious Deed is "gg" to TES/Ichorid/Goblins. The comparison to Goblins is not bad though: After two Swords and a Deed they can still go Matron->Ringleader->Warchief+Piledriver and win, without previous disruption. Same applies to this deck: just let them Thoughtseize the Enchantress, Force the Presence, Stifle the Grove, Waste the Sanctum, then cast Replenish and watch them scoop. It reminds me of the Double-Tendrils-plan of Iggy Pop: You have 2 Forces? I don't care.

Also, please explain what you're actually referring to with "disruption". Elephant Grass and Moat can actually be quite disrupting for the aggro player. Also, please tell me which other deck "simply answers" the disruption as you've written, because I might want to pick it up.

I agree with your statements, broseph, but there are a couple things we should clarify. LIST FTW!!

I'll drink to the difference between "scoops to," and "has problems with." The problem is, though, that Enchantress scoops it to a compotent Storm Combo player. Unless you really change up your list Main (and have like tons of hate side) you're almost always going to lose game 1, maybe win game 2, and lose game 3. There are, of course, rare exceptions. But that's pretty much how it goes.
High five on pointing out static disruption! (if, by some weird chance, I just invented a new term for magic, then two high fives) We dont' have much in the way of reactive, like permission, or pre-emptive disrutpion (like discard), so we have to rely on stuff that fits the kind fo stuff we like:

An Enchantment, if possible.
Not terribly narrow.
Relatively permenant.

Thusly stuff like Rule of Law (when we aren't combo-ing off with Words of War), Ground Seal (having dropped Holistic Wisdom), and Moat are execllent cards for our deck. Screw Thoughtsieze. That shit costs like more than ten bucks a pop still (complained the man with the entirely pimp Enchantress deck).



I've been seeing this deck a lot recently, and heres and it seems to be really fragile. Here are reasons it is so:

1. Scoops to enchantment hate
2. It has 8 of the cards that it absolutely needs to run and those cards can be removed or disrupted (not enough).
3. It seems to only have 2 cards that can win them the game. Whenever I play against this deck, they just mill themselves and lose because they run out of win cons.
4. There is no control element to this deck to protect itself. It's 100% engine. And no, elephant grass doesn't do shit, they'll just pay 2.

Some tips for playing against this deck is to either disrupt their enchantress or their win con (whatever's easier).

Even though everybody else made fun of you already, I'ma get my licks in too.

Yes, we do have issues with Enchantment hate. I will totally accept a 10% win percentage (it appears that I used the same word twice in a sentence) against Kavu/Cure. All day. As for a more specific hate, what are you thinking of? I don't really think that a 3-of Krosan Grip in the board is something worth scooping to, nor, for that matter, is a 3-of in Pernicous Deed. Karmic Justice is the answer to that kind of stuff, and I'm totally cool with being a little naked against hate. It's not like a well-timed Orim's Chant or Force of WIll turns into 6 or 8 mana burn and a definte game loss (or, at least, not that often).
I'ma suppose that this refers to the Enchantress effects? Totally unnecessary to win, but I'll admit that winning without them is a heck of a lot harder. The addition of Hoofprints of the Stag as a win-con (or rather stalling measure) has helped that whole "I need my Enchantresses" problem a whole bunch.
I'll admit that, as a non-math teacher, my counting skills aren't quite top-notch, but I seem to find four. Want to caucus in the hallway and see what we can come up with together? As to the decking themselves, they are clearly pretty new players to the deck. For instance, I've recently put Solidarity together, and I have all kinds of trouble with figuring out The Stack. Give 'em time; I'm sure they'll do fine.
Let me thumb through my current build of Enchantress and see what kind of disruption I run in Enchantment form between the main and the side:

4 Elephant Grass (slows down creatures, is essentially a win against Ichorid and Cephalid Breakfast if it can be maintained, and pretty freaking nuts against :b:-based agro)
1 Moat (it turns out that a fair few Thresh players don't run fliers, or only one or two. Moat also pwns goblin's face until they tutor up a SCG and start tossing goblins at you. Know what this plays well with?)
2 Humility (yup. I think that this shuts off creatures pretty solid. I'll freely admit that it sucks when I have an Argothian out, but it's usually worth the pain)
3 Blood Moon (I hear this deck called Dragon Stompy is making noise around the world. What was that enchantment that costs :2::r: that shuts down non-basics?)
2 Oblivion Ring (sorcery-speed Swords? I don't mind that you get whatever it is back, though - I'll probably be winning by then)
3 Ground Seal (ever play Breakfast and combo off through this? I want to hear that story)
2 City of Solitude (in my experience it's difficult to play counterspells when these are on the table. Unless you counter your own stuff to build storm!)
2 Aura of Silence (this is pretty good at slowing down Stax-centered decks)
I honestly almost forgot Solitary Confinement (x3)
1 Null Chamber (it's so rare that you have a knowledgeable opponent that this is often a one-sided Meddling Mage that forces you to use your other win condition, maybe)
1 Dovescape (I've heard this is pretty good against board control decks. Even 43 land, if you think about it. LFTL doesn't come back, ever, and I'm not afraid of one or two of my Doves getting Maze of Ith'd back)
COP:Red (I'm not sure this'd count, though, on account of it only really R0xx0rz against Burn, Goyf Sligh, and Goblins. Those are pretty good decks, though)

So, yes, you are correct; if you choose to discount Elephant Grass then only like 30 of my 76 MB&SB cards help to control the board against various decks.


I'm too lazy to go up much farther than that, so I think I'll leave it here. Interesting last thought, though:

While testing with the crew, Adam "Nightmare" Barnello made the comment that this deck was like a 12 card engine desiged to pack 4 hate cards against every single deck (not like 4 cards that hate every deck, so much as a deck full of bullets) and too few win conditions. I thought it was worth a chuckle, when I sat back and thought about it.

SpatulaOfTheAges
01-15-2008, 01:48 AM
Damn straight I'm the end-all be-all of Enchantress. If you want to send me money for being this awesome, I'll PM you my address.

I created you; I can destroy you just as easily.


2. It has 8 of the cards that it absolutely needs to run and those cards can be removed or disrupted (not enough).

8 Enchantresses +
3-4 Sterling Grove
1-3 Replenish
1-2 Moat
1 Sacred Mesa
0-1 Hoofprints of the Stag
Usually a couple random slots that may or may not need to be countered(Kirtar's Desire/O Ring/Library/Aura of Silence/Ground Seal/Elephant Grass/City of Solitude/Choke).

dontbiteitholmes
01-15-2008, 03:26 AM
I created you; I can destroy you just as easily.



8 Enchantresses +
3-4 Sterling Grove
1-3 Replenish
1-2 Moat
1 Sacred Mesa
0-1 Hoofprints of the Stag
Usually a couple random slots that may or may not need to be countered(Kirtar's Desire/O Ring/Library/Aura of Silence/Ground Seal/Elephant Grass/City of Solitude/Choke).
Dude 1 Jester's Cap = you lose. [/sarcasm]

@lonelybaritone- I pretty much have always agreed on all those notes to me, except the Wild Growth (by which I also mean Sprawl) and you being the end-all part. Sacred Ground was a 1 of in my side for a while granted this was atleast a year ago and well before Tarmogoyf when AngelStompy and even Goblins both had the possibility of 'Geddon. Of course now things are much different and I don't think any real deck threatens land sweep so I wouldn't waste SB on it now.
-edit Also the way I see it Utopia Sprawl, which obviously >> Wild growth is in a way kind of a meta call.

revenge_inc
01-15-2008, 03:26 AM
Would this deck benefit from Horizon Canopy? (maybe cutting one plains and one forest?)

Xero
01-15-2008, 03:41 AM
Would this deck benefit from Horizon Canopy? (maybe cutting one plains and one forest?)

Canopy seems unnecessary. The deck already has enough card draw and no way to recur lands. It's not worth the pain and the vulnerability to Waste.

revenge_inc
01-15-2008, 05:24 AM
Canopy seems unnecessary.

The keyword there is seems. Would there ever be a time where this deck would benefit from the Canopy's card-drawing ability...


It's not worth the pain and the vulnerability to Waste.

...and if so, how does its ability stand vs the disadvantages you have just named?

Julian23
01-15-2008, 01:12 PM
I also dislike Horizon Canopy in this deck since we already run a low land count (20 or 22), usually 8 nonbasics (not counting Heath) and 4 Utopia Sprawl (which can't enchant Canopy). Thus we're rather vulnerable to LD in the earlygame (which is key to developing board/card advantage).

Regarding the benefits I'd say that you clearly _don't_ want a Canopy in the early game since more than often we keep 2/3 land hands and can't afford losing one. We also don't want Canopy _that_ much in the middle- or lategame since by then our draw enginge should be up and running and with 1/2 Exploration(s) in play I'd rather actually "use" a land than "waste" my exploration-land drop for 1 more card; especially because with 1 more mana you usually draw about 2/3+ cards from dropping another 1 mana enchantment which are quite frequent in this deck.. ;-)

GreenOne
01-15-2008, 03:03 PM
I don't want to come off condecending at all here, hoss. You frequently bump this thread enough for me to talk a bunch, and we all know that I love the sound of my own voice. But you have such a problem with black agro? My most recent list does honestly have only two Elephant Grass mained, but I don't really have that much mono-:b: agro to sweat in my meta. Is your issue with discard, quick creatures, or LD?


The problem comes with dark ritual powered starts (like into thoughtseize + confidant or hippie) and LD. Smallpox is a beating if you have just played argothian too.
I'm running a 22 lands + 4 Sprawl + 2/3 Wild Growth with 2/3 Explorations. I don't miss the 4th exploration at all, and I'm still unsure about the 3rd Expl or 3rd Wild Growth. I really want that land-auras on turn 1 to play a Presence on turn 2, and I really can't see how you don't get screwed with only 20 lands and 2-3 less enchant lands. Maybe it's me, but I open quite frequently a 1 or 2 lands hand.
There's not that much mono :b: or pikula style decks in my meta, that's why I don't care and play the deck anyway. However, I see it as one of the worst matchups after storm combo, considering the Tier ones.

Can you post your most recent list so I can ctrl+c and ctrl+v it to try it and test my land+Exploration skillz?

On another note, if I knew that I'd never become a CanG judge. Those signed Presences are sooo sweet...

Julian23
01-15-2008, 03:52 PM
For the record, my current list:

4x Savannah
2x Taiga
2x Serra's Sanctum
4x Windswept Heath
8x Forest
2x Plains

4x Argothian Enchantress
4x Enchantress' Presence
4x Sterling Grove
4x Utopia Sprawl
4x Elephant Gras
3x Solitary Confinement
2x Ground Seal
2x Exploration
2x Oblivion Ring
2x Replenish
1x Seal of Primordium
1x Aura of Silence
1x City of Solitude
1x Sacred Mesa
1x Words of War
1x Karmic Justice

SB:
4x Rule of Law
3x Choke
3x City of Solitude
3x Aura of Silence
1x Dovescape
1x Sacred Ground

This computer at my university automatically shuts down in 30 seconds, I hope I managed to get everything right.

Zach Tartell
01-16-2008, 12:03 AM
@lonelybaritone- I pretty much have always agreed on all those notes to me, except ....you being the end-all part.

Clearly you weren't thinking correctly when you wrote this. It's understandable - maybe it's hot where you live right now. Or you haven't slept much.

As for the inclusion of Wild Growth (I don't care to look it up on gatherer, so I hope that's the "tap for :g:" one. it's it's the :1::g: one then I'd be awfully embarrassed), I actually meant WIld Growth. GreenOne and the Hatfields have advocated running less explorations and more 1cc accel spells that acutally accel.

Julian23 - Do you actually enjoy those Rule of Laws? Doe they help appreciatable-ly?

Matt: Additional weak Star Wars quote - none come to mind right now.

Julian23
01-16-2008, 12:00 PM
I went 3-2 in my last tournament winning against Cephalid Breakfeast, Aggro Loam and Solidarity with losses against Solidarity and Landstill. At least the loss against Solidarity should have at least been a tie if it wasn't for one more extra turn (after he fizzled after comboing out for about..15? minutes *grr*).

In the two matches versus Solidarity Rule of Law was sooo good (suprise!). Resolving it on turn2/3 backuped by Sterling Grove is such a beating for the blue mage. Once you follow it up with City of Solitude you've almost established a hardlock since your opponent will only be able to bounce the Sterling Grove on his turn and sit still, watching you replay it the next turn. Along with Choke, more Cities and Dovescape from the SB I'm close to declaring Solidarity a "not-so-unfavorable" matchup.
Aggro Loam was just a piece of cake, especially since he didnt run Bruning Wish ( o_0! ). Resolve Confinement and win.
Cephalid Breakfest taught me how important Elephant Grass is. In game 2 he even forced my turn 2 grass discarding his only other blue card, Cephalid Illusionist.

With the rise of Angel Stax (at least in my meta) I think its important to pack both Seal of Primordium _and_ Aura of Silence since otherwise Chalice might rape us even more than it already does.

Regarding Exploration: I think its time to drop the credo, that Enchantress _has_ to run 4 of them. This believe is a relict of old Extended times, when Enchantress was a different deck that abused the Exporation/Words of Wind interaction like several Top8-performances of that time proved (especially Gabriel Nassif at 2003 Yokohama Masters). Nowadays Exploration is just a nice card to draw while running through your card as it gives you something to do with extra lands you draw. But its no more one of the key card the deck revolves around so people should leave the "4-Exploration!"-Dogma behind and not hesitate to fill 1 or 2 slots with buisness-cards.

Right now I'm considering including one Null Chamber again, because Pernicious Deed (even with Replenish/Justice) is just such a beating.


Just my 2 cent :-)

Brehn
01-16-2008, 02:41 PM
Regarding Exploration: I think its time to drop the credo, that Enchantress _has_ to run 4 of them.

I'd go even farther: I think it's time to drop the credo, that Enchantress _has_ to run Exploration. I've been playing Exploration-less lists for some time now and I can't imagine a single situation besides the 4 Land, 1 Exploration, 1 Moat-Hand, where Wild Growth is not strictly better. Also, Wild Growth allows you to run 21 lands, thus 33 Enchantments. The skeleton of my list:

21 Lands:
2 Serra's Sanctum
4 Savannah
4 Windswept Heath
1 Taiga
7 Forest
3 Plains

8 "Sinkhole sucks"-cards:
4 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl -- yep. Sprawls.

12 ZOMG they're so easy to disrupt, yeah right-cards:
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Sterling Grove

5 Cards made of win:
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
2 Replenish

8 Static disruption (nice term, lonelybaritone :] ) cards:
1 Moat
4 Elephant Grass
3 Solitary Confinement

====
54 cards that are almost completely set into stone. I'm only thinking about:
- maybe cutting a Savannah for a basic land
- maybe cutting Hoofprints of the Stag
- maybe fitting in a third Replenish

The other 6 cards are meta-dependant. In an unkown meta my choice would be:
3 Ground Seal
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Karmic Justice
Deed/Explosives-heavy meta: More Karmic Justice. Strange seemingly mono-blue meta (aka Worlds): Well, let's try those 3 City of Solitude. Aggro meta: More Rings. Combo meta: umm.... let's play Threshold. Or Stax.

Also, I would never recommend Blood Moon. This is just not the right deck. It's too symmetrical, it requires to fetch a Taiga or waste a Sprawl on an unneeded color, it doesn't win because everybody is prepared for it unless it comes down turn 1. Turn 1 Moon is actually the main reason Dragon Stompy rapes decks. Just run Choke in the board for blue-based 3-or-4-color decks and Karmic Justice for non-blue 3-or-4-color decks, as the only thing they have is Explosives and Deed.

Bovinious
01-16-2008, 03:23 PM
I doubt you run 8 Sterling Grove, so Im guessing the other 4 Sinkhole sucks cards are Utopia Sprawls. I dont think just cutting Exploration seems wise, the format is only getting faster and Exploration helps speed the deck up I think. Especially without much active distruption speed seems really important to this deck, to me anyways.

Brehn
01-16-2008, 04:15 PM
Could you explain how Exploration speeds up the deck?

Compare:
1st turn Land, Wild Growth, 2nd turn Land, Presence. 4 cards in your hand.
1st turn Land, Exploration, Land, 2nd turn Land, Presence. 3 cards in your hand.

Forest, Exploration, Argothian, Ground Seal, 3 random nonland --- keep or mull?
Forest, Wild Growth, Argothian, Ground Seal, 3 random nonland --- keep or mull?

Land, Land, Exploration, Presence, 3 random nonland --- solid or meh?
Land, Land, Wild Growth, Presence, 3 random nonland --- solid or meh?

22 land, 4 Exploration, 4 Utopia Sprawl: 26 mana sources, in the early game you can speed up by playing 2 mana sources per turn.
21 land, 4 Wild Growth, 4 Utopia Sprawl; 29 mana sources, in the early game you can speed up by playing 2 mana sources per turn.

In my opinion, this sums the Exploration vs Wild Growth debate up, Wild Growth is strictly better in 90% of the situations, because Exploration needs at least 4 lands to be abused. There are some exceptions where it is possible to have 4+ mana available on turn 2 with Explorations to cast Moat - nice vs the Goblin-nutdraw(TM), nice vs Breakfast, nice vs Ichorid, nice vs EtW-Tokens. However drawing the Hey-I-Can-Has-4-Mana-On-Turn-2-Hand PLUS a Moat seems so highly improbable that I doubt its relevance. That's what we play Elephant Grass/Ground Seal/Solitary Confinement for.

Bovinious
01-16-2008, 04:29 PM
Could you explain how Exploration speeds up the deck?

Compare:
1st turn Land, Wild Growth, 2nd turn Land, Presence. 4 cards in your hand.
1st turn Land, Exploration, Land, 2nd turn Land, Presence. 3 cards in your hand.

Forest, Exploration, Argothian, Ground Seal, 3 random nonland --- keep or mull?
Forest, Wild Growth, Argothian, Ground Seal, 3 random nonland --- keep or mull?

Land, Land, Exploration, Presence, 3 random nonland --- solid or meh?
Land, Land, Wild Growth, Presence, 3 random nonland --- solid or meh?

22 land, 4 Exploration, 4 Utopia Sprawl: 26 mana sources, in the early game you can speed up by playing 2 mana sources per turn.
21 land, 4 Wild Growth, 4 Utopia Sprawl; 29 mana sources, in the early game you can speed up by playing 2 mana sources per turn.

In my opinion, this sums the Exploration vs Wild Growth debate up, Wild Growth is strictly better in 90% of the situations, because Exploration needs at least 4 lands to be abused. There are some exceptions where it is possible to have 4+ mana available on turn 2 with Explorations to cast Moat - nice vs the Goblin-nutdraw(TM), nice vs Breakfast, nice vs Ichorid, nice vs EtW-Tokens. However drawing the Hey-I-Can-Has-4-Mana-On-Turn-2-Hand PLUS a Moat seems so highly improbable that I doubt its relevance. That's what we play Elephant Grass/Ground Seal/Solitary Confinement for.

Yeah Exploration is good when you have lands to drop and not so good when you dont...from my experience with this deck it usually does have lands to drop. Im not saying Exploration is better than Wild Growth Im saying I dont think it should be cut completely, Sprawl and Growth are good too. Also "strictly better in 90% of the situations" has no meaning.

Brehn
01-16-2008, 04:38 PM
Yeah Exploration is good when you have lands to drop and not so good when you dont...from my experience with this deck it usually does have lands to drop.
How much lands do you play? From my experience it doesn't. I think I've explained why Exploration needs 4 lands to be better than Wild Growth and you usually don't have 4 lands and an Exploration in your good-to-mediocre opening hand.


Im not saying Exploration is better than Wild Growth Im saying I dont think it should be cut completely, Sprawl and Growth are good too. Also "strictly better in 90% of the situations" has no meaning.

Yeah, I guess that makes all my points superfluous.

Tarmogoyf is "strictly better in 90% of the situations" than Werebear. Blood Moon lock, 3 lands and 4 instants in your grave.... Werebear shouldn't be entirely cut? Run a 2/2-split?

Bovinious
01-16-2008, 04:40 PM
How much lands do you play? From my experience it doesn't. I think I've explained why Exploration needs 4 lands to be better than Wild Growth and you usually don't have 4 lands in your good-to-mediocre opening hand.



Yeah, I guess that makes all my points superfluous.

Tarmogoyf is "strictly better in 90% of the situations" than Werebear. Blood Moon lock, 3 lands and 4 instants in your grave.... Werebear shouldn't be entirely cut? Run a 2/2-split?

I dont play the deck, but Ive played against it some and I never see anyone win with 2 lands on the table, just saying.

Strictly better means its better all the time, so adding the 90% just means the word "strictly" doesnt apply. Its like saying "90% of the time it works all the time", like in Anchorman. Some Thresh lists do run 2/4 Werebear in addition to 4 Goyf/Goose...so I dont know where you are going with that, all Im saying is Exploration shouldnt be cut on the sole reason Wild Growth is (perhaps) better.

Brehn
01-16-2008, 04:54 PM
I've never seen Enchantress winning on turn 3, just saying. (well, does that Stax player scooping to T2 Sacred Ground T3 Aura of Silence count? Then I've won with 2 lands on the table.)

Ok, you got me there with "strictly", that should be removed. The "90%" stays however, and I fail to see how Exploration is not one of the cards you either run as a zero- or as a four-of.

GreenOne
01-17-2008, 10:13 AM
@ Brehn: I'm with you in the Exploration vs Wild Growth debate, and like to add something I said about that 3-4 pages ago about the probabilities of drawing a certain number of lands in a 22 lands build:


I found that an enchant-land on turn 1 is crucial for the deck. This helps playing an enchantress effect on turn 2 and develop your early mana. I really prefer the enchant lands to a massive amount of explorations. Explorations are good when you're digging faster through your deck, and at this point you're already in a winning position. I also saw that I rarely used all my exploration effects in the first 3-4 turns.

Let's suppose we got a 1 lander (10% of possibility). Maybe it's keepable with an enchant land+argothian. It's auto-mull if got exploration instead.

..or a 2 lander (25% of possibility). Here having an exploration is useless on turn 1 unless we draw a land on turn 2. Wild growth shines instead.

Let's suppose we have 3 lands (30% of the times). Here Exploration does the same job of Wild growth in the first turns unless we draw a land on turn 2, or 2 consecutive lands on turn 3.

A hand with 4 or more lands is quite strange to analyze, as it's difficult to have 4+ lands, an exploration and an enchantress effect on 7 cards. And I would mulligan this hand if it doesn't contain an enchantress effect.

Enchant land effects become even better if you're mulliganing, As the average number of lands in hand decrease.
It's also worth noting that 2xEploration is ALWAYS useless in the first turns.


Eploration is useful when you're comboing out and wan to play NOW that Taiga or Sanctum that allows you to win one turn faster. That's why I believe that Exploration it's not a "0 or 4" card. We can decide to run just 1 or 2 because we don't want it in the opening grip, but we'd like to draw it mid-combo.

I'm currently running a 2xExploration build and quite happy with it. Cuttin them, however, could be better. I'll test it and say how it goes.

strom
01-19-2008, 09:35 AM
Eploration is useful when you're comboing out

This is true and thats the reason why its bad to cut Exploration completely.
I think its ok to split 2/2 Exploration/Wild Growth.
We have to remember, that there are enough situations where an Exploration is a lot better than Wld Growth (cards like Rishadan Port, Sinkhole and Deed come to my mind).

Just for reference: Last week I went to a rather big tournament (95 participants) an finished 5-2. I won vs. Dragon Stompy, RGW Beatz with Loam, Tarmosligh, 3c Landstill and Doran.dec (including Duress, Hymn and Deed). I lost to UBTrinketnought (mainly because of two games full of bad draws and manaflood) and 4c ***** (first game a Moat screwed him, second game a Winter Orb screwd me and third game my moat got Forced...)

To sum it up: Karmic Justice is insane and needs to be a MD 1-of.
Moat and Replenish are broken (yeah -you knew that before, I guess)
Counterbalance is a bitch.

GiantGrowth
01-31-2008, 01:33 PM
I am fairly new to enchantress, and I could use some advice. After board control has been assumed, what is the fastest way to turn that control into me winning the game. Several of my games on MWS have consisted of me spending the first 5 minutes making sure there is nothing my opponent can do, then 15-20 of me assembling the win. Any tips on how to speed up that winning process would be much appreciated. (aside from speeding up the playspeed in general)

on a second note, just to keep from making another thread in the rules forum. If I have sacred mesa, and no pegasus tokens. Can't I respond to the ability at the beginning of my upkeep by making a token to sac?

Brehn
01-31-2008, 01:47 PM
There is nothing wrong with winning slowly. Usually I set up a Confinement/Moat lock and protect it with Grove / double Grove before actually trying to win. This is another reason why I'm no advocate of Exploration at all - I don't even need it "mid-combo" because I don't need to win one turn faster if I've achieved a lock. I don't do "combo", I do "lock" and "occassionally win". Compare it to Vintage Stax builds with Goblin Welder as the only win condition or whatever. Enchantress is not a combo deck.

However, this strategy fails against decks carrying Deeds and/or Explosives. In this case, try to draw / tutor for Words of War or Mesa + Sanctum and finish him off fast. Remember though, that Karmic Justice can often maintain the lock against Deeds and Explosives. You wipe my Confinements, I wipe your board and will cast Replenish next turn.

Concerning the Mesa question, it is possible to do so.

GiantGrowth
02-02-2008, 12:42 AM
I really hate to turn this thread into a FAQ for noobs, so I'm not going to ask you a question, I'm going to ask you where to find the answer.

I seem to be having some trouble winning with this deck. I know it can be awesome, I've seen it and done it. But I'm having some trouble picking up how to effectively play it well consistently(on MWS anyways, I don't own the deck... yet :wink: ). I've read that this deck is difficult to play (w00t, goes my fragile self esteem) and so I was wondering, are there any sort of primers/instructional readings that would help a poor noob like myself? (I've looked briefly but my search returned no fruit)

And if such a primer/instructional reading doesn't exist for such a difficult deck to play, I think that should change.

