PDA

View Full Version : [Report] 3rd @ Hadley Volcanic Tourney - White Thresh



TrialByFire
01-20-2008, 05:43 AM
I played my White Threshold list to a third place split at Hadley today. Overall I like the decklist but have a few changes after playing today. Here is the original decklist:


// Lands
4 Tundra
1 Forest
4 Tropical Island
3 Windswept Heath
3 Flooded Strand
2 Island
1 Plains

// Creatures
2 Mystic Enforcer
4 Nimble Mongoose
4 Tarmogoyf

// Spells
1 Oblivion Ring
4 Swords to Plowshares
4 Counterbalance
3 Sensei's Divining Top
2 Stifle
3 Spell Snare
4 Force of Will
4 Brainstorm
4 Ponder
3 Daze

// Sideboard
SB: 3 Krosan Grip
SB: 3 Blue Elemental Blast
SB: 3 Threads of Disloyalty
SB: 2 Engineered Explosives
SB: 4 Meddling Mage

After today I changed:

MD:
-2 Stifle
-1 Tundra
-1 Tropical Island
+1 Flooded Strand
+1 Windswept Heath
+1 Snare
+1 Explosives

-1 SB Explosives
+1 SB B.E.B.

BEBs were amazing and I never used Stifle except once to Stifle a Lackey trigger.


The Tourney was 6 rounds then cut to Top 8 with 36 people.

Round 1
Matt with Goblins splash green

Game 1: He is on the play. He gets turn 1 Vial I have no Force of Will. Things go downhill from there as he gets triple Piledriver, Warchief, Ringleader, and Siege Gang. He cycles to kill a 4/5 Goyf and swings for the win.

I Board out Enforcers and Counterbalance for BEBs and Grips.

Game 2: No Aether Vials for him. I play a Goyf on turn 2 then Daze his Piledriver. Snares, BEBs and StP keep his men off the table and after Forcing a Ringleader, Goyf finally does him in.

Game 3: This was a good game. He has first turn Lackey and I have no Force. Sad face. But I rip BEB off the top like a champ and kill it. His next play gets Dazed (Chalice for 1 I think). Then I get Top and start searching for beaters. I find a Goyf next turn after Spell Snaring a Piledriver. Then I find a Goose. He is trying to mise blockers as he is on 8 life and I have a 5/6 Goyf and a threshed Goose, and the round time is called. He makes men, they block. He makes two more men, they block. On turn 4 he makes a Matron and gets Fanatic and plays it. I EOT BEB Fanatic, then untap and O-Ring his Matron and attack for exactly lethal. What a way to start the day.

Matches 1-0, Games 2-1

Round 2
Andrew Maag (Magler) playing Ichorid

Game 1: He is on the play. He apparently get a really shitty hand because he doesn't do anything till turn 5 when he plays a City of Brass and Breakthroughs for 0. Counterbalance stops that. I have Goyf and am beating for 4. He Breakthroughs again for 1 this time. I have Spell Snare. He Breakthroughs again for two. I Force it and swing for the win.

Board out Enforcers, a Counterbalance, Stifles and and O-ring for 4 Mages and 2 Explosives.

Game 2: He starts dredging, I get double Mage on Dread Return. I am beating with two Goyfs and 3 non threshed Geese. He gets triple Bridge and all 4 Narcomoebas early. I never see Explosives and am eventually run over by Zombies.

Game 3: I start the game with both Explosives in my hand, but I decide to not run them out there to try and surprise him. Then on turn 3, he drops FUCKING CHALICE FOR 0. OWNED. Triple Ichorids (I StP 2 of them), and 4 Bridges make short work of me as I can't find Goyf to stem the bleeding.

Matches 1-1, Games 3-3

Round 3
Caleb (MadManiac42) playing MonoWhite Stax

Game 1: He is on the play. He plays Turn 1 Trinishpere, I Force it. He plays Chalice for 1 and it gets Spell Snared. I run a Goyf out and it gets O-Ringed. He plays a Ghostly Prison and a Crucible before I find another Goyf. Then he play another Ghostly Prison and starts killing my non-basics. I have all my basics out at this point and he plays a THIRD prison. I cannot make more than 4 mana so I can't attack. I concede.

Sideboard an Enforcer, and Counterbalances for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives

Game 2: I am on the play and he doesn't find any Wastelands. I Force Trinishpere and Chalice again. I tap out for Goyf on turn 3 (missed land drop) and he untaps and plays Diamond, Geddon with Ghostly Prison out. I have 1 card in hand. It is not a Daze. Shitty. But apparently not as I rip two lands off the top like a champ and beat him to death with Goyf as he draws no mana sources in the next 5 turns.

