Jander78
05-20-2008, 10:33 PM
This came up in a tournament and while I was sure I was right, I let it slide since no one else at the tournament knew the correct ruling and there was no judge to confirm with. So I'm posting this for my own sanity and to inform those that thought otherwise.
Here's the situation:
Me: Cast Red Elemental Blast targeting Sea Drake already in play.
Opponent: Divert targeting Red Elemental Blast changing the target to Divert.
I explained that ReB is a modal spell and once the mode is chosen ("Permanent" or "Spell" chosen upon anouncement of the spell) it can not be changed. Only the target could be changed and there wasn't any other blue permanents in play.
Q: I have Ophidian in play and I cast Morphling. In response my opponent plays Red Elemental Blast targetting my Morphling on the stack. Can I play Misdirection, making the Red Elemental Blast target my Ophidian?
A: No. Red Elemental Blast is a modal spell. You can change the target of Red Elemental Blast with Misdirection, but you cannot change its mode. In other words, you can make this Blast target another blue spell [I suggest the Misdirection that is currently resolving... -Seamus], but you can't make it target a blue permanent.
Here's the situation:
Me: Cast Red Elemental Blast targeting Sea Drake already in play.
Opponent: Divert targeting Red Elemental Blast changing the target to Divert.
I explained that ReB is a modal spell and once the mode is chosen ("Permanent" or "Spell" chosen upon anouncement of the spell) it can not be changed. Only the target could be changed and there wasn't any other blue permanents in play.
Q: I have Ophidian in play and I cast Morphling. In response my opponent plays Red Elemental Blast targetting my Morphling on the stack. Can I play Misdirection, making the Red Elemental Blast target my Ophidian?
A: No. Red Elemental Blast is a modal spell. You can change the target of Red Elemental Blast with Misdirection, but you cannot change its mode. In other words, you can make this Blast target another blue spell [I suggest the Misdirection that is currently resolving... -Seamus], but you can't make it target a blue permanent.