Redlotus27
02-03-2008, 12:26 PM
Has anyone tried using Sylvan Library to turbocharge the words of war win condition?

The way I understand it is that if you replace the draws from library, you dont have to cough up the life or replace any cards since you never drew them. Just having the library means a minimum 6 damage per turn assuming no further draws are generated and replaced. This sounds like the solution to the how can I end games faster problem.

alebronwebb
02-03-2008, 04:49 PM
Sylvan Library has been in the deck for along time, though it has been removed lately.

I used to run two Library but cut them for Hoofprints of the Stag and something else which eludes of right now. I still like them since it pretty much kill the opponent in 1-2 turns when going off.

EDIT: I agree with Julian23 that it is a win-more, the danger of cool things I suppose. Board control is far more important than winning that exact moment.

Julian23
02-04-2008, 09:52 AM
Sylvan has been tested by many players during the last months and been declared not good enough. It's just a "win-more" condition that uses up slots for business-spells. Sure, that 4 more damage per turn might come in handy but I'd rather cast a 1-mana spell and pay 2 colorless for the same effect if that means that I can cut library.
The point is, enchantress is no deck, that "combos out" at one turn and just wins. Enchantress' first aim is to either establish boardcontrol against aggro or resolve key-spells against combo (like Ground Seal, Rule of Law, Confinement etc.). Only after that we _start_ winning over a period of 2-3 turns via Mesa/Words.

Aznopium
02-04-2008, 03:44 PM
I seem to be having some trouble winning with this deck. I know it can be awesome, I've seen it and done it. But I'm having some trouble picking up how to effectively play it well consistently(on MWS anyways, I don't own the deck... yet :wink: ). I've read that this deck is difficult to play (w00t, goes my fragile self esteem) and so I was wondering, are there any sort of primers/instructional readings that would help a poor noob like myself? (I've looked briefly but my search returned no fruit)
.

I am the new to the board, been running the enchantress in different forms for awhile (Auratog in the old days now to the current type build).

Enchantress is not an easy to play. Period. Even when you play in correctly, have the right cards, you can still lose vs. the other top legacy decks. For me, you have to mull aggresivly to get the cards you need to start with to have a chance at winning. Having 3x Exploration or 3 sprawls with no Enchatnress stuff/ Grove aint gonna help. You have to lock down w/Confinement/Moat/Prison/Grass/G Seal whatever it is asap.

Once you lock, you start getting the cards from enchatnress to setup the win either via hoofprtints, war, mesa whatever. Winning is usually not a one turn massive Words of War/Mesa combo but over a few turns. The most important thing is locking in and keeping your lock mechanism in play before slowing killing them (over 2 to 4 turns) with your win coniditons.

Make sure you are maximizing your draw and that you make correct plays. Play mistakes with the deck is usually gg for you.

GiantGrowth
02-11-2008, 12:31 AM
Hey, heres something to stir up some discussion. I saw an enchantress deck on mws running a different kill con than words of war. Not sure if its any better, but they were using words of worship+test of endurance, piqued my interest a little and I thought it would do this thread good to get some discussion going.

Brehn
02-11-2008, 07:06 AM
You can also win via Words of Wilding or Words of Wind. However, it's suboptimal.

Words of War: 2R for an Enchantment that wins the game.
Words of Wind: 2U for an Enchantment that wins the game.
Words of Worship: 2W for an Enchantment that doesn't win the game. It needs to be accompanied by an Enchantment costing 2WW that does absolutely nothing.
Words of Wilding: 2G for an Enchantment that wins but sucks in combination with Moat. That's why Hoofprints are run.

The only problem of Words of Wind is that it's not useful unless you're winning. Words of War can be used in an emergency situation to kill that Siege-Gang Commander, Goblin Piledriver, Meddling Mage or Hypnotic Specter that's preventing you from setting up. The other two Words enchantments don't fit in the deck.

Zach Tartell
02-11-2008, 04:58 PM
Words of Wind: 2U for an Enchantment that wins the game.

This is where you're wrong, hoss. Words of Wind doesn't win the game - it stops agro and control players from winning the game. Without a wincon all you do is sit there bouncing an Exploration and a Serra's Sanctum while your opponent doesn't do anything. This is really nice against decks that rely on having stuff out to win (e.g.: Almost everything), but it doesn't actually win the game for you. That's my biggest problem, and also why I don't understand the blue splash. Red has Moon, which rocks, and Words of War. Blue has All kinds of cool utility stuff (like In the Eye of Chaos, Energy Flux, Energy Field (or whatever - the one that prevents all damage to you), and probably a couple others), but it warrents the necessity of adding another win condition to the deck. I don't dig it, even a little.

Daze
02-11-2008, 05:02 PM
Words of Wind wins the game by decking the opponent. You won't draw any cards, and your opponent won't be able to do anything.

Brehn
02-11-2008, 05:23 PM
As Daze said, Words of Wind wins the game. However, it takes a long time (in tournaments often too much) and doesn't kill creatures.
Also, Blood Moon sucks. Everybody is prepared for it and it's extremely symmetrical.

SpatulaOfTheAges
02-14-2008, 02:28 PM
Words of Wind requires you to not be on game 3. If you're trying to win game 3 with Words of Wind, you're in a much worse position than if you were just running WoWar.

alebronwebb
02-15-2008, 04:47 PM
The Words of Wind subject can be viewed as such: Is it better than the other win-cons?
Sacred Mesa, nope, I personaly like getting a bunch of flying creatures.
Hoofprints (my new favorite card in the deck) absolutly not, can be very fast.
Words of War, nope, WoR is useful to clear the board if you need to and can be very fast also.

Words of Wind can work as a win-con, but imo, not in a tournament setting. It just takes way to long to deck them. Also the blue splash doesn't really make sense to, all you get is a bunch of cute stuff. Energy Flux is pretty much one of the stand out cards to me, but we have stuff in our colors that already stop artifacts, enchantments, creatures, well pretty much everything.

Joon
02-22-2008, 03:26 PM
Could anyone post his or her recent list? I have just pretty old lists aviable.

I guess the core consists of

4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove
2 Serra's Sanctum (obv.)
x Moat (one? Or two for the case that one gets EE'd, deeded away or so?)
x Confinement (I guess 3-4 as we want to draw them asap?)
3-4 Sylvan Library (insane with Hoofprints, one of our Winconditions)
1 Words of War (second Wincondition)

Now the questions are coming up:

Should Elephant Grass be played? Same question, but this time about Exploration? How much effects of Utopia Sprawl like cards should be run? Should we run any of these cards?

I suppose GW is fix (white for Moat, Hoofprints, Confinement and Grove, green for the whole Engine in form of Echantress effects). A slight red splash in form of one Taiga (Sprawls make red too if you wish them to do so) for Words of Wilding and maybe Blood Moon? Black could also be played (The Abyss, Seal of Doom and nasty things like that). What about blue for a very nice Tutor in form of Intuition or Gifts Ungiven (Gifts is pretty good with holistic wisdom)?

As I wrote before, my list is very old, but here it is:

// Deck file for Magic Workstation (http://www.magicworkstation.com)

// Lands
4 [R] Savannah
1 [B] Taiga
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
5 [MI] Forest (1)
2 [MI] Plains (1)
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
2 [B] Bayou

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
4 [US] Exploration
3 [VI] Elephant Grass
1 [VI] City of Solitude
2 [LG] Moat
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
1 [ON] Words of War
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
3 [LG] Sylvan Library
1 [CHK] Ghostly Prison
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
1 [OD] Holistic Wisdom
4 [NE] Seal of Doom
1 [LOR] Hoofprint of the Stag

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [VI] Elephant Grass
SB: 3 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 1 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 1 [US] Spreading Algae
SB: 3 [MR] Rule of Law
SB: 1 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 1 [MM] Spiritual Focus
SB: 1 [8E] Sacred Ground
SB: 2 [8E] Choke
SB: 1 [MI] Null Chamber

The Sideboard and parts of the mainboard aree completely random.

Should I play Replenish mainboard? What's about Oblivion Ring? Mirri's Guile in combination with S. Library?

Here are some lists, some from American Tournaments, some from German ones (http://www.deckcheck.net/list.php?type=Enchantress&format=Legacy)

I hope to get some help, thanks :smile:

Elf_Ascetic
02-22-2008, 05:03 PM
Here's my list:

4 Savannah
2 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath
6 Forest
3 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum

4 Argothian Enchantress

4 Exploration
3 Elephant Grass
1 City of Solitude
1 Moat
4 Enchantress's Presence
1 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl
1 Words of War
3 Solitary Confinement
3 Sylvan Library
2 Oblivion Ring
4 Sterling Grove
1 Seal of Primordium
2 Hoofprint of the Stag
1 *card i can't remember right now.*

I love the interaction with S. Libary and Hoofprints, it give a clock to this deck. A clock it didn't have before.

EDIT: 1 Sacred Mesa of course..

GiantGrowth
02-23-2008, 12:04 AM
Could anyone post his or her recent list? I have just pretty old lists aviable.

I guess the core consists of

4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove
2 Serra's Sanctum (obv.)
x Moat (one? Or two for the case that one gets EE'd, deeded away or so?)
x Confinement (I guess 3-4 as we want to draw them asap?)
3-4 Sylvan Library (insane with Hoofprints, one of our Winconditions)
1 Words of War (second Wincondition)

Now the questions are coming up:

Should Elephant Grass be played? Same question, but this time about Exploration? How much effects of Utopia Sprawl like cards should be run? Should we run any of these cards?

I suppose GW is fix (white for Moat, Hoofprints, Confinement and Grove, green for the whole Engine in form of Echantress effects). A slight red splash in form of one Taiga (Sprawls make red too if you wish them to do so) for Words of Wilding and maybe Blood Moon? Black could also be played (The Abyss, Seal of Doom and nasty things like that). What about blue for a very nice Tutor in form of Intuition or Gifts Ungiven (Gifts is pretty good with holistic wisdom)?


I hope to get some help, thanks :smile:

Actually, several people have not been running library (myself included)
grass is great for stalling the game when setting up a real lock, or as the occasional fog that cantrips. plus randomly hoses Ichorid. I've been testing with fewer and fewer exploration and I could see taking them out alltogether, but they do have their uses. I don't know about the utopia effects, ive been testing the one wild growth, and it has been useful(especially with the only 2 explorations I'm running), but the reason I like sprawl so much is the ability to give white or red, so idk how many total should be run The black splash was tested awhile back, but was proved unecessary(I think, does anyone dispute this?) O-ring hits a broader range of things than seal of doom, and I've never had the problem of wanting to cast it, but not having any opposing targets. as for the abyss, it helps with the aggro match, but I don't think that is a match that needs helping, so in my opinion at least, the black splash is unecessary.

alebronwebb
02-23-2008, 12:47 AM
Well, since the popular thing right now is posting lists, here's mine.
Maybe I can make Lonelybaritone shudder again.

creatures 4
Argothian Enchantress

other 36
4 Enchantress' Presence
4 Sterling Grove
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Elephant Grass (4 is mandatory, imo, it's just that good)
3 Solitary Confinement
2 Ground Seal
3 Exploration
2 Wild Growth
2 Oblivion Ring
1 Moat
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag (oh, my god. It's awesome)
1 Karmic Justice (might need to be two, not sure)
1 Aura of Silence
2 Replenish

lands 20
4 Savannah
4 Windswept Heath
6 Forests
3 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga

SB
2 Null Chamber
3 City of Solitude
2 Dovescape
2 Rule of Law
3 Choke
2 Ground Seal
1 Karmic Justice

Sylvan Library is very tempting to run with Hoofprints, but I'm not sure if it would be just a win-more card most of the time. I agree with GiantGrowth that the black splash is unnecessary, Oblivion Ring is better than Seal of Doom. The Abyss only helps against aggro, which is a good match-up anyways. I'm still against the blue splash 100% though, not enough good enchantments. The deck doens't need more tutors in the form of Intuition or Gifts, Grove is an actual enchantment and is just a better tutor.

EDIT: And as for the Blood Moon debate, I'll put my two cents in. I think it's too symmetical, yeah it can devastate thier mana-base but it can hurt us just as much. Turning our Savannah/Sanctums into mountains just seems bad to me, we want white late game. It make us rely on WoR too much, since it will very hard/nigh impossible to use Hoofprints or Mesa.

Brehn
02-23-2008, 10:41 AM
4 Elephant Grass (4 is mandatory, imo, it's just that good)
QFT



I love the interaction with S. Libary and Hoofprints, it give a clock to this deck. A clock it didn't have before.

I also love the interaction - in theory. Yes, it gives a clock to this deck.
Question: Does this deck, which is all about stalling until you get a lock, need a clock? Sounds a little bit like including Tarmogoyf in Stax...

GiantGrowth
02-23-2008, 09:51 PM
I also love the interaction - in theory. Yes, it gives a clock to this deck.
Question: Does this deck, which is all about stalling until you get a lock, need a clock? Sounds a little bit like including Tarmogoyf in Stax...

What a great idea... the deck runs green, add tarmogoyf!

but seriously, control and locks=good clocks=uneeded

GreenOne
02-24-2008, 08:17 AM
Note: S. library comboes with words of war too.

The deck didn't need it in the past for sure, but now that Hoofprint has been printed the discussion should be re-opened.

S. Library Upsides:
- Comboes with WoWar and Hoofprints
- Gives the deck a good wincon even with the engine online
- It's quite good in the control matchup, where helps in CA and quality too.

Downsides:
- Not many shuffle effects (4 fetch+ 4 sterling grove)
- Not great in the aggro and aggrocontrol matchup, where you want tthe needed card now.
- It has to compete for its slot with other good cards (Ground Seal, more O. Rings...)

At first sight seems like Library is is better in a control-oriented meta, where Ground Seal is better in a aggro and combo meta.

It deserve some testing time imo.

memnarch
02-29-2008, 04:54 PM
Dude 1 Jester's Cap = you lose. [/sarcasm]


That might be a joke but what about Earwig Squad. That pretty much is jester's cap and goblin players are starting to play that. Wouldn't that give this deck alot of trouble?

Tanarin
03-04-2008, 09:55 PM
Hey, I am new here but am interested in getting into legacy. I was looking at this deck and was wondering why doesn't it run Idyllic Tutor? I mean it isn't an enchantment, but it seems running at least two or three woulda allow you to easily tutor into your wincons, especially since you SHOULD draw one once you get the engine running. Is it because it isn't an enchantment or is it just too slow for some odd reason?

GiantGrowth
03-04-2008, 11:45 PM
Hey, I am new here but am interested in getting into legacy. I was looking at this deck and was wondering why doesn't it run Idyllic Tutor? I mean it isn't an enchantment, but it seems running at least two or three woulda allow you to easily tutor into your wincons, especially since you SHOULD draw one once you get the engine running. Is it because it isn't an enchantment or is it just too slow for some odd reason?

I don't think its needed, after you get control of the board, there's no need to tutor as fast as you can into your wincon, you can win at your leisure. Plus our other tutor doubles as protection and a cantrip with the engine going.

Redlotus27
03-05-2008, 02:27 PM
Hes right. Enchantress is not a "fast" deck, but once it gets rolling things get out of hand for the opposition pretty quickly.

Has anyone tried Mirri's Guile as a 2-3 of? Also I need convincing that exploration is better more often than wild growth. IMO wild growth is great real early and cantrips later, whereas exploration is okay early provided you have the extra land to support it and later in the game when you are drawing 3+ per turn allow you to actually play those lands rather than discarding superfluous ones.

Way back in the day I used Smokestack to clear a few permanents early after flying out of the gates with exploration, and following up with a rancor on something to set a soft lock. Just a random thought....

honz
03-05-2008, 10:04 PM
I have indeed tried guile as a 2-3 of for a long time. Basically, guile is completely useless unless it is in your starting hand. By the time you have an enchantress effect out (turn 3), you draw through your library so fast that the order of the top 3 cards has almost no effect on anything, as you will be drawing all 3 soon enough. Library may combo with a couple random 1-ofs, but the same things are true for library. I would suggest running neither.

You should run exploration over wild growth because of: wasteland, sinkhole, vindicate, armageddon, rishadan port. Exploration is also massive card advantage, and leads to more mana in the long run.

Just as a general question: why are alot of people running WoW, mesa, hoofprints, and solitary? If you like hoofprints so much, why not cut one of our other win-cons (obviously not solitary).

Brehn
03-06-2008, 08:52 AM
You should run exploration over wild growth because of: wasteland
Enchanting Basic lands is tech.

sinkhole
Sinkhole is a problem. But are you really afraid of seeing many Deadguy/Eva Green builds in your meta?

vindicate
If they waste a Vindicate on your land, your manabase is phailing anyway. Exploration doesn't help here.

armageddon
That's why you play Sacred Ground. Wild Growth + Karmic Justice is also quite good. Exploration doesn't help recovering after a successful Armageddon that much. Also, last time I checked, only Stax and some strange Loam builds ran that card.

rishadan port.
Truth. But Goblins are now splashing 2 colors, thus cutting Port more often.

Exploration is also massive card advantage,
Actually, I don't get this. How is playing extra lands card advantage?

and leads to more mana in the long run.
Wild Growth nets you mana in the early game, when you need it. Exploration nets you mana in the late game, when you're winning anyway. I don't need to win with 20 mana on the table. But I like to have 3 mana available on my second turn.

You still haven't adressed the dissynergy of Exploration + less than 25 lands. It's been written many times: In the early game, Wild Growth is almost always strictly better than Exploration (save Sinkhole and Rishadan Port), because you usually don't start with 4 lands in your hand.


Just as a general question: why are alot of people running WoW, mesa, hoofprints, and solitary? If you like hoofprints so much, why not cut one of our other win-cons (obviously not solitary).
First: Please don't use the abbreviation "WoW". Between Words of War, Words of Wilding and Words of Wind (all of which have been played at some time), there's quite some confusion.
On topic: I'd rather cut Hoofprints than anything else. It's still the weakest win condition of those 4, and I just play it to increase the flexibility of the deck, be it to combat multiple Needles, Meddling Mages or Chalice @ 3. 3 Confinements and 3 other Wincons seem like the right number to me. Dropping Hoofprints on turn 2 can be great, but I'd still rather drop an Enchantress.

crazyroundman
03-06-2008, 02:59 PM
I'm currently testing the following list:

Land (20):
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga
3 Savannah
2 Plains
4 Windswept Heath
8 Forest (This might be too high - I'd entertain the notion of going -1 Forest +1 Foothill)

Creatures (4)(duh):
4 Argothian Enchantress

Sourceries (2):
2 Replenish

Enchantments (35, I think):
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Enchantress' Presence
4 Sterling Grove (I'm considering cutting one, but I like how it pulls up anything from your board)(and dodges Grip)
3 Solitary Confinement
3 Elephant Grass (agro isn't that large a concern in my area - I might be convinced to go up to 4)
3 Exploration (I might honestly go down to two)
3 Hoofprints of the Stag
2 Slyvan Library (SVG TEK)
2 Oblivion Ring
1 Karmic Justice
1 Sacred Mesa
1 WoWar
1 Aura of Silence
1 Wild Growth
1 Moat
1 Island Sanctuary (Don't laugh - it's not as bad as it looks. I use it to fog all the time)(Though a Ghostly Prison might be a better thing)

Sideboard: (I'm expecting Dragon Stompy, Thresh, and Stax in my meta)
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Aura of Silence
1 Dovescape
2 COP:Red
1 COP: Green (might bump up to two at the expense of the seal of primordium)
2 Sacred Ground (I HATE armageddon)
2 City of Solitude
2 Ground Seal
1 Karmic Justice
3 that I can't think of - I'll edit when I get back home.

What do y'all think? I'd love constructive imput.

Brehn
03-06-2008, 04:13 PM
What is your reasoning to play more than zero Explorations?

Tacosnape
03-06-2008, 09:08 PM
@Crazy's list:

That's a pretty good build for handling both Dragon Stompy, which is an easy matchup anyway, and Stax, which hates both Karmic Justice and Sacred Ground.

Against Threshold, I'd like to see more protection for draw engines, as draw engine usually = win, and not draw engine usually = uh oh. I'm not positive I know what to suggest, though. Moar City of Solitude in board?


First: Please don't use the abbreviation "WoW". Between Words of War, Words of Wilding and Words of Wind (all of which have been played at some time), there's quite some confusion.

And World of Warcraft. I hear that's played a lot, too.

honz
03-06-2008, 10:34 PM
When i say exploration nets card advantage in the long run i simply mean it allows for more enchantments to be played over time. (if you have the lands) exploration serves as a wildgrowth that gets replayed every turn, which means exploration leads to more mana. More mana leads to more enchantments, which is card advantage.

I would never suggest running 4 exploration, as you really dont have a high enough land count, and more than 1 exploration is useless. I would say 2-3 (i run 2) is right, because it really does speed things up once you start drawing. I don't know why people get the idea that once you start drawing, you have already won, as i have lost numerous games with 1-3 enchantress out.

It is also not uncommon to end up keeping a hand of non-basics, as 1/3 of your lands are non-basic (2 sanctums, 3-4 savanah, 1 taiga), which means wild-growth can very easily end up on a non-basic.

My meta does have sui black, b/w confidant, and white stax lurking around, as well as plenty of wastes everywhere. Deed and EE also make wildgrowth worse. I guess i dont see the arguement for cutting exploration completely in favor of a more vulnerable card that accomplishes the same thing.

Jak
03-06-2008, 11:50 PM
This is the list I have been using on MWS. It has been a blast and the deck is crazy strong. I played against a really bad gobs list and won, zoo and won, and TES to a 1-2 defeat. The deck was really consistent and the game I won against TES I was able to get out a turn 2 or 3 Confinement along with so Enchantress effects. A god hand. Anyway, here is the list.

// Lands
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
4 [B] Savannah
7 [RAV] Forest (3)
1 [B] Taiga
2 [CHK] Plains (4)

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
2 [LG] Sylvan Library
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
4 [B] Wild Growth
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
1 [WL] Aura of Silence
1 [LRW] Hoofprints of the Stag
2 [LRW] Oblivion Ring
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
2 [LG] Moat
1 [MI] Sacred Mesa
1 [ON] Words of War
2 [UD] Replenish
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 1 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
SB: 1 [MM] Spiritual Focus
SB: 3 [TE] Choke
SB: 3 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 4 [MR] Rule of Law
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground

I really liked the Wild Growths because Exploration just never did it for me. It was good in the first 2 or 3 turns, but after that it just sat there. In the games I played, Wild Growth helped throughout the game to keep casting enchantments. Every mana was used and without 1 or 2 the deck would not of been able to lock down the game as fast. I still want to run another HotS.

Redlotus27
03-07-2008, 10:20 AM
Has anyone though of using Verduran enchantress as #9 and #10 effects? Similar to what the ichorid players deem necessary (minimum 10 drredgers) to find one most often in the opening grip.

I also 100% agree that wild growth is an automatic 4 of and exploration is an automatic zero of.

I however disagree with 2x moat, 1 should be good enough as a tutor target. MD should have at least 1 city of solitude as I would guess 2/3rds of all metas play islands

Jak
03-07-2008, 08:13 PM
Playing the deck, I have never been short of Enchantress effects. I either have one in my opening hand or I am able to play a Grass and stall until I draw one like on the third turn or something. Also, more creatures means less Enchantments.

I have been loving Wild Growth more and more. Late game it gets to be like a free Ancestral Recall.

2 Moats have been okay for me. I never minded drawing them. But I may just go with one since I have zero in RL. I do want a City main.


EDIT- I was reading some of your old reports Baritone and it got me thinking that I don not use Words of War right. You sadi you were WOWing them for like 22 turn 5, but was it because you had like 4 Enchantresss effects in play or something? I just want to know the right way to use Words of War.

Zach Tartell
03-09-2008, 10:00 PM
Playing the deck, I have never been short of Enchantress effects. I either have one in my opening hand or I am able to play a Grass and stall until I draw one like on the third turn or something. Also, more creatures means less Enchantments.

With Grove this is an easy problem to address, usually. I'll admit that I've thought about playing the Living Wish plan, which is cool (0 MD'd Sanctums = Savage), but ultimately pretty worthless (as far as my testing showed).


I have been loving Wild Growth more and more. Late game it gets to be like a free Ancestral Recall.

Late game Serenity is an Ancestral Recall. Which helps the mirror and Stax matches a little. In all seriousness, though, that's terrible reasoning. If you're drawing 3 cards off of each card you play then you should be drawing more than one land. Here Exploration shines, if nowhere else.


2 Moats have been okay for me. I never minded drawing them. But I may just go with one since I have zero in RL. I do want a City main.

Two Moats is a healthy amount, usually. You don't want to draw it too early, or against massive LD, or against Dragon Stompy (or any Moon effect when your :w: < 1). One is fine, for me. If you want two feel free to drop the additional $55 or whatever (don't say that Italian ones cost less, on account of Fossato is a fucking ugly name and border and has the tiny little writing on the bottom. FTL).


EDIT- I was reading some of your old reports Baritone and it got me thinking that I don not use Words of War right. You sadi you were WOWing them for like 22 turn 5, but was it because you had like 4 Enchantresss effects in play or something? I just want to know the right way to use Words of War.


Turn 5 is usually pretty early (unless juiced up by a Replenish or well-timed Sanctum), but you should pretty much always be winning in one turn if you're running WoWar. Unless you've got the SVG WOWar + Sylvan Library thing on the table. But that's PWNable, and that's a good thing to avoid. 3 is usually the right amount of Enchantress Effects to have on the table to win with WoWar, I've found. Just tap a bunch of mana and play a handful of :g: or :1::g: or :1::w: or :2::w: or :g::w: cards. It's usually GG.

