"the sacrificed creature" when 2 were sacrificed
On the battlefield, there is
Brutal Suppression
and
at least one nontoken creature with a "sacrifice a creature" activated ability
https://scryfall.com/search?q=type%3...rid&order=name
whose effect refers to something about "the sacrificed creature"
and
something making the at least one nontoken creature
https://scryfall.com/search?q=oracle...rid&order=name
with such an activiated ability into a Rebel
.
To activate such an ability, a player sacrifices 2 creatures, one of which is also a land.
Crackling Emergence , Harmonious Emergence
Does the effect count both creatures, or just the one sacrificed for
"sacrifice a creature" and not the one sacrificed for "sacrifice a land" ?
If it counts both, then
Would Geralf, Visionary Stitcher make 1 token each, or edit: I corrected the numbers here.
1 token total, with X equal to the sum of their toughnesses? (I was thinking of a different card when I typed them before.)
.
Re: "the sacrificed creature" when 2 were sacrificed
I'm pretty sure you're over thinking it and it makes 1 token equal to the the toughness of the the creature you sacrificed to Geralf, not to brutal suppression.
Re: "the sacrificed creature" when 2 were sacrificed
4 tokens vs 2 tokens was due to me getting Geralf, Visionary Stitcher mixed up with a different card.
I'm guessing you think your answer remains correct after my change to 2 tokens vs 1 token ,
but even if you don't, it might remain correct anyway ^_^, which brings up a related question:
If Suppression Field and Vazi, Keen Negotiator are both on the battlefield, can an opponent avoid an activated ability
triggering Vazi by spending Treasure mana for Suppression Field rather than for the activated ability's source?
Re: "the sacrificed creature" when 2 were sacrificed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Phasmoid
4 tokens vs 2 tokens was due to me getting
Geralf, Visionary Stitcher mixed up with a different card.
I'm guessing you think your answer remains correct after my change to 2 tokens vs 1 token ,
but even if you don't, it might remain correct anyway ^_^, which brings up a related question:
If
Suppression Field and
Vazi, Keen Negotiator are both on the battlefield, can an opponent avoid an activated ability
triggering Vazi by spending Treasure mana for
Suppression Field rather than for the activated ability's source?
No.
Vazi doesn't care which costs your paying with treasures only that you are. This includes suppression fields additional only.
E: yeah I thought you had the wrong card. I'm to lazy to look it up but I think you're thinking of Gissa and Geralf? Or just Gissa who makes x 2/2s?
Re: "the sacrificed creature" when 2 were sacrificed
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Phasmoid
To activate such an ability, a player sacrifices 2 creatures, one of which is also a land.
Crackling Emergence ,
Harmonious Emergence
Does the effect count both creatures, or just the one sacrificed for
"sacrifice a creature" and not the one sacrificed for "sacrifice a land" ?
Just 1. The one sacrificed for "sacrifice a creature", not both.
"the sacrificed creature" is a pointer referring to the first object. It does not reference ANY or ALL creatures sacrificed.
If it read "creature X 1/1 tokens where X is the sacrificed creature's toughness", it would only work for one of the creatures sacrificed. It ignores the one sacrificed for Brutal Suppression. The controller gets to choose which is sacrificed for which purpose.
