TrialByFire
01-20-2008, 05:43 AM
I played my White Threshold list to a third place split at Hadley today. Overall I like the decklist but have a few changes after playing today. Here is the original decklist:
// Lands
4 Tundra
1 Forest
4 Tropical Island
3 Windswept Heath
3 Flooded Strand
2 Island
1 Plains
// Creatures
2 Mystic Enforcer
4 Nimble Mongoose
4 Tarmogoyf
// Spells
1 Oblivion Ring
4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Counterbalance
3 Sensei's Divining Top
2 Stifle
3 Spell Snare
4 Force of Will
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
3 Daze
// Sideboard
SB: 3 Krosan Grip
SB: 3 Blue Elemental Blast
SB: 3 Threads of Disloyalty
SB: 2 Engineered Explosives
SB: 4 Meddling Mage
After today I changed:
MD:
-2 Stifle
-1 Tundra
-1 Tropical Island
+1 Flooded Strand
+1 Windswept Heath
+1 Snare
+1 Explosives
-1 SB Explosives
+1 SB B.E.B.
BEBs were amazing and I never used Stifle except once to Stifle a Lackey trigger.
The Tourney was 6 rounds then cut to Top 8 with 36 people.
Round 1
Matt with Goblins splash green
Game 1: He is on the play. He gets turn 1 Vial I have no Force of Will. Things go downhill from there as he gets triple Piledriver, Warchief, Ringleader, and Siege Gang. He cycles to kill a 4/5 Goyf and swings for the win.
I Board out Enforcers and Counterbalance for BEBs and Grips.
Game 2: No Aether Vials for him. I play a Goyf on turn 2 then Daze his Piledriver. Snares, BEBs and StP keep his men off the table and after Forcing a Ringleader, Goyf finally does him in.
Game 3: This was a good game. He has first turn Lackey and I have no Force. Sad face. But I rip BEB off the top like a champ and kill it. His next play gets Dazed (Chalice for 1 I think). Then I get Top and start searching for beaters. I find a Goyf next turn after Spell Snaring a Piledriver. Then I find a Goose. He is trying to mise blockers as he is on 8 life and I have a 5/6 Goyf and a threshed Goose, and the round time is called. He makes men, they block. He makes two more men, they block. On turn 4 he makes a Matron and gets Fanatic and plays it. I EOT BEB Fanatic, then untap and O-Ring his Matron and attack for exactly lethal. What a way to start the day.
Matches 1-0, Games 2-1
Round 2
Andrew Maag (Magler) playing Ichorid
Game 1: He is on the play. He apparently get a really shitty hand because he doesn't do anything till turn 5 when he plays a City of Brass and Breakthroughs for 0. Counterbalance stops that. I have Goyf and am beating for 4. He Breakthroughs again for 1 this time. I have Spell Snare. He Breakthroughs again for two. I Force it and swing for the win.
Board out Enforcers, a Counterbalance, Stifles and and O-ring for 4 Mages and 2 Explosives.
Game 2: He starts dredging, I get double Mage on Dread Return. I am beating with two Goyfs and 3 non threshed Geese. He gets triple Bridge and all 4 Narcomoebas early. I never see Explosives and am eventually run over by Zombies.
Game 3: I start the game with both Explosives in my hand, but I decide to not run them out there to try and surprise him. Then on turn 3, he drops FUCKING CHALICE FOR 0. OWNED. Triple Ichorids (I StP 2 of them), and 4 Bridges make short work of me as I can't find Goyf to stem the bleeding.
Matches 1-1, Games 3-3
Round 3
Caleb (MadManiac42) playing MonoWhite Stax
Game 1: He is on the play. He plays Turn 1 Trinishpere, I Force it. He plays Chalice for 1 and it gets Spell Snared. I run a Goyf out and it gets O-Ringed. He plays a Ghostly Prison and a Crucible before I find another Goyf. Then he play another Ghostly Prison and starts killing my non-basics. I have all my basics out at this point and he plays a THIRD prison. I cannot make more than 4 mana so I can't attack. I concede.
Sideboard an Enforcer, and Counterbalances for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives
Game 2: I am on the play and he doesn't find any Wastelands. I Force Trinishpere and Chalice again. I tap out for Goyf on turn 3 (missed land drop) and he untaps and plays Diamond, Geddon with Ghostly Prison out. I have 1 card in hand. It is not a Daze. Shitty. But apparently not as I rip two lands off the top like a champ and beat him to death with Goyf as he draws no mana sources in the next 5 turns.
