PDA

View Full Version : [REPORT] Top 2 & The Batcave 10/28/2007



Volt
10-29-2007, 01:10 AM
There were only 12 people at this tournament, so I'm not going to make a big deal out of it. However, I thought I'd go ahead and post a brief tourney report. For a metagame breakdown of the tournament, look here (http://mtgthesource.com/forums/showpost.php?p=174168&postcount=11).

I played 4-color Countersliver. Here's the list:

4 Flooded Strand
4 Polluted Delta
4 Tundra
2 Tropical Island
2 Underground Sea
1 Scrubland
1 Island

4 Crystalline Sliver
4 Hibernation Sliver
4 Sinew Sliver
4 Muscle Sliver
2 Winged Sliver

4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Force of Will
4 Daze
4 Duress
4 Brainstorm
2 Ponder
2 Sensei's Divining Top

SB:
4 Blue Elemental Blast
4 Pithing Needle
3 Harmonic Sliver
3 Stifle
1 Ensnare (mirror match tech)

Onto the tournament;

Round 1 vs Burn (Zach)
In game 1, a timely Daze and Force allow my slivers to outrace his burn.

Sideboard: -4 Crystalline +4 BEB

In game 2, he mulls to 5 and gets stuck on 1 land.

1-0, 2-0

Round 2 vs Mono-Red Lando (Jarod)
He opens game 1 with Wasteland, Wasteland, but I draw into more lands. A Crystalline and Muscle go all the way.

Sideboard: -2 StP, -2 Winged, +4 BEB

Game 2 starts off much the same way. He opens with a couple of Wastelands, but I continue to draw land while he doesn't, which leads to him getting slightly mana-screwed and me winning easily. I remember Duressing away a Stone Rain and blue blasting a Sowing Salt, and then running him over with slivers.

2-0, 4-0

Round 3 vs Countersliver (James/Pinder)
Game 1 was ridiculous. James mulled down to 4 cards and kept a no-land hand. I mulled to 6 and kept a 1-land hand. James didn't draw his first land until 5 turns into the game. Meanwhile, I got out 2 lands, but both were Trops, and I couldn't cast a single spell in my hand. James and I both ended up having to discard before we were able to cast a spell. Finally, James drew a land and attempted to cast Aether Vial, which I dazed. Then, I draw a fetchland, got a Scrubland, and proceeded to empty my hand of slivers over the next few turns.

Sideboard: -4 StP, +3 Harmonic Sliver, +1 Ensnare

Game 2 was more interesting. We both got off to decent starts, with each of us building our hives up to 5 slivers each. Then I drew Ensnare, cast it at the end of his turn with Force of Will backup, and won.

3-0, 6-0

Round 4 vs TES (Nick/Nightshade81)
Nick and I were the only 3-0s and were guaranteed to make T4, so we drew. Nick didn't want any part of me, anyway. :)

3-0-1

Finals
The top 4 was:
Countersliver (me)
Countersliver (James/Pinder)
TES (Nick/Nightshade81)
TES (Tommy/Jak)

I was paired against Jak. Pinder and I were both glad we didn't have to play each other again right off the bat.

In game 1 against Tommy, I mulled to 6 cards, keeping a hand with Daze as my only disruption. Tommy had won the die roll, so I was at his mercy. Fortunately, he just played a land and passed the turn. I drew a card, played a land, and passed the turn back. On his second turn, Tommy started to go off, playing out a second land, LED, Lotus Petal, Lotus Petal, Rite of Flame. I dazed the RoF and prayed it was enough to hold him off. I breathed a heavy sigh of relief when he passed the turn. From there it was a simple matter of playing slivers and sculpting my hand while Tommy rebuilt his hand. He tried to go off again 4 turns later, but I had found some more disruption by then and was able to stop him.

Sideboard: -4 Crystalline, -2 Swords, -1 Divining Top, +4 BEB, +3 Stifle

Game 2 was fairly easy for me, as I drew plenty of disruption. I remember blue blasting a RoF, Forcing a Chant, and Stifling a mini-EtW. He did make things interesting by resolving a Diminishing Returns the turn before he was going to die, but he had to tap out to do so, and I drew another handful of disruption. He tried to go off again by playing a land and casting Dark Rit. I dazed it, and he scooped.

Meanwhile, James dispatched his TES opponent 2-0, which meant it was to be an all Countersliver final. Neither James nor I were too interested in playing that out, so we agreed to split. We each took home $30 cash and $15 store credit, while Nick and Tommy got $15 store credit. I used my store credit to get 4 Lorwyn booster packs, and was very happy to open up a Thoughtseize, Mirror Entity, Doran, and foil Dauntless Dourbark.

