WotC Presents: You Make the Card 4

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Barook

How about this?

"Name" :b::b::b:
Enchantment
Whenever a card is put into an opponent's graveyard from anywhere, you may draw a card.
At the beginning of your end step, discard your hand.

---

I fear this one isn't worth the mana because it does nothing on it's own. I feel this is a worse card than Mystic Remora fighting in matchups which burn a lot of Sorceries and instants. Even questionable vs. Dredge and reanimator due to the cost.

Thinking of that idea of "Profit from dumping cards" i would be interested in a Black Version of Greater Goods (without the sac obviously):

"Whenever a creature you Control is put into a graveyard, draw cards equal to it's power."

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by AllIsDust

Doesn't this just go infinite with geralf's messenger while being very very good with gravecrawler or any undying goon? any undying dude just makes this bargain

---

It does, but does that make it necessarily too overpowered? How many combo decks want Geralf's Messenger? It might be playable in the way old Necro was with black aggro though.

I'm guessing that like 40% of the submissions will be Necro variants so I'd steer clear unless you have an absolutely amazing idea for it.

Personally I want to see a Necro+Form of the Dragon hybrid.

Demonform anyone?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by (nameless one)

Personally I want to see a Necro+Form of the Dragon hybrid.

Demonform anyone?

---

That would be pretty cool. Any suggestions?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nihil Credo

I'm guessing that like 40% of the submissions will be Necro variants so I'd steer clear unless you have an absolutely amazing idea for it.

---

I'd put it at 50 but yeah.

I'll be submitting Atropotence, everyone get ready to vote for it.

Underworld Scroll
BBB
Enchantment
Pay X life, sacrifice ~this~: Draw X cards. Play this ability only during your end step.

A variation on Necrologia. This might be far too powerful, I'm not entirely sure. Maybe put a cap on X, e.g. 'X can be no larger than 4'.

Form of the Demon :3::b::b::b::b:
Enchantment
When Form of the Demon enters the battlefield, put an enchantment token named Circle onto the battlefield.
As long as you control a Circle, you don't lose the game for having zero or less life due to an ability.
At the beginning of your draw step. draw five cards and lose five life.
Creatures without flying can't attack you.

I made one I thought was cool


1B

Reverse-Necro

When Reverse -Necro Comes into play choose target player.

Target player discards his or her hand at end of turn.

You lose 1 life for every card discarded this way.


I can actually see a few very good uses for it.

This was my proposal

Hymn to Serenity
BBB
Whenever an opponent discards a card you may look at that player's hand.
You may discard a non land, non creature card from their hand.
If you do, discard a card.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Magic Fanatic

I made one I thought was cool


1B

Reverse-Necro

When Reverse -Necro Comes into play choose target player.

Target player discards his or her hand at end of turn.

You lose 1 life for every card discarded this way.


I can actually see a few very good uses for it.

---

1B imba Mindtwist ... very balanced ... not

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lemnear

1B imba Mindtwist ... very balanced ... not

---

Yeah wtf? Oh no I lost 7 life and you are topdecking on turn 1! Lol.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Nihil Credo

I'm guessing that like 40% of the submissions will be Necro variants so I'd steer clear unless you have an absolutely amazing idea for it.

---

Guess that means I'm in good company. Just because it's going to be popular doesn't mean it's not worth thinking about.
Big precedents for black global enchantments:
- Necro variants
- Phyrexian Arena variants
- Underworld Dreams variants
Less common:
- token produces (e.g. Bitterblossom, Sarcomancy, Breeding Pit)
- Reanimation (Diabolic Servitude)
- discarding (Bottomless Pit, Cabal Shrine)
- killing stuff (Grave Pact, Pestilence, Fevered Convulsions)

My first take on the Demon Form enchantment:

Demonic Ascension :4::b::b::b::b:
Enchantment
You may pay 8 life and sacrifice three black creatures rather than pay Demonic Ascension’s mana cost.

At the beginning of your upkeep, your life becomes 5, each opponent loses 5 life and each player sacrifices a creature.

Creatures without flying can’t attack you.

Okay so it's global. ...lame, fun, broken? Not tournament friendly?


Deviant Oppression :b::b:

Enchantment

Players can not win the game.

Pay 13 life: Sacrifice Deviant Oppression (any player may use this ability)

If players can not win the game, players can still lose the game, I believe. This card would he horrible for what it would do to tournaments. Imagine casting it when bother players are below 14 life and have no way to gain life or remove enchantments. Count cards in libraries, see who would deck out first o_0

It's worse than that. In a tournament, if an opponent loses the game, you would win the game; however, as this card prevents you from winning, the game ends in a tie. If you lose the game, the enchantment disappears, so your opponent wins the game as usual. In sum, a terrible card that only serves to shoot yourself on the foot.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Chikenbok

This was my proposal

Hymn to Serenity
BBB
Whenever an opponent discards a card you may look at that player's hand.
You may discard a non land, non creature card from their hand.
If you do, discard a card.

---

Yawn. I can't see playing that for 0 mana, let alone 3. So I can go down a card and 3 mana to trade cards with someone else, if I hit them with a discadd spell on turn 4 or later, long after most discard spells stop being useful.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Lemnear

I fear this one isn't worth the mana because it does nothing on it's own. I feel this is a worse card than Mystic Remora fighting in matchups which burn a lot of Sorceries and instants. Even questionable vs. Dredge and reanimator due to the cost.

Thinking of that idea of "Profit from dumping cards" i would be interested in a Black Version of Greater Goods (without the sac obviously):

"Whenever a creature you Control is put into a graveyard, draw cards equal to it's power."

---

No, no. I totally want to see his card make it. I want to be able to windmill slam Rest in Peace and win!

What about something original for a change


BB
You can t play lands
You choose the order in which spells and abilities resolve on the stack
"Growth or raw power, you can t have it all"


A nightmare i know :)