Game 3: He mulls and keeps his six. He plays Diamond pitching Plains, Diamond pitching Plains, Ghost Quarter, Crucible and it sticks. He now has no hand. I play turn 3 Grip on his Crucible, and counter a Chalice and another Crucible and StP his Magus. I beat him with Goyf for the win.
Matches 2-1, Games 5-4
Round 4
Pete Meyer (PhaerimmArchlord) Playing Extended Doran.dec with Duals
Game 1: I keep an opener of land, land, 3x Goyf, Ponder, Stifle. He is on the play. He plays turn 1 Treetop Village. I play Ponder and find Force. Then he plays turn 2 Urborg, Duress taking Force. I comment on how nasty Therapy would have been. Then he taps Treetop for black (fuck Urborg) and Therapies me for the 3 Goyfs. Bastard. Can't really recover from that shit.
Sideboard out Enforcers and a Stifle for Threads
Game 2: I set up Turn 2 Countertop, and he is stuck on two lands. I find Threads and keep it on top. It counters a Vindicate next turn. I get a Goyf. Then he plays a Bob and I have no counter or removal. I say fuck it and steal that shit with Threads. He doesn't kill it and Bob and Goyf get in for 6 a turn and I StP a Doran on my way to winning.
Game 3: I get CounterTop, but Balance gets Vindicated. Then I Brainstorm into double Goyf and drop them. He draws nothing but land the next turns and dies.
Matches 3-1, Games 7-5
Round 5
Ben Lukas (ForceofWill) Playing GRW Eternal Garden/Loam kind of pile of junk
Game 1: He is on the play. He casts turn 1 Burning Wish for Loam. He plays it turn two and it gets Snared. I set up Countertop. He makes a misplay and gets owned by Counterbalance. I keep a two cost on top with Top so no Loaming. I get double Goyf and he finds a Confinement with 1 card in hand and Squee in the grave. I think, then tell him I have the O-Ring in the main and will draw cards till I find it. He concedes, and I show him it since he asked me to. It was 3 cards down.
SB out Enforcers, Stifle and and an StP for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives.
Game 2: He resolves Gamble and gets Maze and gets the Loaming going. I really have no chance this game as he gets Tabernacle, Waste-lock (only drew 1 basic and no fetches) and thats enough so I can't come back. He beats with manlands till I die.
I sideboard out more stuff for 4 Mages (forgot exactly what)
Game 3: I keep a creature heavy hand and hope to out aggro him. He gets Gamble into Maze of Ith. I have Mage on Loam. Then he plays Humility. He Loams away and gets Wastelands and Factories going. I put Grip on top with Top to draw it the next turn. I tap my only Island the turn before to play Goyf and keep Plains up to StP his Factory. Instead he Devastaing Dreams for 3 wiping my board and I have Spell Snare in hand but no blue. Pretty good.
Matches 3-2, Games 8-7
Round 6
Braves54321, playing Goyf Sligh
Game 1: This matchup is very in my favor, and I keep a hand containing CB and Top. Prety good. I set that up, then end up getting the beats on with TWO unthreshed Enforcers. He can't resolve anything through the lock and they finish him with help from a Goyf.
Sideboard out an Enforcer and Stifles for 3 BEB
Game 2: He mulls to 6 has turn 1 Cursed Scroll and turn 2 Goyf. I have the Force and a Spell Snare for them. I get double Goyf and Counterbalance, and he can't really do much.
Matches 4-2, Games 10-7
I am 7th place going into top 8.
Quarterfinals
Afro playing Goblins splash black
Game 1: He is on the play. I didn't win many die rolls today. He gets turn 1 Vial and I don't have Force. You know how that goes.
Sideboarded the same as the last Gobs match
Game 2: He gets turn 1 Lackey and that gets BEBed. Turn 2 Chalice for 1 gets Snared. I tap out for Goyf. He plays an Aether Vial. It resolves. He Vials in a Matron to block and gets Warchief. Then he Vials in Warchief on his turn and play Ringleader revealing Driver, Siege Gang, and Ringleader. Things are not looking so good. I EOT see Grip with Top, so I BEB his Warchief, then untap and cast Grip on his Vial. His board is now double Port and Mountain. Goyf gets in, and he concedes on the next turn.