Jak
03-10-2008, 12:17 AM
Late game Serenity is an Ancestral Recall. Which helps the mirror and Stax matches a little. In all seriousness, though, that's terrible reasoning. If you're drawing 3 cards off of each card you play then you should be drawing more than one land. Here Exploration shines, if nowhere else.

I wasn't meaning that was the only reson to run them, but that it was just cool. What I like about the Growths is that playing it turn one, with a two land hand means a 2nd turn Presence. Keeping a 2 land hand with Exploration doesn't do it sometimes.

Thanks for all the help.

Jak
03-11-2008, 03:21 AM
So what is the plan for beating Landstill? UBg Landstill. I won game one against this pretty good player on the back of Replenish, but games 2 and 3 it wasn't really close. 2nd game I got whooped on by 3 Deeds and had him for a while with Choke and Solitude out, but didn't draw shit. 3rd game was interesting. I have City out and a Null Chamber on Deed. I have a decent amount of permanents but I am getting beaten down by factories. I have to sack my only Grove to get Confinement, but he Krosan Grips my O ring holding a deed and wipes the board. Maybe I was unlucky because in both games I got a slow ass start and only saw one or two enchantress effects. What do your boards look like to combat control. This is what I am thinking.

4 Choke
3 City
1 Null Profusion
1 Karmic Justice (owned him game one)

Then I can add stuff like

1 Karmic Justice
1 Aura of Silence
4 Rule of Law

But is there a special way to beat Landstill?

GreenOne
03-11-2008, 06:55 AM
4 Choke
3 City
1 Null Profusion
1 Karmic Justice (owned him game one)

Then I can add stuff like

1 Karmic Justice
1 Aura of Silence
4 Rule of Law

But is there a special way to beat Landstill?

I can't see how null profusion and rule of law effect landstill someway.
However, Choke, City, Karmic Justice and Aura of silence are the key cards to have a good matchup. If your meta is infested with Landstill you can think about running some numbers of maindeck S. Libraries. Dovescape also helps. When it hits it's GG.

Jak
03-11-2008, 07:58 PM
I can't see how null profusion and rule of law effect landstill someway.
However, Choke, City, Karmic Justice and Aura of silence are the key cards to have a good matchup. If your meta is infested with Landstill you can think about running some numbers of maindeck S. Libraries. Dovescape also helps. When it hits it's GG.

I was just finishing off my board. One of the Karmic Justice should be a Sacred Ground. And I meant Null Chamber. So many names. I usually just name Deed with it.

GiantGrowth
03-11-2008, 11:29 PM
4 Choke
3 City
1 Null Profusion
1 Karmic Justice (owned him game one)

Then I can add stuff like

1 Karmic Justice
1 Aura of Silence
4 Rule of Law

But is there a special way to beat Landstill?

blood moon really ruins their game, at least from what I've seen

SpatulaOfTheAges
03-12-2008, 01:15 PM
But is there a special way to beat Landstill?

Dovescape. Replenish. Threat density.

Pack an extra Replenish in the board and aggresively draw cards. Don't dance around with stuff trying to protect your board. Just draw more cards than them. Make that your priority.

Jak
03-12-2008, 08:12 PM
Pretty sure that was the problem I was having. When I knew I could beat the control player by pure CA I would because my hand was so strong, but other times when I didn't have a strong hand I did dance around. I tried to bait counters and I realise that it was probably the bad thing to do. If I had a Choke or something, I was onyl focussing on getting it into play instead of trying to win the game. Anyway, here is a list I have been having sucess with.

// Lands
6 [UNH] Forest
2 [6E] Plains (1)
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
4 [A] Savannah
2 [R] Taiga

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
1 [WL] Aura of Silence
2 [UD] Replenish
2 [LG] Sylvan Library
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
2 [LG] Moat
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
4 [B] Wild Growth
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
1 [ON] Words of War
1 [LRW] Hoofprints of the Stag
1 [MI] Sacred Mesa
2 [LRW] Oblivion Ring

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 1 [UD] Replenish
SB: 1 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 4 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground
SB: 2 [TE] Choke
SB: 3 [MR] Rule of Law
SB: 2 [DK] Blood Moon

I was hesitant on the Moons, but they are awesome. Most of the time better than Choke, because Landstill will wait to get to 6 lands to play and pop Deed. Moon stops that. Thoughts?

GiantGrowth
03-13-2008, 10:00 PM
has anyone been having luck with temporal isolation? during testing, it seemed like just another o-ring.

Thehunter820
03-13-2008, 11:02 PM
has anyone been having luck with temporal isolation? during testing, it seemed like just another o-ring.

hmm it could work, but if you have problems with enchantments or artifacts then I think the Oblivion Ring would work better and its only 1 more mana.

Also, I know its not prime choice, but I was wondering if anyone had tried a black splash with bitterblossom?

scrumdogg
03-13-2008, 11:29 PM
I haven't tried it but the problem which immediately springs to mind is speed-of-kill. Words of War, Sacred Mesa, Hoofprints - all get accelerated by the basic premise of your deck. Bitterblossom gives you 1 guy a turn, period. That is slow regularly, which in a regular control deck might not be an issue, but when you burn through your deck as quickly as Enchantress should, that can be possibly fatal if found too late. Even if not found late, do you really want to spend X turns not playing anything with Enchantress because you will deck yourself?

alebronwebb
03-14-2008, 12:01 AM
O-Ring,in my mind, is so much better than Temporal Isolation, basically because it's more verstitile. The higher cost has never been a problem with me.

On Bitterblossom, I love the card, but Scrumdogg pretty much summed it up.

Also how has Blood Moon been to people that run, I haven't tested it. It looks too symmetrical and pretty makes us rely on Word of War. Has this been the case?

Jak
03-14-2008, 01:16 AM
O-Ring,in my mind, is so much better than Temporal Isolation, basically because it's more verstitile. The higher cost has never been a problem with me.

On Bitterblossom, I love the card, but Scrumdogg pretty much summed it up.

Also how has Blood Moon been to people that run, I haven't tested it. It looks too symmetrical and pretty makes us rely on Word of War. Has this been the case?

I play Moon in the side as a 2-of and it has been great. All you need is a basic forest really because Growths and Sprawls make it easy to run under. Better than Choke IMO.

Brehn
03-14-2008, 05:54 AM
I've always argued against Blood Moon for the reasons alebronwebb posted but I've come to the conclusion now that it can be really good in various metagames and matchups. You don't like Deed. Deed costs 1BG. Usually there are duals involved in paying the cost for it. While Karmic Justice + Replenish is unarguably the most optimal answer to Deed, Blood Moon either gives you another out or gives you some additional time to find Karmic Justice/Replenish/Null Chamber/whatever answer. Just remember that you're not Dragon Stompy, so you can't cast it in every situation and it won't single-handedly win you tons of games (I did that mistake).

My current 19-card sideboard that complements my 56-card mainboard is:
3 Ground Seal
3 Karmic Justice
3 City of Solitude
2 Choke
1 Blood Moon
1 Null Chamber
1 Sacred Ground
1 Compost
1 Rule of Law
1 Aura of Silence
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Dovescape

Other notes:
Temporal Isolation - when is it superior to Oblivion Ring? Only against... Breakfast. That matchup is good anyway. If it's not good enough, play 4 Ground Seals main.
Bitterblossom - Ew. Don't.

Punki
03-17-2008, 10:09 AM
I won a local 13 people tournament with this list.
R1 black green deck with sinkholes, hippies and stuff 2-0
R2 Death and taxes meets angelstompy 2-0 after recovering twice from a cataclysm
R3 43 land 2-0
R4 Terranova (GBW loam) 1-0 (45 minutes for game 1)


Maindeck:
4 Elephant Grass
2 Ground Seal (cantrip + lots of loam decks here in Belgium)
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Sterling Grove
4 Enchantresses Presence
2 Moat
1 Humility (strange choice, but saved me several times: some samurai thet said permanents that go to the graveyard are removed, goyf, terravore, mangara, ...)
3 Solitary Confinement
1 karmic justice because of all the loam decks that pack deed and EE
4 Utopia Sprawl
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
0 exploration (first tried 2, didn't like them and replaced them with the wild growth and a forest)
1 Wild Growth (extra insurance to get enough mana)
2 Sylvan Library (not only because it's good with hoofprints ands woWar but because I really want to minimize the chances of bad draws in the first few turns. I had 2 slots and instead of utility i opted for these, that are never dead draws and you never mind having them in your openinghand. To bad they do not do anything when you have confinement, but I don't mind)
1 sacred mesa (never used it)
1 Words of War (always used this for the kill, mostly because of the humility)
2 Replenish (could become 3 if people are adapting to the deck)
2 Oblivion Ring (he even caught me a deed one time :) )
21 land (found myself having to take a mulligan too often when playing 20 lands)
4 Savannah
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga
7 Forest
3 Plains
4 Windsweapt Heath

Sideboard:
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Replenish
1 Aura of Silence
3 Choke
2 Karmic Justice
1 Dovescape
3 spiritual focus
2 eyes of the wisent
1 ground seal

I really like the deck and it is quite strong if no-one is expecting it. I came across an other list that bacame 2nd in a 21 person tournament here in Belgium. He lost the finals against bridge-ichorid:

my comments ara next to the cards like I did for my own list. I was wondering if you agree with it or not.
Maindeck:
4 Elephant Grass
2 Ground Seal
4 Argothian Enchantress
3 Sterling Grove (only 3? ok, there is little targetted enchantment hate preboard in most decks, but everyone packs grip in SB + it fetches the on-offs)
3 Enchantresses Presence (again: only 3? i find myself always going for 2 enchantress effects as soon as possible to throw down confinement and relaxing for a few turns)
2 Moat
2 Solitary Confinement (2 could be ok, I just really want do draw one as soon as possible)
1 Aura of SIlence (maybe for the mirror, i thought it woild be a dead card to often to maindeck it)
4 Utopia Sprawl
2 Hoofprints of the Stag (I think 1 = enough)
2 Wild Growth
3 Sylvan Library (I believe 3 is a lot, but with the axtra hoofprints and fetch (see below) to shuffle away cards you do not want to draw it's a nice idea)
1 Words of War
2 Replenish
2 Oblivion Ring
4 Savannah
2 Serra's Sanctum
1 Taiga
6 Forest
2 Plains
4 Windsweapt Heath
3 Wooded Foothills (Again the synergy with library is nice; but I prefer the safety of a lot of basics.)

Sideboard:
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Replenish
4 Tormod's Crypt (not an enchantment, but never tested it)
3 Gaddock Teeg (very strange in my opinion, I think i would prefer rule of law of leyline of the void in this and previous slot)
1 Aura of Silence
3 Choke
2 Karmic Justice

Jak
03-28-2008, 05:15 AM
Okay, I keep not wanting to build this deck because I think it will get hated out, but it is just amazing how resilient it is. Not that MWS should count, but I have been winning against Belcher, Landstill, and Thresh with this deck (of course aggro decks also, gobs, burn, sligh, etc). Is anyone still playing this? Is it hated on too easily?

GreenOne
03-28-2008, 01:45 PM
People will start running Aura of Silence, Aura Flux, Tranquil Domain trying to hate on you. Then you'll start packing more Karmic Justice and Replenish and you'll start winning again. Then they'll start playing TES/IGGY and then you're done. No way out of this.

Seriously, noone will ever hate on Enchantress, unless your meta is a small one and there are a sufficient number of Enchantresses.

GiantGrowth
03-28-2008, 02:08 PM
People will start running Aura of Silence, Aura Flux, Tranquil Domain trying to hate on you. Then you'll start packing more Karmic Justice and Replenish and you'll start winning again. Then they'll start playing TES/IGGY and then you're done. No way out of this.

Seriously, noone will ever hate on Enchantress, unless your meta is a small one and there are a sufficient number of Enchantresses.

QFT

but combo usually doesn't make up a large part of any meta (so I'ive heard) so you should be fine with the justices, and all thier hate makes replenish even more of a bomb

alebronwebb
03-28-2008, 03:34 PM
I play this deck religously, when I can (thanks crappy and sporatic meta, but hey 1st out of 18 isn't all that bad, yay Blue Dual prizes). Fast combo sucks, yes. But I'd rather take the loss to one or two people in a tournament then to dilute the deck even more for a small improvement. The deck already has a good chance against control and great chances against aggro, so I'm happy with that.
The deck can be hated on pretty easy too, but packing in more Justices and Replenish helps. But really hate shouldn't be a problem, Enchantress isn't really a popular deck and probably won't be. They might start boarding agaisnt you for a week or two but it shouldn't last since they are pretty much wasting board space.

GiantGrowth
03-29-2008, 02:36 PM
How do you guys board dovescape? I've always had it in my board, but I have no idea what match to side it in for, or what to side out.

also, baritone, what list do you feel is the most optimal list for an untested meta?

GreenOne
03-30-2008, 07:15 AM
I usually side it in vs Combo and Control.

SpatulaOfTheAges
03-31-2008, 06:28 PM
http://www.mtgthesource.com/forums/showthread.php?p=219775&posted=1#post219775

This is the list I ran last saturday at the NOVA D4D.

What worked;

Ground Seal is basically a must if you want to play this deck right. The dig it gives you lets you make up for all the mulliganing you have to do with the deck. Exploration belongs in the deck, but not as a 4x. You want it when you start going off, so 2-3 seems right. Moat and O. Ring and Mesa and Hoofprints are all expensive and white and discourage you from running basic forests, which weakens Utopia Sprawl and prevents you from running Gaea's Touch, which is hot with Replenish.

The 3rd Replenish was probably the MVP as far as non-standard card choices go. Either that or ESG. They worked really well.

The SB was ok. Angels are hot, but my tutor package was mostly rushed together.

Jak
03-31-2008, 09:49 PM
I played around with your list and liked it quite a bit. I like the angels a lot and want to test those some more, but the tutor pachage seems kind of weak. How often was it relevent?

The MD is a lot different than the norm I have been playing with. Less controlling, but the draw was just amazing. I loved 4 Ground Seals. I wanted more Solitary Confinement. 2 was just too few. I didn't like Gaea's Touch. It was cool when comboing out, but I would rather just of had 2 Moats or 2 Island Sanctuary. ESG was awesome for a turn one Argothian. So many thoughts. Anyway, I liked the more explosive list and this is what I want to throw together after testing you list.

// Lands
2 [CHK] Plains (4)
6 [RAV] Forest (3)
4 [R] Savannah
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
1 [B] Taiga (might go to 2)
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress
3 [AL] Elvish Spirit Guide

// Spells
2 [B] Wild Growth
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
1 [WL] Aura of Silence
2 [B] Island Sanctuary
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
2 [UD] Replenish
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
2 [US] Exploration
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
4 [OD] Ground Seal
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
1 [ON] Words of War

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground
SB: 1 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 2 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 1 [UD] Replenish
SB: 4 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 2 [TE] Choke
SB: 2 [MR] Rule of Law
SB: 1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
SB: 1 [DIS] Dovescape

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-01-2008, 12:54 AM
I played around with your list and liked it quite a bit. I like the angels a lot and want to test those some more, but the tutor pachage seems kind of week. How often was it relevent?

Not very, but that was partially due to match-ups. It came up vs. White Stax, Loam, and Survival. My toolbox itself was weak. CotV is solid and an extra Aura and a Seal between MD or board are basically autos, as is Sacred Ground. The others I think could have been better.


The MD is a lot different than the norm I have been playing with. Less controlling, but the draw was just amazing. I loved 4 Ground Seals. I wanted more Solitary Confinement. 2 was just too few. I didn't like Gaea's Touch. It was cool when comboing out, but I would rather just of had 2 Moats or 2 Island Sanctuary.

How many forests were you running?


I don't really like Island Sanctuary. Unless you're playing in a meta-game where the majority of decks have no MD answer to it, it commits you to what's probably a losing strategy if you don't have the engine. If you do have the engine, it's pretty much unnecessary. Grass or Confinement stop basically everything all ready.

I thought about the 4th Grove, but I don't think I'd run it unless people in my meta ran a lot of MD targeted removal. It's 3 mana to use and costs card advantage. It can also be difficult to cast in certain situations. I felt pretty comfortable with 3.

The Choke could easily have become the 3rd Confinement. I think I was expecting more blue than was there. Either Confinement #3 or a single O. Ring probably would have been the correct call.

Jak
04-01-2008, 01:50 AM
Not very, but that was partially due to match-ups. It came up vs. White Stax, Loam, and Survival. My toolbox itself was weak. CotV is solid and an extra Aura and a Seal between MD or board are basically autos, as is Sacred Ground. The others I think could have been better.



How many forests were you running?


I don't really like Island Sanctuary. Unless you're playing in a meta-game where the majority of decks have no MD answer to it, it commits you to what's probably a losing strategy if you don't have the engine. If you do have the engine, it's pretty much unnecessary. Grass or Confinement stop basically everything all ready.

I thought about the 4th Grove, but I don't think I'd run it unless people in my meta ran a lot of MD targeted removal. It's 3 mana to use and costs card advantage. It can also be difficult to cast in certain situations. I felt pretty comfortable with 3.

The Choke could easily have become the 3rd Confinement. I think I was expecting more blue than was there. Either Confinement #3 or a single O. Ring probably would have been the correct call.

I was running 10. I was just getting hands with way too much acceleration. I will still tinker with it. Those were just my initial reactions.

I feel the same about Sanctuary. I will use Moats once I can get them.

Grove felt right as a 4-of. I usually don't like to tutor for stuff if I don't have to, but having one able to tutor for a Moat, Confinement, or WoW was always nice. I also hate Grip and want to eliminate as much hate as possible. Maybe it's just me being anal, but playing against a deck packing Deed, I'd rather not worry about grip too.

I am still tinkering with win cons because runnign a one of that can get hosed when a wasteland hits is bad. There are other ways to win, like decking the opponent, but going to time is not the greatest thing. I still like Hoofprints a lot even though I hardly used it.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-01-2008, 04:41 AM
A wasteland shouldn't stop you. That's the beauty of Utopia Sprawl. Failing that you have Replenish. If you play carefully you should never be stuck unable to play WoWar.

While I can see an argument for putting a Moat back in the deck, 2 seems to be way too many. And if I was running Moat it would take the place of the third Confinement. Up to a certain point, ability to draw cards > protection, since drawing cards draws you into more protection, as well as card advantage.

GiantGrowth
04-02-2008, 09:04 AM
I am still tinkering with win cons because runnign a one of that can get hosed when a wasteland hits is bad. There are other ways to win, like decking the opponent, but going to time is not the greatest thing. I still like Hoofprints a lot even though I hardly used it.

I've accually been tinkering with paneburst as an alternate wincon.

Pros:
-Fast, when you play it you win and move on to the next match.
-doesn't give the opponent time to react.
-can be played and used without the engine running.
-replenish after a board sweep lets you still do the combo that turn.

Cons:
-not good to see until you are ready to win, doesn't work well as something to play just to draw cards like words could.
-two cards insead of one.
-they (almost) always need to be played together. although there are some instances you can play the pandemonium first and not worry about the damage from opponent's creatures. then play saproling burst next turn.

It was just a thought.

Julian23
04-02-2008, 03:31 PM
Playing Pandeburst would make Enchantress too fragile. Not that we now would have to acquire two cards in order to win (which makes use much more fragile to stuff like extirpate/extraction/meddling mage/you name it) but implementing this combo also breakes our mana curve.
Besides that, unlike Mesa and Words, these two cards don't do anything for us on their own and (as a win condition) die to a single stifle.
I know countermagic is always an issue but with such expensive spells as Pandemonium and Saproling Burst it becomes even more difficult to play around it by just casting 2-3 must-counters (City of Solitude/Choke/Replenish) before eventually dropping a win-condition.

By the way, last Saturday I went 3-1 (tied for the 1st place but inferior T-Breakers) in a small tournament (10 participants) with Enchantress.
I faced:
Round1, some random Bob Maher/Tarmogoyf Deck: 2-0
Round2, Landstill: 1-2
Round3, Goblins: 2-1
Round4, RDW: 2-0

got me a pack of EURO-Lands, anyone interested? :D

For reference, this is what I ran:

4x Savannah
2x Taiga
4x Windswept Heath
2x Serra's Sanctum
7x Forest
2x Plains

4x Argothian Enchantress
4x Enchantress' Presence
4x Utopia Sprawl
2x Wild Growth
2x Exploration
4x Sterling Grove
4x Elephant Grass
3x Solitary Confinement
2x Ground Seal
2x City of Solitude
2x Replenish
2x Karmic Justice
1x Oblivion Ring
1x Sacred Mesa
1x Words of War
1x Seal of Primordium

SB:
4x Rule of Law
4x Choke
3x Aura of Silence
1x Replenish
1x Karmic Justice
1x Dovescape
1x Sacred Ground

People always referred to The Rock as so-called "Metagame Deck". Maybe we can settle on Enchantress being sort of the same. There is no "ideal" list that only allows small, tiny tweaks to it. If you're in a meta full of heavy aggro you might consider running 4 confinement, maybe even just to use them as a fog to stall a turn. Problems with control? Run more Chokes, Cities of Solitudes, Dovescapes, Hoofprints - whatever seems to turn the matchup more in your favour.

/EDIT: List fixed, forgot +1 Forest +1 Plains

monopoman
04-03-2008, 03:13 AM
Julian your deck is missing 2 cards I believe I would like to know what they are your list seems solid.

I am wondering if this is a good choice for a unknown meta I am looking at more middle road priced decks and I have a lot of experience with enchantress type decks.

I was also wondering what people think of a transformational sideboard into pandeburst? Is that wise for a unknown metagame?

This tournament also allows 0 proxies so I'm expecting a bit more lower priced decks I assume. I'm sure the better players will bring something net deckish but a lot of the Tier 1 decks are ridiculous in cost.

Zach Tartell
04-03-2008, 07:53 AM
I am wondering if this is a good choice for a unknown meta I am looking at more middle road priced decks and I have a lot of experience with enchantress type decks.

Well, if it's a 0 proxy (which is the usual, as far as I knew), and more budget-oriented meta, then I'd expect a bunch of stupid "land, creature, go" decks, a handful of white or black based control decks (things with lots of wraths) and some combo in the form of Belcher (which is probably the cheapest really competitive deck you can build), TES (which is probably the best storm deck you can build), and maybe some mono-black tendrils based combo.



I was also wondering what people think of a transformational sideboard into pandeburst? Is that wise for a unknown metagame?

No. Never. There's an article called "The Danger of Cool Things" somewhere in the internet. Read it. If you're going to board into anything I'd recommend like 4 Exaulted Angels


This tournament also allows 0 proxies so I'm expecting a bit more lower priced decks I assume. I'm sure the better players will bring something net deckish but a lot of the Tier 1 decks are ridiculous in cost.

If you're trying to build something cheap, don't go for Enchantress. About 10 cards from the entire deck have applications elsewhere in legacy. I'd recommend something more along the lines of TES (budget it as much as you can), Belcher (if they aren't playing blue most things are a bye), or an agro-control deck (like Survival, Thresh, or Rock). An Unknown meta is pretty good for Enchantress, but if you're expecting players to go for a cheap deck then I'd stray away from Enchantress - if they're playing a storm deck it's usually a better deal to scoop it up and grab a slice of pizza or something.

slyfer
04-03-2008, 08:53 AM
I throw you a list that top8ed in italy (47 people tournament, see http://www.dragonsleague.it/archivio_deck.php for more info)
This guy is piloting enchantress for some tournament so the deck is well tested
It's a more combo version. Seal of primordium is tech in 4x vs pernicious, standstill, counterbalance, explosives... it's a perfect answer to the present metagame.... city of solitude is a must counter for blue deck (and you can bluff), otherwise they simply see you combo out and kick them to Mars lol.

// Lands
17 [PT] Forest (1)
2 [R] Savannah
1 [US] Serra's Sanctum

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
3 [TE] Mirri's Guile
3 [IN] Sterling Grove
3 [VI] City of Solitude
1 [ON] Words of Wilding
4 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
1 [LG] Concordant Crossroads
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
4 [US] Exploration
3 [DK] Gaea's Touch
4 [7E] Early Harvest
2 [SC] Hunting Pack

// Sideboard
SB: 3 [AL] Hail Storm
SB: 1 [OD] Ground Seal
SB: 3 [VI] Elephant Grass
SB: 3 [10E] Pithing Needle
SB: 3 [7E] Compost
SB: 2 [4E] Tsunami

Brehn
04-03-2008, 09:08 AM
I can't imagine which card could possibly be more anti-synergistic with the deck than HAIL STORM....

GreenOne
04-03-2008, 09:51 AM
I throw you a list that top8ed in italy (47 people tournament, see http://www.dragonsleague.it/archivio_deck.php for more info)
This guy is piloting enchantress for some tournament so the deck is well tested
It's a more combo version. Seal of primordium is tech in 4x vs pernicious, standstill, counterbalance, explosives... it's a perfect answer to the present metagame.... city of solitude is a must counter for blue deck (and you can bluff), otherwise they simply see you combo out and kick them to Mars lol.

// Lands
17 [PT] Forest (1)
2 [R] Savannah
1 [US] Serra's Sanctum

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
3 [TE] Mirri's Guile
3 [IN] Sterling Grove
3 [VI] City of Solitude
1 [ON] Words of Wilding
4 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
1 [LG] Concordant Crossroads
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
4 [US] Exploration
3 [DK] Gaea's Touch
4 [7E] Early Harvest
2 [SC] Hunting Pack

// Sideboard
SB: 3 [AL] Hail Storm
SB: 1 [OD] Ground Seal
SB: 3 [VI] Elephant Grass
SB: 3 [10E] Pithing Needle
SB: 3 [7E] Compost
SB: 2 [4E] Tsunami

Wow, an Enchantress-Storm list. This is really something we have never seen before. the high number of seal of primordium is probably there for things like Ghostly prison, moat, ensnaring bridge and the like too, as the win condition is reliant on the red zone. I like the idea of experimenting new things, but I can't believe this deck could win in the italian meta. What if they counter your draw engine? you have no replenish/ sterling grove as tutors and against discard..