Game 3: He mulls and keeps his six. He plays Diamond pitching Plains, Diamond pitching Plains, Ghost Quarter, Crucible and it sticks. He now has no hand. I play turn 3 Grip on his Crucible, and counter a Chalice and another Crucible and StP his Magus. I beat him with Goyf for the win.

Matches 2-1, Games 5-4

Round 4
Pete Meyer (PhaerimmArchlord) Playing Extended Doran.dec with Duals

Game 1: I keep an opener of land, land, 3x Goyf, Ponder, Stifle. He is on the play. He plays turn 1 Treetop Village. I play Ponder and find Force. Then he plays turn 2 Urborg, Duress taking Force. I comment on how nasty Therapy would have been. Then he taps Treetop for black (fuck Urborg) and Therapies me for the 3 Goyfs. Bastard. Can't really recover from that shit.

Sideboard out Enforcers and a Stifle for Threads

Game 2: I set up Turn 2 Countertop, and he is stuck on two lands. I find Threads and keep it on top. It counters a Vindicate next turn. I get a Goyf. Then he plays a Bob and I have no counter or removal. I say fuck it and steal that shit with Threads. He doesn't kill it and Bob and Goyf get in for 6 a turn and I StP a Doran on my way to winning.

Game 3: I get CounterTop, but Balance gets Vindicated. Then I Brainstorm into double Goyf and drop them. He draws nothing but land the next turns and dies.

Matches 3-1, Games 7-5

Round 5
Ben Lukas (ForceofWill) Playing GRW Eternal Garden/Loam kind of pile of junk

Game 1: He is on the play. He casts turn 1 Burning Wish for Loam. He plays it turn two and it gets Snared. I set up Countertop. He makes a misplay and gets owned by Counterbalance. I keep a two cost on top with Top so no Loaming. I get double Goyf and he finds a Confinement with 1 card in hand and Squee in the grave. I think, then tell him I have the O-Ring in the main and will draw cards till I find it. He concedes, and I show him it since he asked me to. It was 3 cards down.

SB out Enforcers, Stifle and and an StP for 3 Grip and 2 Explosives.

Game 2: He resolves Gamble and gets Maze and gets the Loaming going. I really have no chance this game as he gets Tabernacle, Waste-lock (only drew 1 basic and no fetches) and thats enough so I can't come back. He beats with manlands till I die.

I sideboard out more stuff for 4 Mages (forgot exactly what)

Game 3: I keep a creature heavy hand and hope to out aggro him. He gets Gamble into Maze of Ith. I have Mage on Loam. Then he plays Humility. He Loams away and gets Wastelands and Factories going. I put Grip on top with Top to draw it the next turn. I tap my only Island the turn before to play Goyf and keep Plains up to StP his Factory. Instead he Devastaing Dreams for 3 wiping my board and I have Spell Snare in hand but no blue. Pretty good.

Matches 3-2, Games 8-7

Round 6
Braves54321, playing Goyf Sligh

Game 1: This matchup is very in my favor, and I keep a hand containing CB and Top. Prety good. I set that up, then end up getting the beats on with TWO unthreshed Enforcers. He can't resolve anything through the lock and they finish him with help from a Goyf.

Sideboard out an Enforcer and Stifles for 3 BEB

Game 2: He mulls to 6 has turn 1 Cursed Scroll and turn 2 Goyf. I have the Force and a Spell Snare for them. I get double Goyf and Counterbalance, and he can't really do much.

Matches 4-2, Games 10-7

I am 7th place going into top 8.

Quarterfinals
Afro playing Goblins splash black

Game 1: He is on the play. I didn't win many die rolls today. He gets turn 1 Vial and I don't have Force. You know how that goes.

Sideboarded the same as the last Gobs match

Game 2: He gets turn 1 Lackey and that gets BEBed. Turn 2 Chalice for 1 gets Snared. I tap out for Goyf. He plays an Aether Vial. It resolves. He Vials in a Matron to block and gets Warchief. Then he Vials in Warchief on his turn and play Ringleader revealing Driver, Siege Gang, and Ringleader. Things are not looking so good. I EOT see Grip with Top, so I BEB his Warchief, then untap and cast Grip on his Vial. His board is now double Port and Mountain. Goyf gets in, and he concedes on the next turn.

Game 3: He mulls to 5 and I go to 6. His turn 1 is Mountain, Fanatic. I play a Ponder and see Goyf. He misses a land drop and attacks. I untap and play Goyf. He finds a land and plays Jitte. So I swing in with Goyf he doesn't block. Then I play Top with two mana untapped. He goes to equip Fanatic and I StP it. I smash again. He plays a Lackey. I smash again. He goes to equip and I StP the Lackey. His mull to 5, land screw and tempo loss are enough, and he succumbs to Goyf.