Game 3: He mulls to 5 and I go to 6. His turn 1 is Mountain, Fanatic. I play a Ponder and see Goyf. He misses a land drop and attacks. I untap and play Goyf. He finds a land and plays Jitte. So I swing in with Goyf he doesn't block. Then I play Top with two mana untapped. He goes to equip Fanatic and I StP it. I smash again. He plays a Lackey. I smash again. He goes to equip and I StP the Lackey. His mull to 5, land screw and tempo loss are enough, and he succumbs to Goyf.
Semifinals
Ross Merriam (theross) playing Dragon Stompy
Game 1: He wins the die roll (again) and says Mountain, go. I did not know what he was playing, so crack my only fetch for Trop (with Tundra in hand) for Ponder and see 3 land and shuffle and draw random shit. He plays turn 2 Blood Moon and that is that. I die to a whatever random guy he musters shortly after.
Game 2: This one went very long, but I Force his early disruption. He then lands a SoFI and follows it up with a Morph and equip the next turn. I play Top, then Plow his Morph when he swings. He plays another Morph and equips again. I Top into another Plow. I StP his guy again, and he plays a Magus and equips. I Top and Draw a Ponder for my turn. I Ponder. What do you think the third card is? Of course, its the 3rd Plow in a row :). I Sword the Magus on attack, and he is out of threats. We play draw go for a couple turns and he drops Trinisphere (I don't care I have 6 lands out) and I draw BEB, Force, etc to stop his stuff. He tries a Pit Dragon, but it gets BEBed. Then I finally draw Goyf and play it. I keep mana open for Force at all times and Goyf kills him like 6 turns later as he doesn't draw anything relevant.
Game 3: He gets a really fast start and gets hellbent Dragon and Spirit Guide to my Goyf. I need to find removal fast and the Dragon domes me for 8. I am at 8 and draw Flooded Strand to go with the Force in my hand. I lose. The top cards of my deck are, in order, StP, BEB, Goyf. Obviously.
I split 3rd/4th and take home some Taigas that the 2nd place person didn't want. Not bad.
Props:
-Kevin for having kickass tourneys of course
-Pete for getting second with his Extended deck. Lol
-Me for being a fucking lucksack
-O. Ring for being amazing
Slops:
-Pat for being addicted to the Crack Machine. You need CAA (Crackaholics Anonymous)
-Bryan for 3-0-1 ing then losing two straight rounds to be out of contention.
-Louis for playing my new Landstill list, owning Goblins in the first round and then failing miserably after playing the deck's worst matchup, Goyf Sligh, in second two matches.
// Lands
4 Tundra
1 Forest
4 Tropical Island
3 Windswept Heath
3 Flooded Strand
2 Island
1 Plains
// Creatures
2 Mystic Enforcer
4 Nimble Mongoose
4 Tarmogoyf
// Spells
1 Oblivion Ring
4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Counterbalance
3 Sensei's Divining Top
2 Stifle
3 Spell Snare
4 Force of Will
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
3 Daze
// Sideboard
SB: 3 Krosan Grip
SB: 3 Blue Elemental Blast
SB: 3 Threads of Disloyalty
SB: 2 Engineered Explosives
SB: 4 Meddling Mage
After today I changed:
MD:
-2 Stifle
-1 Tundra
-1 Tropical Island
+1 Flooded Strand
+1 Windswept Heath
+1 Snare
+1 Explosives
-1 SB Explosives
+1 SB B.E.B.
BEBs were amazing and I never used Stifle except once to Stifle a Lackey trigger.
The Tourney was 6 rounds then cut to Top 8 with 36 people.
Round 1
Matt with Goblins splash green
Game 1: He is on the play. He gets turn 1 Vial I have no Force of Will. Things go downhill from there as he gets triple Piledriver, Warchief, Ringleader, and Siege Gang. He cycles to kill a 4/5 Goyf and swings for the win.
I Board out Enforcers and Counterbalance for BEBs and Grips.
Game 2: No Aether Vials for him. I play a Goyf on turn 2 then Daze his Piledriver. Snares, BEBs and StP keep his men off the table and after Forcing a Ringleader, Goyf finally does him in.
Game 3: This was a good game. He has first turn Lackey and I have no Force. Sad face. But I rip BEB off the top like a champ and kill it. His next play gets Dazed (Chalice for 1 I think). Then I get Top and start searching for beaters. I find a Goyf next turn after Spell Snaring a Piledriver. Then I find a Goose. He is trying to mise blockers as he is on 8 life and I have a 5/6 Goyf and a threshed Goose, and the round time is called. He makes men, they block. He makes two more men, they block. On turn 4 he makes a Matron and gets Fanatic and plays it. I EOT BEB Fanatic, then untap and O-Ring his Matron and attack for exactly lethal. What a way to start the day.