Julian23
04-03-2008, 10:10 AM
Early Harvest is actually a card I thought about for more than once. It would come in handy while running through your deck. However I don't see it being actually making the cut because it's a) no enchantment and b) imho the gain of speed it provides is not worth the loss of quality.

Nihil Credo
04-03-2008, 10:14 AM
Campigotto (the pilot) indeed told me that Early Harvest had underperformed during his other rounds. It was key to a couple of turn-4 wins against me, however, but since I was playing Armageddon Stax he had to go off ASAP and did not have to worry about countermagic.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-03-2008, 01:36 PM
I can't really get behind throwing away what Replenish and Confinement give you. The ultimate denial trump and the ultimate aggro trump combined with a crazy draw engine pretty much make the deck as powerful as it is.

monopoman
04-05-2008, 12:34 AM
Ok If your expecting a lot of random aggro like mono-green or something what kind of sideboard enchantments are best.

I would rather not buy a moat but I know thats one of the top choices. Any other recommendations obviously the deck would be already running 3 confinements and 4 elephant grass.

Jak
04-05-2008, 02:08 AM
Run something close to Spatula's decklist from the NoVa Draft. No Moats, but it is a ton faster and runs a lot smoother. I don't plan on buying Moats anymore.

Serbitar
04-05-2008, 08:56 AM
From my point, this is untested, and I know people have given up the combo matchup, rather choosing not to play Enchantress when expecting to face it, but I was wondering about boarding Orim's Chant.

It should be unexpected, and having only one should buy you enough time against storm combo to land Confinement/Rule of Law/whatever. In contrast, the black discard plan (in the Worlds lists) was off-color, and having one Duress/Thoughseize was never quite enough against storm.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-05-2008, 11:48 AM
That's not a terrible idea, actually. Someone should probably test it.

Jak
04-05-2008, 07:35 PM
I tried Chant for a bit today and liked it a lot. I played a few post-board games against TES and it worked really well. They try to go off as fast as possible or Confinement comes down and you just win. Chant is awesome when they do this because they won't wait to have the mana to Chant since they think they won't need it. It is a great surprise factor and I like it a lot with Confinement. This was my SB:

4 Orim's Chant
1 Solitary Confinement (3 MD)
3 City of Solitude
2 Choke (might become Moon)
2 Karmic Justice
1 Sacred Ground
1 Replenish
1 Aura of Silence

Soto
04-06-2008, 02:00 AM
Spatula, I'm going to use your build this week at a tournament I'm going to and I'd like to know how you sideboard. Also, does the single main deck kill work out that well? A single Pithing Needle beats it...Maybe an Oblivion Ring main deck as well?

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-06-2008, 02:12 AM
Spatula, I'm going to use your build this week at a tournament I'm going to and I'd like to know how you sideboard. Also, does the single main deck kill work out that well? A single Pithing Needle beats it...Maybe an Oblivion Ring main deck as well?

Well, I had an Aura to kill one Needle, so it'd take two.

Angels come in against control/when they're not expecting it. I generally take out 1 Confinement and some accel; usually leaving in Sprawls and taking out the exploration effects and the Wild Growth.

The E Tutor plan is against combo, or any deck where you need to get one hoser out. Sacred Ground against Stax, CotV vs most combo(maybe burn), Seal of Primordium/Cleansing vs Aluren, Elephant Grass vs Ichorid. You should compose your tutor toolbox based on your meta-game. What you take out depends on the deck you're against.

Jak
04-06-2008, 02:28 AM
Just wanted to post my newest list after goldfishing quite a bit today. My after seeing Spat's list, I really wanted to change the deck. My list felt clunky and really only won if I got a strong number of Enchantresses. So I changed it up to a smoother curve and more accel. Loved it. Here is one that I have tweaked. Largely based off Spat's list.

3 Savannah
1 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath
9 Forest
2 Serra's Sanctum

4 Utopia Sprawl
1 Wild Growth
2 Exploration
2 Gaea's Touch
3 ESG

2 Replenish

4 Argothian
4 Presence

4 Elephant Grass
4 Ground Seal
4 Sterling Grove
3 Solitary Confinement
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Aura of Silence
1 Karmic Justice
1 Words of War

Grounded Seal is amazing. The list runs smoother because I am never in a position where I can't cast soemthing. ESG has been pretty awesome and is never dead. Late game yu discard it EOT when your hand is huge or you discard it to Confinement. Gaea's Touch is nice. It is okay to play early but when you are comboing out it is crazy good. I have been really liking the list. SB is posted above.

Jak
04-06-2008, 03:18 AM
Ack, another post. I just wanted to know if I should keep Replenish in against TES. Most lists run a Tranqulity or Cleanfall in the board and that will most likely win them the game. I was just wondering if it wise to keep it in.

Zach Tartell
04-06-2008, 11:38 AM
Ack, another post. I just wanted to know if I should keep Replenish in against TES. Most lists run a Tranqulity or Cleanfall in the board and that will most likely win them the game. I was just wondering if it wise to keep it in.

If they've had time to wish for Cleanfall and you haven't resolved Dovescape then you deserve to lose.

On a more serious note, take them out if you have things to play that are cheaper (even if they don't count). Just to draw into business spells, y'know.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-06-2008, 12:21 PM
Against TES I'd probably keep one, yeah. You're also presumably taking out Grasses, Justice, and O Ring? For 4x Chant, Aura and Confinement?

Jak
04-06-2008, 02:31 PM
Against TES I'd probably keep one, yeah. You're also presumably taking out Grasses, Justice, and O Ring? For 4x Chant, Aura and Confinement?

That's most of what I was taking out. I just wasn't sure about Grass in case they EtW, but that doesn't seem like the worst scenario.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-06-2008, 05:49 PM
Hm. That's a fair point. Maybe take out Groves, actually. They don't seem very relevant vs. combo.

Zach Tartell
04-06-2008, 06:36 PM
Hm. That's a fair point. Maybe take out Groves, actually. They don't seem very relevant vs. combo.

They find Dovescape, if you live that long.

Julian23
04-07-2008, 08:24 AM
Against TES I would go:

-2 Karmic Justice
-1 Oblivion Ring
-2 Exploration
-2 Wild Growth
-1 Replenish

+4 Rule of Law
+3 Aura of Silence
+1 Dovescape

Increasing the threat-densitiy is key against all kinds of fast combo decks.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-07-2008, 01:14 PM
I'm going to have to disagree. Keeping your deck fast is key against combo. Growth effects are especially important. Rule of Law usually won't be useful by turn 3.

Nihil Credo
04-07-2008, 02:26 PM
Why not take out Ground Seal instead of the acceleration effects (which can allow turn 2 Rule of Law)? IGG doesn't target, so it's basically a cycler.

Obfuscate Freely
04-07-2008, 03:13 PM
Rule of Law is awful in Enchantress. It slows you down more than it slows down most storm decks, which will just search up a bounce spell and kill you.

To win against a combo deck, you have to set up a Confinement before they can kill you, and then either create a hard lock (With Groves, Dovescape, or multiple Confinements) or kill them before they find an answer.

Your maindeck should already be mostly optimized to do this, since Enchantress' gameplan against aggro decks is pretty much the same. Thus, boarding in cards that will slow down the opposing combo deck makes sense, but you have to avoid things that will hurt your primary plan too much.

Chalice of the Void is one of the best choices for this, because it is also a great card to board in against Threshold. Unfortunately, it's effectiveness against combo varies, depending on which combo deck your opponent is playing, and which cards they draw.

Serbitar's suggestion of Orim's Chant is a pretty good one, since the threat of the card can buy you almost as much time as the card itself. In a metagame that justifies dedicated combo hate, I would consider running Chant instead of Chalice.

monopoman
04-08-2008, 12:21 AM
// Deck file for Magic Workstation (http://www.magicworkstation.com)

// Lands
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
4 [B] Savannah
2 [B] Taiga
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
7 [UNH] Forest
2 [UNH] Plains

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
2 [UD] Replenish
2 [OD] Karmic Justice
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
2 [US] Exploration
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
2 [OD] Ground Seal
1 [VI] City of Solitude
2 [LRW] Oblivion Ring
1 [TSB] Sacred Mesa
1 [ON] Words of War
1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
1 [LRW] Hoofprints of the Stag
1 [5E] Sylvan Library

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [UD] Replenish
SB: 1 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 3 [TE] Choke
SB: 1 [10E] Aura of Silence
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground
SB: 1 [DIS] Dovescape
SB: 1 [UD] Compost
SB: 1 [TE] Warmth
SB: 2 [CHK] Ghostly Prison
SB: 3 [PS] Orim's Chant

Here is the build im running right now with pretty good success any suggestions would be great. I run Prison cause Im thinking of seeing a lot more aggro then normal.

alebronwebb
04-08-2008, 01:05 AM
I pretty much agree with Obfuscate Freely. Take out Rule of Law, add Orim's Chant to SB. Board out Karmic Justice, Replenish (maybe), and others. Keeping in Growth affects, and imo Ground Seals for cantrips. Maybe adding the fourth Confinement to SB. I think pretty much you have to lock them out(via Dovescape, Confinements) before you can have any hope of killing them.

Brehn
04-09-2008, 08:24 PM
Been lurking for some time, now I'll contribute a somewhat bigger post...

First congratulations to SpatulaOfTheAges for the NoVA win. I'd like to analyze your list and your comments a little bit:



Thought #1: Enchantress mulligans a lot.
Thought #2: Enchantress needs an Enchantress and cheap spells to make a keepable hand, given an unknown opponent.
Thought #3: Moat, Oblivion Ring, Hoofprints of the Stag, even Sacred Mesa, do not fix these problems.

Actually, Moat does fix this. While it's not good against every deck, it's close to "gg" against a whole range of non-combo DtBs / DtWs. At the very least, it's buys you enough time to set up.



3x Elvish Spirit Guide
2x Gaea's Touch
2x Exploration
1x Wild Growth


O_O <-- that's what my first thought was.
1) Exploration + 19 lands = not a combo. This was adressed multiple times in this thread. In a deck with fewer than 25 lands, Exploration does not work as an early game acceleration and therefore it doesn't make hands keepable etc. Actually that's what Wild Growth does.
2) Elvish Spirit Guide. It's always a dead topdeck that makes Confinements more vulnerable. And usually, after you accelerated your presence out, you also need mana to pay for your Enchantments. Permanent Mana > ESG/Lotus Petal.
3) Gaea's Touch - I actually kinda like that one. Any advocates of Exploration "because you want it when going off" (since when is Enchantress a combo deck, geez) might as well consider that one.




1x Choke

This is debatable, but I've found City of Solitude to be the more backbreaking maindeck meta card against blue decks.



3x Sterling Grove
1x Karmic Justice
1x Aura of Silence
(...)
1x Taiga
2x Savannah
2x Serra's Sanctum
4x Windswept Heath
10x Forest

I see a blatant lack of white sources here. I've tested your list a little bit and getting the appropriate mana is kind of difficult sometimes. It doesn't get better with the sideboard that features


4x Exalted Angel
4x Enlightened Tutor
1x Aura of Silence
1x Dovescape



Now some reports of my own. I played what I considered to be an optimal list for a blue meta in Karlsruhe, 16 players (why couldn't it be one more?) so only 4 rounds of swiss.

4 Savannah
1 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath
2 Serra's Sanctum
7 Forest
3 Plains
4 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl

4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove

4 Elephant Grass
2 Replenish
3 Solitary Confinement

1 Moat
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Seal of Primordium
2 Ground Seal
1 Karmic Justice
1 City of Solitude

1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
1 Sacred Mesa

----

2 City of Solitude
2 Choke
2 Karmic Justice
1 Compost
1 Dovescape
1 Blood Moon
1 Aura of Silence
1 Rule of Law
1 Sacred Ground
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Null Chamber
1 Ground Seal

Match 1: UWbg Landstill. Green for Monasteries, featuring Faerie Conclaves, Intuition and Enlightened Tutor
Game 1: He plays a turn 2 Standstill. I break it with Enchantress, he Forces. He brainstorms, fetches and plays another Standstill. I break it with Presence, he Forces. That's how it goes on - the only spells he casts are 3 Standstills, 3 Forces, 2 or 3 Counterspells and 2 or 3 Brainstorms. I never resolve an Enchantress and he wins with Factory/Conclave beatdown
Game 2: Threat density ftw. This time he doesn't have the Standstill->Force->Standstill->Force chain, with the engine going I finally resolve a Choke followed by a Sacred Mesa.
Game 3: He counters an Enchantress, a City of Solitude and a Choke. I resolve Replenish, locking him down. I have 5 mana available, no Enchantress on the board and Enchantress's Presence + Karmic Justice in hand. I think "let's cast the presence" - big mistake. He draws a fetchland, double fetches and blows Explosives @ 3. Presence, City, Choke, all dead. I'm out of this game.

Landstill doesn't forgive mistakes...
0-1, 1-2

Match 2: Affownity (not the new Dreadnought version)
Game 1: Last time he was playing Boros, so I keep a hand without Enchantress, but with Moat. He plays Ornithopter, Frogmite and 2 Enforcers, I play a Moat and feel semi-comfortable. He topdecks Arcbound Ravager and puts 4 (wtf? only 4?) counters on the Ornithopter. The top 5 cards of my library are lands (I've fetched twice before). GG.
Game 2: A turn 2 Aura of Silence eats a Force of Will, but Replenish may resolve. Facing a Plated Cloud of Faeries I establish Moat+Confinement and eventually resolve Words of War, leaving him one final turn. An Echoing Truth on my Confinement makes me frown in the first moment (haven't drawn any Sterling Groves), but I remember that Aura of Silence can destroy Plating on his otherwise lethal Cloud, so I win that one.
Game 3: Turn 2 Aura of Silence rocks. But still, my hand is not the fastest one and he has double Ancient Tomb, so I soon face a plated Ornithopter and a WINTER ORB which causes serious problems. When he also plays Ravager I have to Oblivion Ring his Winter Orb and play a Confinement with 2 Enchantress Effects in my hand and none on the board. It works. Him not drawing any blue mana source (with 2 Echoing Truth in hand) did also help. Words of War finish the game.

Wow, this matchup is a pretty hard one.
1-1, 3-3

Match 3: UGw Threshold with Counterbalance and Hoofprints over Enforcer
Game 1: He gets Counterbalance on turn 3, and beats with 2 Goyfs. I resolve a Presence and when I'm about to die I Time Walk once with a Confinement, then find my Sacred Mesa, producing 2 Tokens. He only finds one StoP in the 9 cards he looked at with Top+2 Fetch, so I survive. However, he finds a Needle shutting down Mesa. I dig for additional outs an find a Replenish bringing back Confinement. I can resolve some Enchantresses afterwards, Seal of Primordium (or Obl. Ring?) deals with Needle and Mesa wins.
Game 2: Having Mongoose = good. Having a Force in Hand = good. Topdecking the second Force = good. Having a Sensei's Divining Top to dig for the second land that is missing = ok, not bad. Discovering that there's no land in the top 7 cards = oh well... That was an easy one. He doesn't have infinite free counterspells so eventually I just resolve 2 Enchantress effects + Hoofprints.

I imagined this to be harder.
2-1, 5-3

Match 4: 4c Landstill with Cunning Wish
Game 1: I'm on the play and face a turn 3 Pernicious Deed. I look at my hand which features Karmic Justice, Replenish and Replenish. This is gonna be fun. After I justiced his board he forces the first Replenish but can't force the second one. Facing two Enchantress effects + Karmic Justice + Confinement + Sterling Grove he scoops.
Game 2: Third turn Karmic Justice. Fourth turn Karmic Justice. He doesn't look happy. I don't remember much of the game, it just included a Forced Moat, a Forced Replenish, Cunning Wish->Dismantling Blow, and Ground Seal > Academy Ruins. I still won with only one Enchantress effect out. Threat density ftw.

Justice rules.
3-1, 7-3

Conclusions:
- The only match I've lost was due to a severe misplay, sounds good to me.
- Never really wanted to see Hoofprints, though, although I've won once with them.
- The Affownity player didn't use his Wastelands properly, he might have been able to screw me in 1 or 2 moments, also, I was lucky that the 4C Landstill-Player didn't have a Wasteland in game 1, it might have cost me the game. I think about doing -1 Savannah +1 Wooded Foothills.
- Disappointed with Ground Seal. Often I would have liked Sylvan Library better.

After the tournament, I read SpatulaOfTheAges' report. I don't like his list, but he says 4 Ground Seals are necessary, so I decide to leave the Sylvan Libraries out and test 4 Seals.

Next weekend, next tournament, this time in Heidelberg. Unknown meta for me, 16 players, 4 rounds Swiss (again...). I scout some Loam, so 4 Ground Seals should be right.

MB:
-1 Hoofprints of the Stag
-1 City of Solitude
+2 Ground Seal
SB:
-1 Ground Seal
+1 Hoofprints of the Stag

As stated, 4 Seals main. I wanted to give the 5-dual-manabase a last chance. Hoofprints in the SB because I feel somewhat uncomfortable with only 2 available winconditions in an unknown meta.


Match 1: Ub Faerie Stompy, no Forces, but Shriekmaws.
Game 1: Sea Drake + Serendib Efreet quickly take me down, but I can establish Confinement just in time (always tried to bait FoW before...). Words of War wins.
Game 2: He has Chalice @ 1 and 2, I spend my time "cycling" Ground Seals and Enchant Lands with one Presence out. I find Sacred Mesa to stop his Mulldrifter beats just in time and misplay by only leaving enough mana open to produce 2 blockers for 2 dudes. He topdecks Pestermite, tapping a blocker. Great, this starts just like the last time, I'm retarded.
Game 3: He mulls to 5 and faces a turn 2 Aura of Silence. I take some beats, then establish Confinement and finish with, I think, Words of War.

Fortunately that stupid mistake in game 2 didn't cost me the match...
1-0, 2-1

Match 2: RG Aggro Loam.
Game 1: Land, Mox Diamond, Mox Diamond, Countryside Crusher. WTF. Hmmm... okay, take that: second turn Presence, third turn Ground Seal, fourth turn Moat. Fifth turn Burning Wish, Reverent Silence, GG. (There are certain hands one can't defeat.)
Game 2: Mulligan to 6, keeping Taiga as the only green source. But otherwise a promising hand including Ground Seal and Enchantress's Presence. He wastes my Taiga and cuts me off green (I draw 2/3 Basic Plains), then he grips my Ground Seal and sets up Loam + Assault. I have a tiny piece of hope when I draw a green source and cast Argothian Enchantress -- just to discover he has Devastating Dreams in his hand.

Opponent draws the nuts game 1, I'm screwed game 2. Oh well...
1-1, 2-3

Match 3: Gbu Loam - >30 lands, Intuition, Dark Confidant, Witness, Crucible, Ruins+EE, Glacial Chasm, Explorations, Manabond. Whatever you want to call it.
Game 1: He Ghost Quarters me 7 (!) times with the help of Loam+Exploration, just to discover that I play enough basics. Ground Seal stops Loam and Moat stops swinging Confidants and Witnesses, the engine is all set up and I'm just about to win when he counts his mana sources and says "Profane Command for 7." .....wtf.....
Game 2: Turn 2 Blood Moon > His Deck. By the time he finds Mox Diamond + Krosan Grip I've already won.
Game 3: Like in game 1, Ground Seal and Moat stop him easily, this time I know I also have to set up Confinement. He dies to his own Confidants.

Strange deck. He keeps talking about how unlucky he was. Hmmm...
2-1, 4-4

Match 4: UGr Threshold. Somebody tells me he might run mainboard Trygon Predators...
Game 1: Yep. Turn 2 Tarmogoyf, Turn 3 Trygon Predator, Force-backup. You need a god-draw to beat this, I didn't have one.
Game 2: I get my revenge with a turn 2 force-baiting Enchantress, turn 3 Choke, locking him down. His single Tarmogoyf is handled by Moat, he scoops to Sacred Mesa.
Game 3: I keep a good hand (Presence, Choke, Confinement) that has one drawback: My first turn must be Savannah + Wild Growth. I haven't seen a Wasteland in those 2 games so I decide it's worth the risk. He ponders into a turn 2 Wasteland that screws me. Mongoose + Goyf beat and I can't do anything about it.

ZOMG Trygon Predator. And ZOMG lost to Wasteland again.
2-2, 5-6

Conclusions:
- I've lost 2 games to a single Wasteland. This was definitely the last time I've played this deck with 5 duals.
- Ground Seal is huge when you face Loam twice. But it sucked against Threshold - again.
- Hoofprints were not boarded a single time. They will leave the deck.

A reworked manabase could look like this:

4 Windswept Heath
3 Wooded Foothills
7 Forest
2 Plains
2 Savannah
1 Taiga
2 Serra's Sanctum
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Wild Growth

What do you gain? Less vulnerability to Wasteland. With 8 Enchant Land-effects you really don't want to draw duals.
What do you lose? Invulnerability to Stifle.
> Getting an enchanted dual wasted is much more devastating than getting a fetchland wasted. ("Just enchant your basic lands" -- I'd like to, but for some reason I always draw my duals)
> Wasteland sees more play than Stifle.
> If you draw all your fetchlands, you should often be able to play around Stifle. But if you draw all your duals, you're not really able to play around Wasteland.

On the combo matchup: Rule of Law is not ideal, but Chalice of the Void sucks even more, don't play it. Orim's Chant might be the best inclusion. Note that Chant works well with a fetchland-heavy manabase.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-09-2008, 09:24 PM
I'm always glad to see any Enchantress player do well, but I have a lot I disagree with in your post.


Actually, Moat does fix this. While it's not good against every deck, it's close to "gg" against a whole range of non-combo DtBs / DtWs. At the very least, it's buys you enough time to set up.

Going over your list I didn't see any games Moat won you, and one where it directly cost you the game (making you think you could hide behind Moat instead of mulling into an enchantress).


1) Exploration + 19 lands = not a combo. This was adressed multiple times in this thread. In a deck with fewer than 25 lands, Exploration does not work as an early game acceleration and therefore it doesn't make hands keepable etc. Actually that's what Wild Growth does.
2) Elvish Spirit Guide. It's always a dead topdeck that makes Confinements more vulnerable. And usually, after you accelerated your presence out, you also need mana to pay for your Enchantments. Permanent Mana > ESG/Lotus Petal.
3) Gaea's Touch - I actually kinda like that one. Any advocates of Exploration "because you want it when going off" (since when is Enchantress a combo deck, geez) might as well consider that one.

Emphasis mine. This difference in attitudes towards the deck is exactly what I was talking about when I say I have a deep distrust for the direction Enchantress is headed, and honestly, I think it's this approach that is keeping Enchantress out of the DTB forum.

You guys are treating Enchantress like it's Parfait with a draw engine. I think of Enchantress as a deck that wins by drawing cards. Not just in the general sense that all decks win by drawing cards. But the decks almost exclusive function is drawing and playing as many cards as possible. A high curve and cards that don't replace their casting cost slow down your main goal of drawing cards. So those cards must be exceptional to make up for their weight. Replenish, Confinement, Grass, Ground Seal, all offer you abilities that are well worth their cost.


blatant lack of white sources here. I've tested your list a little bit and getting the appropriate mana is kind of difficult sometimes. It doesn't get better with the sideboard that features

I think this is again a matter of how you approach the deck. Early game I don't need very much white. If you rely more on playing your bullet enchantments than aggressively drawing cards, I guess more white would make sense.

Although I may change the MD Aura to a Seal.


combo matchup: Rule of Law is not ideal, but Chalice of the Void sucks even more, don't play it. Orim's Chant might be the best inclusion. Note that Chant works well with a fetchland-heavy manabase.

Why do you say CotV sucks?

Brehn
04-09-2008, 10:06 PM
Going over your list I didn't see any games Moat won you, and one where it directly cost you the game (making you think you could hide behind Moat instead of mulling into an enchantress).

It did win games. It won:
- Game 2 vs Ubg Loam (stopped 2x Bob + Witness)
- Game 3 vs Ubg Loam (stopped 3x Bob + Witness)
- Game 2 vs UGr Threshold. This exact game is a major example of a game your list couldn't have won easily. So you resolved a Choke and your Thresh-playing opponent doesn't have any mana anymore. But he does have a 5/6 Goyf. And he forced your Enchantress. What can your list do to stop that clock? You play 2 Confinements - you don't have the setup to achieve a lock. You play 4 Grass (so do I) - but against Threshold you've probably boarded them out (so did I). That's it. I think you'll lose that game. I have Oblivion Rings, I have Moat, I have one more Confinement to do at least a Time Walk, I have Mesa for chumpblockers, I have 4 Groves instead of your three. I win that game.

Moat also could have won:
- Game 1 vs Ubg Loam (hadn't he topdecked his singleton Profane Command, his only maindeck card that beats Ground Seal + Moat)
- Game 1 vs RG Aggro Loam (hadn't he had the Burning Wish in time)

Also it did:
- bait a Force vs 4c Landstill.
- bait a Force vs UGw Threshold, resulting in a resolving Mesa.
- buy several turns vs Affownity (lost anyway because of 5 topdecked lands). A 4/6 Ornithopter is a slower clock than a 0/2 Ornithopter, 2 Myr Enforcers and a Frogmite.

Truth is, I had no matchup like Goblins where I could just write "Moat = gg". But it still was useful in every match except the Faerie Stompy one.


You guys are treating Enchantress like it's Parfait with a draw engine. I think of Enchantress as a deck that wins by drawing cards.(...)Replenish, Confinement, Grass, Ground Seal, all offer you abilities that are well worth their cost.
I also played 8x Enchantress + 4x Ground Seal + 4x Grass + 5x Confinement/Replenish. I just cut cards that are dead in several occasions (namely Exploration, Gaea's Touch, Elvish Spirit Guide) for cards that guarantee you'll have the time to set up your engine, like Oblivion Ring, Moat or even Sacred Mesa (which did the job once and would have done a second time hadn't I been a retard). I actually can't see how Elvish Spirit Guide or Gaea's Touch fit into a strategy of "aggressively drawing cards". They're not Parfait-style cards, for sure. But is Gaea's Touch really superior to Oblivion Ring? I know the comparison is somewhat out of place, but you play Touch where I play Ring.



