PDA

View Full Version : AMC 26th / Legacy in Japan



nicofromtokyo
07-22-2007, 09:54 PM
42 people for the monthly and biggest Legacy tournament in Japan. The TOP8 lists are available here, the 34 others should be available in a few days:

http://f18.aaa.livedoor.jp/~nameless/AMC/AMC_26th_E.html

1/ Reanimator
2/ RG Belcher
3/ RBG Sligh
4/ Loam-Tarmogoyf (?)
5/ Goblins
6/ W Stax
7/ Angel Stompy (?)
8/ Sligh

I did it again with Belcher: 5-1-0 :).
Regarding the list:

2 Taiga
3 Empty the Warrens
3 Pyroblast
4 Goblin Welder
4 Simian Spirit Guide
4 Elvish Spirit Guide
4 Land Grant
4 Burning Wish
4 Goblin Charbelcher
4 Lotus Petal
4 Chrome Mox
4 Lion's Eye Diamond
4 Tinder Wall
4 Seething Song
4 Desperate Ritual
4 Rite of Flame

4 Pact of Negation
2 Pyroclasm
1 Cave-In
1 Simplify
4 Shattering Spree
1 Tendrils of Agony
1 Infernal Tutor
1 Empty the Warrens

I won't play with any REB or Pyroblast, it's sooo useless. Didn't cast it even one time, didn't even want to cast it one time, wasn't even able to cast it to protect something even one time one 6 rounds. I should have play Street Wraith, definitly. Goblin Welder was the man, he won me at least 2 games.
I won against Pikula, Sligh x2, Ichobridge and W Stax, and lost to the winner, a strange Reanimator I am still wondering how it could have been undefeated all day long.

Btw, the CRET version finished 2nd to an other tournament in Nagoya 2 weeks ago (20 people). Belcher ftw!

Machinus
07-22-2007, 10:02 PM
Can we get more details about your report? How was Welder? Did you miss Wild Cantor?

nicofromtokyo
07-23-2007, 01:51 AM
Yep, I took some notes, even though a Belcher report is never very hard to remember!

1/ Pikula
G1: I play Belcher on turn 1 or 2, activate it for... 2 points! No more mana for a second activation, I lost to his shade and Confident.
G2: Belcher kill turn 1.
G3: Etw x 10 ftw.

2/ Sligh
G1: Belcher Kill turn 1.
G2: EtW x 10 or 12 ftw.

3/ Sligh
G1: EtW x 8, but it won't be enough to beat him, he burned me all my men and beat me with Kird Ape.
G2: Mulligan to 5. I manage to play a Belcher with LED, but wait the last moment to activate it as I didn't draw any land nor Land Grant. I won finally.
G3: Mull to 5, play Belcher and activate it next turn ftw.

4/ Ichobridge
G1: I play Belcher after 2 Land Grants, and wait for the last mana to activate it. It came quickly so I won before he can combo off.
G2: Mull to 4, he gets a quick start and kills me with a lot of Haste-creatures.
G3: I play quickly Belcher, and wait again to top-deck one mana to activate it. I win 2 turns later.

5/ Reanimator
G1: Mull to 4. I try to play a Burning Wish but get countered, to be crushed by a reanimated sutured Ghoul the next turn.
G2: Mull to 5. EtW x 8, but he has Intuition in hand = EE x3. Then he plays Negator and begins to beat me down. I play Belcher on my last turn but miss one mana to activate it.

6/ W Stax
G1: I loose the toss. He plays CoV zero, go. Then I play Burning Wish for shattering Spree, go. He plays Smockestack, and Tangle wire on the next turns...My turn, I play Shattering Spree for 2 on Cov and Smockestack, then Lotus Petal and Chrome mox to play Belcher. I will activate it ftw my next turn. Pfiew.
G2: I play EtW for 6, but he plays the White Propanganda and beat me down with something I cannot remember.
G3: The last and longer game of the day. I have nothing revelant in my first hand. He plays CoV 1 at his turn. I manage to play a big EtW, but he plays the white Propaganda then, followed by Stax, Tangle wire, Trinisphere... I am sooooo pissed off, even if I knew it would be an horrible match up. Anyway, I decided to play it until the last second, miracles may exist... Then he plays multiple Stax, Tangle wire, gets an 2/4 creature on play and begins to attacke me. My tokens begin to die, and my life starts to decrease slowly. I just draw and discard, draw and discard, draw and discard... Last 2 minutes, last 3 lives, my last turn, last draw...
SSG!
SSG+ESG+ESG = Seething Song+Seething Song+Seething Song = Belcher ftw!
Miracles do exist.

5-1-0, I finish 2nd in front of 40 guys.

Regarding the list. I am a huge Belcher player, I am playing the deck in Vintage too (finished 2nd too with my Mono-red version at a tournament last week, you can find the report somewhere on TMD), and I first wanted to put my Vintage list on Legacy, but Serum Powder was not so powerfull than in Vintage, because Mull less occurs than in T1, and you rarely want to sacrifice you Petal Lotus to cast a SP. The Card disadvantage of Chrome Mox was crucial, and I was forced to play at least 2 colors.
I played the CRET version last month, but the fact is, even if 3 colors are powerfull, you don't really need Dark Ritual to win. I mean, it may be fancy, but, why would you play with 3 colors when you can play with 2 colors and minimize the risks of dying to a Bayou? Regarding the probabilities of kill turn 1 or 2, I am pretty sure they're the same. I prefer focus on 2 colors for the same results. So I didn't miss Wild Cantor and Dark Ritual at all.
Regarding the disruption, I choosed 4 welder and 3 Pyroblast this time. I guess it's a metagame call, but I really like Welder for its polyvalency. You can get rid of a lot of stuff (less than in Vintage, but Needle, Null Rod, Cov exists in Legacy) and get a lot of mana with it. I actually activate 2 times Belcher with it, by exchanging artifact mana. It's strong again discard and counters too, and you can keep an hand with Belcher and Welder against Pikula first turn Duress.
REB and Pyroblast were my biggest deception. Really. I mean, I just used them to imprint my Chrome Mox. Pact of Negation may be more situationnal, but I guess they're the "less bad" solution, as you can protect your Belcher or protect you for one turn.
I missed street wraith too, as Belcher top-decks like ass.

I dream all night long that Wizards print us a Mage of the Belcher! ^__-

Osse
07-23-2007, 03:00 AM
I had never really thought about Welder in the legacy version. I've had people discuss it in vintage with people hating it, or complete vice versa stance on it. I'll have to try it out. As I play with the people who created CRET Belcher, I have come to all the same conclusions as you (though, they disagree entirely obviously).

Instead of Pact of Negation, have you given any thought to Xantid Swarm? You may be a turn slower, but against Control, that may be best as you can go off and be protected, instead of waiting for the second shot at it. I don't know well it works, I'm just wondering if you've used it at all.

Thanks for the lists, and another Aggro-Loam list catches my eye. Maybe I should make a thread about it.

-Justin

Joe Eigo
07-23-2007, 08:27 AM
Strange Metagame, very, very Aggro... No Threshold except the ones with 100 cards and Gelectrode. Blue seemed to be a bit underplayed, just 6 out of 42 decks had Brainstorm in it :X.
But anyway, grats to 2nd place and thanks for the lists! =]