Second vote is between lands and enchantments since they were extremely close to each other.
Voted for enchantment since they provide more interesting design space than lands.
Printable View
Second vote is between lands and enchantments since they were extremely close to each other.
Voted for enchantment since they provide more interesting design space than lands.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bilb_o
The dream is dead. No cycle for us.
On the other hand, a Stony Silence for land's non-mana abilities, here we go!
So WotC makes a poll, fuck it up so People can vote multiple Times which takes a 3rd grader to find out about that, question their own official result, create a second poll with the same technical issue asking for the "same" question and people in this forum really flame me, if I roast the idiots of this company at every opportunity for such things? Are these the people you expect will create a good Legacy-playable Card? Seriously?
Tbh at the end I really had expected they threw "creatures" in the second poll too, because ... creatures. I'm rather suprised they didn't
Have to disagree. The color/power limitation is a thing with enchantress around. I, again, voted for lands which will enter EDH if not good enough for Legacy (or EDH tailormade, urg) Moreover, WotC is clueless about the cardtype. I argue for years for a clean Split between artifact effects and enchantments so the cardtype makes Sense.Quote:
Originally Posted by Barook
Artifacts: global effects and repeatable effects with activation cost
Enchantments: repeating, triggering, free effects (Phyrexian Arena, Mystic remora) game/rule altering effects (humility, glorios Anthem)
I really wouldn't mind that, although it could be spiced up a bit with another effect.Quote:
Originally Posted by (nameless one)
Stony Silence, Null Rod and Cursed Totem shut down everything including mana abilities. Since you can't do that with lands, it would be nice to have some bonus.
Except Wizards doesn't care about Enchantress.Quote:
Originally Posted by Lemnear
Voted for Land because I want to play with Crop Rotations at some point...,
Number of people registered as one of the guilds on the planeswalker points page since it went live: 84103
Number of people who voted in the poll last week: 88713
Number of people who usually vote in WotC's polls: 2000-20000 (example, example, example)
I can say that I've voted at least 5 times for Instant/Sorcery from different browsers, thought about writing a script to stir things up but decided to stay on the ethical side and just make a post about it in the forums. No number provided by Wizards (including the number of posters) is going to convince me.
POST /Handlers/PollService.ashx
Host: www.wizards.com
pollparamdescrip1=Enchantment&pollparamdescrip2=Land&pollparamyn=2&pollparampollname=ymtc_20130318_poll1&pollparamnumoptions=2&pollparam=Submit
Works without cookies.
So, Land or Enchantment, huh?
That has potential.
I want a land with some kind of sweet sacrifice ability. Needs to be abused with Loam/Crucible.
Maybe it taps for a color of a permanent that you control. Maybe just colorless.
1 mana and tap and sacrifice, do stuff...
I cant think of a fun ability to slap on something like this... Petrified Field already gets back lands... Buried Ruin gets artifacts back... Maybe a snapcaster mage land? Give a spell flashback? Or maybe give a dude unearth?
So this is where we push for "Land - Plains Island Swamp Mountain Forest" right?
Lol.Quote:
Originally Posted by majikal
Land- Plains Island Swamp Mountain Forest
When ~ Taps for mana, add a mana of any color to your mana pool.
Sacrifice ~; Add 2 mana of any color to your mana pool.
Am I doing this right?
You forgot to add Basic as a type.Quote:
Originally Posted by Megadeus
We gotta make the card balanced man. c'mon be realistic :pQuote:
Originally Posted by (nameless one)
How about this:
Unnamed Card
Basic Land- Island
Tap ~ to add one blue mana to your mana pool.
Seems pretty OP to me.
Fetchable - CheckQuote:
Originally Posted by Megadeus
Rainbow Mana - Check
Mana Boost during Comboturn - Check
A TPS' players wet dream
I would be completely satisfied with the next incarnations of Volrath's Stronghold/Academy Ruins. A Fetchable, Legendary Rainbow Land would however be a dream
Yeah. Bryant Cook would be all over this card...Quote:
Originally Posted by Lemnear
I would rather someone vote who actually cares multiple times over Maro's "dudes must turn sideaways - no fun allowed!" followers.Quote:
Originally Posted by bilb_o
Legendary Land
Tap- Add R to mana pool.
Tap- Sacrifice land, target permanent with mana cost 8 or greater deals damage to its owner equal to the converted mana cost of target permanent.
Lol. Seems interesting but incredibly narrow (not to mention completely useless for the most part in standard...)Quote:
Originally Posted by joemauer
Funny. I feel as if Standard is completely useless at the moment.Quote:
Originally Posted by Megadeus