Semifinals
Ross Merriam (theross) playing Dragon Stompy

Game 1: He wins the die roll (again) and says Mountain, go. I did not know what he was playing, so crack my only fetch for Trop (with Tundra in hand) for Ponder and see 3 land and shuffle and draw random shit. He plays turn 2 Blood Moon and that is that. I die to a whatever random guy he musters shortly after.

Game 2: This one went very long, but I Force his early disruption. He then lands a SoFI and follows it up with a Morph and equip the next turn. I play Top, then Plow his Morph when he swings. He plays another Morph and equips again. I Top into another Plow. I StP his guy again, and he plays a Magus and equips. I Top and Draw a Ponder for my turn. I Ponder. What do you think the third card is? Of course, its the 3rd Plow in a row :). I Sword the Magus on attack, and he is out of threats. We play draw go for a couple turns and he drops Trinisphere (I don't care I have 6 lands out) and I draw BEB, Force, etc to stop his stuff. He tries a Pit Dragon, but it gets BEBed. Then I finally draw Goyf and play it. I keep mana open for Force at all times and Goyf kills him like 6 turns later as he doesn't draw anything relevant.

Game 3: He gets a really fast start and gets hellbent Dragon and Spirit Guide to my Goyf. I need to find removal fast and the Dragon domes me for 8. I am at 8 and draw Flooded Strand to go with the Force in my hand. I lose. The top cards of my deck are, in order, StP, BEB, Goyf. Obviously.

I split 3rd/4th and take home some Taigas that the 2nd place person didn't want. Not bad.

Props:
-Kevin for having kickass tourneys of course
-Pete for getting second with his Extended deck. Lol
-Me for being a fucking lucksack
-O. Ring for being amazing

Slops:
-Pat for being addicted to the Crack Machine. You need CAA (Crackaholics Anonymous)
-Bryan for 3-0-1 ing then losing two straight rounds to be out of contention.
-Louis for playing my new Landstill list, owning Goblins in the first round and then failing miserably after playing the deck's worst matchup, Goyf Sligh, in second two matches.

kabal
01-20-2008, 10:31 AM
Did you miss Predict's card advantage?

Did you ever have a hard time reaching Threshold? I counted 6 fetches, no Predict and abundance (18) of permanents.

You mentioned that Stifle was pretty underwhelming, but you played Goblins twice and Stifle is extremely good in that MU. Much more that spell snare.

TrialByFire
01-20-2008, 12:19 PM
No I did not miss any other cantrips card advantage. Usually I was countering so many things that I had Threshold by the midgame. But against decks like Ichorid it doesn;t really happen. But thats fine with me. I had it when it mattered today. As for Stifle, I played it exactly once all day (stifling the Lackey in my report), and drew it maybe 3 or 4 times. The other times I drew it it was too late to Stifle a fetch and it had no other relevance to the matchup. So it usually got pitched to Force/sat in my hand doing nothing. I'd rather have another thing that can kill permamants. And Spell Snare was amazing in every matchup except Ichorid (Obv.) Against Gobins it countered multiple Piledrivers, a couple Chalices for 1 and a Jitte. Sounds good to me.

Afro
01-20-2008, 02:02 PM
Nice report. Our games in top8 were very tight and enjoyable. Sucks the last one had to be a total wash with the mull to 5 into land screw. Also the person who you played from the Albany crew was Braves54321. Hope to see you at the next one.

J.V.
01-20-2008, 04:17 PM
Nice report, just thought I'd add that Andy's source name is Maagler. Also the Chalices were my suggestion on the car ride to Hadley :tongue:

TrialByFire
01-21-2008, 02:23 AM
Cool thanks and yes I had way to many close calls for one day against Goblins. See you guys next month.

theross
01-22-2008, 04:19 PM
Hey, nice report, I was your semifinals opponent. That second game was quite a marathon. Congrats on the finish.

TrialByFire
01-22-2008, 05:31 PM
Thanks you also. Also just in general, I also added the 4th Heath and the 4th Strand. Shuffle effects are good, they help to get Thresh faster, and they help fetch the basics. I cut one of each dual for them. I will update original post.

Oh and congrats on the finish Ross. Chalice for 1: Still good! :tongue:

Rehallek
01-26-2008, 09:01 PM
Look Matt it's not my fault the crack machine is addictive. But I can still quit anytime I choose too, but that is my choice.