Why do you say CotV sucks?

Chalice @ 0 doesn't stop TES from going off. You might be able to slow them down 1 or 2 turns, but then they are able to go off through it, they don't even need to remove it. Removing a Chalice is possible in a single turn. Setting Chalice @ 1 doesn't make much sense to me, and Chalice @ 2 should be too slow, although it can be cast on turn 2 in a list with Elvish Spirit Guides.
What I like about Rule of Law is that they absolutely can't go off through it. TES has to go for Burning Wish -> Cleanfall, which costs two additional turns, not to forget they need multiple lands (they only play 10) and/or Simian Spirit Guides, otherwise they take even longer. In this time you can hopefully set up Null Chamber / Dovescape via Sterling Grove.
However, Orim's Chant should be the best choice as they stop TES after your first turn. But I don't think that Chants are able to do it alone, you'll still need a Rule of Law to back it up after TES has found his own Chant.

technogeek5000
04-09-2008, 10:31 PM
you should probably be running at least 1 moat so you can search it up with sterling grove, anyways thats what ive been doing with my MWS list. Basically whats been working for me is a lot of E accelerants, a playset of groves, and a bunch of different one of's to make a sort of tool box. Its very close to what Spat posted but i dropped some of the more situational cards like choke, aura of silence, etc... and put more versatile ones in. I saved those as 1 ofs for the board and it realy has been working for me.

Jak
04-09-2008, 10:57 PM
I played around with a list that looked exactly like Brehn's. It played well, but lost me games because the engine was slow and clunky while getting going. It was never very fast to get into a lock. After seeing Spat's list, I changed mine a lot. Adding the accel was the first part. ESG is never dead! The mana it provides is awesome. Playing turn one Argothian is awesome. Discarding it to Confinement is awesome. I have never ran into a situation where I hated seeing it.

Exploration has not been bad at all. I do want to add another land to make it more effective first turn, but I have not had repeated problems with mana. He is just great and draws so many cards because it lets me keep playing enchantments.

Moat was a cool card, but I hardly ever played it. I loved it as a stall piece, but I rarely got it down early enough for it to do anything. Most of the time it sat in my hand until I got a Sanctum down to cast it.

Also, I have upped the white count to 3 Savannahs and have never had problems casting stuff.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-09-2008, 11:11 PM
It did win games. It won:
- Game 2 vs Ubg Loam (stopped 2x Bob + Witness)
- Game 3 vs Ubg Loam (stopped 3x Bob + Witness)
- Game 2 vs UGr Threshold. This exact game is a major example of a game your list couldn't have won easily. So you resolved a Choke and your Thresh-playing opponent doesn't have any mana anymore. But he does have a 5/6 Goyf. And he forced your Enchantress. What can your list do to stop that clock? You play 2 Confinements - you don't have the setup to achieve a lock. You play 4 Grass (so do I) - but against Threshold you've probably boarded them out (so did I). That's it. I think you'll lose that game. I have Oblivion Rings, I have Moat, I have one more Confinement to do at least a Time Walk, I have Mesa for chumpblockers, I have 4 Groves instead of your three. I win that game.

Actually, no, I keep in Grass because it combos so well with Choke. I side out Explorations, Touches and Confinements for Angels, Choke, City and Aura. I have more outs there, but that's may be partly because you're keeping in Confinement, which is a mistake against them.

I obviously can't gainsay which games it won, since I wasn't there, but your report doesn't reveal any critical role that the card played. The Moat slot converted into an extra Replenish for me, and that third Replenish won me many games.


I also played 8x Enchantress + 4x Ground Seal + 4x Grass + 5x Confinement/Replenish. I just cut cards that are dead in several occasions (namely Exploration, Gaea's Touch, Elvish Spirit Guide) for cards that guarantee you'll have the time to set up your engine, like Oblivion Ring, Moat or even Sacred Mesa (which did the job once and would have done a second time hadn't I been a retard).

But those are not a guarantee. They're a gamble. And they're very mana hungry gambles. And they have a hidden drawback, in that they prevent explosive Enchantress hands like my list has. If we compared games where you resolved and untapped with an Enchantress, I would bet large that my list has a much higher win rate.


I actually can't see how Elvish Spirit Guide or Gaea's Touch fit into a strategy of "aggressively drawing cards". They're not Parfait-style cards, for sure. But is Gaea's Touch really superior to Oblivion Ring? I know the comparison is somewhat out of place, but you play Touch where I play Ring.

Yes. Because Oblivion Ring tries to do its own thing, whereas Gaea's Touch only works with Enchantresses out, but with Enchantresses out, Gaea's Touch is Gush with Exploration out, and Oblivion Ring is a Counsel of the Soratami.

I guess you could make an argument in certain metas to play stall cards over accel, but really, in any meta where that would make sense, I'd rather just play Ichorid.


Chalice @ 0 doesn't stop TES from going off. You might be able to slow them down 1 or 2 turns, but then they are able to go off through it, they don't even need to remove it. Removing a Chalice is possible in a single turn. Setting Chalice @ 1 doesn't make much sense to me, and Chalice @ 2 should be too slow, although it can be cast on turn 2 in a list with Elvish Spirit Guides.

I don't see why @ 1 doesn't make sense. After the first turn it's not that big a detriment.

The thing is that, outside possibly Chant, none of your options do more than buy a turn or two on their own, but Chalice can do it for free without hurting your gameplan.


However, Orim's Chant should be the best choice as they stop TES after your first turn. But I don't think that Chants are able to do it alone, you'll still need a Rule of Law to back it up after TES has found his own Chant.

But even when they drop their own Chant, you Chant in response and they still can't go off that turn. That still buys at least one turn. I think at least we're agreed that Chant seems like the best option, though of course it needs more actual testing.

thedarkness
04-09-2008, 11:28 PM
Wow...been a while since I posted here.

First off, you need to know that I have neither the money nor the time to invest in real-life M:tG anymore, but I have been playing the game for many years, and of the many decks in this, my favorite format, Enchantress is by and large one of my favorites. Until fairly recently, I kept careful track of the changes in the deck, ran it frequently on MWS (several people who post on these boards will recognize my name, and yeah, it's me if you don't already know), and tested several original changes, many of which elude me at the moment.

However, in the end the list I ended up with was almost invariably along these lines:

Mana
7 Forest
2 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum
4 Windswept Heath
2 Savannah
1 Taiga
2 Wooded Foothills
4 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl

Engine
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence

Spells
3 Replenish

Enchantments
4 Elephant Grass
4 Sterling Grove
2 Oblivion Ring
3 City of Solitude
3 Solitary Confinement
1 Karmic Justice
1 Moat

Win
1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
1 Sacred Mesa

Sideboard
2 Karmic Justice
2 Choke
3 Ground Seal
1 Dovescape
1 Null Chamber
1 Sacred Ground
4 Orim's Chant
1 Compost

This is the most recent list I've tested, and it performed well for me.

I'm aware that there is a degree of unnecessary redundancy in some of the choices, but that is in fact by design.

It's not a matter of superstition, just my observations about the way that MWS randomizes cards. Over more test shuffles and hands than I really care to count, and more than enough test matches to verify those hands' legitimacy, I found that even with 4 Sterling Groves (which incidentally, I haven't seen one of before locking my opponent in several weeks), I needed three City of Solitude just the consistently have an answer to the seemingly common opposing draw of Brehn's mentioned "Standstill->Force->Standstill->Force" chain. It seems that when I run Enchantress, all I face is Landstill or Faerie Stompy. It's kind of disconcerting, but they are (or were at least) fairly common decks in the metagame I play on online.

Anyway, let me revise the list slightly to be less MWS-shuffles-in-the-most-bizarre-fashion-o.O - like.

Mana
7 Forest
2 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum
4 Windswept Heath
2 Savannah
1 Taiga
2 Wooded Foothills
4 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl

Engine
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence

Spells
3 Replenish

Enchantments
4 Elephant Grass
4 Sterling Grove
2 Oblivion Ring
1 City of Solitude
3 Solitary Confinement
1 Karmic Justice
1 Moat
1 Ground Seal
1 Seal of Primordium

Win
1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
1 Sacred Mesa

Sideboard
2 Karmic Justice
1 Choke
2 Ground Seal
1 Dovescape
1 Null Chamber
1 Sacred Ground
4 Orim's Chant
1 Compost
2 City of Solitude

This list may seem, and indeed is, fundamentally similar to Brehn's list, but that's probably because he helped me build it, though it was probably a couple months ago now. My sense of time is almost nonexistent... But regardless, in my testing I've never had major issues with the manabase; it's been almost the same for about as long as I've been playing the deck.

The rest of the deck, besides the core of the deck, staple cards that I personally would never run less than four of (Enchantresses, Groves, G-CC mana auras, and 3 Solitary Confinement), is mostly influenced by my own testing, and I haven't really reconnected with Brehn about the deck until earlier today in fact. Any changes from my 2-3 week old list were not influenced by him, but more by my browsing through this thread looking for updates. There weren't many that I hadn't already added or read of elsewhere, but I enjoy reading the posts here.

On that subject, I actually played against Brehn today in an 8 man tournament (I don't know if I'm allowed to say where; suffice it to say, it was not a real-life tournament). He was using Spatula's list(+-1 card if I remember correctly, though I don't remember what card he changed if he did), and I was running Pox. Now, in my personal experience with the deck, that matchup has the potential to be absolutely awful. I got two decent draws; he got one subpar one and one that just had me confused.

The exact details of the match I don't remember too clearly, as I'm very tired, and I have a bad headache and a generally bad memory already. However, I do recall quite clearly slaughtering his hand game 1 and being thoroughly confused by what I saw, a feeling that was compounded when I was told that he was running 19 lands.

I have to say, the manabase on Spatula's list had me dumbstruck, though I'll let the people who have tested it for themselves pass judgment on that front. I will however agree with Brehn here: Enchantments that let you play more lands make useless 4-ofs if you don't run enough lands to support the effect. I consider it to be along the lines of running a play set of Forces and Dazes as your only blue spells, with only 4 Islands in your deck, for example. I dropped Exploration months ago because it wasn't really serving the purpose it was intended for consistently enough with my 20 land mana base. It was never intended to allow me to drop extra lands while going off. That serves no real purpose, as I'm sure most if not all of the people who actually read my post already know. I DO however like Gaea's Touch; it seems like it could be a very explosive spell in the right situations.

On a similar note, I see no real benefit to drawing Elvish Spirit Guide at ANY point in the game. On turn one on the play, your Enchantress can still be easily Forced, and on the draw Forced or Dazed. After that, any other ESGs seem like dead weight in your hand most of the time unless you have a Confinement to pitch them to. But lands serve that purpose just as well, do they not? But again, I'll let the people who test the list truly pass judgment. I do however plan to be one of those people, though not with the exact list that Spatula won with.

At worst, this has given me something to think about until I keel over from exhaustion. I could use the sleep anyway, but I'll keep monitoring this thread.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-10-2008, 12:58 AM
But lands serve that purpose just as well, do they not?

Only if you have Exploration out.

And not on turn 1.

The problem I have with these lists is that they seem to assume that once an Enchantress is down, the game is won. That simply isn't the case; you need to get an Enchantress down and proceed to draw a ridiculous amount of cards to be in a winning position. The list I'm advocating is much more suited to that task. It has less of a plan B, this is true. But I don't consider the current plan B to be much good anyway.


On that subject, I actually played against Brehn today in an 8 man tournament (I don't know if I'm allowed to say where; suffice it to say, it was not a real-life tournament). He was using Spatula's list(+-1 card if I remember correctly, though I don't remember what card he changed if he did)), and I was running Pox. Now, in my personal experience with the deck, that matchup has the potential to be absolutely awful. I got two decent draws; he got one subpar one and one that just had me confused.

The exact details of the match I don't remember too clearly, as I'm very tired, and I have a bad headache and a generally bad memory already. However, I do recall quite clearly slaughtering his hand game 1 and being thoroughly confused by what I saw, a feeling that was compounded when I was told that he was running 19 lands.

I don't know what to say other than I beat two discard heavy decks in the tournament I played 2 weeks ago, and won both matches 2-0. One of those games I even mulled to 4. I think blaming the deck may be premature; I wouldn't expect anyone used to playing the list you guys have posted to adjust automatically to playing my more aggressive list. It's a very different mentality.

I certainly don't see how having a higher curve would improve your Pox match-up.

Brehn
04-10-2008, 10:43 AM
The problem I have with these lists is that they seem to assume that once an Enchantress is down, the game is won. That simply isn't the case; you need to get an Enchantress down and proceed to draw a ridiculous amount of cards to be in a winning position. The list I'm advocating is much more suited to that task. It has less of a plan B, this is true. But I don't consider the current plan B to be much good anyway.

The problem I have with your list is that you assume you always get an Enchantress down. On turn 1 or turn 2. I've looked through your report again, you've played against exactly one deck with counters, and you lost that match. Also, your Enchantresses were never discarded or removed except for one game (vs Garvish Aggro) which you lost (probably some got discarded in the other discard matchups, but you still got to stick at least one).


Yes. Because Oblivion Ring tries to do its own thing, whereas Gaea's Touch only works with Enchantresses out, but with Enchantresses out, Gaea's Touch is Gush with Exploration out, and Oblivion Ring is a Counsel of the Soratami.

That's the problem. "with Enchantresses out"... I don't doubt it. If you tell me "I always resolve an Enchantress effect on turn 2 and it doesn't get removed ever", I can see an inclusion of Gaea's Touch fully justified.


I guess you could make an argument in certain metas to play stall cards over accel, but really, in any meta where that would make sense, I'd rather just play Ichorid.
The only meta where I wouldn't play Enchantress is called "combo-heavy meta", and I wouldn't play Ichorid there either.


Let's adress two important matchups:

a) Threshold.

Don't think you'll resolve that single Enchantress in your hand, you probably won't. Games I play against Threshold very often involve a Fow'd Enchantress effect on turn 2 or 3, and either BalanceTop or Tarmogoyf or Tarmogoyf+X on their turn 3. This position doesn't look very nice, but winning from it is far from impossible. Some important advantages my list has:
1) Daze-proof. I'll just say: 21 lands > 19 lands. 8 Enchant Lands > 5 Enchant Lands. This makes it very easy to play around Daze, leaving them with only 4 actual counterspells.
2) CB-proof. A high curve (with several spells with cc3) is actually quite useful when facing Counterbalance.
3) More mana available -> additional CB-proof. Exploration and Gaea's Touch are pretty useless without Enchantress effects, while Enchant Lands and lands themselves are not necessarily. Play 3 spells in one turn and the last one might very well resolve through CB (sure, this doesn't always work)
4) I play answers to beaters. Elephant Grass will never resolve through BalanceTop if the Threshold player doesn't want to, and even if it does resolve it won't stop a beating Tarmogoyf without the help of Choke. Without Enchantresses, Confinement just buys you one turn, a hardcasted Spirit Guide just buys you one turn. Grass + Choke is horribly difficult to set up when facing a 2-turn or 3-turn clock. And that's it, you don't play any more answers. Now what about answers like Sacred Mesa, Oblivion Ring or Moat, all of them CB-proof? If I'm somehow able to resolve a Sterling Grove, I don't have any difficulties to stop them. Also, if Grove got countered, I can still Replenish it. Sure you also can do so, but what are you going to tutor for? Enchantress's Presence, while you're on 4 life?
5) Postboard: Threat density. Sure this depends a lot on your sideboard, but with 2-3 Cities and 2 Chokes it's hard not to resolve a key spell. Additional Oblivion Rings also help.

b) Landstill.

Two pages back you described how to beat Landstill:

Dovescape. Replenish. Threat density.

Pack an extra Replenish in the board
I agree....

and aggresively draw cards. Don't dance around with stuff trying to protect your board. Just draw more cards than them. Make that your priority.
...not.
- Karmic Justice is THE MVP in that matchup (after Replenish). Nearly any time you resolve it you're in a favorable position.
- "Just draw more cards than them" -- yeah, I'd love to, but somehow I never draw more than one card per turn. Does this have something to do with them countering and EE'ing all my Enchantresses? This sentence already implies a favorable position. I don't say I have won as soon as I have an Enchantress on the board (as you accused me to), but I say you're at least in a favorable position. Often the problem you have with Landstill is that they actually draw more cards than you do and you're not able to stop that. That's why I think there are two important concepts:

1) Threat density
2) Karmic Justice.

Usually I don't lose postboard games to Landstill with my list (unless I scrub out like in Karlsruhe...). That's because my list (even with only 2 Replenish) looks like this:

If I don't counter this I lose:
3 City of Solitude <-- 3 Force of Will
3 Karmic Justice <-- 4th Force, 2 Counterspell
2 Replenish <-- Counterspell #3 and 4
2 Choke <--- fuck, I'm out.
1 Dovescape <--- :(
1 Blood Moon <--- had I just played MUC...

I'd also like to counter/remove this:
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
2 Solitary Confinement (only one gets boarded out)

That's how it goes. Don't think you could draw more cards than Landstill. Just play more Must-counter cards than they have counters. Save your Replenishes for the end of the counter-baiting key-spell chain and do try to resolve Karmic Justice anyhow, because even after resolving 4 key spells, Deed and EE have the potential to totally wreck you. Boarding gets a little bit more difficult if they play Academy Ruins, because if they do, you really want to see a Ground Seal.

Now look at your list. 3 Replenish, 2 Justice, 1 Choke, 1 Dovescape. I doubt that's enough. With so few gamebreaking spells they might as well let the Justice resolve and just focus on countering/removing your engine and countering your Replenishes. Have you tested the UWb and 4C Landstill matchups? If you did, how did the games end in which you couldn't stick an Enchantress effect?



Last note: Your arguments about the third Replenish make sense, I'll add it at least to the sideboard. However, I'll never cut Moat for it. Maybe you couldn't see it in my reports but Moat was absolutely turning the board position around in 6 games, while being critical in 2 others, see my last post. That's just as gamebreaking as Replenish. And in fact, Replenish would never have been better.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-10-2008, 01:47 PM
Disclaimer: I may come off as combative in this post. It's nothing personal against you, it's that we're each arguing for two very different philosophies for the deck, and I see the distinction as crucial for the future of the deck.


The problem I have with your list is that you assume you always get an Enchantress down. On turn 1 or turn 2. I've looked through your report again, you've played against exactly one deck with counters, and you lost that match. Also, your Enchantresses were never discarded or removed except for one game (vs Garvish Aggro) which you lost (probably some got discarded in the other discard matchups, but you still got to stick at least one).

That's not true. I had multiple Enchantresses discarded in rounds 2 and 3, but I can win through disruption because I only need to stick a single Enchantress to quickly go out of control.

Also, that game against Thresh, had the Replenish I drew been a Moat, would not have won me the game, since all my Replenishes got countered anyway. So blaming the different decklists for my one loss is disengenuous.


That's the problem. "with Enchantresses out"... I don't doubt it. If you tell me "I always resolve an Enchantress effect on turn 2 and it doesn't get removed ever", I can see an inclusion of Gaea's Touch fully justified.

How about this; "if I don't resolve an Enchantress sometime, I'm not going to win"? Because that's what the reality of this deck is. You MUST resolve an Enchantress. If you think you're going to win with Moat and Karmic Justice, you're fooling yourself. Once in a blue moon you may pull out a win just by Pegasus tokens, but then I've won once or twice with ESG beats, so let's drop the flukes and look at what the deck's actual gameplan is.


The only meta where I wouldn't play Enchantress is called "combo-heavy meta", and I wouldn't play Ichorid there either.

I'm not implying that Enchantress is necessarily bad in a control heavy meta. I'm saying that in a meta-game where you can afford to view Enchantress as a control deck, and don't seem to care about your speed is one where I would rather just play Ichorid. Speed matters; you see that a lot in your reports. The best defense against board sweepers is A) Replenish, B) have a full hand post-sweep. It's hard to fill up your hand quickly when you have a bunch of 3cc enchantments.


a) Threshold.

Don't think you'll resolve that single Enchantress in your hand, you probably won't.

I run 1 less must-counter game 1 than you do.

Your list:
8x Enchantresses
4x Grove
2x Replenish
1x Sacred Mesa
1x Hoofprints
1x City of Solitude

My list:
8x Enchantresses
3x Grove
3x Replenish
1x Choke
1x Sylvan Library

BUT I can cast a turn 1 Argothian or Library on the play, before they have Daze or Brainstorm active. So our odds of resolving a spell that matters are about the same, except I can more rapidly take advantage of it, which is especially important if the first Enchantress is countered. I played lists like yours for a while, and what often ends up happening is that they counter or Thoughtseize the first one, and the second, and you resolve the third, but by then you're within one or two swings of death, and you need to draw into answers quickly. So you drop maybe a Moat, which takes your whole turn, and draws one card, but then they cantrip into a Grip or an Enforcer and just kill you anyway, because you couldn't take advantage of your draw engine.


Games I play against Threshold very often involve a Fow'd Enchantress effect on turn 2 or 3, and either BalanceTop or Tarmogoyf or Tarmogoyf+X on their turn 3. This position doesn't look very nice, but winning from it is far from impossible. Some important advantages my list has:
1) Daze-proof. I'll just say: 21 lands > 19 lands. 8 Enchant Lands > 5 Enchant Lands. This makes it very easy to play around Daze, leaving them with only 4 actual counterspells.

You need those extra mana sources because your curve is higher, making you more vulnerable to Daze.

Obviously you have never ESGed a Daze before, or you wouldn't think that my list was more vulnerable to Daze than your's.


2) CB-proof. A high curve (with several spells with cc3) is actually quite useful when facing Counterbalance.

Only if your high cc spells matter. I would rather resolve a Replenish in one game than a Moat in three games, because the Replenish will win me that game single-handedly and the Moat won't win anything on its own.


3) More mana available -> additional CB-proof. Exploration and Gaea's Touch are pretty useless without Enchantress effects, while Enchant Lands and lands themselves are not necessarily. Play 3 spells in one turn and the last one might very well resolve through CB (sure, this doesn't always work)

You know that Gaea's Touch has a second ability, right? And that spells with lower cc's are easier to cast in multiples than spells with higher cc's?


4) I play answers to beaters. Elephant Grass will never resolve through BalanceTop if the Threshold player doesn't want to, and even if it does resolve it won't stop a beating Tarmogoyf without the help of Choke. Without Enchantresses, Confinement just buys you one turn, a hardcasted Spirit Guide just buys you one turn. Grass + Choke is horribly difficult to set up when facing a 2-turn or 3-turn clock. And that's it, you don't play any more answers. Now what about answers like Sacred Mesa, Oblivion Ring or Moat, all of them CB-proof?

Do you PLAY against Threshold?

I've rarely seen a player have any serious difficulty getting a 3 cc spell in their top 3 if they need to.

Sacred Mesa costs seven mana to buy one turn. Seven. 3 to cast, 2 to upkeep, and 2 to actually block one dude(assuming their StP doesn't just eat it). When you're under pressure, ramping up 7 mana to chump one dude isn't going to save you.


If I'm somehow able to resolve a Sterling Grove, I don't have any difficulties to stop them. Also, if Grove got countered, I can still Replenish it. Sure you also can do so, but what are you going to tutor for? Enchantress's Presence, while you're on 4 life?

It depends on what's out on my board. If nothing, Moat is just going to buy a turn or two at most before it gets Gripped or they swing with an Enforcer. In situations like these, you're pretty much done for anyway. I'd rather play a list that concentrates on winning from salvagable positions, rather than playing a lot of sub-par contingencies that slow down your main plan.


5) Postboard: Threat density. Sure this depends a lot on your sideboard, but with 2-3 Cities and 2 Chokes it's hard not to resolve a key spell. Additional Oblivion Rings also help.

Yeah, I was playing more Chokes and Cities for a while. But Angel pretty much stomps every control deck, especially since they don't see it coming. The only creature it doesn't race is Dreadnought.


...not.
- Karmic Justice is THE MVP in that matchup (after Replenish). Nearly any time you resolve it you're in a favorable position.

What?

A lot of this stuff is theoretically debatable, but now you're telling me that card advantage doesn't matter against Landstill?

And that Karmic Justice is MVP, when it doesn't do anything on its own?


- "Just draw more cards than them" -- yeah, I'd love to, but somehow I never draw more than one card per turn. Does this have something to do with them countering and EE'ing all my Enchantresses?

I think it has a lot to do with your high curve and lack of good mid-game accelerants. Which is what I've been trying to get across.


This sentence already implies a favorable position. I don't say I have won as soon as I have an Enchantress on the board (as you accused me to), but I say you're at least in a favorable position.

I didn't say you said that. I'm saying your lists seem to make this (fatal) assumption. And that's going to cost you games. Your deck isn't designed to fully take advantage of a single Enchantress. Mine is. Your deck gives this up in favor of a back-up plan. Maybe I'd understand this if the back-up plan were any good. But it's really not.


If I don't counter this I lose:
3 City of Solitude <-- 3 Force of Will
3 Karmic Justice <-- 4th Force, 2 Counterspell

No. Just no. Karmic Justice and City of Solitude do absolutely nothing on their own. City must be played pro-actively to protect anything, and yet it fights for the same turn that you want to resolve your key spells, either slowing you down or creating a dead topdeck if you hadn't resolved an Enchantress up to that point.

Karmic Justice isn't a threat. It's Enchantress's insurance policy. You can't insure a cardboard box. If you don't have anything else worth protecting, Karmic Justice is useless.


