This also counts for
Green Sun's Zenith, yet Zenith has been the core of this deck for a long time.
Besides, Oath can be cast on turn one, curving nicely into Thalia (or any other hate bear you might find with it).
Oath of Nissa should be viewed as a Ponder for Maverick. I think it should fot the deck really nicely. Right now I am trying out a list with 3-4x Oath, 3x Zenith and 0x
Dryad Arbor, since Zenith->Arbor is our saddest turn one play anyway, and drawing Arbor naturally is usually just bad.
Comparing Oath of Nissa to
Sylvan Library makes sense, so let's do that.
Here are the pro's & con's for each card, as I see them. (Be sure to suggest additions!)
Oath of Nissa:
+ Cheaper (G)
+ Immidiate effect when you cast it
+ Replaces itself (almost guaranteed in this deck)
(+ Makes it easy to splash off colour planeswalkers)
- No card advantage
- No continuous card selection
Sylvan Library:
+ Card advantage against control decks (when C/A matters)
+ Continuous card selection
- More expensive to cast (1G)
- No immidiate effect when cast
- Doesn't replace itself when low on life
So the cards do pretty different things for us. Oath of Nissa seems to be best when cast early. It's cheap and has immidiate effect, so we can use it to improve our early game. This is important against Combo and aggressive decks, since we need our early game to be optimal to not lose games against them. Against control decks we are allowed more time to build up and we lose to bombs and card advantage engines, so Sylvan Library has more impact in those matchups. Oath of Nissa is still a good card there, just not as good.
But... Oath of Nissa helps us splash off colour planeswalkers. I mentioned this on a side note in my pro's and con's analysis, since most won't see any importance in this feature, yet think about it: who would ever destroy an Oath? It doesn't really do anything. Except for allowing me to find and then easily cast
Kiora, Master of the Depths or
Liliana of the Veil. Cards like these can be great assets in grindy games. If we want to play planeswalkers anyway, in an effort to improve our game against control decks, the impact Oath of Nissa can make will improve.
I'm not trying to say we should all play Oath, but it's a VERY interesting option. :smile: