Originally Posted by
Warden
I've been away for a while. Not gonna lie though, this list looks fun as shit.
3 questions for you
1) Tireless Tracker's inclusion?
2) Removal that compliments 2 Decay, 3 Deed?
3) 4 Sneak Attacks vs 3?
1. I am biased against Tireless Tracker because from my experiences, he didn't contribute much. I think decks that abuse the land-dropping gameplan make him work. For Nic Fit (and especially Sneak-Fit), I can't help but think you're better off replacing him outright. Several months ago when Sneak-Fit was under the radar, some of the Nic Fit players ran Sidisi (who is downright stupid OP off a Sneak activation). Maybe Sidisi replaces Tracker, since you can setup the kill shot then and there OR just tutor for [insert answer to current board-state]. Maybe Tracker is replaced in the MD by Meren? Perhaps you can strategically go sideways by including 1x Magus of the Moon. Hear me out on this. Our meta hasn't changed (from the news and decklists I see). Magus is capable of just auto-winning against highly developed 3 and 4 colored decks. It also does damage against shit like Death and Taxes that benefit from extensive non-basics (port, wastes, karakas, cavern). On a side note, Magus can be "tutored" by Bellower he isn't drawn/found naturally.
2. I went back several pages for some points about L. Bolt vs Pfires + Grove. I'd love to hear others discuss how you compliment what I believe is a "lock" in 2 Decay/3 Deed. Pfires is SO goddamn grindy but did the card lose steam with 2017 fast aggro decks? Does it stop pyromancer and mentor? Perhaps 3x Sudden Demise (another wiper that eats our own Vets for R+1)? Demise scales very well over the course of the game but is less grindy than Pfires. On the other hand, a Demise for x=2 kills ~95% of creatures you'll see including TNN, a table of DnT/Maverick, multiple Delvers, a table of elves, etc. Going red is hedging your inevitable loss against a 20/20 Marit token, so that's a sunk cost. Both Pfires and Demise struggle against delve creatures like Anglur, etc.
Another idea is 0 red removal. Black has plenty of options to take care of business -- especially with the recent sets.
3. Do you feel you need 4 Sneaks or can you get away with 3? I ask because there's no way to brainstorm excess ones out of your hand and/or ponder-shuffle them away.