2 Replenish <-- Counterspell #3 and 4
2 Choke <--- fuck, I'm out.
1 Dovescape <--- :(
1 Blood Moon <--- had I just played MUC...

I'd also like to counter/remove this:
4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence

vs.

3x Replenish
1x Choke
8x Enchantresses
1x Library
4x Angels

Also, if you don't view Enchantresses as must counters for control, I am forced to question your understanding of 'Who's the Beatdown?'


2 Solitary Confinement (only one gets boarded out)

Without an engine to back it up, Confinement is a 3 mana fog.


That's how it goes. Don't think you could draw more cards than Landstill. Just play more Must-counter cards than they have counters.

Playing them is irrelevant if you don't draw them. I could play 60 must-counters, but in a 1000 card deck it'd be irrelevant. Drawing more cards is the key to the control match-up.


Save your Replenishes for the end of the counter-baiting key-spell chain and do try to resolve Karmic Justice anyhow, because even after resolving 4 key spells, Deed and EE have the potential to totally wreck you. Boarding gets a little bit more difficult if they play Academy Ruins, because if they do, you really want to see a Ground Seal.

Which is easier if you play 4x. Also, try Aura of Silence against Deed. It's not very good against EE, except in multiples.


Now look at your list. 3 Replenish, 2 Justice, 1 Choke, 1 Dovescape. I doubt that's enough. With so few gamebreaking spells they might as well let the Justice resolve and just focus on countering/removing your engine and countering your Replenishes. Have you tested the UWb and 4C Landstill matchups? If you did, how did the games end in which you couldn't stick an Enchantress effect?

How is it that your friend claims you played my deck but you don't think you bring in Angels vs. Landstill? That's exactly what they're there for.


Last note: Your arguments about the third Replenish make sense, I'll add it at least to the sideboard. However, I'll never cut Moat for it. Maybe you couldn't see it in my reports but Moat was absolutely turning the board position around in 6 games, while being critical in 2 others, see my last post. That's just as gamebreaking as Replenish. And in fact, Replenish would never have been better.

Any match-up where Replenish isn't game-winning is a game you should either win anyway(ie, no disruption), or lost anyway(ie, combo).

Brehn
04-10-2008, 06:53 PM
Disclaimer: I like combative posts :] *also writes one*

Note that I don't necessarily question the inclusion of a) 3 Replenish and b) 4 Ground Seal. I'm playing 4 Ground Seal myself and I'll be upping my Replenish count to 3. So please don't make arguments like this one:

Also, that game against Thresh, had the Replenish I drew been a Moat, would not have won me the game, since all my Replenishes got countered anyway. So blaming the different decklists for my one loss is disengenuous.
3 Replenishes is ok, in my opinion Moat fills another slot. For reference, what I question about your list is:

- Gaea's Touch
- Exploration
- Elvish Spirit Guide
- to a lesser extent, number of white mana sources
- no answers (Oblivion Ring, Moat, ...)


That's not true. I had multiple Enchantresses discarded in rounds 2 and 3, but I can win through disruption because I only need to stick a single Enchantress to quickly go out of control.
Umm.... so it is true. Please read again carefully:

Also, your Enchantresses were never discarded or removed except for one game (vs Garvish Aggro) which you lost (probably some got discarded in the other discard matchups, but you still got to stick at least one).
As I said, you won because somehow you were able to stick one. In the one game you weren't able to, you lost.



How about this; "if I don't resolve an Enchantress sometime, I'm not going to win"? Because that's what the reality of this deck is. You MUST resolve an Enchantress. If you think you're going to win with Moat and Karmic Justice, you're fooling yourself. Once in a blue moon you may pull out a win just by Pegasus tokens, but then I've won once or twice with ESG beats, so let's drop the flukes and look at what the deck's actual gameplan is.
I'm not fooling myself here, I know I have to resolve an Enchantress effect to win (although winning with Pegasus tokens + Sanctum is wayyyyy easier than winning with freaking Gray Ogre beatdown). The main difference I see between your list and my list is:

Scenario A: An early Enchantress effect sticks.
You: Play cheap Enchantments followed by more Enchantress effects, quickly accumulate a ton of card advantage, when the time is right, look for Words of War and win.
I: Play not-so-cheap Enchantments followed by more Enchantress effects, don't get that much of card advantage, but have the right answer for every threat my opponent plays, then eventually win with Words of War or Sacred Mesa.
Result: We both win. Granted, you do so more elegantly.

Scenario B: No possibility to stick an early Enchantress effect. Thoughtseize, Force of Will, lucky Hymn, Pyroclasm, whatever.
You: Look at multiple Gaea's Touches, Explorations and Elvish Spirit Guides. They're absolutely dead. While you're desperately casting Ground Seals to draw into something to get the engine going you suffer beats. Then you finally draw an Enchantress effect or Replenish you can resolve, but you already are in the red zone. You start accumulating card advantage, but the cards you draw don't affect the board state. Note: you only play 3 Groves and 2 Confinements.
I: Look at Oblivion Ring, Sacred Mesa and Moat I play in your "Dead Card unless engine runs"-slots. I, too, suffer beats and I desperately cycle my Ground Seals (remember, I also play four). But I'm able to stall the beats with Mesa chumpblockers, Ringed Goyfs or Moat. Finally, I reach the red zone two-three turns later than you do, and in this time I draw into more and more board state-affecting cards and/or set up / "fog" Confinement.
Result: I win, you lose. Why? Because you play dead cards where I play answers.

Comparing our tournament reports:
You had Scenario A twelve times and went 12-0.
I had Scenario A ten times and went 8-2 (would have been 9-1 without play mistakes).
You had Scenario B three times (2x 5c Thresh, 1x Garvish Aggro [what is that deck?]) and went 0-3.
I had Scenario B eight times and went 3-5 (would have been 4-4 without play mistakes)
(I also had Scenario C [opponent has the unbeatable goddraw] twice and went 0-2).

Do you see the difference here? 12-0 is only marginally better than 9-1, but 4-4 is a LOT better than 0-3.
You could argue that I face Scenario B way more often than you and the reason might be the superiority of your list. But I can tell you: 5 of the 7 times I faced scenario B the reason was Force of Will which strikes against any list. The other 2 times the reason was Wasteland, which I already adressed in my first post.
Sidenote: I can see though, that a list with Elvish Spirit Guide has improved chances of facing scenario A against disruption in the form of discard. I'll probably test a reworked manabase featuring ESG, especially in metas with a lot of black.





I run 1 less must-counter game 1 than you do.

Your list:
8x Enchantresses
4x Grove
2x Replenish
1x Sacred Mesa
1x Hoofprints
1x City of Solitude

My list:
8x Enchantresses
3x Grove
3x Replenish
1x Choke
1x Sylvan Library


(This was adressed to the Threshold matchup)
I absolutely can't understand your reasoning here. How is Sterling Grove a preboard must-counter for Threshold? You counter the target, not the tutor (Postboard with Krosan Grips it's debatable). Also, why Sylvan Library? Sure it's great, but it's not absolutely gamebreaking.

About the Daze argument: Probably your right on that one, the vulnerability to Daze should not be worse with your list.


Only if your high cc spells matter. I would rather resolve a Replenish in one game than a Moat in three games, because the Replenish will win me that game single-handedly and the Moat won't win anything on its own.
Oblivion Ring and Moat matter... They buy you turns to set up. If you're not set up you need that time, read Scenario B.


Do you PLAY against Threshold?

I've rarely seen a player have any serious difficulty getting a 3 cc spell in their top 3 if they need to.

WHAT? Who's the one that doesn't PLAY against Threshold. This should absolutely be not the case. Checking random Threshold lists:
UGr Moon Thresh: 2 Blood Moon main. 2 Blood Moon, 1 Magus of the Moon, 2 Krosan Grip in the Board.
UGr Tempo Thresh: Doesn't play Counterbalance
UGw Thresh with Balance: 2 Oblivion Ring main (not a standard choice...), 3 Krosan Grip in the Board.
5C Thresh (Hatfield list): Nothing main, 3 Krosan Grip in the Board.
Conclusion: They have to be seriously lucky to counter a spell with cc3.


Sacred Mesa costs seven mana to buy one turn. Seven. 3 to cast, 2 to upkeep, and 2 to actually block one dude(assuming their StP doesn't just eat it). When you're under pressure, ramping up 7 mana to chump one dude isn't going to save you.
I count five (there's no upkeep after your main phase) in the first turn and four in each additional turn. Sure it's not the optimal solution but it has the ability to buy you 1 or 2 important turns. Read Scenario B again.

Exalted Angel is a somewhat interesting sideboard option. I'll give it a shot in trying.


Now the Landstill matchup:


A lot of this stuff is theoretically debatable, but now you're telling me that card advantage doesn't matter against Landstill?

That's not what I've said. If you have ways to outdraw Landstill, do so and you're good. But Landstill tends to counter and remove your engine, as well as generate heavy card advantage with Standstill. Often you won't be able to outdraw them. This is where your Threat Density comes in.


And that Karmic Justice is MVP, when it doesn't do anything on its own?
It's a 5 for 1. It essentially shuts down Deed and Explosives. Without Karmic Justice out you can never feel safe against Landstill, no matter how many cards are in your hand.




- "Just draw more cards than them" -- yeah, I'd love to, but somehow I never draw more than one card per turn. Does this have something to do with them countering and EE'ing all my Enchantresses?
I think it has a lot to do with your high curve and lack of good mid-game accelerants. Which is what I've been trying to get across.
This was a somewhat sarcastic comment. It doesn't have to do anything with Spirit Guides, Exploration, Moat, high curve or anything. It just has to do with them countering and removing my Enchantress effects. They do so with mine as well as with yours.


Also, if you don't view Enchantresses as must counters for control, I am forced to question your understanding of 'Who's the Beatdown?'
Enchantress's can be easily removed unlike Karmic Justice and Choke and Blood Moon. That's why I didn't include them in the list.


Without an engine to back it up, Confinement is a 3 mana fog.
No. Against Landstill it's a lategame lock card. Similar to Dovescape, just not as invulnerable.


Playing them is irrelevant if you don't draw them. I could play 60 must-counters, but in a 1000 card deck it'd be irrelevant. Drawing more cards is the key to the control match-up.
Again, you're not adressing Scenario B. Also, 60/1000 is 0.06 where 22/60 is more than 0.33. This means in your first 9 cards will be 3 must-counter cards. And they usually only have 8 counters.


Any match-up where Replenish isn't game-winning is a game you should either win anyway(ie, no disruption), or lost anyway(ie, combo).
You're missing aggro. Replenish does nothing against aggro, Moat does. Do you consistently set up Confinement/Words of War on turn 5 before they've goldfished you?



How is it that your friend claims you played my deck but you don't think you bring in Angels vs. Landstill? That's exactly what they're there for.
I have no idea, what you're referring to here. If you're referring to thedarkness, he was playing Pox, which is a horrible matchup anyway. I haven't tested the Landstill matchup with your list, I've just asked you if you did. Still unanswered:

Have you tested the UWb and 4C Landstill matchups? If you did, how did the games end in which you couldn't stick an Enchantress effect?

GiantGrowth
04-11-2008, 12:57 AM
Sorry if I'm interrupting, but great discussion guys!



Scenario B: No possibility to stick an early Enchantress effect. Thoughtseize, Force of Will, lucky Hymn, Pyroclasm, whatever.
You: Look at multiple Gaea's Touches, Explorations and Elvish Spirit Guides. They're absolutely dead. While you're desperately casting Ground Seals to draw into something to get the engine going you suffer beats. Then you finally draw an Enchantress effect or Replenish you can resolve, but you already are in the red zone. You start accumulating card advantage, but the cards you draw don't affect the board state. Note: you only play 3 Groves and 2 Confinements.
I: Look at Oblivion Ring, Sacred Mesa and Moat I play in your "Dead Card unless engine runs"-slots. I, too, suffer beats and I desperately cycle my Ground Seals (remember, I also play four). But I'm able to stall the beats with Mesa chumpblockers, Ringed Goyfs or Moat. Finally, I reach the red zone two-three turns later than you do, and in this time I draw into more and more board state-affecting cards and/or set up / "fog" Confinement.
Result: I win, you lose. Why? Because you play dead cards where I play answers.

all those cards you named are one ofs and what are the odds that you wouldnt just get a hand of wild growths and utopia sprawls? (as opposed to his explorations, ect...) sure the chance is there, but how likely is it that you have even one of those, that could easily be removed in the same way your enchantress effects were?



No. Against Landstill it's a lategame lock card. Similar to Dovescape, just not as invulnerable.


without an enchantress its not a lock card, spat said "without the engine" meaning, no drawing and loosing cards every turn.

Jak
04-11-2008, 04:57 AM
@Brehn
Spatula's list runs 3 more "mana sources" than your deck. It is not the humongous difference you're making it out to be. Sure, you could take out the ESGs or whatever and play with Moats and Oblivion Ring, but it does slow the deck down. My list is a little different then Spatula's, but it plays the same. I chose to run a more Confinements and Groves, while he ran another Replenish and a Choke. The deck can get the engine online much faster with the accel and can therefore draw into more "answers".

Anyway, this is list of SB cards

4 City of Solitude
2 Choke
2 Blood Moon
2 Karmic Justice
2 Replenish
1 Dovescape
1 Sacred Ground
1 Solitary Confinement
1 Seal of Primordium
1 Aura of Silence
2 Oblivion Ring
2 Moat
4 Orim's Chant
4 Exalted Angel
4 Chalice of the Void

These are all the cards I want in my SB. All 29 of them. I really want to crush Landstill and Thresh, but not hurt the Goblins MU. I really want Chant for Combo. I also want the one ofs to help with stuff like Affinity and Stax. I am pretty solid with this.

1 Aura of Silence
1 Replenish (may run 3 MD. Too much?)
1 Karmic Justice
1 Sacred Ground
2 Choke
3 City of Solitude

That leaves four slots for Chants, Angels, etc. I am leaning towards Angels to pack in some more Win Conditions against other control decks. I basically scoop to combo though.

Brehn
04-11-2008, 08:15 AM
Spatula's list runs 3 more "mana sources" than your deck. It is not the humongous difference you're making it out to be.

I know. I was just adressing the differences in our list. If we both draw Ground Seal/Enchantress effect/random card we're both running in Scenario B, you can't see a difference between our lists. But when he draws a dead card I draw an answer that usually buys me one turn and it has the possibility (Threshold doesn't always find its Krosan Grip) to buy multiple turns. And I have to say, although Spatula won a tournament and I didn't do so well in two, I had much better results out of this kind of position.

I will be testing two ideas of Spatula:
1) Elvish Spirit Guide. I really like how it helps playing around early discard like Thoughtseize / Cabal Therapy. I have yet to test its impact on the Threshold matchup (you can bluff earlygame Dazes, but in total you still have fewer mana available). This will probably result in a further rework of my manabase, because I refuse to play "Green Mana Battery" aka Gaea's Touch and still will play a higher curve.
2) Exalted Angel. I already feel pretty comfortable about the Landstill matchup with >6 sideboard slots devoted to it. And if the Landstill player boards his Swords to Plowshares in again for the third game, I don't know if the Angels are good anymore. If I can somehow find space in my sideboard, I'll give it a try. Question to you Spatula: What matchups do you side them in besides Landstil and UGr Threshold?

Xero
04-11-2008, 07:00 PM
So, what do you all think about the Shadowmoor card Runed Halo:

:w: :w:

As Runed Halo comes into play, name a card.
You have protection from the named card. (You can't be targeted by it, and all damage that would be dealt to you by it is prevented)

I wish the cc was 1W instead of WW, but I still think this is a great card at least for the SB and maybe even the MB. It's the best anti-combo enchantment I can think of, especially when backed by Sterling Grove; and it can name Tarmogoyf, Goblin Piledriver, and Mishra's Factory.

Jak
04-11-2008, 07:30 PM
Played quite a bit with my Enchantress list (the last one I posted). I even played the mirror. His deck was straight GW that looked a lot like Brehn's. I have a log to end the discussion on the accel pieces. His deck was just slow. It had Island Sanctuary in place of moat, O rings, etc. but my deck was able to get a Confinement down early, protect it through his seal of primordiums and win via WoW. The mana accel lead to crazy explosive turns and I would win with WoW shortly after. Here is the log.

NVM. It won't let me post the log for some reason. It wasn't too long or anything. Anyway, I had turns where it would just keep going because of playing Explorations and gaea's Touch. Drawing ESG was always awesome because it also kept the turn alive.

I am not trying to say, "My deck is better than your deck!", or anything, but this was a great comparison on the speed aspect and I was able to draw more cards and get a Confinement lock down much faster. In one game, he had 3 Argothian Enchantresses out to my Presence. I was able to O Ring his and tutor up 2 more Presences and win.

Brehn
04-11-2008, 07:51 PM
Runed Halo: Aww... why not 1W.
So we get another card that stops combo from going off. It may be a little easier to cast than Rule of Law, but it has the obvious drawback that it can be Cleanfalled in one single turn. Still, I guess it will replace the Rule.

Jak:

I am not trying to say, "My deck is better than your deck!", or anything
You're trying to say (and you're saying): "My list wins the mirror." I know that your list wins the mirror against my list. That's because you never reach Scenario B - your opponent doesn't play any disruption (unless he has the lucky Aura of Silence). But saying this:

I have a log to end the discussion on the accel pieces. His deck was just slow.
is out of place. The mirror is absolutely irrelevant, it's "who draws more cards undisruptedly". Normal, non-Enchantress-playing opponents do play disruption and that's where cards like Gaea's Touch are incredibly useless.

Actually you could possibly end the discussion by pasting logs. Test the Threshold and Landstill matchups and focus on the games where you can't stick an early Enchantress. If you are able to win >40% of these games preboard and >50% postboard AND prove that cards like Gaea's Touch played a significant role, you might be able to convince me.

Also:

His deck was straight GW (...) It had Island Sanctuary in place of moat
That sounds horrible.

Jak
04-11-2008, 08:51 PM
The mirror compares both decks side by side. Speed is a big of Enchantress and so is the draw engine. Spat's list and my list both excel at both those. The answers you have don't address any problems the deck has. They just stall against decks you should beat with ease. By making the deck more stream lined and faster, you allow the deck to find a Karmic Justice and get it down before a Deed or set up a Confinement lock before combo can go off.

Also, both our decks lose if we can't stick an Enchantress. I don't see how you look at Spats list and say it loses when it doesn't stick an Enchantress. When you can't, you can only play a beater every 4 turns or make 1/1 tokens. This may be a better back up plan, but I would rather have the chance to set something up quick than have to rely on slow winning Enchantments.

How would Gigapede be in the place of Angel?

Brehn
04-11-2008, 10:41 PM
Also, both our decks lose if we can't stick an Enchantress. I don't see how you look at Spats list and say it loses when it doesn't stick an Enchantress. When you can't, you can only play a beater every 4 turns or make 1/1 tokens. This may be a better back up plan, but I would rather have the chance to set something up quick than have to rely on slow winning Enchantments.

In the last two tournaments I've won 4 out of 8 games when I haven't sticked an Enchantress. Isn't that enough? (Against Landstill I've even played my Enchantresses early to have them countered so I could resolve a more gamebreaking bomb. I don't think I'd have won if I had done it the other way round.)

I've come up with a comparison. What would you prefer in a standard build of Cephalid Breakfast:
4 Tarmogoyf
or 2 Krosan Cloudscraper + 2 Sylvan Tutor?
2 Sylvan Tutor increase the speed and the consistency of the combo. Right? And 2 Cloudscraper are just as big as 4 Tarmogoyf to make your Ghoul lethal, right? So Tutor+Scraper = strictly better?
(Tarmogoyf = Moat + other answers, also called backup plan. Scraper+Tutor = Gaea's Touch + other dead cards. Think about it.)

Jak
04-11-2008, 11:01 PM
In the last two tournaments I've won 4 out of 8 games when I haven't sticked an Enchantress. Isn't that enough? (Against Landstill I've even played my Enchantresses early to have them countered so I could resolve a more gamebreaking bomb. I don't think I'd have won if I had done it the other way round.)

I've come up with a comparison. What would you prefer in a standard build of Cephalid Breakfast:
4 Tarmogoyf
or 2 Krosan Cloudscraper + 2 Sylvan Tutor?
2 Sylvan Tutor increase the speed and the consistency of the combo. Right? And 2 Cloudscraper are just as big as 4 Tarmogoyf to make your Ghoul lethal, right? So Tutor+Scraper = strictly better?
(Tarmogoyf = Moat + other answers, also called backup plan. Scraper+Tutor = Gaea's Touch + other dead cards. Think about it.)

I guess I am confused. What are your bombs? How do you win without Enchantresses? Do you lock them out with Moat, because most good landstill decks should have a way around that via Decree or Enchantment removal. How did you win those games? Beating with Pegasus tokens?

Xero
04-11-2008, 11:23 PM
The mirror compares both decks side by side. Speed is a big of Enchantress and so is the draw engine. Spat's list and my list both excel at both those. The answers you have don't address any problems the deck has. They just stall against decks you should beat with ease. By making the deck more stream lined and faster, you allow the deck to find a Karmic Justice and get it down before a Deed or set up a Confinement lock before combo can go off.



I think the mirror is irrelevant. The chances of two people playing Enchantress meeting in a tournament seems vanishingly small. Anyways, I agree with Brehn. If you don't stick (or draw) an enchantress effect, your acceleration is nearly useless. I know I'd rather topdeck an Oblivion Ring than an Elvish Spirit Guide in virtually any situation. Even after you have an enchantress, most of your cards do little but make mana. Gaea's Touch and Elvish Spirit Guide get worse as the game goes to later turns, while Sacred Mesa and Hoofprints at the very least aren't worse. I'd also be nervous running only one win condition. What if it gets Extirpated? What if your opponent knows you have only 1 win condition, and saves his counters for Replenish and WoWar?

Jak
04-12-2008, 03:55 AM
I think the mirror is irrelevant. The chances of two people playing Enchantress meeting in a tournament seems vanishingly small. Anyways, I agree with Brehn. If you don't stick (or draw) an enchantress effect, your acceleration is nearly useless. I know I'd rather topdeck an Oblivion Ring than an Elvish Spirit Guide in virtually any situation. Even after you have an enchantress, most of your cards do little but make mana. Gaea's Touch and Elvish Spirit Guide get worse as the game goes to later turns, while Sacred Mesa and Hoofprints at the very least aren't worse. I'd also be nervous running only one win condition. What if it gets Extirpated? What if your opponent knows you have only 1 win condition, and saves his counters for Replenish and WoWar?

I agree with the last part of what you said. I do fear the removal of my win con. That is the only thing I dislike in the list. The first part makes it sound like the accel heavy builds run no answers and are all accel. Thats just wrong. Here is Brehn's list.

4 Savannah
1 Taiga
4 Windswept Heath
2 Serra's Sanctum
7 Forest
3 Plains
4 Wild Growth
4 Utopia Sprawl

4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove

4 Elephant Grass
2 Replenish
3 Solitary Confinement

1 Moat
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Seal of Primordium
2 Ground Seal
1 Karmic Justice
1 City of Solitude

1 Words of War
1 Hoofprints of the Stag
1 Sacred Mesa

He runs 2 more answers!!!!! One Moat and one O ring. In my list I actually run one O Ring. So you are telling me that running that one Moat will make Enchantress win when it can't resolve its engine?

I think what you guys are missing here is that the speed does matter. When you are unable to keep and Enchantress on the board for longer than a turn because of Deeds, Explosives, etc, then beeing able to have the mana to go Enchantress plus enchantments is huge. Gaining CA is huge. Being able to set up a KJ or dig for a Replenish is huge. I fail to see how we are arguing about Landstill, but you are saying you will do better in the MU because you have Moat? I know you have 2 more win cons and I will most likely cut Wild Growth for a Hoofprints. But can we please specify what we are discussing. I thought this was about not being able to stick the engine, but I keep hearing about answers.

Brehn
04-12-2008, 10:57 AM
This is the current mainboard I'm testing with. It's influenced by SpatulaOfTheAges' list and by the discussion around here:

4 Windswept Heath
2 Wooded Foothills (Wasteland go home)
2 Savannah ( ^ )
1 Taiga
6 Forest
2 Plains
2 Serra's Sanctum
3 Elvish Spirit Guide (!)
4 Utopia Sprawl
3 Wild Growth

4 Argothian Enchantress
4 Enchantress's Presence
4 Sterling Grove
4 Elephant Grass
3 Solitary Confinement
1 Moat (won't cut that ever)
3 Replenish (<-- result of this discussion)
1 Sacred Mesa
1 Words of War
1 Oblivion Ring
1 Karmic Justice
3 Ground Seal
1 Ground Seal/Sylvan Library

Jak: I've compared it to your list, I run three more answers. Replenish, Moat, Sacred Mesa. And I can tell you, those are powerful answers. Compared to Spatula's list, I run five more answers. Sterling Grove, Sacred Mesa, Oblivion Ring, Moat, Solitary Confinement. Any list I've seen yet that focuses on the acceleration theme runs a 31-slot-manabase. I run a 29-slot-manabase. So I just have more space to include answers.


I guess I am confused. What are your bombs? How do you win without Enchantresses? Do you lock them out with Moat, because most good landstill decks should have a way around that via Decree or Enchantment removal. How did you win those games? Beating with Pegasus tokens?
Not to be misunderstood, I don't win _without_ Enchantresses. I win without _early_ Enchantresses.

