Originally Posted by
Infinitium
Keeping to fiddle around with Living Wish. The card really is quite diverse and has saved my ass in a number of situations and singlehandedly beats any and all hatecards game 1 save Humility (and that's only until they print something with Channeling/Cycling Enchantment removal), so I went ahead and cut a Messenger to adda 3rd copy main (moving the Messenger to the side in lieu of Viridian Shaman). Paying 1G for Cradle or Faerie, 1GG for the 6th Symbiote or 3GGG for Sylvan Messenger or Viridian Zealot are all perfectly viable at different stages of the game (especially as tutoring up Symbiote still is essentially card advantage at a negative mana cost with Priest/Archdruid out), making it another bomb to complement the draw engines.
The difference between 15 and 17 mana for Emrakul is neglible (and I get to play 3 virtual copies to boot without the hassle of actually drawing it), and having access to it without bogging down the main is strangely convenient; Emrakul beats Show and Tell, Emrakul beats damage prevention, Emrakul beats my largely unfounded fears that my opponent is coy enough to play enchantment on Crossroads removal into next turn sweeper. Hell, in conjunction with Masticore Emrakul even beats infinite life combos by singlehandidly locking them out of the game and decking them (combo out, Emrakul, blow up world, play masticore, discard down, kill off as many Elves as I please, then spend 30 mana to burn Emrakul to death (killing Masticore itself in response to avoid StP) and shuffle my gy into my library only to combo out again next turn - rinse and repeat). Also it can be sided in against milling combo decks.
Masticore is there to beat Peacekeeper and Fortune Thief, as well as being a decent ace in the sleeve against tribal decks that might or may not pack Perish/Plague. Witness is overall quite redundant as a card engine with access to Messenger, but does recycly Glimpse and Grip against decks running sweepers and counters (where the combo win is safer when possible).
Is it better than Survival? I think so. It's just more diverse, more mana efficient, doesn't necessitate running Taigas, isn't vulnerable to GYhate and allows me to hold up on running silver bullets maindecked. It doesn't win the game singlehandedly off an empty board given time like survival can however (especially against decks running obnoxious amounts of removal). Giving up half the the sideboard isn't much of an issue; it's mainly for Krosan Grip and GYhate anyhow (even in my non-Wish builds), and unless you really want to commit 7 spots to the combo matchup it's probably better not to side in most matchups anyhow what with how tight the maindeck is. I somewhat miss Needle, but overall it's an improvement in testing.