Search:

Yes it definitely was. Premodern is more popular than Legacy now.

The format feels awesome. Legacy at its very best, with cards like Gush and Survival legal and format staples.

The more premodern I play, the more confident I grow that the banlist is just about perfect.

Yes it would be better if Tide didnt feel so oppressive or if Oath didnt punish aggro decks but those...

Lots of fantastic feedback everyone. So basically….

Storm combo could no longer compete without LED - which makes nonblue decks competitive

There would be an incentive to stay monocolored -...

Makes sense. There has been talk about Necropotence being unbanned in Premodern in order to give black a boost. Early testing suggests that Necro is not too strong for Premodern.

Let's hope that...

I think its a mistake that Dark Ritual is banned in Middle School.

Dark Ritual was always legal and is legal in Premodern and causes zero issues. The best black deck (BW Control) doesnt even play...

Why isnt middle school popular enough to be listed on mtgtop8 and reddit? It seems wiser to invest in Premodern lists since that format actually seems have to surged in popularity and has an active...

Overall very happy with the Troll ban. But I was secretly hoping they nuke Entomb so that its price collapses and it gets unbanned in Premodern.

Dark Ritual into Duress, Entomb,...

Ive gotten super into Premodern the past few months and its amazing. Everyone that played Magic before 2010 (ie everyone that occasionally ventures onto this forum or mtgsalvation, manadrain, scg...

I would absolutely make room for Hullbreacher. Its the 2U threat in legacy given how disruptive it is.

Lately, our local playgroup all got into Premodern, 2015 Modern and PreWar Legacy aka 2018 Legacy/PreFIRE Legacy. 2018 is the last year before Wizards implemented the FIRE philosophy to card design...

Lately, our local playgroup all got into Premodern, 2015 Modern and PreWar Legacy aka 2018 Legacy/PreFIRE Legacy. These variant formats are soo much fun that it made us discuss what a competitive No...

So if they ban Reanimate or Entomb on Monday, this deck goes up a tier? That would be fun to finally see this deck at Tier One.

Thought literally every single time boshnroll plays this deck on...

I agreed with it and signed it, because like a lot of people, I hated how MH3, LOTR and MH2 rotated legacy…

Wanted to share since most people here dont use Reddit…...

The updated list looks solid. I fully agree with the decision to drop Ornithopter and Retrofitter to free up the slots to play Tamiyo, Psychic Frog and Chrome Mox.

Just posting to say that Kaito,...

The Grief ban did kill the deck. But Pyrogoyf, Barrowgoyf and Unstoppable Slasher brought it back to life.

We already know how strong Sawing a Caves of CA can be.

But now, with these new cards...

Black is only worth splashing for Thoughseize as a way to clear the path for your Dreadnought. But I vastly prefer UW and UWg lists with a light green splash for Uro.

Here is the list that Im...

Damn, that is such a cool list. Its awesome that its monoblue.

I see every reason to cut an Island for an Otawara, Soaring City.


I would also want to play 2 maindeck Harbinger of the Seas to...

Curie is cool tech but the deck has minimal room for flex slots. Its insane this listisnt playing Nulldrifter for instance.

Dressnought is having its moment though. It has the second best win...

Uro is much better than Psychic Frog.

Play this list…

https://youtu.be/41AWAgAzOtc?si=ukuGjIrNhv96Gpi5

But add 3 Uro and the 4th Thrull.

I think its worthwhile as a 1-3 of.

Boshnroll posted a fantastic video with UW Dressnought…

https://youtu.be/41AWAgAzOtc?si=ukuGjIrNhv96Gpi5

I already posted my thoughts on Monoblue earlier. But Ive talked up Thrull since day one and do think that in the current meta, the white splash is worth it even for just Thrull alone.

As far UW...

Yes this list looks solid, but it doesnt use the graveyard at all so could easily support 2 Murkide as a bonus big threat. And definitely brazen over misdirection.

I would cut a stifle and daze...

No other 1s in the deck means we dont get to play Brainstorm, Ponder or Stifle.

The splash colors contain all the removal. You cut them off the splash color and they cant StP, Boseiju or Meltdown our threats.

Our threats are much faster clocks than their threats with the...

4eak, both of your lists should make room for 3 Nulldrifter and 4 Dress Down.

20 Lands + 8 cantrips is excessive, 19 is as high as I would go. I would probably cut a Daze too, Daze works better as...