Printable View
Hey guys,
So I messed up. After testing Jund for a really long time I went to the SCG LA side event on Saturday, went 1-3 in the grinder (beat death and taxes, lost to grixis delver, lost to dredge, lost to BG loam pox), and then I panicked at the last second the night before the big event and switched to Punishing Nic Fit. Needless to say, it didn't go well. Wish I had a tournament report but I don't.
What? We were all depending on you! What am I supposed to do at the next FNM?!
(lol, only joking :-)
That's so funny. I didn't know you were Ironclad.Quote:
Originally Posted by ironclad8690
So I took Punishing Jund after playing Dark Maverick for years as a Meta call and was very much expecting a heavy Delver/Miracles/Elves meta. I ended with a 6-2 finish to 16th place with $100.00 and a playmat for my efforts. It was heavy, heavy combo, with my losses being first round Omnitell and fourth round ANT. I imported put 2 Scavenging Ooze in my main (from maverick) as a meta call because he is very good against Goyf, Goose, Deathrite, Punishing Fire, Keeping decks off delve, etc. I went down a goyf, because he is essentially replacing the goyf and went down on a Lily, because I feel 4 is too much. I played Omni in the final round and won due to Slaughter Games, so that is a definite keep. I last minute replaced Chains with it, but after my poor showing against Storm, I am putting it back in. I will probably replace Null Rod with it, because I feel pithing needle already does a lot of what Null Rod does, but we are already so heavily favored again equipment decks it really not necessary. Although, I'm not sure how the MUD match-up is and I brought it in-case I ran into that deck (which I didn't of course). All in All I am really happy with the deck and will probably be playing it for a while. I feel like we are weaker to Storm (obvisously) than Maverick, but also graveyard based strategies. Which was another reason why I am included 2 Scooze. This is definitely a first step in tweaking the deck to my fancy, but I thought I would share. Below is my list:
http://sales.starcitygames.com//deck...p?DeckID=80345
I was just thinking. Null Rod keeps storm from using L.E.D. and Petal. So it maybe better than pithing needle. The only thing I can see pithing needle being better is against Sneak Attack. How is our MUD matchup? I'm not sure. What are your thoughts?
Why did you cut down on the lightning bolts?Quote:
Originally Posted by DudeItsCorey
Great job! I am still crying over ONE Lightning Bolt, but congratulations :)
Null Rod is pretty bonkers vs. Storm. Great idea.
Between 4 Punishing Fires, 4 Abrupt Decays, 3 Lilianas I felt I had removal covered. I wasn't even going to include it until I was told to have a miser as a "extra reach" contingency. I really don't know what else I would cut to add more.Quote:
Originally Posted by skyout
I had a conversation with someone over Lightning Bolt. The consensus is that it's in Punishing Jund to be a turn one removal against Delver. The problem is that most delver decks run daze, so if you're on the play (where it would be relevant) if you're just running it into Daze and you're going to have a bad time. Now with Abrupt decay being uncounterable, Turn 1 thoughtseize to remove the daze (or eat it), or if you're on the play, turn 1 Deathrite into turn 2 punishing fire (having 1 extra mana with Deathrite) you're still getting the same outcome. You may take 1 or 3 damage, but one swing from Delver isn't going to kill me.
With Elves, which is another reason to run 1 drop removal, I'm boarding into Golgari Charms and Toxic Deluge, so I'm not too worried about it.
I think that conversation was with me lol.Quote:
Originally Posted by DudeItsCorey
Yeah, the thing I like about lightning bolt is that it makes it easier to play around daze in the event that you don't have Abrupt Decay (corner case, but still). I have gotten punishing fire dazed so many times that after a while I just wanted more ways to not worry about that. Also, Thalia tax is annoying to me vs D&T and Maverick (3 mana punishing fire makes me wanna puke).
I lowered my bolt count for a tournament one time, and D&T messed me up pretty bad. Like flat out pounded the dog shit out of me, no answer to T1 Mom + Thalia taxing my ass. I couldn't handle all the critters. Plus Serra Avenger is a 3/3 which is relevant. So it might be because I'm traumatized lol, but I will never trim the bolt count in Jund EVER again.
Funny, I found D&T to be one of our best match-ups. This is why Toxic Deluge is better than Engineered Plague. Best Panic/Reset button made in black. Under Gaddock Teeg and can hit things like Progenitus, Emerkul, Blightsteel, etc. Also, Golgari Charm does work against D&T. Also, with mother of runes I will end step Punishing Fire and then on my main phase punishing fire Mom. Punishing fire, to me, seems like the best anti-mom card out there. Also, the -x/-x sweepers mentioned above.Quote:
Originally Posted by jake556
This was Pre-Deluge, and paying at least 5-7 mana to kill mom doesn't give me a good feeling in the face of Wasteland, Thaila, Vial etc...Quote:
Originally Posted by DudeItsCorey
This is not a deck that struggles with DnT. I am pretty sure the first sweeper or Punishing Fire without a Rest in Peace (and even then) is pretty game.
I was rarely ever able to fit in a Toxic Deluge (sadly). The card is fun.
So I'm new to this deck ,coming from elves, and I'm wondering what the sideboard plan with reb/Pyro is. If they cone in do the bbe's come out? Do they come in agent blue bases combo and tnn decks only?
You usually want them against delver decks as more 1 mana answers to delver (usually you can take out some hymns or thoughtseizes vs them), as well as vs tnn decks and shardless. Vs any combo deck with brainstorm it is more valuable than p fire or abrupt decay, so you dont need to worry about eating up extra slots.Quote:
Originally Posted by jim111589
I want to follow this up with how good it is against combo decks. Being able to stop them from scuplting their hand while also taking things with discard is a great way to help Jund beat decks like Storm.Quote:
Originally Posted by ironclad8690
Also, when you Hymn and they Force (which happens to protect their combo pieces) and you follow up with a REB, you just 4 for 2 them. Such a great feeling. Keep in mind that Pyroblast can be redirected/misdirected to one of your permanents (thus fizzling). REB can't. I learned that the hard way this last weekend and will now be running REB.Quote:
Originally Posted by skyout
Pop quiz:
(assuming you have a second land in your starting seven)
Turn 1 on the play - how do you choose between DRS or Thoughtseize, against which decks?
Turn 1 on the draw - same question.
[I would give you my suggestion on this but.... I have no idea, hence the question!]
If you fear combo, thoughtseize. If not, Drs. If Miracles and youre on the play, TS.
Hmmm.... but if I play DRS first turn, I could play spells worth 3 mana on my second turn. That's enough for the TS as well as a Hymn/Sylvan/Decay/Edict. Or even a turn 2 Lilly.Quote:
Originally Posted by sdematt
Or die on turn 1 against combo. If against Miracles, you want to take Top.