Props:
Pinder and Jay for making the trip down from Seattle.
Burgerville for delicious burgers, fries and ice cream after the tournament.

Slops:
None. It was nothing but good times.

MattH
10-29-2007, 03:09 AM
What's the story on the Tops?

Pinder
10-29-2007, 03:52 AM
What's the story on the Tops?

I'm also pretty interested to see how Top turned out for you.

I suppose I should get a report (of sorts) out here too. First, the list:

//Land
4 Tundra
4 Flooded Strand
3 Polluted Delta
2 Tropical Island
2 Polluted Delta
1 Scrubland
1 Island

//Slivers
4 Crystalline
4 Hibernation
4 Sinew
4 Muscle
3 Winged

//Spells
4 Force of Will
4 Duress
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Aether Vial

//Sideboard
3 Pithing Needle (I didn't have a fourth, but three worked out okay)
4 Meddling Mage
3 Harmonic Sliver
3 Spell Snare
1 Cover of Darkness <-------savage mirror match tech
1 Sliver Queen <----was supposed to be CoD #2, but Mike (the shop owner) only had 1. So in it went.

I didn't take notes, so descriptions will be brief

Round 1: Ryan (DeathwingZERO) with Bardo's Countertop Thresh

Game 1: He gets dudes and I don't get dudes. I die of a tragic Tarmogoyf related incident.

Out: Some stuff
In: Spell Snare x3

Game 2: I get dudes and he doesn't get dudes. He dies of a tragic Hive-related incident.

Game 3: We both get some dudes, but due to awful draws his stay tiny. I send both of his dudes farming and send my dudes in for the win. Also I Spell Snared a Daze.

1-0, 2-1

Round 2: Nathan (?) with Angel Stompy

All of the games were close, but in the end I took the first and third. I also remember that Hibernation + FoW > Cataclysm.

2-0, 4-2

Round 3: Chris (Volt) with the list in the first post.

Game 1: I draw a 7 card, 1 land hand that looks amazing...if I draw another land. There were no cantrips or Vials in there, though, so I threw it back. Turns out I would have topdecked a fetch. I proceed to mulligan into 3 no land hands in a row, eventually keeping the last because I don't want to mull to 3. He played spells and I, you know, didn't.

Out: Something
In: Cover of Darkness

Game 2: This one started off well, as I had more Hibernation and Crystallines than he did, so my guys were slightly bigger. I swung in with a couple, only to eat an Ensnare and an ensuing attack with ludicrously huge guys next turn. Apparently this was the first time Chris ever beat the mirror with Ensnare, and he says it was hugely satisfying.

2-1, 4-4

Round 4: Bret with Psychatog

Game 1: I lost this one, but it was close. I remember doing all sorts of crazy combat math to make sure I wouldn't die (I spent 8 life saving my army from a Deed), only to have him discard Wonder and make my blockers irrelevant anyway.

Out: 1 of a bunch of things
In: 3 Meddling Mage, 3 Pithing Needle.

Game 2: I do spiffy things with everyone's favorite Hive. I think I Maged Deed, too.

Game 3: This one was close again, but I got an early Needle (and Mage!) on Deed, beat some, then topdecked 2 Needles in a row, one of which resolved to keep his Psychatog from ever getting big.

3-1, 6-5

After finding out that the Top 4 was 2 Slivers and 2 TES, I prayed desperately that I wouldn't get the mirror again. Luckily my wish was granted and I played Nick (Nightshade81) in the semis with TES.

Game 1: I nab an LED with a Duress, then he gets and early Xantid, which I swords. He tries to go off, but I have a well timed FoW. I proceed to lay down the beats before he can recover.

Out: 4 Something (Swords?)
In: 4 Meddling Mage

Game 2: He plays a lot of cantrips and sees a lot of cards, but unfortunately none of them good. He had me under Xantid the whole time, and chanted me a couple of times, but I had a Mage on Infernal Tutor and some big slivers. Turns out he died with 3 Infernals in hand.

I was sort of curious to see how the Sliver mirror would have turned out if I didn't mull to a 4 card, no land hand game 1, but then I realized that would require me to play the Sliver mirror. I offer the split and Volt accepts readily. I walk out with $30 in cash and a Tenth Edition Wrath from my $15 in store credit (I wanted to pick up a Flooded Strand, but they didn't have any /cry).


Props:
Burgerville. I'd almost drive to Vancouver just for that.
Everyone in general, for being generally awesome.
Ensnare, for actually winning the mirror for once.
Burgerville again, for having a burger called the 'Pepper Bacon Cheeseburger'. Shit was awesome.