Matches 1-0, Games 2-1
Round 2
Andrew Maag (Magler) playing Ichorid
Game 1: He is on the play. He apparently get a really shitty hand because he doesn't do anything till turn 5 when he plays a City of Brass and Breakthroughs for 0. Counterbalance stops that. I have Goyf and am beating for 4. He Breakthroughs again for 1 this time. I have Spell Snare. He Breakthroughs again for two. I Force it and swing for the win.
Board out Enforcers, a Counterbalance, Stifles and and O-ring for 4 Mages and 2 Explosives.
Game 2: He starts dredging, I get double Mage on Dread Return. I am beating with two Goyfs and 3 non threshed Geese. He gets triple Bridge and all 4 Narcomoebas early. I never see Explosives and am eventually run over by Zombies.
Game 3: I start the game with both Explosives in my hand, but I decide to not run them out there to try and surprise him. Then on turn 3, he drops FUCKING CHALICE FOR 0. OWNED. Triple Ichorids (I StP 2 of them), and 4 Bridges make short work of me as I can't find Goyf to stem the bleeding.
Matches 1-1, Games 3-3
Round 3
Caleb (MadManiac42) playing MonoWhite Stax
Game 1: He is on the play. He plays Turn 1 Trinishpere, I Force it. He plays Chalice for 1 and it gets Spell Snared. I run a Goyf out and it gets O-Ringed. He plays a Ghostly Prison and a Crucible before I find another Goyf. Then he play another Ghostly Prison and starts killing my non-basics. I have all my basics out at this point and he plays a THIRD prison. I cannot make more than 4 mana so I can't attack. I concede.
Sideboard an Enforcer, and Counterbalances for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives
Game 2: I am on the play and he doesn't find any Wastelands. I Force Trinishpere and Chalice again. I tap out for Goyf on turn 3 (missed land drop) and he untaps and plays Diamond, Geddon with Ghostly Prison out. I have 1 card in hand. It is not a Daze. Shitty. But apparently not as I rip two lands off the top like a champ and beat him to death with Goyf as he draws no mana sources in the next 5 turns.
Game 3: He mulls and keeps his six. He plays Diamond pitching Plains, Diamond pitching Plains, Ghost Quarter, Crucible and it sticks. He now has no hand. I play turn 3 Grip on his Crucible, and counter a Chalice and another Crucible and StP his Magus. I beat him with Goyf for the win.
Matches 2-1, Games 5-4
Round 4
Pete Meyer (PhaerimmArchlord) Playing Extended Doran.dec with Duals
Game 1: I keep an opener of land, land, 3x Goyf, Ponder, Stifle. He is on the play. He plays turn 1 Treetop Village. I play Ponder and find Force. Then he plays turn 2 Urborg, Duress taking Force. I comment on how nasty Therapy would have been. Then he taps Treetop for black (fuck Urborg) and Therapies me for the 3 Goyfs. Bastard. Can't really recover from that shit.
Sideboard out Enforcers and a Stifle for Threads
Game 2: I set up Turn 2 Countertop, and he is stuck on two lands. I find Threads and keep it on top. It counters a Vindicate next turn. I get a Goyf. Then he plays a Bob and I have no counter or removal. I say fuck it and steal that shit with Threads. He doesn't kill it and Bob and Goyf get in for 6 a turn and I StP a Doran on my way to winning.
Game 3: I get CounterTop, but Balance gets Vindicated. Then I Brainstorm into double Goyf and drop them. He draws nothing but land the next turns and dies.
Matches 3-1, Games 7-5
Round 5
Ben Lukas (ForceofWill) Playing GRW Eternal Garden/Loam kind of pile of junk
Game 1: He is on the play. He casts turn 1 Burning Wish for Loam. He plays it turn two and it gets Snared. I set up Countertop. He makes a misplay and gets owned by Counterbalance. I keep a two cost on top with Top so no Loaming. I get double Goyf and he finds a Confinement with 1 card in hand and Squee in the grave. I think, then tell him I have the O-Ring in the main and will draw cards till I find it. He concedes, and I show him it since he asked me to. It was 3 cards down.
SB out Enforcers, Stifle and and an StP for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives.
Game 2: He resolves Gamble and gets Maze and gets the Loaming going. I really have no chance this game as he gets Tabernacle, Waste-lock (only drew 1 basic and no fetches) and thats enough so I can't come back. He beats with manlands till I die.