#1, Landstill: Argothian? Force. City of Solitude? Force. Choke? Counterspell. Karmic Justice? Counterspell. Replenish? Ok. (Threat density!!!) Now I have >10 turns time to find any Enchantress effect because he's locked out of the game. Eventually I've drawn one (probably turn 15 or so) and won with Sanctum+Mesa.
#2, Threshold: Turn 2 Enchantress forced, turn 3 BalanceTop, double Goyf beats. Confinement buys a turn. And another one. Sacred Mesa buys a turn before it's needled. Then I draw and resolve an Enchantress effect (this is turn >8), Replenish into Confinement and keep it for the rest of the game. (Without "Fog" answers I would have died immediately)
#3, Landstill: He answers my turn two Enchantress with a turn three Deed. I resolve Karmic Justice, making his Deed activation suck. Double Replenish helped (Karmic Justice = MVP against Landstill, believe it or not).
#4, Landstill: I have 2 Karmic Justices and a Sterling Grove in my hand. Double Justice shuts down his removal (that buys me ~10 turns again - 4c Landstill doesn't have a clock) and even before I try to tutor up a Presence with Grove, I try to resolve more gamebreaking bombs like Choke, Moat (I haven't seen another win condition besides Factories. 4c lists usually don't play Decree. And if they Enchantment Removal my Moat, they have one less to use on my other bombs) or Replenish. I've played my first Enchantress effect around turn 12. He never had a chance.
#5, Threshold: Turn 2 Enchantress to draw the Force out of his hand, turn 3 Choke making him manaless. He still has a Goyf I need to draw an answer for, because I don't have another Enchantress. I draw and resolve Moat (this is Gaea's Touch in your list). I draw and resolve Sacred Mesa (this is the second Gaea's Touch in your list) with Sanctum, he scoops. Not a single Enchantress resolved in this game.

One question you should always ask yourself when designing a list is: You keep a hand with one Enchantress effect. Your opponent forces the Enchantress and plays a 4/5 Goyf. Can you still win this game? What if Goyf is 5/6?
(I can't see Spatula's list winning without savagely topdecking. That's why I don't like it)



I fail to see how we are arguing about Landstill, but you are saying you will do better in the MU because you have Moat? I know you have 2 more win cons and I will most likely cut Wild Growth for a Hoofprints. But can we please specify what we are discussing. I thought this was about not being able to stick the engine, but I keep hearing about answers.

I've never said I'll do better because of Moat. Moat is just a threat like everything else. It gets boarded out against UW/UWb versions with Decree and/or Dragon and/or Conclave, while it stays in against 4C/Ugb versions with only Factories and/or Monasteries and/or Goyfs and/or Garruk. This is how I approach the Landstill matchup:

Can I resolve an Enchantress effect and keep it for longer than one round?

1) Yes, I can: Accumulate card advantage, dig for Replenish, resolve further Enchantresses.
1a) preboard: Sterling Grove either goes for a win condition (if I can win in no more than 3 turns) or Karmic Justice (I sense removal and can't win fast).
1b) postboard: Look for Karmic Justice. You should play 3. Draw it or Grove it, resolve it. City of Solitude is huge and Choke wins if it hits 80% of the time.

2) No, he forced my Enchantress/es: Plan B.
2a) preboard: Not nice. Most probably he will outdraw you now. Try topdecking Enchantresses ASAP. Sterling Groves straightly go for Presence. A resolved City of Solitude / Choke can turn the game around (if you play one main).
2b) postboard: Not a big problem, you have threat density now. Play as many relevant spells as possible each turn, eventually some will resolve. Replenish, Karmic Justice and Choke are the game winners.

3) No, I've kept a hand without Enchantress
3a) preboard: Shouldn't happen unless you've mulliganed to 4. You'll probably lose.
3b) postboard: If you've kept a hand without Enchantress, it probably has at least 3 relevant spells in it. See 2b).

There is a difference in approaching the Landstill matchup. While you're playing Combo, trying to race the counters/removal they play, I'm playing Hate.dec with >15 must-counter bombs. A huge portion of my sideboard is dedicated to Landstill (those cards are pretty good in other matchups, too). I think the "racing" plan you follow is disrupted too easily, playing 4-5 spells per turn doesn't sound too good if only 2 of them are relevant.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-14-2008, 01:59 PM
I was in NYC over the weekend, so I'll get back to all this sometime today or tomorrow.


As I said, you won because somehow you were able to stick one. In the one game you weren't able to, you lost.

I'm not fooling myself here, I know I have to resolve an Enchantress effect to win (although winning with Pegasus tokens + Sanctum is wayyyyy easier than winning with freaking Gray Ogre beatdown). The main difference I see between your list and my list is:

Scenario A: An early Enchantress effect sticks.
You: Play cheap Enchantments followed by more Enchantress effects, quickly accumulate a ton of card advantage, when the time is right, look for Words of War and win.
I: Play not-so-cheap Enchantments followed by more Enchantress effects, don't get that much of card advantage, but have the right answer for every threat my opponent plays, then eventually win with Words of War or Sacred Mesa.
Result: We both win. Granted, you do so more elegantly.

Scenario B: No possibility to stick an early Enchantress effect. Thoughtseize, Force of Will, lucky Hymn, Pyroclasm, whatever.
You: Look at multiple Gaea's Touches, Explorations and Elvish Spirit Guides. They're absolutely dead. While you're desperately casting Ground Seals to draw into something to get the engine going you suffer beats. Then you finally draw an Enchantress effect or Replenish you can resolve, but you already are in the red zone. You start accumulating card advantage, but the cards you draw don't affect the board state. Note: you only play 3 Groves and 2 Confinements.
I: Look at Oblivion Ring, Sacred Mesa and Moat I play in your "Dead Card unless engine runs"-slots. I, too, suffer beats and I desperately cycle my Ground Seals (remember, I also play four). But I'm able to stall the beats with Mesa chumpblockers, Ringed Goyfs or Moat. Finally, I reach the red zone two-three turns later than you do, and in this time I draw into more and more board state-affecting cards and/or set up / "fog" Confinement.
Result: I win, you lose. Why? Because you play dead cards where I play answers.

Comparing our tournament reports:
You had Scenario A twelve times and went 12-0.
I had Scenario A ten times and went 8-2 (would have been 9-1 without play mistakes).
You had Scenario B three times (2x 5c Thresh, 1x Garvish Aggro [what is that deck?]) and went 0-3.
I had Scenario B eight times and went 3-5 (would have been 4-4 without play mistakes)
(I also had Scenario C [opponent has the unbeatable goddraw] twice and went 0-2).

I didn't have scenario B at all. There was no game where I stuck an Enchantress and lost. If I get a mid or late Enchantress, I explode into a Confinement lock quickly, or throw out enough Grasses to buy a turn. This is what you're missing. Those cards that "don't effect the board state" all draw cards for free. Or with an untapped Sanctum, or Touch with a basic forest in hand, they actually create mana. If I have half as many cards that save me defensively but draw twice as many cards, we're even on that front, but I'm in a better position to go offensive sooner.

I had Scenario C: Games where you don't stick an Enchantress at all 3 times. How many times did you have it, and what was your record?


Do you see the difference here? 12-0 is only marginally better than 9-1, but 4-4 is a LOT better than 0-3.

Whoah whoah whoah, Selective McGee. 8-2, not 9-1. 3-5, not 4-4. If you get to reimagine past mistakes, so do I, and I potentially threw away both games against 5c Thresh, so my pretendy record there is 2-1, which is better than 4-4, AND 3-5.

Let's stick with stuff that really happened.


(This was adressed to the Threshold matchup)
I absolutely can't understand your reasoning here. How is Sterling Grove a preboard must-counter for Threshold? You counter the target, not the tutor (Postboard with Krosan Grips it's debatable). Also, why Sylvan Library? Sure it's great, but it's not absolutely gamebreaking.

If resolved early, Library will give you amazing card selection, that will make it extremely difficult for Thresh to answer your threats consistently.

If we don't count Sterling Grove, we're even by the way. I realize they'll counter the target, not the Grove itself, but it still functions similiarly to actually having an Enchantress.


Oblivion Ring and Moat matter... They buy you turns to set up. If you're not set up you need that time, read Scenario B.

Oblivion Ring does so very situationally. It's not hard for Thresh to get multiple beaters out.

Moat does, and against Thresh, this probably is an advantage of your list. But that's the only match-up where I would consider it worthwhile, and in most meta-games you have so many other decks to worry about, I wouldn't want to drag down the MD for that one card, especially with it's double white.



WHAT? Who's the one that doesn't PLAY against Threshold. This should absolutely be not the case. Checking random Threshold lists:
UGr Moon Thresh: 2 Blood Moon main. 2 Blood Moon, 1 Magus of the Moon, 2 Krosan Grip in the Board.
UGr Tempo Thresh: Doesn't play Counterbalance
UGw Thresh with Balance: 2 Oblivion Ring main (not a standard choice...), 3 Krosan Grip in the Board.
5C Thresh (Hatfield list): Nothing main, 3 Krosan Grip in the Board.
Conclusion: They have to be seriously lucky to counter a spell with cc3.

Huh. I guess I got unlucky. Either way, this doesn't seem to make a difference between our lists. Oblivion Ring buys a turn max unless they get really unlucky and can't draw enough threats. That's roughly the same as ESG chump-blocking buys. Moat is the only real advantage your decklist has in the Thresh match-up, and as I said, I don't consider that advantage to be worth the hiccup it causes your main game-plan.


I count five (there's no upkeep after your main phase) in the first turn and four in each additional turn. Sure it's not the optimal solution but it has the ability to buy you 1 or 2 important turns. Read Scenario B again.

Sacred Mesa is...ok, in that scenario. The thing I found myself hating about it is that you would drop it and make a dude, but then when you found your real threats, the 2 mana you had to tie up in Mesa would make you vulnerable to Daze. Or when you pay 5 for a token to chump-block, and it gets StPed for 1, and you're in the red zone again.


That's not what I've said. If you have ways to outdraw Landstill, do so and you're good. But Landstill tends to counter and remove your engine, as well as generate heavy card advantage with Standstill. Often you won't be able to outdraw them. This is where your Threat Density comes in.

It's a 5 for 1. It essentially shuts down Deed and Explosives. Without Karmic Justice out you can never feel safe against Landstill, no matter how many cards are in your hand.

This was a somewhat sarcastic comment. It doesn't have to do anything with Spirit Guides, Exploration, Moat, high curve or anything. It just has to do with them countering and removing my Enchantress effects. They do so with mine as well as with yours.

Threat density is important, but you don't have more threats against Landstill than I do. You have the same, but your fluff comes in the form of expensive and inapplicable bullets, whereas mine are cheap mana generators. This makes my list stronger in the face of sweepers, since I can refill my hand and draw into more of the actual threats.

Karmic Justice is ok, but on its own, it's nothing. That's why you can't count it as a threat against them. It's like Confinement. It's completely dependent on the Enchantresses to be any good.


Enchantress's can be easily removed unlike Karmic Justice and Choke and Blood Moon. That's why I didn't include them in the list.

But if you're drawing lots of cards, and have 3 Replenishes, you're in a far better position when they are removed. You'll either have more Enchantresses in hand or a Replenish.


No. Against Landstill it's a lategame lock card. Similar to Dovescape, just not as invulnerable.

Explain how so, without Enchantresses?


Again, you're not adressing Scenario B. Also, 60/1000 is 0.06 where 22/60 is more than 0.33. This means in your first 9 cards will be 3 must-counter cards. And they usually only have 8 counters.

It was just a random example. The point being that drawing more cards off your Enchantresses is what lets you play more must-counters. And the way to draw more cards is A) Ground Seal and B) cheap enchantments.

They play only 8 counters and 3-4 sweepers. That's exactly why the deck that can counter the sweepers better will have the better Landstill/(any board control deck) matchup.


You're missing aggro. Replenish does nothing against aggro, Moat does. Do you consistently set up Confinement/Words of War on turn 5 before they've goldfished you?

That's the point I was making. Straight aggro with no disruption, you should be 70%+. If they have no disruption, Confinement should come online turn 4 at the latest.


I have no idea, what you're referring to here. If you're referring to thedarkness, he was playing Pox, which is a horrible matchup anyway. I haven't tested the Landstill matchup with your list, I've just asked you if you did. Still unanswered

Not in a tournament. My testing on MWS indicates that my strategy is better vs any list that plays sweepers as a control supplement.

My conclusions;

Pros of my list;
Improved board control matchup(+1 Replenish, able to take advantage of an Enchantress more quickly, making their sorcery speed removal less damaging; to a lesser extend, Aura is much better than Seal vs Deed)
Improved match vs discard(ESG lets you race their disruption better)

Pros of your list;
Better Thresh match-up(Moat, and to a lesser extend, Mesa)

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-15-2008, 02:05 PM
Seperate post to keep this seperate from the accel/defense debate;

http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=110203


Sun-and-moon wheel G/W G/W

Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Player (R)
Whenever a card would be put into the graveyard of enchanted player from anywhere the card is revealed and put onto the bottom of that players library.


This seems really hot as a SB option. And fits beautifully with the E Tutor anti-combo package.

Brehn
04-15-2008, 02:46 PM
My conclusions;

Pros of my list;
Improved board control matchup(+1 Replenish, able to take advantage of an Enchantress more quickly, making their sorcery speed removal less damaging; to a lesser extend, Aura is much better than Seal vs Deed)
Improved match vs discard(ESG lets you race their disruption better)

Pros of your list;
Better Thresh match-up(Moat, and to a lesser extend, Mesa)

So I think we can agree on this:
- Elvish Spirit Guides should be played.
- Three is the right number for Replenish.
- Deed-heavy metas ask for mainboard Aura of Silence as well as Karmic Justice.
- Ground Seal - 4x, if the meta allows it.
- We have a very different way of approaching the Landstill matchup. I'm very fine with my testing results. You claim your matchup is even better. Sounds good.

And we disagree on whether pseudo-acceleration (Exploration, Gaea's Touch) or answers (Oblivion Ring, Sacred Mesa) is better. Those are 4 slots at max.

Just some more statements:

I had Scenario C: Games where you don't stick an Enchantress at all 3 times. How many times did you have it, and what was your record?
I didn't have it at all. After having early game Enchantresses removed/countered, they very often wasted the remaining counters in their hands on Sacred Mesa / Moat or sideboard cards (Choke, Karmic Justice). That's how I resolved my midgame Enchantresses. You play blanks instead of those counter-baiting cards.
EDIT: Just remembered, I've had it once. And won with Sanctum+Mesa.


Oblivion Ring buys a turn max unless they get really unlucky and can't draw enough threats. That's roughly the same as ESG chump-blocking buys.
Oblivion Ring requires them to draw either a threat or a removal. ESG doesn't. Bad comparison (I'd rather have them Grip my Ring so I can play Confinement).


Sacred Mesa is...ok, in that scenario. The thing I found myself hating about it is that you would drop it and make a dude, but then when you found your real threats, the 2 mana you had to tie up in Mesa would make you vulnerable to Daze.
I know. That's why I'm playing more permanent mana sources than you.


Threat density is important, but you don't have more threats against Landstill than I do. You have the same, but your fluff comes in the form of expensive and inapplicable bullets, whereas mine are cheap mana generators. This makes my list stronger in the face of sweepers, since I can refill my hand and draw into more of the actual threats.

Karmic Justice is ok, but on its own, it's nothing. That's why you can't count it as a threat against them. It's like Confinement. It's completely dependent on the Enchantresses to be any good.

I think the Landstill matchup discussion is leading nowhere, so I'll just accept that you approach it quite differently. Note: I'd almost always rather resolve a Karmic Justice against Landstill than a Choke or an Enchantress's Presence. The only spell that tops it is a mid- or lategame Replenish.
Also, did you just call Gaea's Touch a "bullet" against Landstill, while calling Moat inapplicable? What?
EDIT: Not "bullet", "threat" is what you've called it. Even more strange.

Stuff:

Sun-and-moon wheel G/W G/W

Enchantment - Aura
Enchant Player (R)
Whenever a card would be put into the graveyard of enchanted player from anywhere the card is revealed and put onto the bottom of that players library.
Yay, another anti-Ichorid tool. Wait, I beat Ichorid anyway unless they go nuts. Hmmm... what would you want it against? TES/FT to stop Ill-Gotten Gains? Nah...
EDIT: But unlike Runed Halo it can be powered out on turn 1 against TES. It's been a while since I've tested TES, but the last lists I've tinkered with (with 2 Draw 4 spells maindeck, I think) were not that Ill-Gotten-Gains-dependant, so still probably not worth it.

strom
04-15-2008, 02:50 PM
A few suggestions for the "speed variant":

- Playing with only 19 lands two of which are Serra`s Sanctums which dont net you anything Turn 1 or 2 is really supbar.
Sanctum is great in conjunction with Mesa and cards that cost double white (like Moat). Both cards arent played in that version so there is no need for Sanctum anymore.
- Mirri`s Guile is really great for the speed version. We are running about ten shuffle effects which basically means we can always see three fresh cards in our upkeep. It also helps to draw into better cards with our enchantresses. Guile works under Confinement, fixes early mana problems, and can find early enchantresses -for the cost of only one green mana.

My list for reference:

// Lands
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
2 [ON] Wooded Foothills
10 [UNH] Forest
2 [B] Savannah
1 [B] Taiga

// Creatures
3 [AL] Elvish Spirit Guide
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [TE] Mirri's Guile
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
2 [IA] Wild Growth
2 [US] Exploration
1 [ON] Words of War
4 [OD] Ground Seal
2 [UD] Replenish
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
2 [JU] Solitary Confinement
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium

GreenOne
04-15-2008, 03:55 PM
Seperate post to keep this seperate from the accel/defense debate;

http://forums.mtgsalvation.com/showthread.php?t=110203

This seems really hot as a SB option. And fits beautifully with the E Tutor anti-combo package.

It's really on-color and it would be good against anything with IGG and Dread Return. It's also good against solidarity, if anyone is still playing it.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-15-2008, 06:55 PM
I didn't have it at all. After having early game Enchantresses removed/countered, they very often wasted the remaining counters in their hands on Sacred Mesa / Moat or sideboard cards (Choke, Karmic Justice). That's how I resolved my midgame Enchantresses. You play blanks instead of those counter-baiting cards.
EDIT: Just remembered, I've had it once. And won with Sanctum+Mesa.

The only different cards that are counter-baiting are Moat against Thresh and Mesa against Landstill(potentially Mesa against Thresh, but usually they're too quick or run Needle/Echoing Truth/Clasm. Granted, if they're running Pyroclasm, it could have gone at Argothians instead, but that's more situational.


Oblivion Ring requires them to draw either a threat or a removal. ESG doesn't. Bad comparison (I'd rather have them Grip my Ring so I can play Confinement).

They'd be pretty bad to waste a Grip on Ring. It'd be much smarter to simply play another threat.


I know. That's why I'm playing more permanent mana sources than you.

I meant with lists similiar to yours.


I think the Landstill matchup discussion is leading nowhere, so I'll just accept that you approach it quite differently. Note: I'd almost always rather resolve a Karmic Justice against Landstill than a Choke or an Enchantress's Presence. The only spell that tops it is a mid- or lategame Replenish.

Choke is weaker depending on which build of Landstill it is. Presence though is always better, because it can draw you into Replenish or Justice, but Justice by itself does nothing, and if they DO run targeted removal(even bounce), they can knock it off and then sweep anyway.


Also, did you just call Gaea's Touch a "bullet" against Landstill, while calling Moat inapplicable? What?
EDIT: Not "bullet", "threat" is what you've called it. Even more strange.[/size]

No, I said it lets you draw into your threats, because you can play it for free or for +1 mana.

[quote]Yay, another anti-Ichorid tool. Wait, I beat Ichorid anyway unless they go nuts. Hmmm... what would you want it against? TES/FT to stop Ill-Gotten Gains? Nah...
EDIT: But unlike Runed Halo it can be powered out on turn 1 against TES. It's been a while since I've tested TES, but the last lists I've tinkered with (with 2 Draw 4 spells maindeck, I think) were not that Ill-Gotten-Gains-dependant, so still probably not worth it.

It also cancels Rite of Flame and Cabal Ritual. And is good against any Loam strategy/random Solidarity decks. Possibly against Threshold? Stops Enforcer, Mongoose, and limits Goyf to 4/5 max, 3/4 more likely, quite possibly 2/3.

Jak
04-15-2008, 11:24 PM
A few suggestions for the "speed variant":

- Playing with only 19 lands two of which are Serra`s Sanctums which dont net you anything Turn 1 or 2 is really supbar.
Sanctum is great in conjunction with Mesa and cards that cost double white (like Moat). Both cards arent played in that version so there is no need for Sanctum anymore.
- Mirri`s Guile is really great for the speed version. We are running about ten shuffle effects which basically means we can always see three fresh cards in our upkeep. It also helps to draw into better cards with our enchantresses. Guile works under Confinement, fixes early mana problems, and can find early enchantresses -for the cost of only one green mana.

My list for reference:

// Lands
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
2 [ON] Wooded Foothills
10 [UNH] Forest
2 [B] Savannah
1 [B] Taiga

// Creatures
3 [AL] Elvish Spirit Guide
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [TE] Mirri's Guile
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
2 [IA] Wild Growth
2 [US] Exploration
1 [ON] Words of War
4 [OD] Ground Seal
2 [UD] Replenish
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
2 [JU] Solitary Confinement
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium

Uh... run Sanctum. Have you played with the deck? With out Sanctum it would be so much harder to combo out with WoW. Did you know there is generic mana in the deck? There is also still white. I have never run into a situation where I had too much mana.

I don't see why everyone is thinking Gaea's Touch is a joke. Have you tested it? It's like a free Exploration most of the time. Brehn, you keep bringing it up when Spat or I say we draw into more threats. That just seems like a weak arguement. The card is strange and I haven't seen it in any other decks, but it is awesome in Enchantress. It's usually a free draw spell that adds mana to the pool or acceleration. Just test it if you haven't.

GiantGrowth
04-15-2008, 11:41 PM
I like that new enchantment, GY-based combo is always going to be relevant, and it stops a lot more stuff than ground seal (effect, not comparing including the card draw).

Pltnmngl
04-16-2008, 12:09 PM
I must say that I'm really excited about the future of this deck, thanks to the contributions Shadowmoor seem to be making on it. So many potential enchantments (especially on-color) can help our game.

Brehn
04-16-2008, 12:43 PM
I don't see why everyone is thinking Gaea's Touch is a joke. Have you tested it? It's like a free Exploration most of the time. Brehn, you keep bringing it up when Spat or I say we draw into more threats. That just seems like a weak arguement. The card is strange and I haven't seen it in any other decks, but it is awesome in Enchantress. It's usually a free draw spell that adds mana to the pool or acceleration. Just test it if you haven't.

I have tested it.
It's a free Exploration. Good. But Exploration sucks.
"It's usually a free draw spell" - No. It's a free draw spell if you have an Enchantress out, if you don't, it's dead. And even if I have an Enchantress out, I prefer to play a draw spell that is not free, but affects my opponent's clock.
Granted, it's better than Exploration. Gaea's Touch can actually put you in a favorable position, which Exploration can't. Whenever you reach a situation in which Exploration is better than Wild Growth you a) already have won or b) are playing against a deck with Sinkholes. While Gaea's Touch is a suboptimal choice, Exploration is a horrible choice.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-16-2008, 01:23 PM
Granted, it's better than Exploration. Gaea's Touch can actually put you in a favorable position, which Exploration can't. Whenever you reach a situation in which Exploration is better than Wild Growth you a) already have won

It's better in any situation where you have an Enchantress out. For instance:


Match 2: RG Aggro Loam.
Game 1: Land, Mox Diamond, Mox Diamond, Countryside Crusher. WTF. Hmmm... okay, take that: second turn Presence, third turn Ground Seal, fourth turn Moat. Fifth turn Burning Wish, Reverent Silence, GG. (There are certain hands one can't defeat.)

This is the perfect example of a time when my list would have done better. You had to spend your entire fourth turn G1 playing Moat. If that had been an Exploration, you'd have gone through many more cards and been able to Replenish or reload your board next turn, to deal with the Silence. In this sort of situation Exploration is much more useful than Moat because it supplements your main engine, and Moat doens't. Moat isn't a team player. It just does what it does. It's not particularly synergistic with Enchantress. In the basic fact that it's an enchantment it is, but that's it. It doesn't help you pursue your main goal of playing out your deck.

Also, going back;


Karmic Justice? Counterspell.

Any Landstill player who counters a Justice when you don't have anything worth destroying is a bad player. Plays that beat bad players are not worth arguing about.


Sanctum is great in conjunction with Mesa and cards that cost double white (like Moat). Both cards arent played in that version so there is no need for Sanctum anymore.

What Jak said. Sanctum is good in any version that wants to play lots of permanents, i.e., any version.


Even after you have an enchantress, most of your cards do little but make mana. Gaea's Touch and Elvish Spirit Guide get worse as the game goes to later turns, while Sacred Mesa and Hoofprints at the very least aren't worse.

They are worse, because they DON'T make mana. Hoofprints and Mesa basically suck on their own. Only with an Enchantress drawing you into lots of mana or cards do they start to not suck. Occasionally against straight up control Mesa might win you the game, or if you happen to get Library and Hoofprints(but if you get Library out you could probably pursue a better plan anyway).

Exploration, Touch and ESG only get worse if you're all ready losing. That's the reality of this decktype. Enchantress doesn't function without its namesake.

Cards that make mana and are enchantments let you draw more cards. Drawing more cards draws you into more Enchantresses. Drawing more Enchantresses lets you draw more cards. Drawing more cards gets you more mana. Getting more mana and cards lets you win. This is the main plan of Enchantress. Everything else is a distraction.


I'd also be nervous running only one win condition. What if it gets Extirpated? What if your opponent knows you have only 1 win condition, and saves his counters for Replenish and WoWar?

What if they Extirpate 2 targets? What if they Earwig Squadron me?

I'm not going to waste slots for unlikely scenarios.

Who draws 4 hard counters by the mid-game? Because that's when I'll go off if they don't do anything about the Enchantresses. Again, I'll take my chances, thanks.

Julian23
04-16-2008, 02:21 PM
I'd also be nervous running only one win condition. What if it gets Extirpated? What if your opponent knows you have only 1 win condition, and saves his counters for Replenish and WoWar?

