Originally Posted by
Worldslayer
Not that a comment that short really merits response, but fuck it, I'm feeling froggy.
1) Jin Gitaxias is a smaller body for four more mana. Though the actual mana cost is usually irrelevant, I have casted Sire fairly regularly. Four life is also four life.
2) Jin is actually much more vulnerable than Sire in a format where REB and the like are borderline maindeckable cards.
3) Karakas. If you're playing reanimator and have two similar creatures, one of which is legendary, you opt for the nonlegendary. The less Karakas irritates you game 1, the better. Since Sire is actually my game 1 go to against Karakas decks, I'd prefer him to not be legendary and bounced off the top.
Jin hasn't been playable since Griselbrand, and was questionable before that.