Slops:
Only 12 people :(
Zilla and Bardo, for not showing up
Brian (Maverick676), for copping out like a pussy :P
The 3 hour drive, both ways (it was fun and all, but the commute is a bitch).

Volt
10-29-2007, 05:43 AM
I've been testing out the SDT's for a little while. Compared to Ponder, they're a little bit worse in the first couple turns, but much better in the mid- to late-game. The ability to dig 3 deep every turn really comes in handy for those long, drawn out games.

xsockmonkeyx
10-29-2007, 06:12 AM
Also I Spell Snared a Daze.

Savage play, Pindah. :tongue:

DeathwingZERO
10-29-2007, 07:56 AM
Spell Snaring that Daze let the EE for 2 hit the board and put a glimmer of hope on that third game for me.

Unfortunately, Thresh really, really hates it when you try piloting it after saying you hate the deck for 5 years.

FakeSpam
10-29-2007, 10:07 AM
Spell Snaring that Daze let the EE for 2 hit the board and put a glimmer of hope on that third game for me.

Unfortunately, Thresh really, really hates it when you try piloting it after saying you hate the deck for 5 years.

You can play an EE for 3+ mana using 2 different colors. That's the same thing. Gets around counterbalance, spell snare, etc.

DeathwingZERO
10-29-2007, 11:41 AM
Ya, I had already planned on doing that, but it was just amusing that my Daze which was a now defunct card (he was sitting on like 5-6 mana) got hit by his Spell Snare just because.

I ended up losing that match horribly anyways, my 2 poor Goyf's never went past 3/4, then farming soon after, compared to his multitude of 4/4 unStP'able Slivers.

I still can't believe I got beat down by a Hibernation Sliver, though. If it wasn't Crystallines, it was the ones that could just bounce back for 2 life, and me with just StP as removal. I was so screwed, lol.

Kronicler
10-29-2007, 11:50 AM
My big question is whether or not you can consistently run a 4c list without Aether Vial. I have a hunch that the answer is no, yet volt seemed to do fine with it at the tourney. I'm definitely a bit skeptical about the SDTs. While I agree that they are good in the late game, I think that Ponder's land finding ability early game is much more relevant, especially if you aren't running Aether Vials. Also, Volt, what did you think of 2 winged slivers? I know we have been discussing the 61 card version and trying to figure out what to cut, with the 3rd winged being a likely candidate. What did you think of only 2 winged? Did you find them when you needed to? Perhaps the 2 SDTs are necessary if we are only running 2 winged as they will allow us to dig for them late game. Lots to think about....

Kronicler

godryk
10-29-2007, 12:31 PM
//Land
4 Tundra
4 Flooded Strand
3 Polluted Delta
2 Tropical Island
2 Polluted Delta
1 Scrubland
1 Island

//Slivers
4 Crystalline
4 Hibernation
4 Sinew
4 Muscle
3 Winged

//Spells
4 Force of Will
4 Duress
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Aether Vial

//Sideboard
3 Pithing Needle (I didn't have a fourth, but three worked out okay)
4 Meddling Mage
3 Harmonic Sliver
3 Spell Snare
1 Cover of Darkness <-------savage mirror match tech
1 Sliver Queen <----was supposed to be CoD #2, but Mike (the shop owner) only had 1. So in it went.

Running 5 Polluted Delta seems techy... :tongue: I suposse they're Seas.

Hum, what a funny Top8, makes me consider borrow a friend of mine a pair of Underground Seas...

Anyway, a pair of thoughts:
@Volt: Haven't you thought about including a pair of Counterbalance in the SB...? As others have asked before, how did you felt with "only" a pir of Winged Slivers? Would you side Ensnare against another deck?

Volt
10-29-2007, 02:19 PM
My build for this tournament was very metagame dependent. I felt that Aether Vial was unnecessary because I knew there was going to be very little Thresh and Landstill (a complete 180 from previous Batcave tournaments). Against decks besides Thresh and Landstill, I prefer to have extra disruption in those slots.

I was going to run 3 Hibernation + 3 Winged, but decided to swap 1 of the Winged out for the 4th Hibernation, because I also knew there was probably only going to be 1 Goblins deck there (mine, which I loaned to a friend). The Winged Slivers are primarily for the Goblins and Thresh matchups. Against most other decks, you can get away with just 2 Winged Slivers.

As I said, I've been pretty happy with the Divining Tops. I think it's worth it to swap out 2 Ponders for them. I've considered running the CounterTop package in the sideboard, but haven't really tested it with the 4-color version of the deck. If I were going to do it, I would probably want 3 Counterbalance + 1 Divining Top in the sideboard. It seems like an attractive idea.