If it gets extirpated you lose unless you're able to bluff your opponent out of the game..which is unlikely as he was able to look through your library/hand. The point is, it's rather hard to extirpate because it will have to hit the yard first. You might argue about Duress and the like but how likely are you to actually have a one-off in your hand? If you know your opponent plays discard and extirpate you don't want to pass the turn with it in your hand. And to go further than that: you run Confinment and - especially with only 1 wincon - 4 copies of Ground Seal.

Regarding the counter-saving issue: You might have noticed that Enchantress does not simply rely on praying in control matchups. If you know your opponent plays only a small amount of countermagic you might start aggressivly trading Enchantresses etc. for them. If he denies to do so chances are he doesn't hold any countermagic; if so, you might run out a testspell like City of Solitude or Choke to check if the path is clear.
Against more counter-heavy decks my testing showed that most players wont counter your early acceleration which will put you into a better position, mana-wise (ok, I once got a 1st turn exploration forced but does anyone think that's a good move? my opponent was knowing I was playing Enchantress). Then I will wait for the right moment to drop 3-4 must-counters like City of Solitude, Choke, a win-condition and - in the end - Replenish. If your opponent got enough hardcounters (meaning Counterspell and Force of Will) to combat this, these are the games that you might lose. But nobody says that you're not gonna draw into another Replenish the next turn especially since you'll quite likely have a board of 2-3 enchantress-effects if your opponent was holding back counters to fight your stuff the turn before.

Julian23
04-16-2008, 02:24 PM
-delete please- sorry, I somehow double-posted :-/

Brehn
04-16-2008, 03:26 PM
This is the perfect example of a time when my list would have done better. You had to spend your entire fourth turn G1 playing Moat. If that had been an Exploration, you'd have gone through many more cards and been able to Replenish or reload your board next turn, to deal with the Silence.

There's no next turn if your opponent has a 10/10 Crusher and a 5/6 Goyf. That was a goddraw of the Loam player, no Enchantress list can possibly beat it (unless lists running Seal of Doom, I suppose).


Any Landstill player who counters a Justice when you don't have anything worth destroying is a bad player.
WRONG WRONG WRONG. Karmic Justice WRECKS Landstill, whenever it hits. It makes 4-8 of their cards become either dead cards or one-sided Armageddons. They only have their counters left, I've won the threat density war.
Statement should be: Any Landstill player who has a counter in his hand and doesn't counter Karmic Justice is a bad player. (not universally true, but applies in most cases)


Exploration, Touch and ESG only get worse if you're all ready losing. That's the reality of this decktype. Enchantress doesn't function without its namesake.
I don't lose in this situation. See report. That's what I'm trying to tell you all the time but it seems that you won't listen...

(Also, you've pretty much just admitted you have a bad Landstill matchup. Because you won't stick an Enchantress against Landstill early game (FoW, Counterspell, EE) and midgame:

Who draws 4 hard counters by the mid-game? Because that's when I'll go off if they don't do anything about the Enchantresses. Again, I'll take my chances, thanks.
Landstill.
)

Just me
04-16-2008, 05:07 PM
Maybe it has been discussed but since I didn't see it in this thread I'll ask. Why not play Chrome Mox as accelaration? The 1 card you'll lose compared to Elvish Spirit Guide is won back in this deck easily once the engine goes online. Which is turn 1 best case, allowing turn 2 to make up for the lost card through cheap enchantments drawing cards. And it's 1 mana every turn. Turn 2 Ghostly Prison is pretty much game vs Goblins, even without Enchantress. Morph is turn 2 as well in this set up. But the best use is still 3 mana on turn 2 to go crazy on accel with an Enchantress in play (Explorations, Utopia Sprawl,...).

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-16-2008, 06:53 PM
There's no next turn if your opponent has a 10/10 Crusher and a 5/6 Goyf. That was a goddraw of the Loam player, no Enchantress list can possibly beat it (unless lists running Seal of Doom, I suppose).

Or Karmic Justice. How is it that you went second turn Presence, 3rd turn Ground Seal? Is that all you could play?

My list would have been more likely to dig for a Justice or at least an ESG/Argothian to chump Goyf.


WRONG WRONG WRONG. Karmic Justice WRECKS Landstill, whenever it hits. It makes 4-8 of their cards become either dead cards or one-sided Armageddons. They only have their counters left, I've won the threat density war.
Statement should be: Any Landstill player who has a counter in his hand and doesn't counter Karmic Justice is a bad player. (not universally true, but applies in most cases)

How on earth do you figure?

Why would I counter a card that helps protect threats that you don't even have? That's such a waste of resources.

Also, it doesn't make their Wrath of Gods dead, so 4-8 is being pretty wildly optimistic. Most lists only run ~4 cards that Justice effects.. It certainly doesn't "wreck" them. It gives you insurance IF you've all ready resolved an Enchantress.


I don't lose in this situation. See report. That's what I'm trying to tell you all the time but it seems that you won't listen...

(Also, you've pretty much just admitted you have a bad Landstill matchup. Because you won't stick an Enchantress against Landstill early game (FoW, Counterspell, EE) and midgame:

Landstill.
Who draws 4 hard counters by the mid-game? Because that's when I'll go off if they don't do anything about the Enchantresses. Again, I'll take my chances, thanks.


A) Yes, you do. If you NEVER resolve an Enchantress, you lose. You keep equivocating this with resolving a late Enchantress. I don't lose if I resolve a late Enchantress. I only lose if one never resolves. Your odds of resolving one are no better than mine.

B) I have a better defense against EE, because I draw lots of cards now, which draws me into my threats. You draw much more slowly, making EE/Deed/whatever much more effective against you.

C) Landstill almost never has the ability to cast 4 hard counters by turn 5-6. And if it does, it would have to use all its resources to get there, so you could just go ESG beats in that extremely unlikely scenario.


Maybe it has been discussed but since I didn't see it in this thread I'll ask. Why not play Chrome Mox as accelaration? The 1 card you'll lose compared to Elvish Spirit Guide is won back in this deck easily once the engine goes online. Which is turn 1 best case, allowing turn 2 to make up for the lost card through cheap enchantments drawing cards. And it's 1 mana every turn. Turn 2 Ghostly Prison is pretty much game vs Goblins, even without Enchantress. Morph is turn 2 as well in this set up. But the best use is still 3 mana on turn 2 to go crazy on accel with an Enchantress in play (Explorations, Utopia Sprawl,...).

Because Chrome Mox isn't very good in a deck that mulligans as much as Enchantress does.

Zach Tartell
04-17-2008, 02:01 AM
thew biggest problem that I have right now is this (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sqv8UJc72SU)


are theyieir any good postboard options? or just ground seal?

Pinder
04-17-2008, 02:17 AM
are theyieir any good postboard options? or just ground seal?

You could try that new Sun and Moon Wheel thing from Shadowmoor, but I'm not sure that's really any better than Ground Seal at keeping them from doing what they want to, you know? Especially if it's something dirty.

edit - You might ask the Unicorns, they have all kinds of experience with this sort of thing.

Just me
04-17-2008, 07:23 AM
About Chrome Mox. Why is the Mox more suspectible to mulligans as ESG is? Especially given the potential? It does add more explosiveness to the deck which in my experience is essential to keep up with the fastest goldfishes of decks like Goblins, combo and others.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-17-2008, 09:10 AM
About Chrome Mox. Why is the Mox more suspectible to mulligans as ESG is? Especially given the potential? It does add more explosiveness to the deck which in my experience is essential to keep up with the fastest goldfishes of decks like Goblins, combo and others.

Consider a hand like Land, Land, ESG, Argothian, Ground Seal. A Chrome Mox in place of ESG would make that hand unkeepable. When you've all ready mulliganned, having to pay an extra card for your mana sources isn't very good.

Obfuscate Freely
04-17-2008, 11:41 AM
Consider a hand like Land, Land, ESG, Argothian, Ground Seal. A Chrome Mox in place of ESG would make that hand unkeepable. When you've all ready mulliganned, having to pay an extra card for your mana sources isn't very good.
That's pretty specious reasoning. I can come up with a sample hand to support Chrome Mox just as well (Chrome Mox, Land, Argothian, Ground Seal, Exploration), but that is an extremely poor way to argue for a card.

Mad Zur and I have found Chrome Mox to be quite good in this deck, for the same reasons we have found ESG to be good. Both cards let you get your engine online faster, at the cost of cards.

However, comparing the two directly is misleading, because Chrome Mox is a permanent mana source. This means it slots into the deck in place of lands, and it is the best acceleration to draw when you are light on mana. You can think of Mox as a land that turns another card in your hand (of your choice) into an ESG, although you don't get this effect if Mox is the only "land" you play in a turn.

Just me
04-17-2008, 12:32 PM
Given the high importance of many in the first turns I think it's a strong card (Mox). It simply ensures a fast Enchantress which can be followed by more cheap enchantments (which allows the digging for threats, this fits well with the deck that uses more cards like Wild Growth, Utopia Sprawl and so on). In my experience the deck get's about half a turn faster which is very relevant.

Problem is that it does compete with ESG, even though they might not compare directly. Not just because they're both accelerants for the deck but also because you can only run that much non-enchantments in this deck. So then the question becomes, Mox or ESG and why?

ESG
Less mulligans (apparantly, I didn't test this), slightly less bad draw late game because it is also a bear

MOX
Faster buildup of mana which makes the deck faster

Obfuscate Freely
04-17-2008, 06:30 PM
Problem is that it does compete with ESG, even though they might not compare directly. Not just because they're both accelerants for the deck but also because you can only run that much non-enchantments in this deck. So then the question becomes, Mox or ESG and why?
This is false. The two cards do not directly compete, because they do not do quite the same thing. Chrome Mox is a permanent mana source, and replaces lands in the decklist. Elvish Spirit Guide is purely an acceleration card (similar to Dark Ritual in Suicide Black), and generally has to take the place of a spell.

The two cards cannot, therefore, be considered for the same slots in the decklist. They are not, necessarily, mutually exclusive to one another.

If you were to run only one or the other, however, Chrome Mox is the best choice. This is because it provides functionality that is superior to ESG (both let you trade a spell in hand for an increase in mana development, but Chrome Mox grants you an advantage for the rest of the game), and because Mox slots right into the manabase, without requiring you to trim any spells from the deck.

My main point, though, is that it is very possible (and probably optimal) to run both Chrome Mox and ESG in the same deck. You don't really want to see either card in multiples early in a game, but seeing one of each works out fine (ESG pitches to Mox very well). Thus, running two or three of each card lets you maximize the chance of seeing at least one in your opening hand, while minimizing mulligans caused by seeing two-of-a-kind.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-17-2008, 11:33 PM
I disagree.

How many lands do you suggest running in a build with both?

honz
04-17-2008, 11:36 PM
If you are considering chrome mox as a pseudo-land, i can only assume that you would cut lands to fit it into the deck. If that is the case, the obvious problem i see would be the usefullness of exploration / touch going down even more. Cutting lands would also lead to some issues with your enchant lands. Doubling up enchantments on one land (especially when you only have 2-3) is near wreckless in an enviroment full of land-hate, not to mention it can slow down your early turns.

I guess i can't see an arguement for cutting lands in favor of mox. I guess there could be cuts in the exploration / touch area, as well as 1-2 lands.

Obfuscate Freely
04-18-2008, 12:22 AM
I disagree.

How many lands do you suggest running in a build with both?
We've run nineteen permanent mana sources in our lists for some time, now. Here's a list Zur posted (http://mtgthesource.com/forums/showpost.php?p=144598&postcount=98) in this very thread, about a year ago, which you can compare with the manabase of this list, which he played in a local tournament about a month ago:

//11
3x Argothian Enchantress
4x Enchantress's Presence
4x Living Wish

//10
4x Utopia Sprawl
3x Wild Growth
3x Exploration

//16
4x Elephant Grass
4x Solitary Confinement
3x Sterling Grove
1x City of Solitude
1x Blood Moon
1x Seal of Cleansing/Primordium
1x Words of War
1x Dovescape

//1
1x Replenish

//21
3x Chrome Mox
2x Elvish Spirit Guide

5x Forest
4x Windswept Heath
2x Wooded Foothills
3x Savannah
2x Taiga
1x Plains

//sideboard
2x Replenish
2x City of Solitude
2x Blood Moon
1x Seal of Cleansing/Primordium
1x Argothian Enchantress
1x Serra's Sanctum
1x Squee, Goblin Nabob
1x Eternal Witness
1x Magus of the Moon
3x ...?


If you are considering chrome mox as a pseudo-land, i can only assume that you would cut lands to fit it into the deck. If that is the case, the obvious problem i see would be the usefullness of exploration / touch going down even more. Cutting lands would also lead to some issues with your enchant lands. Doubling up enchantments on one land (especially when you only have 2-3) is near wreckless in an enviroment full of land-hate, not to mention it can slow down your early turns.

I guess i can't see an arguement for cutting lands in favor of mox. I guess there could be cuts in the exploration / touch area, as well as 1-2 lands.
We absolutely have cut lands to fit Chrome Mox into the deck, as I tried to explain in my previous post. If you cut anything else to include Chrome Mox in a deck, you end up increasing the number of mana sources, which increases the chance of getting manaflooded.

Elvish Spirit Guide is different, because it is not a permanent mana source. Replacing nonlands with ESGs will lead to manaflooding (at least, in terms of threat density), but replacing lands with ESGs will lead to more manascrew. This creates an ugly design quandary, in which you have to determine whether the value of accelerating your plays is worth a hit to either your mana consistency, your threat density, or both. If ESG was as powerful as Dark Ritual, it would be easy to justify (and as a four-of), but as it is, finding the optimal balance is more challenging.

Now, you are correct that there are some drawbacks, independent of mana source count and threat density, incurred by cutting lands. The value of early Explorations is reduced, and the enchant lands become slightly harder to utilize. However, in my experience, neither of these factors are significant.

Just me
04-18-2008, 04:10 AM
I must say though, that with a strong start (engine + enchantment) I usually draw more cards and therefore lands then I can play. I think the issue only is valid in the first 2 turns (about landratio being to low for optimal use with Exploration and the like). But more speed (Mox + ESG in some configuration) also helps to overcome this very problem (after creating it, funnily enough) because it allows you to get the engine online 1 turn sooner, decreasing the significance of the potential problem.

As is, I propably will start testing again with 4 Mox and 2 ESG.

Joe_C
04-18-2008, 07:27 AM
Im sure everyone realizes it, but noone has mentioned one of the strengths ESG has is getting a spell through a daze. Setting them back a turn when they brainstorm/bounce land daze is worth way more than pitching a card to mox. Sure mox is permanent mana. But I dont think it gets you any further ahead than a well timed ESG will

Jak
04-18-2008, 07:54 PM
I am not sure about Mox. The accel is nice, but I question how often I will need the mana to stick around. With ESG you get 1 mana for one card. With mox you get 1 more mana a turn for 2 cards. I just question how many turns I will need that one extra mana. Lowering the land count also makes Exploration much worse and increases the weakness to Deed. I'll test it, but I usually end up woth a surplus amount of mana by turn 3 because ESG accels into it. Do I need any more mana in there?

ESG does also own Daze, so that is another plus. While Chrome Mox makes the decks win turn faster, most likely.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-19-2008, 11:47 AM
I don'y really see any need to run Living Wish now that Replenish is unbanned. Without Living Wish, Chrome Mox's ability to stick around becomes less relevant.

You can pick apart one example and offer others, but my experiene tells me that there are many more scenarios where losing that one extra card to Mox is going to hurt than there are scenarios where ESG not sticking around is going to hurt.

Illissius
04-19-2008, 01:52 PM
You can pick apart one example and offer others, but my experiene tells me that there are many more scenarios where losing that one extra card to Mox is going to hurt than there are scenarios where ESG not sticking around is going to hurt.

I think the appropriate comparison might be: losing the card to Mox vs. ESG not being a different card.

Mr Wiggl3s
04-21-2008, 07:50 PM
I dont want to sound like a dick, but does anyone have a pretty current decklist?

Zach Tartell
04-21-2008, 08:34 PM
// Lands
2 [R] Savannah
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
1 [B] Taiga
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
1 [CHK] Plains (4)
10 [RAV] Forest (3)

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress

// Spells
1 [ON] Words of War
1 [WL] Aura of Silence
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
2 [UD] Replenish
1 [TSB] Sacred Mesa
1 [VI] City of Solitude
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
1 [4E] Wild Growth
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
3 [MR] Chrome Mox
3 [OD] Ground Seal
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
2 [US] Exploration

// Sideboard
SB: 1 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 1 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 4 [PS] Orim's Chant
SB: 1 [PLC] Seal of Primordium
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground
SB: 2 [8E] Choke
SB: 1 [DIS] Dovescape


This is a 59 card list and a 11 card board. I haven't figured out what I like for the open slots yet.

Mr Wiggl3s
04-21-2008, 08:54 PM
What is ground seal being used for?

Jak
04-21-2008, 09:15 PM
What is ground seal being used for?

Extra draw and GY hate. This is mine.

// Lands
2 [US] Serra's Sanctum
4 [ON] Windswept Heath
3 [B] Savannah
9 [RAV] Forest (3)
1 [B] Taiga

// Creatures
4 [US] Argothian Enchantress
3 [AL] Elvish Spirit Guide

// Spells
4 [VI] Elephant Grass
1 [OD] Karmic Justice
1 [WL] Aura of Silence
4 [IN] Sterling Grove
1 [ON] Words of War
3 [UD] Replenish
4 [DIS] Utopia Sprawl
4 [ON] Enchantress's Presence
3 [JU] Solitary Confinement
2 [US] Exploration
2 [DK] Gaea's Touch
4 [OD] Ground Seal
1 [LRW] Oblivion Ring

// Sideboard
SB: 2 [OD] Karmic Justice
SB: 1 [WL] Aura of Silence
SB: 3 [VI] City of Solitude
SB: 2 [TE] Choke
SB: 1 [SH] Sacred Ground
SB: 4 [PS] Orim's Chant
SB: 2 [ON] Gigapede

honz
04-21-2008, 09:30 PM
Ground seal is an amazing little card, that does very well in the current meta. At the very least, it cantrips to help you dig for whatever you need however its usefulness goes far beyond that. The list of cards it shuts down (from immediate memory) goes like:

Life from the loam (aggro loam, loam confinement, landstill, land.dec)
Eternal witness (rock, survival, aluren)
Dread return (ichorid)
Extirpate
Genesis (survival)
Volrath's stronghold (rock)
Academy Ruins (landstill, blue stax)
Wort, Boggart Auntie (gobblins)

All of those cards see play in decks currently denoted "decks to beat". There is an even bigger list of just random cards that float around in random decks. All in all, i would not run less than 3 ground seals in the main in the current environment. Its power in undeniable.

Julian23
04-22-2008, 05:00 AM
@Zach: I wonder why you choose to run Exploration over Gaea's Touch especially since you only run 20 lands. If tested the Touch and have to say that I really really like it. It's not even a free spell (which will draw you some more cards) but it can also net you with 1 more mana if you hit your forest-drop (which you run 10 of).

Just me
04-22-2008, 06:59 AM
Hi All,

A very strange idea which might be interesting. Did enyone try using black over white to create a dedicated combodeck?

I made a build that has a strong focus on (cheap) mana to cast a fast Cadaverous Bloom (3GB, enchantment, remove a card in hand to add GG or BB to your manapool).

When the Cadaverous Bloom resolves the deck wins. It draws cards into oblivion to cast a huge Consume Spirit (though I have to see if Tendrils of Agony isn't better vs counters. That would free up slots from the 3 City of Solitude).

List currently
4 Arg. Enchantress
4 Enchantress Presence
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Gaea's Toucg
4 Wild Growth
2 Exploration
4 ESG
3 City of Solitude
3 Cadaverous Bloom
1 Consume Spirit
3 Ground Seal
4 Elephant Grass
4 Windswept Heath
2 Bayou
2 Serra's Sanctuum
12 Forest

It runs nice, wins turn 4 for sure. But that's slower as other combo and the stall tactics from white are gone. The problem is that on turn 2 the engine is set up, allowing you to combo off not sooner than turn 3 (no matter the type of Enchantress). That might be why the white version will always be better, because it has more defensive tools. Anyhow, comments on this list (how to improve (= more speed) would be appreciated even more as why the traditional build is better. But that's also interesting :wink:

Jak
04-22-2008, 11:45 AM
Hi All,

A very strange idea which might be interesting. Did enyone try using black over white to create a dedicated combodeck?

I made a build that has a strong focus on (cheap) mana to cast a fast Cadaverous Bloom (3GB, enchantment, remove a card in hand to add GG or BB to your manapool).

When the Cadaverous Bloom resolves the deck wins. It draws cards into oblivion to cast a huge Consume Spirit (though I have to see if Tendrils of Agony isn't better vs counters. That would free up slots from the 3 City of Solitude).

List currently
4 Arg. Enchantress
4 Enchantress Presence
4 Utopia Sprawl
4 Gaea's Toucg
4 Wild Growth
2 Exploration
4 ESG
3 City of Solitude
3 Cadaverous Bloom
1 Consume Spirit
3 Ground Seal
4 Elephant Grass
4 Windswept Heath
2 Bayou
2 Serra's Sanctuum
12 Forest

It runs nice, wins turn 4 for sure. But that's slower as other combo and the stall tactics from white are gone. The problem is that on turn 2 the engine is set up, allowing you to combo off not sooner than turn 3 (no matter the type of Enchantress). That might be why the white version will always be better, because it has more defensive tools. Anyhow, comments on this list (how to improve (= more speed) would be appreciated even more as why the traditional build is better. But that's also interesting :wink:

Cavius the Great (his chosen name, not title), made a storm Enchantress list so you can probably talk to him and get ideas.

Cavius The Great
04-22-2008, 01:59 PM
My current B/G Enchantress list runs 4 Duress and 4 Thoughtseize and a slightly lower enchantment count sacrifing speed for disruption. Running 8 Duress effects is a must if you want the Combo version to be even close to competitive. I run 4 Cadaverous Bloom and 4 Squandered Resources (redundancy is essential in Blooms case, believe me, I've tested 3) and some other techy cards that I won't divulge just yet, but will eventually post about it in the future.

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-22-2008, 02:04 PM
Given that you lose Replenish, Solitary Confinement, and Sterling Grove, basically in exchange for discard, is the B/G the right call in anything but a combo-heavy meta-game?

Cavius The Great
04-22-2008, 02:16 PM
Given that you lose Replenish, Solitary Confinement, and Sterling Grove, basically in exchange for discard, is the B/G the right call in anything but a combo-heavy meta-game?

I've had good matchups versus Thresh and MUC, in addition to having a decent combo matchup. BG Enchantress also gives non-Goblin aggro a hard time as well, but note that 43land.dec is an auto-loss for me as well as Ichorid (Even with 4 Leylines and 2 Planar Void in the SB). Ray of Revelation and Krosan Grip can be a bitch.

Just me
04-22-2008, 02:37 PM
My current B/G Enchantress list runs 4 Duress and 4 Thoughtseize and a slightly lower enchantment count sacrifing speed for disruption. Running 8 Duress effects is a must if you want the Combo version to be even close to competitive. I run 4 Cadaverous Bloom and 4 Squandered Resources (redundancy is essential in Blooms case, believe me, I've tested 3) and some other techy cards that I won't divulge just yet, but will eventually post about it in the future.

Ok, that's fair enough. Could you maybe give an old list without the techy cards? Did you ever consider tutors for Arg. Enchantress? Worldly Totor and Summoners Pact both fit the manacurve very well (though in different ways).

@ Spatula
Against Aggro, you have a 4 turn clock on a normal draw, as do the most aggro decks. So it shouldn't be that bad if you play something like 4 Elephant Grass as semi fog. And you could combo in 2 steps, using a Tendrils to gain life (time) and finish it with a second kill card. But that isn't optimal.

Cavius The Great
04-22-2008, 02:42 PM
Ok, that's fair enough. Could you maybe give an old list without the techy cards? Did you ever consider tutors for Arg. Enchantress? Worldly Totor and Summoners Pact both fit the manacurve very well (though in different ways).


Why would you need a tutor with 8 Enchantress effects? If you feel you need more Enchantress cards, why not just run Verduran Enchantress? Both the tutors you've mentioned are pretty much sub-optimal in this type of deck.

Just me
04-22-2008, 06:07 PM
Why the tutors?
They act as additional Enchantresses. Verduran not really an option. It is way to easy to kill, it turns on all removal opponents might have. Burn, Smother, Swords, you name it.

The Worldy Tutor is a good turn 1 play, ensuring a turn 2 'engine' and this deck really needs it's engine, no matter the version you're running. The Pact is propably only good the turn you're winning (with the black combo version). Biggest downside has always been the facts that they're not enchantments. I used to run 4 tutors back in the day with Endless Wurm, Auratog and Rancor and believe me, it was very useful (and in that build able to fetch more cards as just Enchantress. Now maybe with Exalted Angel-tech from this thread? Make it less dead after turn 1?).

What does the deck must have? An Enchantress, a.s.a.p. What does a tutor get you?

SpatulaOfTheAges
04-22-2008, 06:23 PM
Yeah, but without Confinement and Replenish, I have strong doubts your aggro and control match-ups are as good as GWr's match-ups. They may still be positive, but losing two critical cards. I can sort of buy that the discard offsets this a bit, but Duress doesn't single-handedly win the game the way Replenish can.

Turn 4 is about the same turn you should throw down Confinement lock, which is GG vs just about everything. So your clocks are about the same. You're trading your outs vs. sweepers (Replenish and Justice), Confinement and Sanctum for some game vs. combo.

re: Verduan Enchantress - She's terrible MD, but she has SB potential.

Cavius The Great
04-22-2008, 06:55 PM
re: Verduan Enchantress - She's terrible MD, but she has SB potential.

I agree that Verduran Enchantress is horrible. I just disagree with running Worldly Tutor, when you can be playing discard for the same exact converted mana cost.