I sideboard out more stuff for 4 Mages (forgot exactly what)
Game 3: I keep a creature heavy hand and hope to out aggro him. He gets Gamble into Maze of Ith. I have Mage on Loam. Then he plays Humility. He Loams away and gets Wastelands and Factories going. I put Grip on top with Top to draw it the next turn. I tap my only Island the turn before to play Goyf and keep Plains up to StP his Factory. Instead he Devastaing Dreams for 3 wiping my board and I have Spell Snare in hand but no blue. Pretty good.
Matches 3-2, Games 8-7
Round 6
Braves54321, playing Goyf Sligh
Game 1: This matchup is very in my favor, and I keep a hand containing CB and Top. Prety good. I set that up, then end up getting the beats on with TWO unthreshed Enforcers. He can't resolve anything through the lock and they finish him with help from a Goyf.
Sideboard out an Enforcer and Stifles for 3 BEB
Game 2: He mulls to 6 has turn 1 Cursed Scroll and turn 2 Goyf. I have the Force and a Spell Snare for them. I get double Goyf and Counterbalance, and he can't really do much.
Matches 4-2, Games 10-7
I am 7th place going into top 8.
Quarterfinals
Afro playing Goblins splash black
Game 1: He is on the play. I didn't win many die rolls today. He gets turn 1 Vial and I don't have Force. You know how that goes.
Sideboarded the same as the last Gobs match
Game 2: He gets turn 1 Lackey and that gets BEBed. Turn 2 Chalice for 1 gets Snared. I tap out for Goyf. He plays an Aether Vial. It resolves. He Vials in a Matron to block and gets Warchief. Then he Vials in Warchief on his turn and play Ringleader revealing Driver, Siege Gang, and Ringleader. Things are not looking so good. I EOT see Grip with Top, so I BEB his Warchief, then untap and cast Grip on his Vial. His board is now double Port and Mountain. Goyf gets in, and he concedes on the next turn.
Game 3: He mulls to 5 and I go to 6. His turn 1 is Mountain, Fanatic. I play a Ponder and see Goyf. He misses a land drop and attacks. I untap and play Goyf. He finds a land and plays Jitte. So I swing in with Goyf he doesn't block. Then I play Top with two mana untapped. He goes to equip Fanatic and I StP it. I smash again. He plays a Lackey. I smash again. He goes to equip and I StP the Lackey. His mull to 5, land screw and tempo loss are enough, and he succumbs to Goyf.
Semifinals
Ross Merriam (theross) playing Dragon Stompy
Game 1: He wins the die roll (again) and says Mountain, go. I did not know what he was playing, so crack my only fetch for Trop (with Tundra in hand) for Ponder and see 3 land and shuffle and draw random shit. He plays turn 2 Blood Moon and that is that. I die to a whatever random guy he musters shortly after.
Game 2: This one went very long, but I Force his early disruption. He then lands a SoFI and follows it up with a Morph and equip the next turn. I play Top, then Plow his Morph when he swings. He plays another Morph and equips again. I Top into another Plow. I StP his guy again, and he plays a Magus and equips. I Top and Draw a Ponder for my turn. I Ponder. What do you think the third card is? Of course, its the 3rd Plow in a row :). I Sword the Magus on attack, and he is out of threats. We play draw go for a couple turns and he drops Trinisphere (I don't care I have 6 lands out) and I draw BEB, Force, etc to stop his stuff. He tries a Pit Dragon, but it gets BEBed. Then I finally draw Goyf and play it. I keep mana open for Force at all times and Goyf kills him like 6 turns later as he doesn't draw anything relevant.
Game 3: He gets a really fast start and gets hellbent Dragon and Spirit Guide to my Goyf. I need to find removal fast and the Dragon domes me for 8. I am at 8 and draw Flooded Strand to go with the Force in my hand. I lose. The top cards of my deck are, in order, StP, BEB, Goyf. Obviously.
I split 3rd/4th and take home some Taigas that the 2nd place person didn't want. Not bad.
Props:
-Kevin for having kickass tourneys of course
-Pete for getting second with his Extended deck. Lol
-Me for being a fucking lucksack
-O. Ring for being amazing
Slops:
-Pat for being addicted to the Crack Machine. You need CAA (Crackaholics Anonymous)
-Bryan for 3-0-1 ing then losing two straight rounds to be out of contention.
-Louis for playing my new Landstill list, owning Goblins in the first round and then failing miserably after playing the deck's worst matchup, Goyf Sligh, in second two matches.